Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:15618
Digitally
signed by
JYOTI
SHARMA
JYOTI
SHARMA Date:
2026.04.07
10:50:49
+0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SA No. 577 of 2025
Dashrath Lal S/o Late Keja Ram Sahu Aged About 54 Years R/o
Village- Bhawarmara, Post- Singhola, Tahsil And DistrictRajnandgaon (C.G.)
... Appellant(s)
versus
1. Ghanshyam Gupta S/o Kishan Gopal Gupta Aged About 46
Years R/o Village- Bhawarmara, Post- Singhola, Tahsil And District
- Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
2. Sarpanch Village Panchayat Bhawarmara, Post- Singhola,
Tahsil And District - Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
3. State Of Chhattisgarh Through Collector District - Rajnandgaon
(C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Ashok Patil, Advocate
For Respondent/
State
: Mr. Lekhram Dhruv, P.L.
Hon'ble Shri Bibhu Datta Guru, Judge
Judgment on Board
06.04.2026
1. The plaintiff/appellant has preferred this second appeal under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for brevity
CPC) against the judgment & decree dated 10.09.2025
passed by the Learned 3rd Additional District Judge,
Rajnandgaon C.G. in Civil Appeal No. 63A/2024 ( Dashrath
Lal & Ghanshyam & Ors.) arising out of the judgment and
decree dated 06.07.2024 passed by the Trial Court in Civil
Suit No. 93A/2018 (Dashrath Lal & Ghanshyam
& Ors.)
whereby the learned trial Judge has dismissed the suit of the
plaintiff/ appellant. For the sake of convenience, the parties
would be referred as per their status before the learned trial
Court.
2. The plaintiff instituted a Civil suit seeking declaration of title
over the property described in Schedule ‘A’ and a decree of
permanent injunction pleading inter alia that pursuant to
resolution No. 6 dated 10.10.2009 of the Gram Panchayat
and order dated 12.11.2009, an abadi patta in respect of land
bearing Khasra No. 696/1, Plot No. 113, admeasuring 2½
dismil, situated at Village Bhanwarmara, Patwari Halka No.
25, Tahsil and District Rajnandgaon, was granted in his
favour. It is pleaded that the plaintiff has been in peaceful
possession of the said land since the year 2000 and has
constructed a kutcha house in the year 2002, where he
resides and carries on his tailoring business. Out of the said
land, the plaintiff has constructed a house over 330 sq. ft. and
the remaining portion has been enclosed by a pakka
boundary wall. It is further pleaded that the mother of
defendant No.1, namely Laxmibai, had also been granted
abadi patta for 2½ dismil land in the same village; however,
Laxmibai and defendant No.1 allegedly made unauthorized
construction over an area measuring 47 × 48 feet. The
plaintiff lodged complaints before the competent authorities in
this regard, due to which defendant No.1 started harbouring
animosity towards the plaintiff and has been attempting to
dispossess him from the suit property with the help of
members of the Gram Panchayat. It is further stated that on a
complaint made by defendant No.1, a revenue case bearing
No. 45-बी/131 for the year 2015–16 was initiated before the
Naib Tahsildar, Rajnandgaon, which was decided by order
dated 02.06.2017.
3. The defendants No.1 and 2 filed their written statement
denying the averments made in the plaint and contended that
the patta relied upon by the plaintiff is forged and fabricated. It
is pleaded that upon a complaint made by defendant No.1,
the matter was duly enquired into by the competent
authorities and the Gram Sabha in its meeting dated
25.06.2014 cancelled the earlier Resolution No.6, by which
the alleged patta had been granted, and also passed
Resolution No.3 recommending action against the then
Sarpanch. It is further pleaded that on the complaint of
defendant No.1, a revenue case bearing No.45-ब/121 for the
year 2015–16 (Ghanshyam Gupta Vs. Dashrath Sahu) was
registered before the Naib Tahsildar, Rajnandgaon and the
matter was travelled to the Sub-Divisional Officer for
appropriate decision. The Sub-Divisional Officer, by order
dated 20.06.2017, upheld the resolution of the Gram Sabha
cancelling the patta and directed initiation of encroachment
proceedings
against
the
plaintiff.
According
to
the
defendants, the plaintiff has illegally encroached upon
Government land on the basis of a forged patta, whereas the
mother of defendant No.1, Laxmibai, had been validly granted
a patta by the Gram Panchayat and is in lawful possession
thereof. On these grounds, the defendants prayed for
dismissal of the suit.
4. After framing the issues and upon due appreciation of the oral
as well as documentary evidence available on record, the
Trial Court, upon appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence adduced by the parties, held that though an Abadi
Patta in respect of the suit land bearing Khasra No. 696/1,
Plot No. 113 admeasuring 2½ dismil situated at Village
Bhanwarmara was issued in favour of the plaintiff by the
Gram
Panchayat,
the
material
available
on
record,
particularly the Gram Sabha resolution and the orders passed
by the competent revenue authorities, established that the
said Patta had been issued in a fraudulent manner and was
subsequently cancelled. The Court further observed that
since the Patta forming the very basis of the plaintiff’s claim
stood cancelled (Ex. D-5), the plaintiff failed to establish any
lawful right, title or interest over the suit property.
Consequently, the Trial Court concluded that the plaintiff was
not entitled to the relief of declaration of title or permanent
injunction.
5. Aggrieved
by the said judgment and decree dated
06.07.2024, the plaintiff preferred a First Appeal under
Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure before the learned
First Appellate Court. The learned First Appellate Court, on
re-appreciation of the entire evidence on record, affirmed the
findings recorded by the Trial Court and dismissed the appeal
by the impugned judgment. Hence, the present appeal.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the impugned
judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below are
perverse and contrary to the material available on record. It is
contended that the appellant was granted an Abadi lease on
12.11.2009 by the competent authority, which establishes his
right over the suit property, but the same has not been
properly appreciated by the Courts below. It is further
submitted that the said lease was cancelled without affording
any opportunity of hearing to the appellant, thereby violating
the principles of natural justice. Learned counsel also argues
that the dismissal of the suit on the ground of non-compliance
with Section 246 of the Chhattisgarh Land Revenue Code,
1959 is erroneous and therefore the impugned judgments
deserve to be set aside.
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the appellant on the question
of admission, and the impugned judgments and decrees
passed by the learned trial Court as also the learned First
Appellate Court have been carefully examined.
8.
The Lower Appellate Court, on re-appreciation of the entire
oral and documentary evidence on record, affirmed the
findings recorded by the Trial Court and held that the plaintiff
had failed to establish any lawful right or title over the suit
property. The Court observed that although the plaintiff relied
upon an Abadi Patta dated 12.11.2009 allegedly issued
pursuant to the Gram Panchayat resolution, the evidence
adduced by the defendants, particularly the revenue records,
encroachment report, Panchanama, eviction warrant and the
proceedings of the Gram Panchayat meeting, clearly
established that the said Patta had been fraudulently entered
in the proposal register and was subsequently cancelled by
the Gram Panchayat by resolution dated 25.06.2014. The
Appellate Court further noted that the plaintiff himself
admitted during cross-examination that encroachment
proceedings had been initiated against him and that an
eviction warrant had been issued in respect of the
government land bearing Khasra No. 696/1. In view of these
facts, the Appellate Court concurred with the Trial Court that
the plaintiff failed to prove his entitlement to the relief of
declaration and permanent injunction, and accordingly
dismissed the appeal while affirming the judgment and
decree passed by the Trial Court. Accordingly, the judgment
and decree dated 06.07.2024 passed by the trial Court was
affirmed and the appeal was dismissed.
9.
Even otherwise, the scope of interference in a Second Appeal
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is extremely
limited. Interference is permissible only when the appeal
involves a substantial question of law. Concurrent findings of
fact recorded by both the Courts cannot be interfered with
unless such findings are shown to be perverse, based on no
evidence, or contrary to settled principles of law.
10.
In the present case, both the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court have concurrently recorded findings, on the
basis of evidence available on record, that the appellants/
plaintiffs failed to establish their case by placing cogent and
sufficient material. The appellants have failed to demonstrate
any perversity, illegality, or misapplication of law in the
findings so recorded.
11.
The questions sought to be raised in the present Second
Appeal essentially relate to re-appreciation of evidence and
challenge to concurrent findings of fact. Such questions do
not give rise to any substantial question of law within the
meaning of Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
12.
It is well established that when there is a concurrent finding of
fact, unless it is found to be perverse, the Court should not
ordinarily interfere with the said finding.
13.
In the matter of State of Rajasthan and others Vs. Shiv
Dayal and another, reported in (2019) 8 SCC 637, reiterating
the settled proposition, it has been held that when any
concurrent finding of fact is assailed in second appeal, the
appellant is entitled to point out that it is bad in law because it
was recorded de hors the pleadings or based on misreading
of material documentary evidence or it was recorded against
any provision of law and lastly, the decision is one which no
Judge acting judicially could reasonably have reached.
14.
Be that as it may, the argument advanced by learned counsel
for the appellants and the proposed question of law cannot be
regarded as satisfying the test of being ‘substantial question
of law’ within the meaning of Section 100 of CPC. These
questions, in my view, are essentially question of facts. The
appellants failed to raise any substantial question of law
which is required under Section 100 of the CPC. In any event,
the Second Appeal did not involve any substantial question of
law as contemplated under Section 100 of the CPC, no case
is made out by the appellants herein. The judgments
impugned passed by the learned trial Court as as well as by
the learned First Appellate Court are just and proper and
there is no illegality and infirmity at all.
15.
On perusal of the record of the case and in view of the above
settled legal proposition, I find absolutely no merit in this
appeal, involving no question of law much less substantial
question of law within the meaning of Section 100 of the CPC.
In my view, the judgment and decree passed by both the
Courts appear to be just, proper and legal. The findings
recorded are based on proper appreciation of evidence
available on record and there is no illegality or perversity in
the same and they does not call for any interference.
16.
Consequently, the Second Appeal fails and is hereby
dismissed resulting in upholding the judgment and decree
passed by the learned Appellate Court.
SD/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Jyoti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review