Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE
C.O. 3776 of 2024
Sri Deba Pratim Majumder & anr.
Vs.
Arun Dutta & ors.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Dhiraj Trivedi
Mr. Bikash Kumar Singh
For the Opposite Party Nos. 4 to 8
:
Mr. Amal Krishna Saha, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Nandita Baksi
Mr. Souvik Sarkar
Md. Shakeel Khan
Mr. Jane Alam
Heard on
:
28.11.2025
Judgment on
:
30.01.2026
Dr. Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, J.
1.
The petitioners herein have assailed the order dated 20th February,
2024 passed in T.S. 65 of 2015, by which the court below allowed plaintiffs
prayer for amendment of the plaint.
2.
Being aggrieved by the said order passed by learned trial court learned
counsel for the petitioner Mr. Trivedi submits that the opposite parties
herein filed the instant T.S. 65 of 2015
praying for declaration that the
plaintiffs and defendant no. 1 to 5 are joint owners in respect of schedule
mentioned suit property and for preliminary decree for partition and also for
final decree along with other reliefs. Petitioners entered appearance in the
said suit and filed their written statements and thereafter issues have been
framed and the suit was posted for peremptory hearing on 25.07.2017. On
that very date, when the suit was fixed for adducing evidence by the
plaintiff/opposite parties, they came up with the instant application for
amendment of the plaint.
3.
Defendant No. 6 & 7 who are petitioners herein contended in their
written objection that by way of proposed amendment the opposite parties
herein /plaintiffs want to bring on record certain facts which were well
within their knowledge at the time of the filing of the suit. Their further
contention is one Uddharani Dashi became owner of the property after the
death of original owner Benimadhab Das by way of inheritance and
thereafter, she by way of deed of release and relinquishment dated April 4th,
1921 had released and relinquished the suit property in favour of her four
sons who thereafter by a registered deed of conveyance dated 16th August,
1922, had sold the property to Kamini Moni Dashi and the petitioners are
the grand sons of Kamini Mony Dasi, and defendant no. 1 to 5 are their
tenants and as such the question of ownership of Uddharani Dashi is
extraneous and not at all important for the adjudication of the case.
Moreover the application has been made after an inordinate delay and at the
stage of hearing of the suit, as the issues have been framed long back.
4.
He further contended that proposed amendment is not at all required
for proper adjudication of the suit, in view of the fact that Uddharani had
relinquished all her rights in respect of the suit premises way back in the
year 1921 in favour of her sons. The amendment prayed for by the
plaintiff/Opposite parties,
which primarily relates to the contention that
udharani had no right to relinquish the suit property, cannot be agitated
100 years after said transaction and that too by making a prayer for
amendment of the plaint. The proposed amendment is neither proper nor
necessary for adjudication of the suit and if it is allowed, it will change the
nature and character of the suit and would lead to retraction of certain
statements made by the plaintiffs in the plaint. He further argued that since
the issues have already been framed by the trial court for trial, the proviso
to Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure attracts, since hearing of
the suit already commenced and in the absence of any proper explanation
for the delay, such amendment cannot be allowed.
5.
Mr. Trivedi further argued that the petitioners have already obtained a
decree on January, 31st, 1997 against the plaintiff/opposite party in respect
of the suit property and the said decree has been affirmed by this High
Court vide judgment dated 24th April, 2008 and thereafter the instant suit
was filed by the plaintiff with an ill motive to thwart the decree passed in
aforesaid Ejectment Suit no. 726 of 1978. The plaintiff/opposite no. 1 to 3
and 4 to 8 herein are illegally residing in the suit building without paying
any rent.
6.
Moreover, the proposed amendment seeks to set up a case entirely
different from the one originally pleaded. The plaintiffs original suit is
founded upon the averment that Uddharani is the owner of the suit property
in respect of which cause of action for filing the suit arose but now by way of
amendment the plaintiff/opposite parties seek to introduce a new cause of
action stating Udharani had no right title interest over the suit property,
which fundamentally changes the basis of the lis.
7.
It is trite law that an amendment that substitutes or introduces a new
and mutually destructive cause of action is impermissible. In this context he
relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in Modi Spinning and
Weaving Mills Co Ltd. and Ladha Ram and Co. reported in (1976) 4 SCC
320 where it was held that amendments that altered the fundamental
character of the suit or the nature of the case originally pleaded, must not
be permitted. Therefore, plaintiff cannot be allowed to introduce a new case
which is contrary to his earlier pleading. Relying upon another judgment
reported in Vineet Kumar Vs. Mangal Sain Wadhera, reported in (1984) 3
SCC 352, he contended that though it is general rule that amendments are
to be liberally allowed but they cannot introduce a new cause of action or
fundamentally alter the nature of the original pleading. In this context he
also relied upon the judgment of Revajeetu Builders and Developers Vs.
Narayanaswamy and Sons, reported in (2009) 10 SCC 84.
8.
He further argued that plaintiff has sought to amend the plaint after
framing of issue and after commencement of trial and therefore under the
proviso to Order VI rule 17 of CPC they require to show due diligence, but
the OP have failed to meet this requirement. The facts sought to be
introduced were available to the plaintiff at the time of filing of the suit,
demonstrating lack of diligence. Therefore, the proposed amendment which
have been filed to fill up lacuna or to improve his case, cannot be allowed
and as such the instant application is required to be allowed by setting
aside the order impugned.
9.
The learned counsel for the opposite party opposed the prayer made
on behalf of the petitioners and contended that Uddharani Dasi got 3
cottahs of land with building from Beni Madhav Das, wherefrom she sold 1
cottah of land to Umesh Majumder in July, 1911 relating to a non suit
property. She mortgage rest 2 cottah of land with building to Kamini Mohini
Dashi on 16.08.1911. Plaintiffs in their plaint in para 1 have admitted that
Udharani was the absolute owner of the property by way of inheritance. By
the proposed amendment the plaintiffs sought to incorporate the fact that
Udharani had limited interest in the property under the prevailing law of
the land and therefore she had no right to sale or mortgage the property in
the year 1911.
10.
In this context Mr. Saha on behalf of plaintiffs/OP argued that in the
instant case there was no admission as alleged by the petitioners under the
provision of order XII of the Code. In Para 4 to 7 of the plaint, the plaintiff
categorically stated that Udharani repaid the loan and the mortgagor
acknowledged
the
same.
The
property
became
free
from
any
charge/mortgage. The plaintiffs jointly inherited the same and possessed the
same free from all encumbrances and the defendant no. 6 and 7 have not
specifically denied the same and as per provisions of CPC, it amounts to
admission on the part of the defendant no. 6 and 7 about the said
statement. In fact the proposed amendment is only for incorporation of
alternative additional ground of law to prove the title of the plaintiff as
claimed in the suit. The court below has not committed any gross mistake
which calls for interference by this court and as such the instant application
is liable to be dismissed.
Decision
11.
On perusal of the original plaint as well as the written statement filed
by the defendant no. 1 to 5, adopting the averments made in the plaint,
discloses that plaintiffs initial case was that Udharani Dasi was the absolute
owner of 3 cotthas of land and she sold a portion of the property on 4th July,
1911 and in respect of remaining 2 cotthas of land, she created an equitable
mortgage in favour of one Smt. Kamini Moni Dasi, the predecessor of
defendant no. 5 and 6 who are petitioners herein and during her lifetime she
repaid all her loan to the mortgagee Kamini Moni Dasi, in connection with
erstwhile premises no.1/1A Ramdhan Mitra Lane, and thereafter Udhrarani
died intestate on 03.06.1933 leaving behind 5 sons, who inherited the said
property and thereafter the property devolved upon their legal heirs by
succession who are plaintiff and defendant no. 1to 5 in the said suit and
predecessor of defendant no. 6 and 7 Kamini Moni Dasi was allowed by said
Udharani to use and enjoy part of the ground floor northern side of the said
property as a monthly tenant in respect of two rooms under Udharani and
rest portion was possessed by Udharani where she resided with her family
members.
12.
Now by way of amendment the plaintiff wanted to incorporate in the
plaint that Udharnai being the female legal heirs of the deceased original
owner Benimadhav Das had acquired limited interest in the property and
therefore Udharani did not have any right to execute either registered or
non-registered deed before her death during the period 1911 to 1933.
13.
The main objection against the amendment application raised herein
is that plaintiff in his plaint admitted that Udharani became the absolute
owner of the property with the death of her father and accordingly by way of
amendment plaintiffs cannot withdraw such admission by incorporating
statement in the plaint that Udharani being a female member had acquired
only limited interest in the property and as such before her death she
cannot have any right to transfer either by the sale or by way of mortgage
during the period 1911 to 1933.
14.
It is fundamental that the amendment which would render suit
infructuous and/or introduce a totally different new and inconsistent case
and or challenges fundamental character of the suit, should not be allowed.
15.
In Revajeetu Builders and Developers Vs. Narayanaswamy and
sons (supra) the Apex Court on analysing both English and Indian cases
have laid down some basic principles which may be kept in mind while
dealing with applications filed under order VI rule 17, which are though
illustrative and not exhaustive may be reproduced below:1) whether the amendment sought is imperative for proper and effective
adjudication of the case;
(2) whether the application for amendment is bona fide or mala fide;
(3) the amendment should not cause such prejudice to the other side which cannot
be compensated adequately in terms of money;
(4) refusing amendment would in fact lead to injustice or lead to multiple litigation;
(5) whether the proposed amendment constitutionally or fundamentally changes
the nature and character of the case; and
(6) as a general rule, the court should decline amendments if a fresh suit on the
amended claims would be barred by limitation on the date of application.
16.
in Rajesh Kr. Agarwal & other Vs. K.K. Modi & others, reported in
(2006) 4 SCC 385, the Apex Court insisted that the real controversy tests is
the basic or cardinal test and it is the primary duty of the court to decide
whether such an amendment is necessary to decide the real dispute
between the parties
and while considering whether an application for
amendment should or should not be allowed, the court should not go into
the correctness or falsity of the case in terms of the amendment
17.
Therefore, from the aforesaid settled proposition of law relating to
amendment of plaint, I am now required to consider first of all whether the
proposed amendment, if allowed would constitutionally or fundamentally
change the nature and character of the suit and secondly whether such
amendment is necessary to decide the real dispute between the parties.
18.
As I have stated above, even in the original plaint at para 14, the
plaintiff had indicated that plaintiffs and defendant no. 1 to 5 are the
undivided joint owners which they got by way of inheritance from their
predecessor Udharani Dasi who got the same from her paternal side and
during her lifetime she never transferred her said property by way of
“absolute sale or otherwise” in any means whatsoever. Therefore the real
controversy tests in the present context is whether Udharani’s right title
interest in the property in question was limited or not and whether she had
any right to execute deed either registered or unregistered in between the
period 1911 to 1933.
19.
In view of above, it is clear that if the proposed amendment is allowed
it would neither change the cause of action of the suit, nor the relief as
sought for would be materially affected. It is settled law that undoubtedly
categorical admission cannot be resiled from but in a given case it may be
explained or clarified. Offering explanation in regard to admission or
explaining away the same cannot be said to be mutually destructive. In the
instant case what the plaintiff has averred in para 14 that Udharani never
transferred such property by way of absolute sale has been sought to be
explained and/or clarified by way of proposed amendment.
20.
Now in answer to the ground taken by the defendant that the prayer
for amendment is belated one it appears that even if it is belated then also
the question that needs to be decided is whether by allowing the amendment
the real controversy between the parties i.e. whether Udharani was owner of
the property till her death or predecessor of defendant no. 6 and 7
Kaminimoyee Dasi acquired Title in the property during the life time of
Udharani needs to be resolved in the instant suit. A belated amendment
cannot be refused if it is found that for deciding the real controversy
between the parties, it is required to be allowed on payment of costs,
because in such cases the court must bear in favour of doing full and
complete justice in the case where the party against whom the amendment
is to be allowed can be compensated by costs and/or by allowing him to file
additional written statement.
21.
In the instant case by the proposed amendment the plaintiff has not
sought for any additional relief in the plaint. Even after the proposed
amendment the suit will remain confined to the relief as prayed in the
original plaint which is for a declaration that the plaintiffs and the
defendant no. 1 to 5 are the joint owners in respect of the property
mentioned in the scheduled to the plaint and thereby to pass a decree for
partition and for permanent injunction along with other reliefs. Therefore
the subsequent fact which basically involves the question of law is required
to be included to adjudicate the matter completely.
22.
This is also because there cannot be any estoppel against the statue.
In the instant case one of the issue that will have to be considered by the
trial court is whether under the prevailing statute Udharani had any right to
execute registered or unregistered deed and in the event of execution of such
deed, what would be its fate. In fact the legal point that has been sought to
be incorporated by way of amending the plaint has certain impact over the
main relief for declaration of title as sought for in the suit. For the same
reason, though in paragraph no.1 of the plaint, plaintiff has stated that
predecessor-in-title of the plaintiffs and defendants no. 1 to 5, Uddharani
Dasi was the absolute owner of the property, but from the facts and
circumstances of the case, it is clear that such admission even if made is
not conclusive and subject to court’s scrutiny. Amendment of plaint cannot
be refused simply because it seeks to withdraw or seeks to explain the
admission already made. It in fact depends upon facts and particulars of
each case. In the instant case aforesaid alleged admission that Uddharani
had absolute title in the suit property does not depend upon admission
because admission does not create title and therefore not conclusive and
may or may not be held to be erroneous. Therefore, as the same is a triable
issue, the proposed amendment cannot be refused.
23.
It is well settled that the dominant purpose of allowing the
amendment is to minimize litigation. If the granting of amendment really
subserve the ultimate cause of justice and avoids further litigation, the same
should be allowed. In my opinion the proposed amendment shall not
introduce a different case when the necessary factual basis that predecessor
of defendant no. 5 and 6 never acquired title in the property had already
been laid down in the plaint in regard to the plaintiffs title. Furthermore by
way of proposed amendment plaintiff does not want for deletion of any
statement relating to any alleged admission nor he has prayed for
substitution of one set of fact in the place of facts already stated in the
pleading or in the evidence and as such I do not find any reasons as to why
the plaintiffs prayer for amendment shall not be allowed, specially when
proposed amendment, if allowed, would not change the nature of the suit or
the cause of action, so as to set up an entirely new case, foreign to the case
set up in the plaint
24.
Therefore in view of above discussion it is clear that plaintiff had not
made any fresh allegation or sought to be added fresh relief by way of
amendment but only tried to clarify the existing pleading, which does not in
substance add to or alter the existing pleading. Therefore I find that the
order of the court below allowing the proposed amendment does not suffer
from any impropriety or perversity which can call for interference by this
court invoking this court’s jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India.
25.
C.O. 3776 of 2024 thus stands dismissed.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the
parties, on priority basis on compliance of all usual formalities.
(Dr. AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review