Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010261672025
2026:GAU-AS:9730
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6825/2025
DEEPAK THAPA
S/O- RAJAN THAPA,
R/O- VILLAGE- BAJALTOLI, CIRCUIT HOUSE, TINSUKIA, PS-TINSUKIA,
DIST- TINSUKIA,ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF
ASSAM,PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT,DISPUR, GUWAHATI-06, DIST.KAMRUP (M), ASSAM.
2:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (BUILDING)
CHANDMARI
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
3:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT.
TINSUKIA DISTRICT TERRITORIAL BUILDING DIVISION
TINSUKIA
DIST.- TINSUKIA
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. R BORA, MS R MEDHI
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, SC, PWD
BEFORE
Page No.# 2/11
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 16-07-2026
Heard Mr. R. Bora, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. R. Dhar,
learned standing counsel, PWD appearing for the respondents.
2.
The petitioner in the present writ petition is presented a challenge to an order
dated 18-11-2025 issued by the Executive Engineer, PWD, Tinsukia District Territorial
Building Division, Tinsukia, terminating the services of the petitioner invoking the
provision of Rule 7 of the Assam Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1964.
3.
The petitioner on being selected by the State Level Recruitment Committee for Gr-
IV post was vide order dated 22-05-2023 appointed as Chowkidar (MTS) in the office of
the Executive Engineer, PWD, Tinsukia District Territorial Building Division, Tinsukia. While
the petitioner was continued with his services in pursuance to the order dated 22-052023, the petitioner was involved in a criminal case being Hamren P.S. Case No. 14/2023,
registered under Section 419/ 468/ 471/ 120(B) IPC.
4.
The petitioner was placed under arrest in connection with the said case on 16-06-
2023. Consequently, the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner vide order dated 16-062023, proceeded to place the petitioner under suspension. The petitioner was, thereafter,
enlarged on bail by this Court vide order dated 10-08-2023 passed in B.A. No. 2350/2023.
The suspension of the petitioner having been continued and the subsistence allowance of
the petitioner not being released, the petitioner being aggrieved had approached this
Court by way of instituting W.P.(C) No. 4389/2025. While the said writ petition was
Page No.# 3/11
pending consideration by this Court, the subsistence allowance of the petitioner was
released to him. A notice was issued to the petitioner on 04-10-2025, requiring him to
submit written justification explaining the reason for his arrest in the criminal proceeding
and to furnish detail and present status of the police case registered against him. He was
also required to adduce valid grounds for revocation of his order of suspension before the
Enquiry Committee constituted in the matter. The petitioner, thereafter, submitted a reply
to the said notice dated 04-10-2025. It is projected that the petitioner had also appeared
before the constituted Enquiry Committee. The Committee, thereafter, submitted a report
before the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner. The Disciplinary Authority of the
petitioner on perusal of the said report concurred with the recommendations of the
Enquiry Committee and proceeded vide order dated 18-11-2025 to terminate the services
of the petitioner by invoking the provision of Rule 6 of the Assam Services (Discipline &
Appeal) Rules, 1964 (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules of 1964”).
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has instituted the present writ petition.
5.
Mr. R. Bora, learned counsel for the petitioner by reiterating the facts noticed
hereinabove has submitted that the termination/ dismissal of the services of the petitioner
was so effected by the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner by invoking the provision of
Rule 7 of the Rules of 1964. He submits that although the provision of Rule 7 was so
invoked for the purpose of dismissing the petitioner from his services, no proceeding as
mandated under the provision of Rule 9 of the said Rules of 1964, came to be instituted
against the petitioner. He submits that no show-cause notice in terms of the provision of
Rule 9(2) of the Rules of 1964 was issued to the petitioner in the matter instituting a
Page No.# 4/11
Departmental Proceeding against him. Mr. Bora by referring to the notice dated 04-102025, has submitted that the same was so issued only in respect of the order of
suspension issued to the petitioner and the same was not in connection with any charges
framed against the petitioner as mandated under the provisions of Rule 9(2) of the Rules
of 1964. Accordingly, he submits that the invocation of the provisions of Rule 7 of the
Rules of 1964 for the purpose of terminating the services of the petitioner was so done in
clear violation of the provision of Rule 9 of the Rules of 1964 and accordingly, the order
dated 18-11-2025 would not be sustainable.
6.
Per contra, Mr. R. Dhar, learned standing counsel, PWD has submitted that the
petitioner was terminated from his service by following the required procedure prescribed
under Rule 9 of the Rules of 1964. He submits that the Enquiry Committee was
constituted by the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner for review of suspension of the
petitioner as well as for conduct of Departmental Proceeding. The said Committee had
duly examined the petitioner in the matter and after examining the materials furnished by
the investigating agency with regard to the criminal proceeding instituted against the
petitioner, the Committee had recommended for termination of the services of the
petitioner. He submits that adequate materials having come on record demonstrating
commission of misconduct by the petitioner in the matter, the Disciplinary Authority of the
petitioner on a due consideration of the materials coming on record including the
statement of the petitioner recorded by the Enquiry Committee proceeded vide order
dated 18-11-2025 to impose the penalty of termination from services of the petitioner. Mr.
Dhar submits that the petitioner was actually imposed with the penalty of dismissal from
Page No.# 5/11
service. Accordingly, he submits that the penalty of dismissal from service being imposed
upon the petitioner on the ground of proved misconduct, the same would not mandate
interference from this Court.
7.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the
materials available on record.
8.
The petitioner, herein, in pursuance to the recommendations made by the State
Level Recruitment Committee for Gr-IV post, was appointed as Chowkidar (MTS), in the
establishment of the respondent No. 3, vide order dated 22-05-2023. Thereafter, the
petitioner was attached to the Election Branch of the office of the Deputy Commissioner,
Tinsukia vide order dated 07-06-2023. The petitioner was, thereafter, released from the
establishment of the respondent No. 3 vide order dated 12-06-2023. The petitioner
continued on attachment in the establishment of the Deputy Commissioner, Tinsukia, till
16-06-2023. The petitioner at the relevant point of time, was arrayed as an accused in
Hamren P.S. Case No. 14/2023 and was placed under arrest on 16-06-2023. The
petitioner having been placed under detention on 16-06-2023, the Disciplinary Authority
of the petitioner, i.e. the respondent No. 2 vide order dated 16-06-2023, proceeded to
place the petitioner under suspension until further order. Thereafter, the petitioner was
enlarged on bail by this Court vide order dated 10-08-2023 in B.A. No. 2350/2023. The
petitioner had projected that he had informed his Disciplinary Authority vide
communication dated 16-08-2023 about his enlargement of bail by this Court. However,
the said position is disputed by the respondent authority. Being aggrieved by the
prolonged suspension occasioning in his case as well as non-release of the subsistence
Page No.# 6/11
allowance, the petitioner had approached this Court by way of instituting a writ petition
being W.P.(C) No. 4389/2025.
9.
A Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 26-09-2025, while requiring the
respondent authorities to release to the petitioner his subsistence allowance had required
the counsel representing the respondents to receive the up-to-date status with regard to
the Disciplinary Proceeding, if any instituted against the petitioner, herein. In pursuance
to the passing of the said order, the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner, i.e. the
respondent No. 2 vide order dated 14-10-2025 required the petitioner to submit written
justification and appear before the Enquiry Committee as constituted in the matter and to
place his contention before the said Committee for revocation of his suspension. The
petitioner, accordingly, submitted his written statement before the Disciplinary Authority
on 14-10-2025, denying any involvement with the allegations as existing in Hamren P.S.
Case No. 14/2023. The petitioner also projects to have appeared before the Enquiry
Committee as constituted in the matter. The Enquiry Committee on conclusion of the
enquiry conducted, submitted its report in the matter. The Enquiry Committee concluded
that the petitioner at the time of his arrest was on probation and was named as accused
in Hamren P.S. Case No. 14/2023. Accordingly, the Enquiry Committee recommended that
the petitioner be dismissed from Government service in view of this proved misconduct.
Basing on the said recommendation of the Enquiry Committee, the Disciplinary Authority
of the petitioner, i.e. the respondent No. 3, proceeded vide order dated 18-11-2025 to
terminate the services of the petitioner invoking the provision of Rule 7 of the Rules of
1964. The petitioner was held to have been dismissed from Government service w.e.f. the
Page No.# 7/11
date of issuance of the said order.
10.
The Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner having invoked the provision of Rule 7
of the Rules of 1964 for the purpose of terminating the services of the petitioner, this
Court would now examine the provision of Rule 7 of the Rules of 1964. Rule 7 of the
Rules of 1964 prescribes the penalties which would be permissible to be imposed upon a
Government servant. Rule 9 of the Rules of 1964 mandates that any penalty specified in
Rule 7, shall be permissible to be so imposed after an enquiry, held as far as may be in
the manner provided therein.
11.
Rule 9(2) of the Rules of 1964 mandates that the Disciplinary Authority shall frame
definite charges on the basis of the allegations on which the enquiry is proposed to be
held. It further stipulates that the said charge together with a statement of the allegations
on which they are based shall be communicated in writing to the Government servant,
and he shall be required to submit, within such time as may be specified by the
Disciplinary Authority, a written statement of his defense and also to state whether he
desires to be heard in person. Accordingly, on a conjoint reading of the Rule 7 and Rule 9
of the Rules of 1964, it is seen that a proceeding under Rule 9 of the Rules of 1964, is
mandatorily required to be instituted and concluded before a penalty specified under Rule
7 of the said Rules is permissible to be so imposed upon the delinquent.
12.
In the case on hand, the purported initiation of the Disciplinary Proceeding against
the petitioner is projected to be so done vide issuance of notice dated 04-10-2025. On a
perusal of the said notice dated 04-10-2025, this Court does not find that the same was
so issued invoking the provisions of Rule 9 of the Rules of 1964. The said notice was only
Page No.# 8/11
in respect of the order of suspension issued against the petitioner and the petitioner was
called upon vide the said notice to urge grounds for revocation of the same. The said
notice cannot under any circumstances be construed to be a show-cause notice issued
complying with the provisions of the Rule 9(2) of the Rules of 1964. The notice dated 0410-2025, being not a notice as contemplated under the provision of Rule 9(2) of the Rules
of 1964, no Departmental Proceeding can be held to have been instituted against the
petitioner, herein. Accordingly, the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner cannot be held
to have the jurisdiction to invoke the provision of Rule 7 of the Rules of 1964 to impose
upon the petitioner any penalty as specified, therein.
13.
This Court finds that the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner vide order dated
18-11-2025, had considered the report submitted by a Departmental Enquiry Committee.
The said Committee is projected to have been constituted in compliance with the order
dated 26-09-2025 passed by this Court in W.P.(C) No. 4389/2025, to review the
suspension of the petitioner and to conduct a Departmental Proceeding against him. From
the materials brought on record, it is seen that only a review of the suspension of the
petitioner was carried out by the Enquiry Committee so constituted and no Departmental
Proceeding came to be instituted against the petitioner in the matter. Further, the said
Enquiry Committee cannot also be held to be a Committee as constituted by the
Disciplinary Authority in terms of the provision of Rule 9(4) of the Rules of 1964. The
Committee in the considered view of this Court was a Committee only constituted to carry
out a preliminary enquiry in the matter and nothing further. Accordingly, the report of the
said Enquiry Committee cannot be elevated to one submitted in terms of the provisions of
Page No.# 9/11
Rule 9(7) of the Rules of 1964. Accordingly, the said report submitted by the Enquiry
Committee could not have been reckoned by the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner
for the purpose of imposition of any penalty specified under the provisions of Rule 7 of
the Rules of 1964 upon the petitioner. Accordingly, the order dated 18-11-2025 issued by
the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner, imposing upon the petitioner the penalty of
dismissal from service, in the considered view of this Court, has been so issued without
jurisdiction and in clear violation of the provisions for conduct of a Departmental
Proceeding as contemplated under the provisions of the Rules of 1964.
14.
At this stage, this Court would notice that in the affidavit filed in the present writ
petition by the respondent authorities, it was categorically contended that some
procedural lapses might have occasioned in the conduct of the proceeding in the matter
against the petitioner due to the fact that the Division was newly created and majority of
the staff were recruited only in the year 2023 and no experienced personnel was available
to handle such Disciplinary Proceeding and court related cases. It was further contended
in the said affidavit that there was no witness available to depose in the matter against
the petitioner and there was also no documentary evidence available as all such
documents were seized by the Hamren Police in connection with the Hamren P.S. Case
No. 14/2023. The said contentions made by the respondent authorities in the affidavit
further goes to fortify that there was, in fact, no Disciplinary Proceeding instituted in the
matter against the petitioner and the order dated 18-11-2025 was so issued without
jurisdiction by the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioner.
15.
In view of the above conclusions reached by this Court, the impugned order dated
Page No.# 10/11
18-11-2025 is held to be not sustainable and accordingly, the same stands set aside.
16.
This Court having interfered with the order dated 18-11-2025, the respondent No.
3 is directed to forthwith reinstate the petitioner in his services. A Departmental
Proceeding having not been instituted against the petitioner in the matter till date in
terms of the provisions of Rules of 1964, this Court directs that within a period of 01
(one) month from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order, the respondent
authorities, more particularly, the respondent No. 3, shall take a decision basing on the
materials available on record as to whether commission of a misconduct by the petitioner
in the matter is discernable therefrom. In the event, the respondent authorities including
the respondent No. 3, is of the view that a misconduct is discernable in the matter against
the petitioner, the respondent authorities shall within the period of 01 (one) month, as
permitted by this Court, hereinabove, institute appropriate Departmental Proceeding
against the petitioner strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Rules of 1964.
17.
The period w.e.f. 18-11-2025 till today, i.e. 16-07-2026, during which period the
petitioner had to remain out of service on account of the order of dismissal from service
imposed upon him as well as the period of suspension, undergone by the petitioner, shall
be dealt with in the manner required, after completion of the Departmental Proceeding if
instituted against the petitioner, by acting upon the liberty granted to the respondent
authorities to institute such proceeding by this Court, hereinabove. In the event no such
proceeding is instituted against the petitioner within a period of 01 (one) month from the
date of receipt of a certified copy of this order, the period of absence of the petitioner,
w.e.f. 18-11-2025, till the date of his reinstatement in terms of the directions passed,
Page No.# 11/11
hereinabove, shall be regularized as on duty and the petitioner shall be released his
salaries for the said period. Further the period of suspension of the petitioner shall also be
regularized as on duty with release of his salaries after deducting the subsisting allowance
already paid to him.
18.
With the above observations and directions, the present writ petition stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review