Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 43 of 2022
Debasish Paul,
son of Sri Hiran Chandra Paul,
resident of Bardowali, Madhyapara,
P.S. A.D. Nagar, District- West Tripura
---- Plaintiff-Appellant(s)
Versus
Shri Ratan Debnath,
son of late Joy Chand Debnath,
resident of Gholaghati (Noabari),
P.S. Takarjala, Sub-Division-Bishalgarh,
District-Sepahijala Tripura
----Defendant-Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Sarkar, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of Hearing
:
15.03.2024
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
04.04.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. K. Nath, Learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff-appellant as
well as Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, Learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Sarkar, Learned counsel appearing for the defendant-respondent.
02.
This
appeal
is
challenging
the
judgment
preferred
dated
under
Section
03.03.2022
and
decree
of
CPC
dated
11.03.2022 delivered by Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala
in connection with Title Appeal No.06 of 2019. By the said judgment, the
Learned District Judge has allowed the appeal of the appellant and has
reversed the judgment dated 10.10.2018 and decree dated 13.11.2018
delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala in Title Suit No.113 of 2016.
03.
Before entering into the merit of the appeal, let us project
the subject matter of dispute amongst the parties. The present appellant
as plaintiff filed a suit before the Court of Learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala for a decree of recovery of
possession under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act. The gist of the
case of the appellant-plaintiff was that the suit land measuring 0.225
acres appertaining to khatian No.23685 under mouja-Badharghat, SubDivision-Sadar of West Tripura is owned by one Paritosh Saha and the
said Paritosh Saha entered into an agreement with the plaintiff-appellant
to sell the suit land along with some other lands and in this regard, he
executed a Deed of Agreement vide No.1-4424 dated 12.06.2013 with
the plaintiff-appellant and it was registered. In the agreement it was
mentioned that the price of the suit land shall be Rs.12,37,500/- and in
the agreement it was also mentioned that Sri Paritosh Saha received
Rs.10,00,000/- out of the aforesaid amount and the balance amount of
Rs.2,37,500/- only is to be paid by the plaintiff-appellant to him. The
said Paritosh Saha in spite of receipt of money did not execute and
register the sale deed in favour of the appellant-plaintiff in spite of his
repeated requests and demands and his willingness to pay the balance
amount to him. Finding no other alternative way the appellant-plaintiff
filed the Title Suit bearing No.184 of 2013 for specific performance of
agreement against Sri Saha and the suit was decreed on 17.04.2014.
During pendency of the suit, it came to the knowledge of the appellantplaintiff that said Paritosh Saha may dispose of the suit property for
which the appellant-plaintiff published notices in the newspaper on
11.10.2013, 17.11.2013, 19.11.2013 and 20.11.2013 informing that the
suit property should not be purchased by anybody. However, to establish
his right, the appellant-plaintiff as a precaution also filed a petition for
temporary injunction in the aforesaid Title Suit bearing No.184 of 2013
and the said case was registered as Civil Misc.151 of 2013. After hearing,
Learned Court passed an order of injunction restraining said Paritosh
Saha from disposing of the suit property till finalization of the suit. But
said Saha inspite of injunction order disposed of the suit property to the
respondent-defendant Ratan Debnath violating the provisions of Section
52 of the Transfer of Property Act. Thereafter, the appellant-plaintiff filed
an execution case bearing No.Execution(T)15 of 2014 against said Sri
Saha as well as the present respondent-defendant and both of them
contested the execution case and the Learned Court by order dated
12.03.2015 directed for execution and registration of sale deed in favour
of the appellant-plaintiff and the same was done by Senior Sheristadar of
the District Judge’s Court, West Tripura, Agartala as the said owner in
spite of order of the Court did not turn up. It was further asserted that
the appellant-plaintiff took possession of the suit property on 24.04.2015
but on 25.05.2015 the respondent-defendant forcefully dispossessed the
appellant from the suit land and took possession of the suit land and also
managed to obtain khatian bearing No.23685 most illegally. After that
the appellant-plaintiff filed the suit for recovery of possession of the suit
land.
04.
The respondent-defendant after receipt of notice contested
the suit by filing written statement denying the assertions of the
appellant-plaintiff in the plaint. It was further pleaded that the suit filed
by the appellant-plaintiff was not maintainable as the same was barred
by the provision of Section 47 of CPC. The respondent-defendant further
pleaded that the said Paritosh Saha and the defendant entered into an
unregistered Deed of Agreement on 28.04.2013 and it was executed on
27.12.2013 and as per said agreement, Sri Saha agreed to sell the suit
property to the respondent-defendant for an amount of Rs.35,00,000/and the respondent-defendant accordingly paid the said amount to Sri
Paritosh Saha by three demand drafts. It was further submitted that on
27.12.2013 the respondent-defendant entered into an unregistered Deed
of Agreement for purchase of the suit land with said Paritosh Saha. The
appellant-plaintiff for illegal gain published notices in the newspaper on
several dates and the transfer of the suit land to the respondentdefendant by said Paritosh Saha does not fall within the purview of the
Transfer of Property Act and not hit by Section 52 of the Transfer of
Property Act. It was further submitted that the decree passed in T.S.184
of 2013 and execution case thereafter vide Ex(T)15 of 2014 are nullity
and not enforceable in the eye of law. It was further submitted that the
suit land is under peaceful possession of the respondent-defendant and
finally the respondent-defendant by WS prayed for dismissal of the suit
with costs.
05.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Court below
framed the following issues :
“i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form
and nature ?
ii) Whether the suit is barred by limitation ?
iii) Whether the plaintiff got any cause of action to
institute this suit ?
iv) Whether the plaintiff has right, title and interest
over the suit land ?
v) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to get recovery of
possession over the suit land by evicting the defendant
on removing his hut at the costs of the defendant ?
vi) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to get a decree as
prayed for ?
vii) To what other relief/relief(s), the parties are
entitled according to law ?”
06.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have adduced
oral/documentary evidence on record.
“In order to prove the claim, plaintiff examined two
number of witnesses, namely-
(1) Sri Debasish Paul (plaintiff) – as P.W.1
(2) Sri Dilip Kumar Banik – As P.W.2
The following documents were also exhibited
plaintiff side in support of his claim in the suit :
by
1) Computerized khatian vide no.23685 of MoujaBadharghat in one sheet-(Exbt.1).
2) Certified copy of judgment in TS 184/13 and decree
in 12 sheets (Exbt.2/A to 2/L).
3) Certified copy of order passed in Misc.(Inj.)151/13,
dated 12.11.2013 in three sheets (Exbt.3/A to Exbt.C).
4) Certified copy of registered Sale Deed vide No.11992, dated 24.03.2014 in 11 sheets (Exbt.A to
Exbt.4/K).
5) Certified copy of order, passed in Exe(T)15/14, dated
12.03.2015 in 4 sheets (Exbt.5/A to 5/D).
6) Original registered Sale Deed vide No.1-2419, dated
21.03.2015 in 8 sheets (Exbt.6/A to Exbt.6/H).
7) Certified copy of order, passed in Misc.(Exe)06/15,
dated 28.03.2013 in 4 sheets (Exbt.7/A to Exbt.7/D).
8) Certified copy of Agreement for sale vide no.1-4424,
dated 12.06.2013 in 8 sheets (Exbt.8/A to 8/H).
Defending the suit, the defendant side
examined four number of witnesses, namely(1) Sri Ratan Debnath, defendant-as D.W.1
(2) Sri Ranjit Kr. Saha-as D.W.2
(3) Sri Kshitish Debnath-as D.W.3 and
(4) Smt. Pramila Debnath-as D.W.4
has
also
The following documents were also exhibited by the
defendants side against the claim of the plaintiff :
1) Photo copy of registered Sale deed bearing no.11992, dated 24.03.2014, consisting of 8 sheets after
comparing with the original copy of the same lying with
record bearing no.M.S.29/2015 (Exbt.A).
2) Photo copy of registered Sale deed bearing no.11993, dated 24.03.2014, consisting of 10 sheets after
comparing with the original copy of the same lying with
record bearing no.M.S.29/2015 (Exbt.B).
3) Computer generated copy of Khatian bearing
no.23681 of Mouja & Tahshil-Badharghat, Revenue
Circle-Dukli, Sub-Division-Sadar consisting of one,
(Exbt.C) and ;
4) Computer generated copy of Khatian bearing
no.23685 of Mouja & Tahshil-Badharghat, Revenue
Circle-Dukli, Sub-Division-Sadar consisting of one,
(Exbt.D).
5) Signatures of DW-2 Sri Ranjit Kumar Saha in two sale
deed (Exbt.A/2 and Exbt.B/2).
The Court also examined Sri Sajal Chakraborty as C.W.1
and exhibited his signatures as scribed in two sale
deeds bearing no.1-1992 dated 24.03.2014 and Sale
deed bearing no.1-1993, dated 24.03.2014 (Exbt.A/1
and Exbt.B/1).”
07.
Finally, after hearing arguments of both the sides and on
conclusion of trial Learned trial Court below decreed the suit in favour of
the appellant-plaintiff by judgment and order dated 10.10.2018. For the
sake of convenience, I would like refer herein below the relevant portion
of the order of Learned trial Court which is as follows :
“In the result, this suit is hereby decreed on contest
without costs.
It is hereby declared that plaintiff has the right, title
and interest over the suit land and thereby, is entitled
for decree for recovery of the possession of the suit land
by way of evicting the defendant from the suit land and
by removing the standing hut and all obstructions
therefrom.
The defendant is hereby, directed to hand over the
vacant possession of the suit land mentioned in
schedule-2 of the plaint to plaintiff within 2(two)
months from the date of this judgment and order,
failing which, plaintiff is at liberty to file execution case
for the same before the court.
Thus, the suit is disposed of on contest.
Sheristadar is hereby directed to prepare decree
accordingly and put up the same before me within
15(fifteen) days latest by 26.10.2018.
Record be consigned to the Record Room after lapse of
the appeal period in due compliance.”
08.
Challenging that judgment, the defendant as appellant
preferred an appeal before the Court of Learned District Judge, West
Tripura, Agartala under Section 96 of CPC and the Learned District
Judge, West Tripura, Agartala after hearing arguments of both the sides
allowed the appeal reversing the judgment and decree of the Learned
trial Court in Title Appeal No.06 of 2019. For the sake of convenience, I
would also like to mention herein below the operative portion of the
order of the Learned First Appellate Court which reads as under :
“In the result, this appeal filed by the defendant
appellant stands allowed. As a consequence, the
Judgment and Decree dated 10.10.2018 and 13.11.2018
respectively passed by the Learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in Title
Suit No.113 of 2016 is set aside and the said Title Suit
No.113 of 2016 is dismissed accordingly.
Prepare the appellate decree accordingly.
This Title Appeal stands disposed of on contests.
Send down the L.C. record along with a copy of this
Judgment.
Enter the result in the relevant register as well as in
the CIS.”
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree of the Learned First Appellate Court, the plaintiff as appellant has
preferred this appeal under Section 100 of the CPC before the High
Court.
09.
At the time of admission of appeal by order dated
04.01.2023,
the
following
substantial
question
of
law
has
been
formulated which reads as under :
“(i) Whether the learned Appellate Court misunderstood
and misapplied Section 52 of the Transfer of Property
Act, 1882 ?
(ii) Whether the decree suffers from the principle of lis
pendence ?”
10.
At the time of hearing, Mr. P. Roy Barman, Learned senior
counsel appearing for the appellant-plaintiff submitted that considering
the oral/documentary evidence on record, the Learned trial Court
delivered the judgment in favour of the appellant but the Learned first
appellate Court misinterpreting and misconstruing the factual and legal
aspects reversed the finding of the Learned trial Court.
11.
Mr. Roy Barman, Learned senior counsel further submitted
that the appellant-plaintiff in the suit for Specific Performance of Contract
got decree against the original owner of the suit land, but he did not
comply with the judgment of the Learned trial Court. Finally, the
appellant-plaintiff filed one execution proceeding and in the execution
proceeding, the present defendant and the original owner contested the
same and as per the order of the execution proceeding, the suit deed
was executed and registered in favour of the appellant-plaintiff by the
Sheristadar of the Court and the possession was handed over at the time
of execution and registration of deed. But, later on, the respondentdefendant in collusion with the original owner Paritosh Saha dispossessed
the appellant-plaintiff from the suit land on 25.05.2015.
12.
Mr. Roy Barman, Learned Senior counsel for the appellant-
plaintiff further submitted that the original owner violating the order of
injunction order of the Court executed the sale deed in favour of the
respondent-defendant which was barred by the principle of lis pendence
under Section 52 of TP Act and furthermore, creation of khatian does not
confer any title.
13.
Mr. Roy Barman, Learned Senior counsel further submitted
that in the execution proceeding also, the present respondent-defendant
filed objection which was also dismissed by order dated 28.03.2016 in
case No. Misc.(Exe)6 of 2015 and challenging that order, the respondentdefendant preferred an appeal which was also dismissed. So, considering
all the aspects, the Learned trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the
appellant-plaintiff. Furthermore, during pendency of the said suit and
inspite of issuing injunction order by the Court said Paritosh Saha
transferred the suit land to the respondent-defendant which was barred
in view of the provision provided under Section 52 of TP Act. But the
Learned first appellate Court misinterpreted and misconstrued the factual
and legal aspects and ultimately came to an erroneous finding that no
possession was given to the appellant-plaintiff. So, the question of
dispossession does not arise and ultimately came to an observation that
no possession was given to the appellant-plaintiff. Furthermore, the suit
land was mutated in the name of respondent-defendant vide khatian
No.23685 which remain un-rebutted. The appellant-plaintiff also did not
challenge the order of mutation (Exbt.1) and disbelieved the story of
possession and dispossession of the appellate-plaintiff and finally,
reversed the finding of the Learned trial Court for which Learned Senior
counsel urged for intervention of this Court by allowing the appeal
setting aside the judgment of the First appellate Court and to uphold the
judgment of the Learned trial Court.
14.
Per contra, Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, Learned senior counsel
appearing for the respondent-defendant submitted that as alleged by the
appellant-plaintiff, the civil suit was filed against said Paritosh Saha but
the present respondent-defendant was not a party of the said civil suit
for which the suit was suffering from defect of necessary party.
15.
Mr. Chowdhury, Learned senior counsel further submitted
that as relied upon by Learned trial Court Section 52 of TP Act would not
apply in this case and furthermore, no possession was given to the
appellant-plaintiff by the Court, even, no order was passed for handing
over possession of the suit land to the appellant-plaintiff. So, the story of
possession and dispossession as alleged by the appellant-plaintiff was
nothing but a false and concocted story.
16.
Mr. Chowdhury, Learned senior counsel further submitted
that even the sale deed of the respondent-defendant was not challenged
by the appellant-defendant to any other forum. So, according to Learned
senior counsel for the respondent-defendant, Learned first appellate
Court rightly and reasonably reversed the finding of the judgment of the
Learned trial Court and urged for dismissal of the present appeal with
costs.
17.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and gone
through the records of the Learned Court below very carefully. Here in
this case, it is to be decided whether the judgment of the Learned first
appellate Court is perverse or not. The detailed fact of the case has
already been discussed earlier and now it is on record that the Learned
trial Court below decreed the suit in favour of the present appellantplaintiff which the Learned first appellate Court reversed. The crux
question to be decided is that whether the appellant-plaintiff got
possession of the suit land as per order of the Court or not and if the
appellant got possession of the suit land then the next question will come
regarding the fact of alleged dispossession. Learned counsel for the
respondent-defendant
strongly
objected
the
submission
made
by
Learned senior counsel for the appellant-plaintiff that no possession was
given to the appellant-plaintiff at any point of time rather the suit land
was under peaceful possession of the respondent-defendant and he got
the land mutated in his favour and khatian stands in his favour which has
not been challenged by the appellant-plaintiff. Even, the deed of the
respondent-defendant was also not challenged by the appellant-plaintiff.
It is on record that during pendency of the suit filed by the appellantplaintiff, the suit land was transferred by the original owner Paritosh
Saha in favour of the respondent-defendant violating the order of
injunction passed by the Court in connection with Misc. (Inj.)151 of 2013
dated 12.11.2013 for which the purchase of the respondent-defendant
was barred by the provision of Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act.
Here, I would like to refer herein below the relevant provision of Section
52 of Transfer of Property Act which reads as under :
“52. Transfer of property pending suit relating thereto.-During
the [pendency]
in
any
Court
having
authority [within the limits of India excluding the State
of Jammu and Kashmir] or established beyond such
limits] by [the Central Government] of any suit or
proceeding [which is not collusive and] in which any
right to immoveable property is directly and specifically
in question, the property cannot be transferred or
otherwise dealt with by any party to the suit or
proceeding so as to affect the rights of any other party
thereto under any decree or order which may be made
therein, except under the authority of the Court and on
such terms as it may impose.
[Explanation.-- For the purposes of this section,
the pendency of a suit or proceeding shall be
deemed to commence from the date of the
presentation of the plaint or the institution of the
proceeding in a court of competent jurisdiction,
and to continue until the suit or proceeding has
been disposed of by a final decree or order, and
complete satisfaction or discharge of such decree
or order has been obtained, or has become
unobtainable by reason of the expiration of any
period of limitation prescribed for the execution
thereof by any law for the time being in force.]”
18.
Furthermore, on perusal of Exbts.6/A to 6/H it appears that
at the time of execution of deed on 21.03.2015, the possession of the
suit property was handed over to the appellant-plaintiff. More so, it also
appears that challenging the execution proceeding, the respondentdefendant filed an application under Order 21 Rule 98 to 101 of CPC
which was also dismissed by order dated 28.03.2016 passed in
Misc.(Exe)06 of 2015 and that order was also challenged to the appellate
forum which also has been dismissed by the Learned Appellate Court. So,
the plea of respondent-defendant that suit was defect of necessary party
and the matter was beyond the knowledge of the respondent-defendant
cannot be legally accepted.
19.
Furthermore, the Learned First Appellate Court at the time
of delivery of the judgment came to an observation that no possession
was given to the appellant-plaintiff at the time of execution of deed
which
in
my
considered
view
Learned
First
Appellate
Court
misinterpreted in appreciating the evidence on record because on perusal
of Exbt.6/A to 6/H it is crystal clear that at the time of execution and
registration of the sale deed the suit property was handed over to the
appellant-plaintiff
and
thereafter,
he
was
dispossessed
by
the
respondent-defendant. But the Learned First Appellate Court also came
to the observation that since the khatian stood in the name of
respondent-defendant, so, the presumption will go in favour of the
respondent-defendant is also not tenable as per law and appreciated in
view of established principles of law that khatian does not confer any
title. In Suraj Bhan & Ors. versus Financial Commissioner & Ors.
reported in 2007 Legal Eagle (SC) 451 the Hon’ble Apex Court in para9 of that judgment observed as under :
“9. There is an additional reason as to why we
need not interfere with that order under Article
136 of the Constitution. It is well settled that an
entry in Revenue Records does not confer title on a
person whose name appears in Record of Rights. It
is settled law that entries in the Revenue Records
or Jamabandi have only 'fiscal purpose' i.e.
payment of land-revenue, and no ownership is
conferred on the basis of such entries. So far as
title to the property is concerned, it can only be
decided by a competent Civil Court (vide Jattu Ram
v. Hakam Singh and Ors., AIR 1994 SC 1653). As
already noted earlier, Civil Proceedings in regard to
genuineness of Will are pending with High Court of
Delhi. In the circumstances, we see no reason to
interfere with the order passed by the High Court
in the writ petition.”
But the Learned First Appellate Court at the time of delivery
of judgment did not consider all the legal and factual aspects and
misinterpreted the legal provisions and ultimately reversed the finding of
Learned trial Court which in my considered view Learned First appellate
Court committed serious error and for that, the interference of the Court
is required for meeting up of the principles of natural justice. The
substantial questions of law framed are accordingly answered in favour
of the appellant-plaintiff.
20.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-plaintiff is
hereby allowed on contest with costs against the respondent-defendant.
The judgment dated 03.03.2022 and decree dated 11.03.2022 delivered
by Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Title
Appeal No.06 of 2019 is hereby set aside. The judgment dated
10.10.2018 and decree dated 13.11.2018 delivered by Learned Civil
Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in connection
with Title Suit No.113 of 2016 is hereby upheld and accordingly it is
affirmed.
The case is thus disposed of on contest.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.04.06 17:06:01 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review