Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/38
GAHC040014542025
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
WP(C)/295/2024
Tomin Ete and 2 Ors
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late T Ete
resident of Vivek Vihar
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papumpare District
Arunachal Pradesh
2: Vijay Passing
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Ano Passing
resident of Parbuk Village
PO and PS Roing
Lower Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh
3: Sawimso Tayeng
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tuku Tayeng
permanent resident of Rangan Village
PO Hayuliang
PS Khupa
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The State of AP and 17 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Commissioner/ Secretary
Page No.# 2/38
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
2:Dollo Pura
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
3:Jobom Bam
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
4:Donya Lollen
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:Oni Ejing
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 3/38
6:Haniya Nabam Hina
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
7:Nabam Titu
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
8:Jumdo Kena
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
9:Hukkar Taipodia
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
10:Migo Basar
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 4/38
11:Gyati Tani
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
12:Dojum Lollen
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
13:Rajen Mudang
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
14:Miss Nampi Boli
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
15:Ringgong Bitin
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 5/38
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
16:Smti Mum Tapak
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
17:Tumbom Angu
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
18:Pura Butang
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner / Secretary
Hydro Power Development Department
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Nikita Danggen
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 17 Ors: Advocate ,
,
,
,
,
,
,
Page No.# 6/38
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14,
15,
16,
Page No.# 7/38
17,
18, respectively.
WP(C)/14/2022
Tomin Ete and 2 Ors.
Age: 67
Occupation :
Address:S/o Late T. Ete
Resident of Vivek Vihar
Itanagar
P.O/P.S Itanagar
District Papumpare
Arunachal Pradesh
2: Vijay Passing
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:S/o Ano Passing
Permanent Resident of Parbuk Village
P.O/P.S Roing
Lower Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh
3: Sawimso Tayeng
Age: 57
Occupation :
Address:S/o Lt. Tuku Tayeng
Permanent Resident of Rangan Village
P.O Hayuliang and P.S Khupa
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The State of AP and 13 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Represented by the Chief Secretary
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar cum Chairman
Departmental Promotion Committee held on 31/10/2019
Page No.# 8/38
2:The Commissioner/Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Hydro Power Development Department
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
A.P
3:Haniya Nabam Hina
Age: 37
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Tatik Nabam Hina
presently posted Assistant Engineer(Civil)
Seppa Division
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4:Migo Basar
Age: 40
Occupation :
Address:Son of Tomi Basar
presently posted at the office of the CE (Monitoring) DHPD
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:Jumdo Kena
Age: 44
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tajum Kena
presently posted at the office of the CE (Monitoring) DHPD
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6:Hukkar Taipodia
Age: 37
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Mihuk Taipodia
presently posted at the office of the Assistant Engineer
Tirbin Sub Division
Basar
Lepa Rada District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 9/38
7:Dojum Lollen
Age: 42
Occupation :
Address:Son of Kido Lollen
presently posted as Assistant Engineer (Civil) Geku Sub Division
Geku
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8:Nabam Titu
Age: 37
Occupation :
Address:Son of Nabam Tanang
presently posted at the office of the Executive Engineer NERIST
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
9:Gyati Tani
Age: 39
Occupation :
Address:Son of Gyati Taji
presently posted at the office of the Chief Engineer
P and D
DHPD
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
10:Rajen Mudang
Age: 39
Occupation :
Address:Son of Mudang Ranka
presently posted as Assistant Engineer (Civil)
Palin Sub-Division
Kra Daadi District
Arunachal Pradesh.
11:Dollo Pura
Age: 44
Occupation :
Address:Son of Pura Tama
C/o the Commissioner/ Secretary
Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 10/38
12:Jobom Bam
Age: 44
Occupation :
Address:Son of Tope Bam
C/o the Commissioner/ Secretary
Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
13:Donya Lollen
Age: 42
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Bindo Lollen
C/o the Commissioner/ Secretary
Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
14:Oni Ejing
Age: 42
Occupation :
Address:C/o the Commissioner/ Secretary
Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Civil Secretariat
Itanagar
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Nikita Danggen
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 13 Ors: Advocate ,
,
,
,
,
,
,
Page No.# 11/38
,
,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13,
14, respectively.
WP(C)/459/2022
Darmar Ete and Anr.
Age: 46
Occupation :
Address:S/o Late Hendar Ete
Permanent Resident of Village Darka
PO/PS Aalo
West Siang District
Page No.# 12/38
Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Gola Ravi
Age: 58
Occupation :
Address:S/o Late Gola Krishnaiah
Presently serving as ASW under Chief Engineer (WZ) Jalvidyut Bhawan
Itanagar.
Phone No. 936299087
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP and 2 Ors.
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Represented by the Chief Secretary
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar cum Chairman
Departmental Promotion Committee held on 31.10.2019
2:The Commissioner/Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:(DHP and D) Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:Dollo Pura
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Presently serving as AE
Ziro Division
DPHPD
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : Rintu Saikia
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for THE STATE OF AP and 2 Ors.: Advocate ,
, appearing for 2,
3, respectively.
WP(C)/284/2025
Jumdo Kena and 7 Ors
Age: 44
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Late Tajum Kena
Page No.# 13/38
presently serving as Assistant Engineer(Civil) in the Office of Chief Engineer
(Monitoring)
Department of Hydro Power and Development
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Haniya Nabab Hina
Age: 37
Occupation :
Address:Son of Shri Tatik Nabam Hina
presently posted Assistant Engineer (Civil)
Seppa Division
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Nabam Titu
Age: 37
Occupation :
Address:Son of Nabam Tanang
presently posted at the office of the Executive Engineer NERIST
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Hukkar Taipodia
Age: 37
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Mihuk Taipodia
presently posted Assistant Engineer
Tirbin Sub Division
Basar
Leparada District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Migo Basar
Age: 40
Occupation :
Address:Son of Tomi Basar
presently posted at the Office of Chief Engineer (Monitoring) Department of Hydro
Power Development
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Gyati Tani
Age: 39
Occupation :
Address:Son of Gyati Taji
Page No.# 14/38
presently posted at the Office of Chief Engineer
P and D
Department of Hydro Power Development
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Dojum Lollen
Age: 42
Occupation :
Address:Son of Kido Lollen
presently posted Assistant Engineer (Civil)
Geku Sub Division
Geku
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8: Rajen Mudang
Age: 39
Occupation :
Address:Son of Mudang Ranka
presently posted Assistant Engineer (Civil)
Palin Sub Division
Basar
Kra Daadi District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 7 Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Commissioner
Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
2:The Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
Page No.# 15/38
4:The Under Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Department of Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
5:The 3 member Committee
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:constituted by the Commissioner (Hydro Power Development) Govt of
Arunachal Pradesh vide order dated 30.05.2025 issued on 03.06.2025 under the
Chairmanship of Chief Engineer
Western Zone
Department of Hydro Power Development
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
6:Tommin Ete
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late T Ete
permanent resident of Vivek Vihar
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7:Vijay Passing
Age: 53
Occupation :
Address:Son of Ano Passing
permanent resident of Parbuk Village
PO and PS Roing
Lower Dibang Valley District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8:Sawinso Tayeng
Age: 52
Occupation :
Address:Son of Late Tuku Tayeng
presently permanent resident of Rangan Village
PO Hayuliang
PS Khupa
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
------------
Page No.# 16/38
Advocate for : Dicky Panging
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and 7 Ors: Advocate ,
,
,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8, respectively.
-Before–
Hon’ble MR. JUSTICE sanjay kumar medhi
Date on which judgment is
:
03.02.2026
:
09.02.2026.
Reserved.
Date of pronouncement of
Judgment.
Whether the pronouncement :
is of the operative part of the
judgment?
NA.
Page No.# 17/38
Whether the full judgment
:
Yes.
has been pronounced?
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
All these four writ petitions and interlocutory applications being
connected, the same have been heard together and are disposed of by this
common judgment and order.
2.
Before going into the issues which have arisen for consideration, it would
be necessary to briefly state the basic facts of the cases. Suffice it to mention
that the dispute is with regard to the seniority and consequential benefits
between the promotees and the direct recruits in the Department of Hydro
Power Development. Though the facts are common and overlapping, for the
sake of convenience, the facts of each of the writ petitions, along with the
submissions made are stated separately.
3.
I have heard Shri K.N. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms N.
Danggen,
learned
counsel
for
the
applicants/petitioners
in
I.A.(C)
No.217(AP)/2025;I.A.(C) No.218(AP)/2025 WP(C) No.14(AP)/2022 and WP(C)
No.295(AP)/2024; Shri D. Panging, learned counsel for the petitioners in WP(C)
No.284(AP)/2025;
and
Shri
R.
Saikia,
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioners/applicant in WP(C) No. 459(AP)/2022 and IA(C) No.207(AP)/2025.
Also heard Shri R. H. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General for the State
respondents; Shri D. Mozumdar, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri B.
Kaushik, learned counsel for the respondent Nos.11 to 14 in WP(C)
Page No.# 18/38
No.14(AP)/2022 and for the respondent Nos. 2 to 5 in WP(C) No.295(AP)/2024
and Mr. D. Panging, learned counsel for the respondent Nos.3 to 10 in both the
WP(C) No.14(AP)/2022 and WP(C) No.495(AP)/2022.
WP(C)Nos. 14 of 2022 and 295 of 2024.
4.
There are three petitioners who are common in these two cases. The
petitionerno. 1 was appointed as a Junior Engineer in the erstwhile Power
Department on 24.11.1997, whereas petitioner nos. 2 and 3 were appointed as
Junior Engineers on 17.12.1997. The erstwhile Power Department was
subsequently bifurcated and the Department of Hydro Power Development
came into being. It is also not in dispute that there is a set of Rules, namely,
“Recruitment to the Posts of Assistant Engineer Rules, 2005”. The Schedule to
the Rules provides the mode of induction into the services, which can be either
by direct recruitment or by promotion. Promotion can be made from amongst
the Junior Engineers who have served for a particular length of time, depending
upon whether they are Degree holders or Diploma holders and who have
qualified in an accounting examination. The petitioners claim to have attained
such eligibility in December 2002. The petitioners were accordingly allowed to
officiate as Assistant Engineers in the Department in the year 2005 and 2007.
Thereafter, vide an order dated 04.02.2009, the petitioners were given the pay
scale of Assistant Engineer. The private respondents are direct recruits to the
post of Assistant Engineer, appointed in the years, 2009 and 2012.
5.
As the cases of the petitioners for regular promotion was not considered,
the petitioners had earlier filed two writ petitions, WP(C) No. 574 of 2016 and
WP(C) No. 26 of 2016, with a prayer to constitute a Departmental Promotion
Committee (hereinafter referred to as “DPC”). The said writ petitions were
Page No.# 19/38
disposed of vide an order dated 16.01.2017, pursuant to which a DPC was
convened and on 31.10.2019, the petitioners were given substantive promotion
to the post of Assistant Engineer. The petitioners submitted representations
seeking grant of retrospective effect to their promotions. Consequently, vide an
order dated 19.05.2020, a Sub-Committee was constituted to consider the
representations, which held its meeting on 23.06.2020. The Committee was of
the opinion that the representations submitted by the promotees and the direct
recruits were required to be considered and the matter was accordingly referred
to the Administrative Reforms Committee.
6.
The grievance of the petitioners is with regard to the non-grant of
retrospective effect to their promotions from at least the year 2009, in which
case they would be treated as senior to the private respondents who were
subsequently appointed as Assistant Engineers by direct recruitment. The
grievance is also against the decision to treat the petitioners as members of the
cadre of Assistant Engineer only with effect from 31.10.2019.
7.
Shri K. N. Choudhury, learned senior counsel for the petitioners has
submitted that from the year 2002, the petitioners became eligible for
promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer in terms of the Rules, both in
respect of length of service as well as educational qualification. However, no
DPC was conducted and in the meantime, the petitioners were allowed to
officiate as Assistant Engineers in the years 2005 and 2007 and subsequently,
on 04.02.2009, they were also given the pay scale of Assistant Engineer. He has
submitted that the petitioners cannot be faulted or blamed for not holding of the
DPC and therefore, they cannot be made to sufffer. He has further submitted
that the seniority list subsequently published, whereby the petitioners have
Page No.# 20/38
been shown to be junior to the private respondents, is liable to be interfered
with and the seniority is required to be recast.He has also submitted that during
the pendency of the present writ petitions, a Committee was constituted on
30.05.2025 for re-examining the issue and the numerous representations.
However, the same is the subject matter of challenge in a connected writ
petition, being WP(C) No. 284 of 2025 instituted by certain direct recruits. He
has submitted that the said writ petition was instituted on a fallacious notion
and without disclosure of all relevant facts. He has submitted that the challenge
in WP(C) No. 284 of 2025 was on the ground of alleged violation of the
principles laid down by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in Akaddas Ali
vs. State of Assam and Others., reported in 2014 (4) GLT 55, wherein it was laid
down that when the Court is in seisin of a matter, the administrative authority
should not act on the same. He submits that the interim order dated 27.06.2025
was, in fact, based on the principles laid down in Akaddas Ali.
8.
The learned senior counsel submits that the facts and circumstances of the
case of Akaddas Ali (supra) are completely different and therefore, the said
principles are not applicable in the present case. He has also drawn the
attention of this Court to the order dated 19.01.2022 passed in WP(C) No. 14 of
2022, wherein an observation was made that the pendency of the writ petition
shall not be a bar to re-consideration of the representations submitted on the
issue of seniority and this aspect was not brought to the notice of the Court.
9.
Accordingly, Shri Choudhury, learned senior counsel submits that a
direction be issued to reckon the petitioners as senior to the private respondents
or, in the alternative, to remit the matter to the Administrative Department to
take a final decision as per the order dated 30.05.2025. He has submitted that
Page No.# 21/38
there is no bar in law for the administration to review an earlier decision.
10. In support of his submissions, Shri Choudhury, the learned senior counsel
has drawn the attention of this Court to the following case laws:
(i)
Direct
Recruit
Class
II
Engineering
Officers’Association Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others
reported in (1990) 2 SCC 715
(ii)
State of West Bengaal and Others Vs. Aghore Nath
Dey reported in(1993) 3 SCC 371
(iii)
N. K. Chouhan and Others Vs. State of Gujarat and
Others reported in (1977) 1 SCC 308
(iv)
Radha Mohan Malakar and Others Vs. Usha
RanjanBhattacharjee and Others reported in(2009) 14 SCC
(v)
Union of India and Others Vs. N. R. Banerjee and
Others reported in (1997) 9 SCC 287
(vi)
R. R. Verma and Others Vs. Union of India and Others
reported in (1980) 3 SCC 402
(vii)
B. S. Mathur and Another Vs. Union of India and
Others reported in(2008) 10 SCC 271
11. The case of Direct Recruit (supra) has been cited wherein, a Constitution
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down the principles to be followed
for determining the inter-se seniority between direct recruits and promotees. For
Page No.# 22/38
ready reference, the relevant observations are extracted hereinbelow:
“44. To sum up, we hold that:
(A) Once an incumbent is appointed to a post according to rule, his seniority
has to be counted from the date of his appointment and not according to the
date of his confirmation.
The corollary of the above rule is that where the initial appointment is only ad
hoc and not according to rules and made as a stop-gap arrangement, the
officiation in such post cannot be taken into account for considering the
seniority.
(B) If the initial appointment is not made by following the procedure laid down
by the rules but the appointee continues in the post uninterruptedly till the
regularisation of his service in accordance with the rules, the period of
officiating service will be counted.
(C) …”
12. The case of Aghor Nath Dey (supra) has been cited so as to bring home
the explanation/clarification given on the principles laid down in the Direct
Recruit case (supra). For ready reference, the relevant observations of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court are extracted hereinbelow:
“21. We shall now deal with conclusions (A) and (B) of the Constitution Bench
in the Maharashtra Engineers' case, quoted above.
…
25. In our opinion, the conclusion (B) was added to cover a different kind of
situation, wherein the appointments are otherwise regular, except for the
deficiency of certain procedural requirements laid down by the rules. This is
clear from the opening words of the conclusion (B), namely, 'if the initial
Page No.# 23/38
appointment is not made by following the procedure laid down by the ‘rules'
and the later expression 'till the regularisation of his service in accordance with
the rules'. We read conclusion (B), and it must be so read to reconcile with
conclusion (A), to cover the cases where the initial appointment is made against
an existing vacancy, not limited to a fixed period of time or purpose by the
appointment order itself, and is made subject to the deficiency in the procedural
requirements prescribed by the rules for adjudging suitability of the appointee
for the post being cured at the time of regularisation, the appointee being
eligible and qualified in every manner for a regular appointment on the date of
initial appointment in such cases. Decision about the nature of the appointment,
for determining whether it falls in this category, has to be made on the basis of
the terms of the initial appointment itself and the provisions in the rules. In
such cases, the deficiency in the procedural requirements laid down by the rules
has to be cured at the first available opportunity, without any default of the
employee, and the appointee must continue in the post uninterruptedly till the
regularisation of his service, in accordance with the rules. In such cases, the
appointee is not to blame for the deficiency in the procedural requirements
under the rules at the time of his initial appointment, and the appointment
notbeing limited to a fixed period of time is intended to be a regular
appointment, subject to the remaining procedural requirements of the rules
being fulfilled at the earliest. In such cases also, if there be any delay in curing
the defects on account of any fault of the appointee, the appointee would not
get the full benefit of the earlier period on account of his default, the benefit
being confined only to the period for which he is not to blame. This category of
cases is different from those covered by the corollary in conclusion (A) which
relates to appointment only on ad hoc basis as a stopgap arrangement and not
according to rules. It is, therefore, not correct to say, that the present cases can
fall within the ambit of conclusion (B), even though they are squarely covered
by the corollary in conclusion (A).”
13. In the case of N. R. Banerjee (supra) the aspect of preparation of a yearly
Page No.# 24/38
panel for the purpose of promotion has been held to be mandatory. It is
submitted that the petitioners cannot be blamed for not conducting a DPC in
spite of they being eligible in the year 2002 itself. The relevant observations of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court made in the aforesaid case read as follows:
“12. Considered from that perspective, the question ariseswhether the view
taken by the Tribunal is justified in law. It is true that filling up of the posts are
for clear or anticipated vacancies arising in the year. It is settled law that mere
inclusion of one's name in the list does not confer any right in him/her to
appointment. It is not incumbent that all posts may be filled up. But the
authority must act reasonably, fairly and in public interest and omission thereof
should not be arbitrary. In Shankarasan Dash v. Union of India [(1991) 2 SCR
567], the Constitution Bench had held that inclusion of the name of a candidate
in a merit list does not confer any right to be selected unless the relevant
recruitment rules so indicate. The State is under no legal duty to fill up all or
any of the vacancies even though the State acts in arbitrary manner. In Babita
Prasad v. State of Bihar, it was held that mere inclusion of one's name in the
panel does not confer on him/her any indefeasible right to appointment. It was
further held that the purpose of making panel was to finalise the list of eligible
candidates for appointment. The preparation of the panel should be to the
extent of the notified or anticipated vacancies. Unduly wrong panel should not
be operated. In Union Territory of Chandigarh v. Dilbagh Singh,it was held that
the mere fact that a candidate's name finds a place in the select list as a
selected candidate for appointment to a post, does not confer on him/her an
indefeasible right to be appointed in such post in the absence of any specific
rule entitling him to such appointment. In State of Bihar v. Secretariat Assistant
Successful Examinees Union 1986, it was held that a person who is selected
and empanelled does not on account of empanelment alone acquire any
indefeasible right to appointment. Empanelment is, at the best, a condition of
eligibility for the purposes of appointment and that by itself does not amount to
Page No.# 25/38
selection or creation of a vested right to appointment unless relevant rules state
to the contrary. However, in the light of the above principles and in the light of
the clear rules extracted hereinbefore, it is seen that the exercise of preparation
of the panels is undertaken well in advance to fill up the clear vacancies of
anticipated vacancies. The preparation and finalisation of the yearly panel,
unless duly certified by the appointing authority that no vacancy would arise or
no suitable candidate was available, is a mandatory requirement. If the annual
panel could not be prepared for any justifiable reason, yearwise panel of all the
eligible candidates within the zone of consideration for filling up the vacancies
each year should be prepared and appointment made in accordance
therewith. In Nagar Mahapalika v. Vinod Kumar Srivastava , this Court had
pointed out with respect to the prescription of the limitation of one year of the
waiting list thus.
"The reason underlying the limitation of the period of list for one year is
obviously to ensure that other qualified persons are not deprived of their
chances of applying for the post in the succeeding year and being
selected for appointment."
14. The Case of R. R. Verma (supra) has been cited to support the contention
that there can be no restriction on the part of the Government to review its
decision.
15.
The case B. S. Mathur
(supra) has been cited to bring home the
contention that the safest way to determine the seniority is the aspect of
continuous lengthof service. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the said case has
laid down the follows:
“40. Perusal of the seniority list drawn by application of principle of rota-quota
as laid down in Rule 8(2) read with Rule 7 of DHJS Rules shows that in case the
principle of rota-quota is followed, then it would cause a serious injustice to the
Page No.# 26/38
promotee officers inasmuch as, the direct recruits who have not yet entered the
service would rank senior to the promotee officers promoted in their quota way
back on 16.8.2000. If this is allowed to happen, this would not only be
unreasonable but create a great heart-burning amongst the officers appointed
from the two sources. Hence, in our view, the principle of rota-quota contained
in the statutory Rule 8 (2) read with Rule 7 of DHJS Rules, does not properly
address the problem of resolving inter se seniority dispute between the direct
recruits and the promotee officers.
…
52. As observed earlier, perusal of the seniority list prepared on the basis of the
principle of "continuous length of service"clearly demonstrates that in case the
seniority of the officers of DHJS is fixed by reference to their date of
appointment, then nobody would suffer any injustice. Each and every officer
would get due weightage of the service rendered by him or her in the cadre of
DHJS. If inter se seniority is finally decided by applying the principle of
"continuous length of service", it may bring an end to litigation between the
officers of the two groups. Therefore, the principle of "continuous length of
service" should be applied for determining the inter se seniority of the officers
of Delhi Higher Judicial Service appointed up to the year 2006. In case of
officers appointed on the same date, whether direct appointees or promotees,
the seniority should be fixed on the principles as stated in O.M. dated 3.7.1986
since it cannot be determined on the basis of length of service alone in case of
appointment from two different sources on the same date.”
WP(C) 259 of 2022
16. There are two petitioners in this case. However, this Court has been
informed that one of them has retired. These two petitioners are also the
applicants in IA(C) No. 207 of 2025 filed in WP(C) No. 284 of 2025 for vacation
of the interim order. The petitioners, who are Degree holders, were appointed
Page No.# 27/38
as Junior Engineers on 24.11.1997 and were allowed to officiate as Assistant
Engineers on 02.07.2007. Subsequently, vide an order dated 04.02.2009, the
scale of pay of Assistant Engineers was also given to the petitioners. As the
aspect of regularization was not considered, the petitioners had earlier filed
WP(C) No. 574 of 2016, in which this Court passed an order dated 16.01.2017
directing the authority to identify the vacancy position under the promotion
quota and to hold the DPC. Accordingly, a letter was issued by the Committee
on 11.04.2018 along with a report, wherein vacancies were identified for the
year 2008 and a recommendation was made for regularization of the services
with effect from 15.09.2008.
17.
Shri R. Saikia, learned counsel for the petitioners, has submitted that in
the impugned minutes of the meeting dated 31.10.2019, the Committee report
dated 11.04.2018 has been ignored and the impugned direction has been issued
recommending seniority with effect from 31.10.2019. He has also drawn the
attention of this Court to an order dated 29.05.2020 to consider the seniority of
the petitioners as per the Sub-Committee’s recommendation. However, a
seniority list was published on 29.07.2022, whereby the seniority of the
petitioners has been ignored. He has, however, drawn the attention of this Court
to the observations appearing in the impugned list itself that the Government
may further consider the matter. He has also informed this Court that in the
present petition, an interim order was passed on 24.11.2022, wherein it was
observed that any promotions made shall be subject to the outcome of the writ
petition and that there would be no bar to revisit the seniority position.
18. Shri Saikia, learned counsel, has also referred to the affidavit filed by the
State on 28.03.2023, wherein it has been stated that the stand of the State has
Page No.# 28/38
been taken by relying upon “Swamy’s Handbook”. He submits that such an
approach is apparently fallacious and all the principles laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court on the subject have been ignored.
19. He has further submitted that his clients have also filed IA(C) No. 207 of
2025 in WP(C) No. 284 of 2025 for vacating the interim order, which, according
to him, was obtained by suppression of material facts. He has specifically
pointed out that the petitioners in WP(C) No. 284 of 2025 were also parties to
WP(C) No. 14 of 2022, in which there was a clear order of this Court dated
19.01.2022 that pendency of the writ petition shall not be a bar to
reconsideration of the matter by the State respondents and this important and
relevant fact was suppressed.
20. Shri Saikia, learned counsel has also relied upon the case of P. Rammohan
Rao v. K. Srinivas and Other, reported in (2025) 4 SCC 127, which follows the
principles laid down in the case of Direct Recruit Class II (supra). He has further
submitted that he adopts and endorses the contentions advanced by Shri K. N.
Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel.
WP(C) 284 of 2025
21.
The petitioners in the present writ petition are respondent Nos. 3–10 in
WP(C) Nos. 14 of 2022 and 459 of 2022, and respondent Nos. 6–13 in WP(C)
No. 295 of 2024. The petitioners, 8 in numbers, are direct recruits to the post of
Assistant Engineer of the 2012 batch.
22. Shri Panging, learned counsel for the petitioners in this case, has submitted
that in the year 2004 the Department of Hydro Power Development was
Page No.# 29/38
bifurcated from the erstwhile Power Department and the cadre strength of
Assistant Engineer was 20. However, at that stage, all the aforesaid posts were
filled on an officiating basis by promotion from the consolidated Department.By
drawing the attention of this Court to the vacancy position which has been given
in a tabular form in the affidavit-in-opposition filed in WP(C) No. 14 of 2022, he
has submitted that there were no vacancies at all in the post of Assistant
Engineer. As a corollary, he has submitted that non-holding of the DPC would be
inconsequential, as there were no vacancies at all.He has reiterated that the
aforesaid position by referring to the Government affidavits filed in WP(C) Nos.
14 of 2022, 459 of 2022, and 295 of 2024. He further submits that, in that
context, there was no occasion to issue the notification dated 30.05.2025, and
accordingly, the present challenge has been instituted against the said
notification.
23. Shri D. Mazumdar, learned senior counsel assisted by Shri B. Kaushik,
learned counsel, has appeared for the respondent Nos. 11-14 in WP(C) No. 14
of 2022 and respondent Nos. 2–5 in WP(C) No. 295 of 2022. He has opposed
both the writ petitions and has submitted that the proposition laid down at
Serial No. (B) in the case of Direct Recruits (supra) is not applicable in the
instant case inasmuch as the pre-condition of there being vacancies is not
fulfilled. He has submitted that even in the case of Aghore Nath (supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has clarified the requirement of existing vacancies so as
to give benefits to promotees. He has further submitted that in the instant case,
the petitioners were given officiating appointments in the quota of the direct
recruits and, therefore, are not entitled to seniority. He has submitted that
petitioner no. 1 was promoted as a stopgap arrangement on 10.08.2005.
Further, in the subsequent orders of promotion dated 29.08.2007 and
Page No.# 30/38
04.02.2009, a condition was imposed that such appointments were made only
on exigency and would not count towards seniority.
24. By referring to the affidavit-in-opposition filed in WP(C) No. 295 of 2024,
Shri Mazumdar, the learned senior counsel, has submitted that the vacancy
position has been disclosed and that, as on 2004, all 20 posts in the cadre of
Assistant Engineers were filled up from the promotion quota. By drawing the
attention of this Court to the list of officers who are 20 in numbers, he has
submitted that two officers at Serial Nos. 19 and 20 were promoted in a DPC
held on 24.07.2012, and these two officers had been officiating in the post of
Assistant Engineer since 2005. Both the officers are senior to the petitioners and
their seniority was given retrospective effect, which was the subject matter of
challenge in WP(C) No. 66 of 2013 filed by the Direct Recruit batch of 2006. The
said writ petition was disposed of by this Court. However, a writ appeal being
WA No. 11 of 2021 has been filed, in which an interim order was passed on
29.11.2021, which is operating and the writ appeal is pending. He has
submitted that the present petitioners were not even considered in the DPC held
in 2012 due to lack of vacancies and two persons senior to the petitioners were
considered and promoted, which is the subject matter in WA No. 11 of 2021.
25. By referring to the affidavit-in-opposition filed in WP(C) No. 14 of 2022,
Shri Mazumdar, the learned senior counsel, has drawn the attention of this Court
to a judgment dated 17.01.2006 passed in WP(C) No. 543 of 2005. In the said
judgment, the grievanceshave been observed that more than 50% was reserved
for direct recruits. However, the version of the Government was also taken into
account that there were no vacancies. He has categorically submitted that while
the respondents were appointed as Assistant Engineers on 24.08.2009, the
Page No.# 31/38
petitioners were appointed on 31.10.2019 and accordingly, the claim of the
petitioner are not maintainable.
26. Shri Mazumdar, the learned senior counsel, has also referred to IA(C) No.
218 of 2025 filed in WP(C) No. 294 of 2024, in which an interim order was
passed by this Court on 31.07.2024. However, on the ground of suppression of
material facts pertaining to the DPC held on 24.07.2012, this Court, vide order
dated 18.09.2024 had vacated the interim order. He has also submitted that on
20.11.2024, two of the applicants were promoted and that there are no other
vacancies. He has submitted that without the petitioners being adjudged to be
holding substantive posts of Assistant Engineer as on 2009, the aspect of
seniority would not arise at all. To buttress his arguments, Shri Mazumdar has
taken the aid of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (1977)
3 SCC 399 [S.B. Patwardhan vs. State of Maharashtra] and has relied upon the
following observations:
“39. If officiating Deputy Engineers belong to Class II cadre as much as direct
recruits do and if the quota system cannot operate upon their respective
confirmation in that cadre, is there any valid basis for applying different
standards to the members of the two groups for determining their seniority?
Though drawn from two different sources, the direct recruits and promotees
constitute in the instant case a single integrated cadre. They discharge identical
functions, bear similar responsibilities and acquire an equal amount of
experience in their respective assignments. And yet clause (iii) of rule 8
provides that probationers recruited during any year shall in a bunch be treated
as senior to promotees confirmed in that year. The plain arithmetic of this
formula is that a direct recruit appointed on probation, say in 1966, is to be
regarded as senior to a promotee who was appointed as an officiating Deputy
Engineer, say in 1956, but was confirmed in 1966 after continuous officiation till
Page No.# 32/38
then. This formula gives to the direct recruit even the benefit of his one year's
period of training and another year's period of probation for the purposes of
seniority and denies to promotees the benefit of their long and valuable
experience. If there was some intelligible ground for this differentiation bearing
nexus with efficiency in public services, it might perhaps have been possible to
sustain such a classification. It is interesting that time and again the State
Governments themselves found it difficult to justify the hostile treatment
accorded to the promotees. In various affidavits filed on their behalf, entirely
contradictory contentions were taken, sometimes in favour of the promotees
and sometimes in favour of direct recruits. Instead of adopting an intelligible
differentia, Rule 8(iii) leaves seniority to be determined on the sole touchstone
of confirmation which seems to us indefensible. Confirmation is one of the
inglorious uncertainities of government service depending neither on efficiency
of the incumbent nor on the availability of substantive vacancies. A glaring
instance widely known in a part of our country is of a distinguished member of
the judiciary who was confirmed as a District Judge years after he was
confirmed as a Judge of the High Court. It is on the record of these writ
petitions that officiating Deputy Engineers were not confirmed even though
substantive vacancies were available in which they could have been confirmed.
It shows that confirmation does not have to conform to any set rules and
whether an employee should be confirmed or not depends on the sweet will
and pleasure of the government.”
27. Shri R. H. Nabam, learned Additional Advocate General, Arunachal Pradesh,
has submitted that the contention of the petitioners that DPCs should have been
held is fallacious and unsustainable inasmuch as to hold a DPC, there must be
clear-cut vacancies. Such a DPC was held in 2012 for 21 nos. of vacancies,
however, the petitioners did not fall within the zone of consideration. He submits
that the grant of pay scales of the post of Assistant Engineer to the petitioners
Page No.# 33/38
in 2009 cannot be a basis for claiming seniority, as an employee must be borne
in the cadre permanently to claim seniority.
28. On behalf of the petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 14 of 2022 and 295 of 2024,
Ms. N. Danggen, learned counsel, has replied to the counterarguments made on
behalf of the respondents. She has submitted that there are serious disputes
with the proposition that there were no vacancies. She has submitted that the
vacancy position has been taken as a defence by the respondents by relying
upon an annexure containing data in tabular form, which, however, does not
bear any signature. She has also disputed the contents of the said table. She
has also hastenedto add that as per the replies dated 20.11.2022 and
30.06.2022 to an RTI applications, vacancies were stated to be available.
29. The rival submissions of the learned counsel for the rival parties have been
duly considered and the materials placed before this Court have been carefully
perused.
30. While the mainstay of the claim of the petitioners in WP(C) Nos. 14 of
2022, 259 of 2022and 295 of 2024 is their officiating arrangement from the
years 2005 and 2007, including the order dated 04.02.2009 whereby the
petitioners were also given the scale of pay of Assistant Engineers, the defence
taken by the respondents is that such arrangements would not confer seniority
as there were no vacancies in the promotion quota. It is the further defence
that vacancies in the promotion quota arose much later and accordingly, the
petitioners were given substantive appointments on promotion vide order dated
31.10.2019. Reliance has also been placed by the respondents on the DPC held
in the year 2012, wherein two persons senior to the petitioners were promoted
Page No.# 34/38
against the existing vacancies in the promotion quota.
31. The aspect of lack of vacancy has been highlighted in the affidavits filed in
the writ petitions, wherein data including the vacancy position has been given in
the form of a table in an annexure. A perusal of the same would show that a
compilation has been made regarding the cadre strength at various periods and
the mode of induction, either by way of promotion or direct recruitment. At this
stage, it would be necessary to note that the Department of Hydro Power
Development was bifurcated from the original Power Department and at the
initial stage, all posts of Assistant Engineer were filled through deputation by
promotees on an officiating basis.
32. The annexure containing the table on vacancies which has been enclosed
to the affidavit, however, does not bear any signature and this issue has been
highlighted by the petitioners with the contention that such dataare not reliable.
Though this Court may not term the data to be unauthentic, in the absence of
the signature of the appropriate authority, it is difficult for this Court to arrive at
a definite conclusion on the matter, more so when the original records were not
produced on behalf of the State.
33. At this stage, certain important aspects are required to be taken into
account. The seniority list was published on 29.07.2022, which is the subject
matter of challenge in WP(C) No. 459 of 2022 and other connected matters.
There is, however, an observation made in the list itself, which reads as follows:
“the seniority position of Shri Yimi Angu, AE (now officiating EE) as
indicated at Sl.12 shall vary subject to the outcome of the Hon’ble
Page No.# 35/38
High Court Itanagar Permanent Bench, Naharlagun in case no. WA
11/2021 filed by Shri Yimi Angu -vs- Shri Obi Dai and 14 others and
as regards Sl.No. 41, 42, 44, 45 and 47 will remain same unless the
competent authority of the Govt. considers their request for
promotion with retrospective of officiating promotion or any order
comes from the Hon’ble High Court.”
34. What is more striking is that the Government, on its own, has taken a
decision on 30.05.2025 to have the various representations considered by a
committee constituted for the said purpose. For ready reference, the relevant
extracts of the aforesaid order are quoted hereinbelow:
“No. SHPD-11018/4/2024 (E-209672)
Government of Arunachal Pradesh
Department of Hydro Power Development
A P CivilSecretariat::ltanagar
Block No3. 5thFloorRoomno.1
Dated Itanagar, the 30h May, 2025
ORDER
A Committee is hereby constituted to examine the joint representation
submitted by Shri Vijay Passing, Shri Tomin Ete, and Shri Swaimso Tayeng
concerning the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) held for promotion
from the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) to Assistant Engineer (Civil), dated
30/10/2019, and the fixation of seniority in compliance with the Addendum
Order No. PWRS/E-1437/06/Pt./2012 dated01.06.2020.
The Committee shall examine the issues raised in the joint representations as
contained in the Sub-Committee Reports dated 23rd June 2020 and 29th April
2025, and submit itsrecommendations accordingly.
The composition of the Committee is as follows:
1. Er. Jummar Kamdak, Chief Engineer (WZ) - Chairman
2. Er. Moto Basar, Chief Engineer (P&D) - Member
Page No.# 36/38
3. Shri K. M. Pakman, Under Secretary, DHPD - Member Secretary
The Committee shall examine the matter in detail and submit a comprehensive
report within one (1) month from the date of issue of this order.
This order is issued with the approval of the competent authority.
Encl:- all relevant documents as stated above.
Sd/(Sonam Chombay) IRS
Commissioner (HPD)
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
M/No. SHPD-11018/4/2024 (E-209672)/432-38 Dated Itanagar,
the 3rd June `2025”
35. The aforesaid communication dated 30.05.2025 is the subject matter of
challenge in WP(C) No. 284 of 2025. This Court, however, is of the view that
there cannot be any restraint upon the Government to re-examine a contentious
issue which has caused heartburn to the officers/employees of a Department.
Ultimately, it is the Government which is required to resolve all such anomalies
or disputes, which are, however, subject to judicial review.
36. In this connection, this Court finds force in the contention advanced by Shri
Choudhury, the learned senior counsel, who has relied upon the case of R. R.
Verma (supra). In the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has laid down as
follows:
“5. The last point raised by Shri Garg was that the Central Government had no
power to review its earlier orders as the rules do not vest the Government with
any such power. Shri Garg relied on certain decisions of this Court in support of
his submission : Patel Narshi Thakershi v. PradyumansinghjiArjunsinghji; D. N.
Roy v. State of Bihar and State of Assam v. J. N. Roy Biswas. All the cases cited
by Shri Garg are cases where the Government was exercising quasi-judicial
Page No.# 37/38
powers vested in them by statute. We do not think that the principle that the
power to review must be conferred by statute either specifically or by necessary
implication is applicable to decisions purely of an administrative nature. To
extend the principle to pure administrative decisions would indeed lead to
untoward and startling results. Surely, any Government must be free to alter
policy or its decision in administrative matters. If they are to carry on their daily
administration, they cannot be hidebound by the rules and restrictions of
judicial procedure though of course they are bound to obey all statutory
requirements and also observe the principles of natural justice where rights of
parties may be affected. Here again, we emphasise that if administrative
decisions are reviewed, the decisions taken after review are subject to judicial
review on all grounds on which an administrative decision may be questioned in
a Court. We see no force in this submission of the learned counsel. The appeal
is, therefore, dismissed.”
37. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the discussions made,
while WP(C) No. 284 of 2025 is dismissed, the other writ petitions, namely,
WP(C) Nos. 14 of 2022, 459 of 2022 and 295 of 2024 are disposed of by
directing the Government in the Department of Hydro Power Development to
conclude the exercise initiated vide the order dated 30.05.2025 by considering
the representations of the officers/employees of the Department expeditiously
and preferably within a period of 3 (three) months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order. To make the exercise a consolidated one, if any
further representations are to be submitted by any aggrieved persons on the
issue, liberty is granted to do so within a period of 10 (ten) days from today. It
is needless to state that in the exercise to be conducted, the representationists
shall be given an opportunity of hearing. After such consideration, the
Department is required to pass a speaking order which is required to be
Page No.# 38/38
communicated to all the parties.
38. The interim orders operating in the writ petitions stand merged with this
final order.
39. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review