Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Petn. No.2 of 2020
Date of Decision: 27.09.2023
Vs. M/s Jud Cements Limited.
Shri. Deepak Mittal
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Nongbri, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Khyriem, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Heard Mr. P. Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Khyriem,
learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
This application under Section 482 Cr.P.C has been filed
praying for setting aside and quashing of the criminal complaint
bearing CR Case No.3/2018 and impugned orders dated 30-10-2018
and
20-11-2018
passed
therein
by
the
Additional
Deputy
Commissioner (J), East Jaintia Hills District, Khliehriat.
3.
The notable facts of the case are that the respondent
M/s Jud
Cements Limited had vide purchase order dated 21-03-2016 placed an
order before M/s Mittal Alloy Casting Company, wherein the
petitioner is a partner, for supply of Grinding Media Balls to the tune
of Rs. 55,36,687/-. On 31-03-2016 the respondent issued four post
dated cheques dated 07-05-2016, 10-05-2016, 17-05-2016 and 13-052016, all from IDBI Bank Guwahati, Assam in favour of M/s Mittal
Alloy Casting Company amounting to Rs 55,36,687/- in total as a
financial security for the order. Thereafter, the petitioner company
supplied the grinding media ball to the respondent and, accordingly,
issued sale invoices dated 09-04-2016, 15-04-2016 and 25-04-2016.
On receipt of the materials, the respondent made a part payment of
rupees 5 (five) lakhs on 09-05-2016 to the petitioner company vide
RTGS. On 07-06-2016, the respondent made another part payment of
rupees 3 (three) lakhs vide RTGS. Since the respondent did not make
any further payment, on 20-06-2016 the petitioner deposited all the
cheques, which were received as financial security from the
respondent, to the Union Bank of India, Raigarh. All the cheques
were dishonoured because of insufficient funds in the account of the
respondent. Thereafter, the petitioner issued a legal notice dated 0707-2016 to the respondent demanding payment of dues of
Rs.46,28,260/- within a period of 15 (fifteen) days from the date of the
receipt of the said legal notice. However, the respondent did not come
forward to make any payment even after the lapse of 15(fifteen) days.
Consequently, the petitioner filed a complaint case being Criminal
Case No.214 of 2017 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument
Act, 1881 against the respondent before the Court of Judicial
Magistrate, First Class, Raigarh, C.G. The case was registered vide
order dated 09-05-2017 and on being aggrieved by the said order, two
revision petitions were filed being Criminal Revision No.161 of 2018
and Criminal Revision No.162 of 2018 by the respondent and
different directors of the respondent-company. The learned Court of
the Additional Sessions Judge, Raigarh, CG after hearing the parties
vide order dated 07-09-2019 dismissed both the aforesaid revision
petitions.
4.
In the meanwhile, on 30-10-2018 after more than two years of
the supply of the Grinding Media Balls by the petitioner, the
respondent filed a complaint case being CR case No.3 of 2019 under
Section 200 Cr.P.C. before the Additional Deputy Commissioner (J)
East Jaintia Hills District, against the petitioner alleging, inter-alia,
that M/s Mittal Alloy Casting Company had made supply of inferior
quality of Grinding Media Balls to the respondent and that M/s Mittal
Alloy Casting Company refused to replace the said Grinding Media
Balls as agreed in the purchase terms. On the basis of the fact, it was
alleged that the petitioner has committed an offence under Sections
406,418,420, 422, 425 and 427 IPC. On the filing of the complaint,
the statement of the complainant was recorded and thereafter by order
dated 30-10-2018 a bailable warrant of arrest was issued against the
petitioner for his appearance before the Trial Court. Subsequently by
another order dated 20-11-2018 a non-bailable warrant of arrest was
issued against the petitioner in the matter.
5.
The petitioner, in the present application, has stated that the
bailable warrant of arrest and the non-bailable warrant of arrest which
were issued by the Trial Court had never been executed against him.
In fact, the petitioner had no knowledge of criminal complaint bearing
CR case No.3 of 2018 pending against him. It was only on 09-042019 when he was approached for settlement in the matter, he came to
know about the said complaint case. The petitioner stated that after
the effort of settlement failed, he engaged his lawyer to pursue the CR
case No.3 of 2018 and after obtaining certified-copy of all the
materials, has decided to approached this Court seeking quashing of
the entire proceedings of the aforesaid complaint case.
6.
Mr. P. Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner contends that
the CR case No.3 of 2018 which has been filed after the lapse of two
years from the date of supply of materials has come as a counter-blast
to the filing of the criminal complaint under Section 138 of the
Negotiable Instument Act, 1881 by the petitioner. He submits that if
at all there was any criminal complaint with regard to the supply of
materials and quality thereof, it should have been filed immediately on
the receipt of the materials supplied. He further submits that the
criminal case No.3 of 2018 has been filed by the respondent with an
ulterior motive to harass the petitioner and also for the purpose of
escaping from making payment of remaining dues of Rs.46,26,628/to the petitioner. It is also the contention of the learned counsel for
the petitioner that the respondent admitted in the complaint that there
exist an agreement/contract stipulating the terms and conditions for
supply of Grinding Media Balls to the respondent and, in such a
situation, the respondent could not have filed a criminal case against
the petitioner.
The dispute raised by the respondent against the
petitioner is purely civil in nature and by no stretch of imagination the
same can be used for initiating criminal action against the petitioner.
He submits that mere deficiency of service cannot be termed as either
breach of trust or cheating. Furthermore, he contends that there is no
specific allegation against the director of M/s Mittal Alloy Casting
Company and if the entire complaint petition is accepted at its facevalue, the same would not make out any criminal offence against the
petitioner. The initiation of the criminal proceeding is an abuse of
process of law. He, as such, submits that the entire CR case No.3 of
2018 and subsequent impugned orders dated 30-10-2018 and 20-112018 are not tenable in the eye of law and liable to be set aside and
quashed.
7.
In support of his submission, Mr. P. Nongbri, learned counsel
placed reliance on the following decisions:i)
Inder Mohan Goswami and Another Versus State of
Uttaranchal and Others: (2007) 12 SCC 1 at Paras
46,51& 54;
ii)
Medmeme, LLC and Others Versus Ihorse BPO
solutions Private Limited: (2018) 13 SCC 374 at Paras
12 & 13;
iii)
Sushil Sethi and Another Versus State of Arunachal
Pradesh and Others: (2020) 3 SCC 240 at Paras 6, 7.7
& 8.2;
iv)
Govind Prasad Kejriwal Versus State of Bihar and
Another: (2020) 16 SCC 714 at Paras 6.1 & 6.3 and
v)
Chanchalpati Das and Madhupandit Das. Versus The
State of West Bengal & Another in Criminal Appeal No.
1592 of 2023 along with Criminal Appeal No. 1593 of
2023. At paras 16 & 17
8.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel for the respondent, per
contra, submits that institution of the Criminal Case No.3 of 2018 by
the respondent against the petitioner cannot be termed as a countermeasure against the complaint case filed under Section 138 of
Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 by the petitioner against the
respondent.
By referring to the legal notice dated 07-07-2016
addressed to the respondent on behalf of the petitioner wherein
demand for payment of dues amounting to Rs.46,28,216 was made, he
submits that the said notice was addressed in the year 2016 and the
CR case was filed in the month of October, 2018 after lapse of more
than 2 (two) years; had there been any intention on the part of the
respondent to take counter-measure by filing a criminal case, it would
have been done immediately after the receipt of the legal notice dated
07-07-2016. He submits that the Criminal case was filed on the
detection of defects in the materials supplied and refusal by the
petitioner to replace the same. Referring to the paragraphs 6,7,8 & 9
of the complaint in CR case No.3 of 2018, the learned Senior counsel
submits that there is a clear intention on the part of the petitioner to
cheat the respondent by supplying inferior quality of materials and the
petitioner has also committed breach of trust by not replacing the
defective materials. He further submits that a prima facie case under
Section 406,418, 420, 422, 425 and 427 IPC has been clearly made
out against the petitioner and the issuance of process in the criminal
case cannot be faulted with. He submits that the allegations made in
the complaint cannot be termed as absurd and inherently improbable.
He submits that the allegations made in the complaint disclosed the
commission of offence and clearly makes out a case for proceeding
against the petitioner. Further, the learned Senior Counsel submits
that it is a settled law that a fact may give rise to a civil claim and also
amount to an offence. Merely because a civil claim is maintainable, it
does not mean that criminal complaint cannot be maintained. He
contends that at this stage it cannot be stated that the complaint filed
by the respondent is a frivolous complaint. He submits that power
possessed by the High Court under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. is very
wide but the same requires great caution in its exercise. Court must be
careful to see its decision in exercise of this power is based on sound
principle. The inherent power should not be exercised to stifle a
legitimate prosecution.
In a proceeding instituted on complaint,
exercise of the inherent power to quash the proceeding is called for
only in a case where complaint does not disclose any offence or is
frivolous, vexatious or oppressive.
The learned Senior Counsel
submits that it is not necessary at this stage that there should be
meticulous analysis of the case to find out whether case would end in
conviction or acquittal. In the present criminal case filed by the
respondent, the ingredient of the offences are disclosed and there is no
material to show that the complaint is mala fide, frivolous or vexatious
and, in that event, it would not be justified at this stage that any
interference be made by the High Court. He thus submits that the
present application under Section 482 Cr.P.C filed by the petitioner is
devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
9.
The learned Senior counsel placed reliance on the Judgment of
the Apex Court in the following decisions:i)
State of Haryana & Ors. Vs. Bhajan Lal :1992 Supp (1)
SCC 335 (Para 102).
ii)
Lalmuni Devi (Smt) Vs. State of Bihar and Others :
(2001) 2 SCC 17 (Para – 8)
iii)
Zandu Pharmaceutical Works Limited and Others Vs.
Mohd. Sharaful Haque and Another: (2005) 1 SCC 122 (Paras –
8,9, 10, 11).
10.
Paragraph 4 of the complaint in CR Case No.3 of 2018
discloses that there exists an agreement/contract between the parties
hereto with regard to the supply of Grinding Media Balls. Annexure-
V of the complaint contains a guarantee/warranty clause which reads
as here under:“GUARANTEE/WARRANTY: Our supplied material will
be guaranteed against manufacturing defects Breakages
guarantee/Warrantee we will stand by UP to 2 % - No
Replacement, up to 2 – 5% - Actual Breakage
Replacement and above 5 % - Full Replacement.”
11.
Paragraph 5 of the said complaint reveals that defects in
Grinding Media Balls were detected on 12-05-2016 whereas the
complaint, as per the record, was filed only on 26-10-2018, that is
after lapse of more than 2 years. The respondent after receipt of the
supply of Grinding Media Balls undisputedly, apart from making
payment of rupees 5 (five) lakhs on 09-05-2016, has also made a
payment of rupees 3 (three) lakhs on 07-06-2016, which is after the
date of detection of defect in the Grinding Media Balls. In addition to
the above facts, vide a communication made through e-mail dated 2805-2016 by the respondent to the petitioner annexed as Annexure-V to
the present revision application, it was stated by the respondent that
the material received from the petitioner was not up to the mark and a
request was made to compensate the loss. It is pertinent to note that in
the said communication the respondent also stated that as directed by
the CMD they are going to clear all the dues within the period from
02-06-2016 to 15-07-2016 on an average of rupees 7 (seven) to 8
(eight) lakhs on weekly basis through RTGS; the respondent has also
sought for cooperation from the petitioner in that regard.
The
aforesaid communication vide e-mail was also made after the date on
which defect in the materials was noticed by the respondent.
12.
The aforesaid uncontroverted facts make it amply clear that the
respondent never had raised any grievance against the petitioner
which is criminal in nature at the stage of detection of defects in
materials and even immediately thereafter also. The case record of the
CR case No.3/2018, the supporting documents and the allegations
contained therein do not reveal that the petitioner at any point of time
had undertaken to replace the entire material supplied to the
respondent.
13.
There is no materials to prima facie satisfy the ingredients
constituting the alleged offences under Sections 406, 418, 420, 422,
425 and 427 IPC. Even if the allegations and the documents appended
to the CR case No. 3/2018 are taken in their face value, none of the
ingredients constituting the alleged offences are culled out.
The
learned counsel for the respondent did not specifically argue on the
ingredients of the offences alleged, except for referring to Section 406
IPC and analyzing the provision of Section 405 IPC to impress upon
the Court about the presence of the ingredients of the aforesaid
Sections of IPC. To attract the offence of criminal breach of trust
under Section 406 IPC, it is mandatory to allege that the accused was
entrusted with property or dominion over it and the accused must have
misappropriated the property or disposed of that property in violation
of such trust. It is not that case of the respondent in the present matter
that the petitioner was entrusted with any property and he has
dishonestly misappropriated the property.
Further, there is no
allegation in the complaint that the petitioner had fraudulent and
dishonest intention from the very beginning of the transaction with the
respondent. It is required to be noted that as per the order placed by
the respondent, the petitioner made supply of Grinding Media Balls.
Even after the detection of the defects in the materials on 12-05-2016,
the respondent vide e-mail dated 28-05-2016 made assurance to pay
the remaining balance; in fact an amount of rupees 3 (three) lakhs was
paid on 07-06-2016 vide RTGS to the petitioner as part payment.
Therefore, it cannot be said that a prima-facie case under Sections 418
and 420 has been made out against the petitioner. Insofar as, section
422 IPC is concerned, the complaint and the materials on record do
not project that the petitioner incurred a debt or demand and that the
petitioner prevented that said debt or demand due to himself from
being available to the respondent. It is thus obvious that there exists
no ingredient of Section 422 IPC. Section 425 IPC defines mischief
and does not prescribe any punishment. Section 427 IPC prescribes
punishment for committing mischief and thereby causing loss or
damage to the amount of fifty rupees or more.
To maintain a
complaint on the allegation of mischief, there must be an accusation
of causing destruction of some property or any change in it or in its
situation resulting in destruction or diminish its value or utility, or
affect it injuriously. In the complaint filed by the respondent, there is
no whisper of any accusation of destruction of any property or any
change in its situation by the petitioner. The entire complaint filed by
the respondent appears to be frivolous and vexatious.
14.
A perusal of the Trial Court record pertaining to the CR Case
No. 3/2018 reveals that on the filing of the complaint, the complainant
was examined and the Trial Court issued bailable warrant against the
complainant at the very first instance by order dated 30-10-2018.
Subsequently, by another order dated 20-11-2018, the Trial Court
issued the non-bailable warrant of arrest against the complainant
without ascertaining whether the bailable warrant issued earlier was at
all executed or not. No reason was recorded as to why summon was
not issued at the very first instance. It is important to notice that the
Trial Court before issuing the process, did not even bother to record
whether sufficient grounds for proceedings against the accused exist
or not. The formation of such opinion is required to be stated in the
order itself as per mandate of Section 204 Cr.P.C. The order is liable
to be set aside if no reason is given justifying the issuance of process
against the accused. The first order dated 30-10-2018 passed by the
Trial Court in CR case No.3/2018 reads as follows:“30/10/2018
Seen the endorsement of the Ld.
ADC (J) for disposal of the complaint case filed
U/s 200 Cr.PC by the complainant registered as
CR case No. 3/2018.
The complainant appeared alongwith Ld. Counsel
Shri. S. Pdang.
Statement of the Complainant is taken and
recorded accordingly before this Court today.
Issue BWA of Rs. 50,000 to the accused person
with a copy of the complaint petition.
Fix 28/11/2018 for appearance of the accused
person.”
15.
From the above, it is apparent that no satisfaction with regard to
the existence of sufficient grounds for proceedings against the accused
was recorded by the Trial Court. Thus, the impugned order dated 3010-2018 passed by the Trial Court in the above case is liable to be set
aside on this ground alone. The above view gains support from the
proposition of law laid down by the Apex Court in Lalankumar
Singh and Others versus State of Maharashtra, (2022) SCC OnLine
SC 1383. At paras 38 and 39 of the aforesaid judgment, it is held:“38. The order of issuance of process is not an empty formality.
The Magistrate is required to apply his mind as to whether sufficient
ground for proceeding exists in the case or not. The formation of such
an opinion is required to be stated in the order itself. The order is
liable to be set aside if no reasons are given therein while coming to
the conclusion that there is a prima facie case against the accused. No
doubt, that the order need not contain detailed reasons. A reference in
this respect could be made to the judgment of this Court in the case of
Sunil Bharti Mittal v. Central Bureau of Investigation , which reads
thus:
“51. On the other hand, Section 204 of the Code
deals with the issue of process, if in the opinion of the
Magistrate taking cognizance of an offence, there is
sufficient ground for proceeding. This section relates to
commencement of a criminal proceeding. If the
Magistrate taking cognizance of a case (it may be the
Magistrate receiving the complaint or to whom it has
been transferred under Section 192), upon a
consideration of the materials before him (i.e. the
complaint, examination of the complainant and his
witnesses, if present, or report of inquiry, if any), thinks
that there is a prima facie case for proceeding in respect
of an offence, he shall issue process against the accused.
52. A wide discretion has been given as to grant or
refusal of process and it must be judicially exercised. A
person ought not to be dragged into court merely because
a complaint has been filed. If a prima facie case has been
made out, the Magistrate ought to issue process and it
cannot be refused merely because he thinks that it is
unlikely to result in a conviction.
53. However, the words “sufficient ground for
proceeding” appearing in Section 204 are of immense
importance. It is these words which amply suggest that
an opinion is to be formed only after due application of
mind that there is sufficient basis for proceeding against
the said accused and formation of such an opinion is to
be stated in the order itself. The order is liable to be set
aside if no reason is given therein while coming to the
conclusion that there is prima facie case against the
accused, though the order need not contain detailed
reasons. A fortiori, the order would be bad in law if the
reason given turns out to be ex facie incorrect.”
39. A similar view has been taken by this Court in the
case of Ashoke Mal Bafna (supra).
16.
In the case of Inder Mohan Goswami (supra) at paras 46 and
51, it was held that the Court must ensure that the criminal
prosecution is not used as an instrument of harassment or for seeking
private vendetta or with ulterior motive to pressurize the accused. It
was also held that issuance of non-bailable warrant of arrest involves
interference with personal liberty. Arrest and imprisonment means
deprivation of the most precious right of an individual. The Courts
have to be extremely careful before issuing non-bailable warrant of
arrest.
In the case of Medmeme, LLC (supra), it was held that the
Court is to see whether dispute between the parties is essentially of
civil in nature or any case is made out against the accused for
launching criminal prosecution under Sections of law as alleged in the
complaint.
The observation made in the case of Govind Prasad Kejriwal
(supra) cited by the petitioner is based on the factual background of
that case. However, what can be gathered from therein is that even
after consideration of the allegation in the complaint as they are, if no
prima-facie case is made out, to continue criminal proceedings against
the accused will be abuse of process of Court and Law.
In the case of Sushil Sethil (supra) on the background of
absence of specific allegations against the Managing Director or even
the Director, it was held that the Penal Code does not contain any
provision for attracting vicarious liability on the part of the Managing
Director or the Director of the Company when the accused is the
company. It was further observed and held that the vicarious liability
of the Managing Director and Director would arise provided any
provision exists in that behalf in the statute. It was further observed
that the statute indisputably must contain provision fixing such
vicarious liability. It was further observed that even for the said
purpose, it is obligatory on the part of the complainant to make
requisite allegation which would attract the provision containing
vicarious liability.
In the case of Chanchalpati Das (supra), it was held that
unexpected inordinate delay must be taken into consideration as a very
crucial factor and a ground for quashing a criminal complaint.
17.
The case-laws cited by the learned Senior counsel for the
respondent reported in i) State of Haryana & Ors. Vs. Bhajan Lal
(supra), ii) Lalmuni Devi (Smt) (supra), iii)Zandu Pharmaceutical
Works Limited (supra) have been carefully taken into consideration by
this Court while appreciating the facts and circumstances of the
present case. There is no quarrel with the proposition of law laid
down therein. However, in view of the averments and allegations
maid in the complaint, the decisions cited are not of much help to the
respondent’s case before this Court.
18.
Having gone through the averments and documents appended to
the complaint in the CR case No.3 of 2018 and having anxiously
considered the submissions made by the parties, it emerges that the
learned Trial Court did not even bother to adhere to the provisions of
law contained in Section 204 Cr.P.C. before issuing process and
mechanically proceed to issue bailable warrant and non-bailable
warrant against the petitioner. There is no clear statement in the
complaint as to how and what manner the petitioner, being the
Director/partner of Ms. Mittal Alloy Casting Company, was
responsible for the conduct of the entire transaction with the
respondent.
The allegations contained in the
complaint and the
materials on record do not even make out a prima facie case for
offences under Sections 406, 418, 420, 422, 425 and 427 IPC. The
fact that the assurance made vide e-mail dated 28-05-2016 for making
the remaining payment, and subsequent payment of rupees 3(three)
lakhs on 07-06-2016 as part payment by the respondent to the
petitioner, by itself makes the complaint and the proceeding vexatious,
frivolous and mala-fide. In the opinion of this Court, the criminal
machinery set in motion by filing the complaint for alleged offences
which had taken place more than two years ago is an act of sheer
misuse and abuse of process of the Court.
19.
In view of the discussions made above and in the light of
aforestated legal position, this criminal petition under Section 482
Cr.P.C succeeds. The Criminal proceeding emanating from the CR
case No. 3 of 2018 pending in the Court of Additonal Deputy
Commissioner (J) East Jaintia Hills District, Khliehriat
and the
impugned orders dated 30-10-2018 and 20-11-2018 passed therein
stand quashed and set aside.
20.
Lower Court record be returned forthwith.
21.
This Crl. Petn. No.2 of 2020 stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
27.09.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review