Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED: 20th November, 2018
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SB: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE VIJAI KUMAR BIST, CHIEF JUSTICE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
:
Petitioner
Shri Deepesh Chandra Sharma,
S/o late K.P. Sharma,
R/o Gyalshing,
West Sikkim,
P.O. Gyalshing,
P.S. Tikjuk,
Pin-737111.
Versus
Respondents
: 1.
State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
The Secretary,
Health Care, Human Services &
Family Welfare Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------------------Appearance:
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Advocate with Mr. Shakil Karki and
Mr. Ratan Gurung, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with Mr. S.K.
Chettri, Mrs. Pollin Rai, Asst. Govt. Advocates and Mrs. Neera
Thapa, Advocate (HC, HS & FW Department) for the StateRespondents No. 1 & 2.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
JUDGMENT
Chief Justice
1.
Petitioner was appointed on compassionate ground as
Male Ward Attendant in the year 2005 in the Health Care, Human
Services & Family Welfare Department, Government of Sikkim, vide
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
Order dated 20.09.2005. On being appointed, he was posted at
Gyalshing
District
Hospital
w.e.f.
20.09.2005.
Thereafter,
on
01.08.2013, the petitioner was transferred to Namchi District
Hospital. On 03.09.2014, the petitioner was again transferred to
Shipsu PHC under District Hospital Singtam. On 01.05.2015, he was
posted at Shipsu Health Post. On 28.12.2015, he was sent back to
District Hospital Singtam and then on 01.05.2016 again transferred
to Shipsu PHC, East. In the year 2017, the petitioner moved a joint
application for mutual transfer. His prayer for mutual transfer was
accepted and order was passed on 25.04.2017 transferring him
from Sipchu to Rimbik. On 03.03.2018, a transfer order was passed
again and the petitioner was transferred from Rimbik to STNM
Hospital, Gangtok. There were some technical mistakes in the
transfer Order dated 03.03.2018 which were corrected by another
order dated 07.04.2018. Aggrieved by the transfer order, present
writ petition is filed.
2.
The case of the petitioner is that the order impugned
has been passed with a mala fide intention to harass the petitioner.
It is submitted that the petitioner has let out one flat on rent to run
the office of the opposition party „Sikkim Krantikari Morcha (SKM)
on monthly rent of Rs.5000/- (Rupees five thousand) only. The
petitioner was pressurized and asked to get the office of the SKM
vacated from his rental premises but the petitioner could not do so
without following due process of law i.e. by filing eviction suit and
the petitioner had no money to proceed for eviction suit. Due to this
reason, the petitioner was harassed and he has been frequently
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
transferred to all the odd places despite resistance from public. It is
submitted that the petitioner has performed his duty very sincerely
and diligently. It is submitted that most of the Primary Health Sub
Centers (PHSCs) are dependent on the health attendant for minor
ailment and to provide services to public and most of the villagers
cannot travel far flung, as such their basic needs are dependent
upon PHSCs. The villagers of Rimbik area approached the Chief
Medical Officer (CMO) for retaining the petitioner at Rimbik. The
concerned CMO told the villagers that transfer of petitioner has been
done as per the order of the higher authority. The villagers also
approached the concerned area MLA. He also categorically stated
that transfer of the petitioner cannot be stopped because he has let
out his house on rent to run the office of opposition party SKM. The
case of the petitioner is that the transfer of the petitioner is not
done for professed purposes, such as in normal course or in public
interest or administrative interest or in exigencies of service but for
other purpose with a mala fide intention at the instance of outside
or extra-legal authority to harass him. Same is a punitive transfer.
3.
Dr. Doma T. Bhuta, learned Counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the transfer order is arbitrary and unreasonable. The
petitioner is a Class-IV employee and none of the other employees
has been transferred from one place of posting to another and the
petitioner alone was picked up for transfer. It is also contended that
even the petitioner has not been paid any travelling allowances
whereas it was the duty of the respondents to pay the travelling
allowances. It is also contended that the transfer order is against
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
the public interest which is clear from the fact that public of the area
also made a representation for retaining the petitioner at his place
of posting. She submitted that by keeping the petitioner at Rimbik,
the villagers will be benefitted. It is also contended that the transfer
order is also against the Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS)
norms.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted that
the transfer order is in violation of Article 14 and 15 of the
Constitution of India, as it is not only arbitrary but discriminatory
also. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that it is a
rarest of the rare cases where transfer order has been passed with
mala fide intention and the Court should interfere with the same.
Learned counsel also submitted that the place from where the
petitioner has been transferred, no one has been posted there and
people of that area are suffering. Learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that the petitioner has already joined his place of posting
at STNM Gangtok. Learned counsel also submits that the petitioner
is ill, his wife is illiterate, he has two minor children and his place of
present posting i.e. Gangtok, costing him a lot as Gangtok is a
costly city. Therefore, it is not possible for the petitioner to maintain
himself. It is submitted that the petitioner could be sent back to his
previous place of posting at Rimbik. Learned counsel submitted that
the petitioner was transferred from east to west and west to east. It
is submitted that the transfer order is full of mala fide which is clear
from the fact that only after the petitioner gave accommodation to
the opposition political party, he was transferred several times. It is
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
reiterated by the counsel for the petitioner that the transfer order
has been passed at the behest of the present ruling party and the
same deserves to be set aside.
5.
In support of her arguments, Dr. Doma T. Bhuta,
learned counsel for the petitioner referred to paragraphs 8, 11, 13,
16 of the judgment passed by Kerala High Court in G. Babu vs. C.E.
(PS & GL) and Others : (1990) ILL J 202 Ker, which are reproduced
below:
“8. On the first question, I am reasonably certain that
the power of transfer also shall be exercised only for
bona fide purposes and any such order is liable to be
reviewed on grounds of absence of good faith or abuse
of power. There is certainly an area of discretion in the
Authority in such matters. But that discretion may
have to be tested on the touch-stone of
reasonableness when it is challenged on grounds of
arbitrariness or unreasonableness, absence of good
faith or abuse of power. It is elementary that all
wielding of power shall be bona fide and reasonable
and shall not amount to abuse of power. In E.P. Royappa
v. State of Tamil Nadu [A.I.R. 1974 SC 555] the question
was considered with specific reference to transfer of a
Senior Civil Servant. The following observations are
relevant in this context:
“… Articles 14 and 16 strike at arbitrariness in
State action and ensure fairness and equality of
treatment. They require that State action must
be based on valid relevant principles applicable
alike to all similarly situate and it must not be
guided by any extraneous or irrelevant
considerations because that would be denial of
equality. Where the operative reason for State
action, as distinguished from motive inducing
from the antechamber of the mind, is not
legitimate and relevant, but is extraneous and
outside the area of permissible considerations, it
would amount to mala fide exercise of power
and that is hit by Articles 14 and 16..."
Almost to the same effect are the observations of the
Supreme Court in Venkataraman S.R. (Smt.) v. Union of
India [1978-IIL L.M. 479]. The Court held at page 481:
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
"It is, however, not necessary to examine the
question of malice in law in this case, for it is
trite law that if a discretionary power has been
exercised for an unauthorised purpose, it is
generally immaterial whether its repository was
acting in good faith or in bad faith. As was
stated by Lord Goddard C. J., in Pilling v.
Abergele Urban District Council (1950) 1 KB
636, where a duty to determine a question is
conferred on an authority which state their
reasons for the decision,
„… and the reasons which they state show
that they have taken into account matters which
they ought not to have taken into account, or
that they have failed to take matters into
account which they ought to have taken into
account, the Court to which an appeal lies can
and ought to adjudicate on the matter.‟”
Reliance was placed on the observations of Lord
Goddard, C.J. in Pilling v. Abergele Urban District
Council, (1950) 1 KB 636 and Lord Esher M.R. in The
Queen on the Prosecution of Richard Westbrook v. The
Vestry of St. Pancras [1890 (23) Q.B.D. 371]. The
same position is covered by the decisions of Lord
Greens in Associated Provincial Picture Houses v.
Wednesbury Corporation [1947 (2) All ER 680] of Lord
Parker C.J. in Taylor v. Munrow [1960 (1) All ER 455]
and Lord Macnaghtan in Kennedy v. Birmingham
Licensing Planning Committee [1972 (2) All ER 305].
Decisions in this regard are a legion. I do not propose
to multiply authority on this point. It is, sufficient for
me to follow E.R. Royappa case (AIR 1974 S.C. 555]
(vide supra). I am therefore of the opinion that the
claim of the Authority that it shall not subject itself to
any guideline, any principle, any standard, in the
matter of ordering transfer of its employees cannot be
accepted.
………………………………………………………………………………………..
11. The Supreme Court had occasion to consider
the effect of the recital of such statutory formula on
the scope of judicial review of administrative action in
Narayan v. State of Maharashtra [A.I.R. 1977 S.C. 183].
The Court held:
"32. It is also clear that, even a
technically correct recital in an order or
notification stating that the conditions precedent
to the exercise of a power have been fulfilled
may not debar the Court in a given case from
considering the question whether, in fact, those
conditions have been fulfilled. And, a fortiori, the
Court may consider and decide whether the
authority concerned has applied its mind to
really relevant facts of a case with a view to
determining that a condition precedent to the
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
exercise of power has been fulfilled. If it
appears, upon an examination of the totality of
facts in the case, that the power conferred has
been exercised for an extraneous or irrelevant
purpose or that the mind has not been applied
at all to the real object or purpose of a power,
so that the result is that the exercise of power
could only serve some other or collateral object,
the Court will interfere."
13. The same question was considered by this
Court and the Supreme Court in a number of decisions.
Perhaps one of the earliest among the decisions of this
Court is by K.K. Mathew, J., as he then was, in Abdul
Khader v. R.D.D. Ernakulam [1967-K.L.T. 354]. It was
clearly laid down that the power of transfer shall be
used only in a reasonable manner even in the
exigencies of service, and shall not be used for
collateral purposes or as an instrument of harassment
or for punishing an employee.
…………………………………………………………………………………………
16. Recent decisions of the Supreme Court have
put the position regarding the scope of review of
orders of transfer of government employees beyond
controversy. In Varadha Rao (B.) v. State of Karnataka
[1986-II L.L.N. 753], the Court observed in Paras. 5
and 6, pages 755 and 756:
". . . It is no doubt true that if the power of
transfer is abused, the exercise of the power is
vitiated".
x
x
x
One cannot but deprecate that frequent,
unscheduled and unreasonable transfers can
uproot a family, cause irreparable harm to a
Government servant and drive
him to
desperation. It disrupts the education of his
children
and
leads
to
numerous
other
complications and problems and results in
hardship and demoralisation. It should be
reasonable and fair and should apply to
everybody equally. But, at the same time, it
cannot be forgotten that so far as superior or
more responsible posts are concerned, continued
posting at one station or in one department of
the Government is not conducive to good
administration. It creates vested interest and
therefore we find that even from the British
times the general policy has been to restrict the
period of posting for a definite period. . . "
(emphasis supplied)
Gujarat Electricity Board v. Atmaram Sungomal
Poshani [1989-II L.L. N. 299], dealt with a case
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
of discharge from service of an employee who
refused to comply with an order of transfer. The
Gujarat High Court held, that the discharge was
violative of the principles of natural justice.
Relying on clause 113 of the Service
Regulations, which provided for summary
discharge from service without the necessity of
disciplinary proceedings under the relevant
rules, the 'Supreme Court allowed the appeal
filed by the employee. In that context the Court
made the following observations in Para. 4, at
page 303:
"Transfer of a Government servant
appointed to a particular cadre of
transferable posts from one place to the
other is an incident of service. No
Government servant or employee of
Public Undertaking has legal right for
being posted at any particular place.
Transfer from one place to other is
generally a condition of service and the
employee has no choice in the matter.
Transfer from one place to other is
necessary in public interest and efficiency
in the public administration. Whenever a
public servant is transferred he must
comply with the order, but if there be any
genuine difficulty in proceeding on
transfer, it is open to him to make
representation to the competent authority
for stay, modification or cancellation of
the transfer order. If the order of transfer
is not stayed, modified or cancelled the
concerned public servant must carry out
the order of transfer. In the absence of
any stay of the transfer order a public
servant has no justification to avoid or
evade the transfer order merely on the
ground of having made a representation,
or on the ground of his difficulty in
moving from one place to the other. If he
fails to proceed on transfer in compliance
to the transfer order, he would expose
himself to disciplinary action under the
relevant Rules, as has happened in the
instant case. The respondent lost his
service as he refused to comply with the
order of his transfer from one place to the
other."
Counsel for the third respondent sought to rely on the
above observations to contend that orders of transfer
cannot be challenged in proceedings under Article 226
of the Constitution of India.”
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
6.
petitioner‟s
Per
contra,
case
appointment
of
order
the
Respondent
clearly
provided
is
that
the
that
the
appointment carries with it the liability to serve in any part of the
state. Therefore, now the petitioner cannot be permitted to
challenge the transfer order. It is also the case of the respondent
that the petitioner never objected to any of his transfer orders
except the present one. In fact, he himself requested for mutual
transfer in the year 2017. On his request, mutual transfer order was
passed and he was given posting of his choice. The allegation of
mala fide has no leg to stand. It is also the case of the respondents
that the transfer order has been passed in routine manner. The
same has neither been passed on administrative ground nor on any
disciplinary ground.
7.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, learned Additional Advocate General,
submitted that the allegation made by the petitioner is absolutely
incorrect. It is submitted by him that accommodation was given by
the petitioner on rent to run the office of the opposition party in the
year 2013. He was transferred thereafter but he had not made any
complaint against the transfer orders. In the year 2017, the
petitioner made a request for mutual transfer, which was accepted
by the authority. This clearly shows that there was no element of
bias against the petitioner. He submitted that petitioner has not
been subjected to discrimination as other employees have also been
transferred which is clear from Annexure P-5, which shows that
other similarly placed persons were also transferred. He submitted
that transfer is an incident of service career and authority is
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
competent enough to transfer its employee in public interest or
interest of work. He submitted that scope of judicial review in the
transfer matter is very limited and High Court should not interfere in
such matter unless it is proved that power is exercised by the
authority in total arbitrary manner with mala fide intention, which is
not found in the present case.
8.
Learned Additional Advocate General also referred to
Rule 9 of the Sikkim Government Service Rules, 1974, which
provides that government employee can be transferred from one
post to another. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submitted that it was and is open for the petitioner to raise his
grievances before the authority concerned. And such grievances will
be dealt with in accordance with law.
9.
Learned Additional Advocate General in support of his
arguments placed reliance on various judgments passed by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Registrar General, High Court of Judicature
of Madras vs. R. Perachi & Ors : (2011) 12 SCC 137, N.K. Singh vs. Union
of India and Others : (1994) 6 SCC 98, Rajendra Singh and Others vs.
State of Uttar Pradesh and Others : (2009) 15 SCC 178, Mohd. Masood
Ahmad vs. State of U.P. and Others : (2007) 8 SCC 150, State of U.P. and
Others vs. Gobardhan Laal with D.B. Singh vs. D.K. Shukla and Others :
(2004) 11 SCC 402, State of U.P. and Others vs. Ashok Kumar Saxena and
Another : (1998) 3 SCC 303, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh vs. G. Venkata
Ratnam : (2008) 9 SCC 345, Rajendra Singh and Others vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh and Others : (2009) 15 SCC 178, Rajendra Roy vs. Union of India
and Another : (1993) 1 SCC 148, Airports Authority of India vs. Rajeev
Ratan Pandey and Others : (2009) 8 SCC 337, Ratnagiri Gas and Power
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
Private Limited vs. RDS Projects Limited and Others : (2013) 1 SCC 524
and G. Jayalal vs. Union of India and Others : (2013) 7 SCC 150.
10.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for
the parties.
11.
It is settled law that in a matter of transfer of a
government employee, scope of judicial review is limited and the
High Court should not interfere with the order of transfer lightly, be
it at interim stage or final stage. This is so because the courts do
not substitute their own decision in the matter of transfer. It is also
settled position of law that an order of transfer is a part of the
service conditions of an employee which should not be interfered in
exercise of its discretional jurisdiction under article 226 of the
Constitution of India. The government servant has no vested right
to remain in a particular place of posting for a long period. He can
also not insist that he must be posted at a particular place because
the people of that area want him to continue at the place of posting.
Transfer order can be set aside when transfer order is vitiated by
violation of some statutory provisions or suffers from mala fides.
Transfer order can also be set aside when same is passed by an
authority who is not competent to pass such orders. It can also be
set aside when by such order the person is sent to a lower post.
[Mohd. Masood Ahmad vs. State of U.P. and Others : (2007) 8 SCC 150,
Rajendra Singh and Others vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others : (2009)
15 SCC 178, Rajendra Singh and Others vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Others : (2009) 15 SCC 178].
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
12.
This Court is conscious of the fact that the allegations of
mala fide should not be accepted lightly by the court. The Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of U.P. and Others vs. Govardhan
Lal
(supra), observed that allegations of mala fides must inspire
confidence of the court and ought not to be entertained on the mere
asking of it or on consideration borne out of conjectures and
surmises and except for strong and convincing reasons, no
interference could ordinarily be made with an order of transfer. The
burden of proving mala fide is on a person leveling such allegations
and the burden is heavy, admits of no legal ambiguity. Mere
assertion or bald statement is not enough to discharge the heavy
burden that the law imposes upon the person leveling allegations of
mala fides, it must be supported by requisite materials.
13.
In Ratnagiri Gas and Power Private Limited vs. RDS Projects
Limited and Others (supra), similar view was taken by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that as and
when allegations of mala fides are made, the persons against whom
the same are leveled need to be impleaded as parties to the
proceedings to enable them to answer the charge. In the absence of
the person concerned as a party in his/her individual capacity it will
neither be fair nor proper to record a finding that malice in fact had
vitiated the action taken by the authority concerned. It is important
to remember that a judicial pronouncement declaring an action to
be mala fide a serious indictment of the person concerned that can
lead to adverse civil consequences against him. Courts have
therefore, to be slow in drawing conclusions when it comes to
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
holding allegations of mala fides to be proved and only in cases
where based on the material placed before the court or facts that
are admitted leading to inevitable inferences supporting the charge
of mala fides that the court should record a finding in the process
ensuring that while it does so, it also hears the person who was
likely to be affected by such a finding.
14.
The main argument advanced by counsel for the
petitioner is that the transfer order is bad in law as same has been
passed by the authority with mala fide intention. It is contended
that the petitioner rented out one flat to run the office of the
opposition party „SKM‟ on a monthly rent of Rs.5000/- (Rupees five
thousand) only. The ruling party got annoyed by this action of the
petitioner and pressurized the office of the petitioner to transfer him
from that place. It is contended by learned counsel for the petitioner
that transfer order was passed under pressure. In the present case,
this Court finds that only general allegations has been leveled that
due to the fact that since the petitioner rented out his flat to run
office of the opposition party „SKM‟, the petitioner has been
transferred. Nothing more has been said. That sentence in itself is
not sufficient to prove that transfer order vitiates from mala fides.
Nothing is said that in what manner the authority was influenced by
the ruling party. Neither allegation has been made against a
particular person nor has any person been impleaded as a
respondent. Therefore, this Court is of the view that the petitioner
has not been able to substantiate that the impugned order of
transfer was passed with mala fide intention him.
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
15.
Next argument of learned counsel for the Petitioner is
that the petitioner has been transferred several times from one
place to another, only to harass him. It is also contended that
authorities should not be permitted to transfer a government
employee frequently. No doubt, a government employee should not
be transferred frequently, as frequent transfers cause unnecessary
hardships not only to such government employee but also to his
family members and his children who are pursuing their studies. It
is true that before 2017, the petitioner was transferred from one
place to another but the petitioner never raised that issue. In 2017,
he himself made a representation for mutual transfer which was
accepted by the authority concerned. Therefore, the petitioner
should not have any grievances, so far, transfer orders passed
before 2017 are concerned. The petitioner has now been transferred
from Rimbik to Gangtok, which is admittedly a better place. The
learned Additional Advocate General referred to Rule 9 of the Sikkim
Government Service Rule, 1974, and submitted that it was and it is
always open for the petitioner to raise his grievances before the
authority concerned. He is fair enough to suggest that in case such
grievances are made by the
petitioner before the authority
concerned, the same will be dealt in accordance with law.
16.
Learned counsel for the petitioner then submitted that
the petitioner has been transferred from one place to another but he
has not been paid travelling allowance which should have been paid
to him as per law. She submitted that non-payment is deliberate
and to harass the petitioner. On this, learned Additional Advocate
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
General submitted that in fact, the petitioner himself did not submit
any travelling bills in time, therefore, the amount was not paid to
him. (This fact was again denied by learned counsel for the
petitioner.) Learned Additional Advocate General fairly submitted
that in case the petitioner submits his travelling bills, those bills will
be processed and the petitioner will be paid the travelling allowance
as per law. This statement of learned Additional Advocate General is
recorded and it is expected that payment of travelling allowance will
be made to the petitioner at the earliest.
17.
Case law cited by learned counsel for the petitioner, also
does not support the case of the petitioner.
18.
In view of all of the above, I am of the view that the
impugned transfer order cannot be set aside. His prayer for
quashing the transfer order is rejected.
19.
However, considering the fact that the petitioner is a
Class-IV employee and also considering the fact that he has some
personal problems, this Court permits the petitioner to move before
the competent authority by filing a representation. In case, such a
representation is moved on or before 31st December, 2018, the
authority concerned is directed to decide the same within a period of
three months from the date of filing of the representation.
20.
During the course of hearing, it came to the notice of
this Court that the State Government has neither made Transfer Act
WP(C) No. 15 of 2018
Deepesh Chandra Sharma vs. State of Sikkim and Another
nor any Rules have been framed in this regard. Even Guidelines
have also not been framed by the State Government. In fact, for
proper functioning of government departments, at least some
guidelines regarding transfer of its employees should be framed by
the Government. The State-Government is requested to look into
the matter and to either frame Guidelines or Rules or Act regarding
transfer of its employees, at the earliest.
21.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition stands disposed of with
the above directions.
22.
No order as to costs.
23.
Let a copy of this judgment be sent to the Chief
Secretary of the State.
( Vijai Kumar Bist )
Chief Justice
20.11.2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review