The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. Having held so, ordinarily this Court would have remanded the matter for fresh consideration but then it is seen that the petitioner has been litigating since the year 2012 and has had to approach this Court twice earlier. Equitable considerations therefore, militate against further order of remand, more so as this Court finds that the available materials are sufficient to prove the claim of the petitioner over the case land.
15. For the foregoing reasons therefore, the writ application is allowed. The impugned order is set aside. The Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar is directed to make necessary changes in the ROR by recording the name of the petitioner in respect of the case land. The above order shall be carried out within two months from the date of production of certified copy of this order by the petitioner. ……..………………….. Sashikanta Mishra, Judge Orissa High Court, Cuttack, The 23rd April, 2026/ A.K. Rana, P.A. Designation: P.A. Reason: Authentication Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No. 34076 of 2025
An application under Articles 226 & 227 of Constitution of
India.
AFR
--------------...…
Debasis Mohanty
Petitioner
-VersusState of Odisha & others
...….
Opp. Parties
Advocate(s) appeared in this case though hybrid mode :_______________________________________________________
For Petitioner
:
Mr. D.C. Mohanty, Sr. Adv.
with M/s. S.K. Choudhury,
P.K. Das & D.K. Sahoo, Advocates
For Opp. Parties :
Mr. A.R. Dash,
Addl. Government Advocate
_______________________________________________________
JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA
JUDGMENT
23rd April, 2026
SASHIKANTA MISHRA, J.
The petitioner assails the order dated 22.09.2025
passed by the Additional Commissioner, Additional Revision
Court-IV, Odisha, Bhubaneswar in OSS Case No.664 of
2022 in dismissing the said case filed by him.
2.
Facts of the case, briefly stated, are that one
Radhu Nayak was the recorded tenant and owner in
possession of land measuring Ac.1.00 dec. pertaining to
Sabik Plot No. 552/774 under Sabik Khata No. 140/72 in
Mouza Bhola under Chandaka Police Station. Said land
corresponds to Hal Plot Nos. 814 and 815 under Hal Khata
No. 305. The land was leased out to Radhu Nayak as per
order passed in Waste Land Lease Case No. 137/68-69 by
the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar. During subsistence of the
lease, Radhu Nayak sold portions of the land to the
petitioner by executing two registered sale deeds being RSD
No. 2681 dated 27.05.1998 and RSD No. 2682, also dated
27.05.1998, each for Ac.0.62 dec.. The petitioner after
purchase, is continuing to be the owner in possession of the
case land. During the last settlement operation, the draft
record of rights and Yadast was prepared in the name of the
petitioner acknowledging his ownership and possession over
the case land. The Asst. Settlement Officer, Rental Colony,
Bhubaneswar
initiated
a
suo
motu
proceeding
being
Objection Case No. 5811/575 of 2012. By order dated
11.12.2012, the objection case was disposed of refusing to
acknowledge the petitioner’s claim over the case land and by
directing the same to be recorded in the name of State as
Abada Jogya Anabadi. The petitioner challenged such order
before this Court in W.P.(C) No. 28250 of 2013. By order
dated
04.05.2022,
this
Court
disposed
of
the
writ
application directing the petitioner to prefer revision under
Section 15(b) of the Odisha Survey and Settlement Act
against the impugned order. As such, the petitioner filed the
aforementioned revision.
3.
By order dated 06.09.2024, the revision was
rejected on the ground that in the absence of certified copy
of the waste land lease and Hal Sabik index, the flow of title
is not established. It was thus held that the petitioner has
no valid title. It was also held that it was an attempt to grab
government land. The petitioner challenged such order
before this Court in W.P.(C) No. 28753 of 2022 inter alia,
contending that by letter dated 04.05.2005, the Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar had stated that though the WL Case record is
not readily available but upon perusal of the relevant Khata,
the subsistence of the lease in favour of the original lessee
was proved. By order dated 11.08.2025, this Court set aside
the order of the revisional Court and remitted the matter for
fresh consideration by taking note of the aforesaid letter of
the Tahasildar and by calling for the records of the WL Case.
The Revision was thus heard again but by order passed on
22.09.2025, it was dismissed by holding that the petitioner
has no valid title and that it was an attempt made by him to
grab government land by misleading the revisional Court.
Said order is impugned.
4.
Counter affidavit has been filed by opposite
party No.3 justifying the impugned order. It is, inter alia,
stated that though the land was recorded in pattadar status
in the name of the petitioner, the record of right was finally
published recording the land in Government Khata.
5.
Heard
Mr.
D.C.
Mohanty,
learned
Senior
Counsel appearing along with Mr. D.K. Sahoo, learned
counsel for the petitioner and Mr. A.R. Dash, learned Addl.
Government Advocate for the State.
6.
Mr. Mohanty would argue that the impugned
order cannot be sustained for the reason that the burden of
producing the lease case record was erroneously cast upon
the petitioner even though such record is supposed to be
maintained
in
the
office
of
the
concerned
revenue
authorities. In any case, the Tahasildar’s letter dated
04.05.2005 adequately proves that lease was granted in
favour of the petitioner’s vendor and that the same was
never cancelled. The vendor having sold the case land to the
petitioner for his legal necessity by executing two sale deeds,
the same was duly reflected in the draft ROR and Yadast. All
these adequately prove the petitioner’s claim. The revisional
Court has drawn adverse inference against the petitioner
and gone further to hold that his claim is based on fraud
without any basis whatsoever.
7.
Per contra Mr. A.R. Dash, learned Addl.
Government Advocate would submit that the claim of the
petitioner is entirely based on the supposition that his
vendor
was
a
valid
lessee.
Since
the
relevant
records/documents could not be produced, his claim has to
be treated as unproved. According to Mr. Dash therefore,
there is no infirmity in the impugned order warranting
interference by this Court.
8.
After considering the rival submissions and on
going through the pleadings and other materials on record,
this Court finds that the fact that the land in question was
leased out in favour of Radhu Nayak in WL Case No.
137/68-69 is not seriously disputed. The letter dated
04.05.2005, copy of which is available on record as
Annexure-8, also supports the above fact. The said letter is
reproduced below:
“Office of the Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar
To
Sri D.C. Mohanty, Advocate
Sub-
W.L. Case No. 137/1968-69 (Radhu Naik
vrs. State)
Sir,
In response to your petition, I am to say that,
the W.L. Case No. 137/68-69 is not readily
available in this office. But upon perusal of
Khata No. 140/72 of mouza- Bhola it is revealed
that an area of Ac.1.000 pertaining to
correction plot No.552/774 in mouza-Bhola was
granted on lease to one Radhu Naik S/o Ishwar
Naik of Bhola cast-Gopal vide order passed in
W.L. Case No. 137/68-69 by the Tahasildar,
Bhubaneswar. The said lease has not been
cancelled till date.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar”
9.
The petitioner has also enclosed a copy of the
Yadast, where the aforesaid letter has been referred to and
the fact of the property being leased out in favour of Radhu
Nayak and of being sold thereafter to the petitioner has also
been explicitly mentioned. Of course, the ROR was finally
published in the name of the State.
10.
In the counter affidavit, the following is stated
in paragraph-4.
“xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxOn claim of the petitioner with regard to
recording of the land in his favour in Draft Khatian, it is
submitted that in Form-309 (Janch Bother Form) it was noted
that in Jamabandi No.149/62 the land in question was
recorded in the name of Radhu Nayak son of Iswar Nayak in
Pattadar status in Sabik Khata No. 140/72 consisting of Sabik
Plot No. 552/774, Ac.0.62 decimals out of Ac.1.00 decimals.
Sabik Plot No.552/774 corresponds to Hal Plot No. 814 and
similarly Sabik Plot No.552/774 corresponds to Hal Plot No.
875. It is revealed from the above record that Debasis
Mohanty, the present petitioner has been recorded in Pattadar
status in draft ROR in respect of Hal Plot No. 219. In
Objection Case No. 5811/575 of 2012 the case land has been
recorded in Govt. Khata. This deponent has nothing to
comment on other averments made in Para-1 of the writ
petition which are matters of record.”
11.
All these facts and records taken cumulatively
fortify the claim of the petitioner. Though this Court, while
remitting the matter had specifically directed the revisional
Court to consider the effect of letter dated 04.05.2005 of the
Tahasildar, yet the revisional Court has not rendered any
finding in such respect. Obviously, the petitioner himself not
being the lessee but a vendee under the lessee cannot be
expected to produce the lease case record. The custodian of
the lease case record is the Tahasildar, who expressed his
inability to produce the same as it was untraceable. This
Court fails to understand as to why the petitioner should be
blamed for such inability of the Tahasildar. Therefore,
drawing adverse inference by the revisional Court against
the petitioner on such score appears to be entirely
unjustified and unconscionable.
12.
This Court is further surprised to find that the
revisional Court has forayed into the question of fraud
though the same does not appear to have been raised
specifically before him on behalf of the State (Tahasildar). It
is well-settled that fraud has to be specifically pleaded and
proved.
Fraud
cannot
be
presumed.
The
relevant
observations of the revisional Court are reproduced below.
“In view of the foregoing examination of facts and records, it
is thus clear that the petitioner has no valid title in support of
his claims. I do not find any infirmity in the order of Settlement
authorities in keeping the suit land in Government Khata.
Rather, it is an attempt to grab Government land by
misleading this revision court. If the petitioner’s case is to be
considered in the absence of lease records, then vast acres of
Government land, deity land, Jungle land and (common
property resources) will be settled illegally. The petitioner has
not approached this court with clean hands. This is a naked
attempt to mislead the Hon’ble Court and commit the fraud by
way of taking undue advantage as being a senior lawyer and
suppress the fact. Fraud has been defined by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court as follows”
“Fraud
avoids
all
judicial
acts,
ecclesiastical or temporal” observed Chief Justice
Edward Coke of England about three centuries
ago. It is the settled proposition of law that a
judgment or decree obtained by playing fraud on
the court is a nullity and non-est in the eyes of law.
Such a judgment/decree by the first court or by the
highest court has to be treated as nullity by every
court, whether superior or inferior. It can be
challenged in any court even in collateral
proceedings”
“A “fraud” is an act of deliberate
deception with the design of securing something by
taking unfair advantage of another. It is a
deception in order to gain by another’s loss. It is
cheating intended to get an advantage (See S.P.
Changalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath (1994(1)SCC
1)”
13.
This Court fails to understand as to on what
basis the revisional Court arrived at such a conclusion
casting aspirations on the petitioner. The further observation
that “if the case is to be considered in the absence of the
lease records, then vast acres of the government land xxxxxxx
will be settled illegally” is entirely fallacious and speculative.
Such so-called loyalty to the State appears to be unfounded.
It goes without saying that each case has to be considered
on its own merit. Such sweeping and general assumptions
have no place in law as against hard facts. The revisional
Court, instead of rendering a finding as regards acceptability
or otherwise of the available documents including the letter
of the Tahasildar referred above as directed by this Court in
the earlier writ application, has digressed into non-issues.
The impugned order cannot therefore, be sustained.
14.
Having held so, ordinarily this Court would
have remanded the matter for fresh consideration but then it
is seen that the petitioner has been litigating since the year
2012 and has had to approach this Court twice earlier.
Equitable considerations therefore, militate against further
order of remand, more so as this Court finds that the
available materials are sufficient to prove the claim of the
petitioner over the case land.
15.
For the foregoing reasons therefore, the writ
application is allowed. The impugned order is set aside. The
Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar is directed to make necessary
changes in the ROR by recording the name of the petitioner
in respect of the case land. The above order shall be carried
out within two months from the date of production of
certified copy of this order by the petitioner.
……..…………………..
Sashikanta Mishra,
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
The 23rd April, 2026/ A.K. Rana, P.A.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: AJAYA KUMAR RANA
Designation: P.A.
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 23-Apr-2026 14:06:51
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review