Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:683
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 32 of 2023
Date of Decision: 31.07.2024
Smti Daritimai Lyngdoh
- Versus –
1. State of Meghalaya
Represented by the Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya,
PWD (R&B), Shillong.
2. Chief Engineer,
PWD (Roads), Meghalaya,
Shillong.
3. Assistant Chief Engineer,
PWD (Roads), Meghalaya,
Shillong.
… Petitioner(s)
… Respondent(s)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. E. Nongbri, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:683
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The facts in brief are that the petitioner was initially
appointed as Typist (Grade-III) on regular basis through the Meghalaya
Public Service Commission (MPSC) and joined her service on
01.12.1989 in the Office of the Chief Engineer, PWD (Roads)
Meghalaya, Shillong. After serving for nearly 25 years, the petitioner had
appeared for a Speed Test for promotion to Grade-II, but however failed
to qualify. The petitioner thereafter, on being considered by a
Departmental Promotion Committee held on 30.11.2020, was promoted
to the post of Lower Division Assistant (LDA) vide order dated
10.12.2020, to which she immediately joined. However, vide an
impugned office order dated 02.07.2021, the petitioner was reverted to
the post of Typist on the ground that the promotion granted was
erroneous, as the respondents had not taken into account the Office
Memorandum dated 16.03.2006, that provided that a Typist who opts for
the Grade System would not be eligible for the post of LDA. The
petitioner being aggrieved thereby, had approached this Court by way of
WP(C) No. 240 of 2021, wherein vide order dated 27.05.2022, this Court
disposed the matter by directing that the representation of the petitioner
2024:MLHC:683
be disposed of within 2(two) months. The respondents thereafter, by the
impugned order dated 14.06.2022, upheld the earlier order of reversion,
hence the instant writ petition.
2.
Mr. E. Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the promotion of the petitioner to the post of LDA from the quota of
the Typists had been carried out as per Rule 9 (4) of the Meghalaya
Directorate Establishment (Ministerial) Service Rules, 2010 by the DPC
held on 30.11.2020, and with regard to the option of the Grade System
and undergoing the Speed Test by the petitioner to qualify for promotion
from Grade-III to Grade-II, it is contended that the exercise of this option
cannot be considered a bar for promotion to LDA, inasmuch as, the
Speed Test notice dated 11.08.2015, had indicated that the same was to be
conducted by the MPSC as per Rule 11(2) of the Rules as amended in
2012. He submits that this Rule, is silent about what is stipulated in the
Office Memorandum dated 16.03.2006, referred to by the respondents in
their impugned order, which provides that once a person has opted for the
Grade System will no longer be eligible for promotion to the post of
LDA. The stipulation in the Office memorandum he contends not having
been incorporated in the Original Rules of 2010 and in the amended
2024:MLHC:683
Rules of 2012, the same cannot override the provisions of the Rules
which have been made under the powers conferred by the proviso to
Article 309 of the Constitution of India.
3.
The learned counsel further submits that even the Office
Memorandum at Para 2(b) thereof, has clearly laid down that Typists
appearing in a Speed Test conducted by the MPSC, the placement in the
Grade was subject to passing the Speed Test. As such, he submits the
petitioner having not qualified in the Speed Test cannot be considered to
be in the Grade System. It is also submitted that in Para 5(b) thereof, it
has also been provided that the appointment to the LDA cadre was open
to the cadre of Grade-III Typist and on such promotion to LDA, shall
continue as such, and shall not be eligible to the Grade Scales in future.
The petitioner being in Grade-III, he asserts, was therefore eligible to be
considered for promotion to the post of LDA, as this would be in
consonance, and as per the Rules.
4.
The learned counsel then argued that the recourse taken to
Clause 5(a) and 5(c) of the Memorandum to justify the reversion of the
petitioner is incorrect and arbitrary. He contends that though Clause 5(a)
2024:MLHC:683
provides that a Typist who opts for the Grade System shall continue as
such and not be eligible for promotion to LDA, and 5(c) provides that the
option once exercised is final, both these situations are not applicable to
the petitioner, who as by the operation of Clause 2(b) cannot be
considered to be in the Grade System as she had failed the Speed Test. It
is also submitted that the recourse taken to the Office Memorandum to
revert the petitioner is therefore illegal, more so considering that the
petitioner having been granted the promotion, natural justice demands
that she be heard before any orders are passed reverting her to the lower
post. The impugned reversion order, he submits is prima facie illegal and,
on the ground that the same is violative of the principles of natural
justice, is liable to be set aside and quashed.
The learned counsel in support of his arguments, has placed
5.
reliance on the following cases given hereinbelow:i)
Paluru Ramkrishnaiah & Ors. vs. Union of India & Anr.
reported in AIR 1990 SC 166
ii)
Dr. Rajinder Singh vs. State of Punjab & Ors. reported in
(2001) 5 SCC 482
iii)
Ashok Ram Parhad & Ors. vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.
2023 SCC OnLine SC 265
2024:MLHC:683
6.
Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG assisted by Ms. Z.E.
Nongkynrih, learned GA in reply has submitted that the petitioner is
estopped from challenging the reversion order, inasmuch as, she
voluntarily having opted for promotion to Typist Grade-II by way of the
Speed Test, though having failed the Test has been placed in the Grade
System, and the promotion granted to LDA which was not open to
Typists who had opted for the Grade System was erroneous, and as such
she was reverted to her substantial post with immediate effect. It is also
submitted that the petitioner can once more opt for the Grade System by
taking part in the Speed Test as and when the same is conducted by the
MPSC.
7.
The learned AAG in support of the Office memorandum
dated 16.03.2006, submitted that the placement of Typist into 3 Grades
i.e. Grade-I, II & III, had been made to allow the option to typists to
appear for the Speed Test in furtherance of their career and therefore the
Memorandum had provided that, a typist who opts for the Grade System
shall continue as such and not be eligible for promotion to the post of
LDA irrespective of their seniority in the cadre. The Departmental
Promotion Committee held on 30.11.2020, he submits had failed to take
2024:MLHC:683
into account that the petitioner had exercised the option for the Grade
System, thus making her ineligible for promotion to LDA, and as such,
on the same being noticed, a review DPC held on 23.06.2021, decided to
revert back the services of the petitioner to that of a Typist. It is further
submitted that the reversion of the petitioner is not in any way punitive or
penal in nature, and that the temporary promotion of an employee done in
contradiction of Rules or provisions in force will not confer any vested
right upon the said employee. He lastly submits that executive
instructions, such as the Office Memorandum had been made to
supplement the Rules as the Rules are silent on this particular point. The
learned AAG has placed the decision in the case of Union of India vs.
Ashok Kumar Aggarwal reported in (2013) 16 SCC 147, in support of
this point, and reiterates his submission that the writ petition being barred
by principles of waiver, estoppel and acquiescence is liable to be
dismissed.
8.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, two issues
have arisen for consideration i.e. whether the reversion of the petitioner
was justified in the circumstances and whether the Office Memorandum
supplements the Rules rather than supplant it. Before embarking upon the
2024:MLHC:683
determination of the issues noted above, it would be expedient to first
examine the Meghalaya Directorate Establishment (Ministerial)
Service Rules, 2010 as amended as applicable to the case which are
quoted hereinbelow: Rule-9 (unamended)
“9. Lower Division Assistant: Appointment to the post of
L.D. Assistants shall be made:
(1) By direct recruitment on the result of the
competitive examination conducted by the Commission.
(2) By selection on the basis of merit from
amongst Typists of the respective Directorate who have
rendered not less than 4 years of continuous service on the
first day of the year in which the selection is made.
(3) By selection on the basis of merit from
amongst the Grade IV staff of the respective office who
have passed the H.S.L.C. examination or any examination
declared equivalent thereto and have rendered not less than
7 years of continuous service on the first day of the year in
which selection is made.
(4) The quota to be filled up in the cadre of Lower
Division Assistant in any year accordingly to sub-rules (1),
(2) and (3) above shall be in the ratio of 8:1:1 respectively.
This means that 80 percent of recruitment of Lower
Division Assistants shall be by direct recruitment, 10
percent by selection from amongst the Typists and 10
percent by selection from amongst the Grade IV staff. In
the event of sufficient qualified or suitable persons not
being available in either of categories (2) or (3), the
balance shall be made up from category (1), i.e., through
direct recruitment. The quota shall be determined on the
basis of strength of staff both permanent and temporary in
the Lower Division Assistant’s cadre.”
Rule 11 as amended on 05.12.2012
2024:MLHC:683
“Rule 11.
(1) Typist (Grade III) – Appointment to the
post of Typist (Grade III) shall be made by direct
recruitment on the result of the competitive examination
conducted by the Commission.
“(2) Typist (Grade II) – Typist with minimum 3 (three)
years of qualifying service in Grade III shall be eligible for
appearing the Speed Test of 45 words per minute to be
conducted by the Meghalaya Public Service Commission
and their placement in the Grade shall be subject to passing
the Speed Test.
“(3) Typist (Grade I) - Typist with minimum 3 (three)
years of qualifying service in Grade II shall be eligible for
appearing the Speed Test of 60 words per minute to be
conducted by the Meghalaya Public Service Commission
and their placement in the Grade shall be subject to passing
the Speed Test
The Office Memorandum dated 16.03.2006, for the sake of
9.
convenience is reproduced hereinbelow: “GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
SECRETARIAT ADMNISTRATION DEPARTMENT ESTABLISHMENT
BRANCH
No. SAE. 178/86/211
Dated Shillong, the 16th March, 2006.
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject:-
Promotion Scheme for Typist.
The undersigned is directed to say that in pursuance of the Government
decision on the Recommendation of the 3rd Meghalaya Pay Commission, announce
in Resolution No. F(PR150/98/7, dated 21.12.1998, the Governor of Meghalaya is
pleased to decide placement of Typist into 3(three) grades as indicated below:
1. (a) Typist Grade-I :-Rs.4250-110-4910-EB-120-5870-130-7170/- P. M.
(b) Typist Grade - II :-Rs.3725-90-4265-EB-100-5065-110-6165/- P. M.
(c)
Typist Grade - III :- Rs. 3100-70-3520-EB-80-4160-90-5060/- P. M.
2. The placement of the Typists in the three grades on their options shall be
2024:MLHC:683
subject to the following conditions :(a) Grade - I :- Typists with a minimum of 3 (three) years of qualifying
service in Grade - II shall be eligible for appearing the Speed Test of
60 words per minute, to be conducted by Meghalaya Public Service
Commission and their placement in the grade shall be subject to passing
the Speed Test.
(b) Grade - II :- Typists with a minimum of 3 years qualifying service in
Grade - III shall be eligible for appearing the Speed Test of 45 words
per minute to be conducted by Meghalaya Public Service Commission
and their placement in the Grade shall be subject to passing the Speed
Test.
(c) The existing Ordinary Grade Typist shall henceforth be categorized as
Grade - III Typists.
3. Existing ordinary Grade Typists who have already passed the Speed Test of 45
w. p. m. shall be eligible to be placed directly in Grade - II and those who have
already passed the Speed Test of 60 w. p. m. shall be eligible to be placed
directly in Grade - I provided that they have rendered a minimum of 3 years of
qualifying and satisfactory service in the Ordinary Grade.
4. With the introduction of the three tier system in the Typist Grade the advance
increment(s) hitherto admissible shall cease to operate.
The existing system of having Selection Grade Typists shall henceforth stand
abolished. However, the existing Selection Grade Typists shall remain
categorized as such and shall be allowed to draw the corresponding Revised
Scale of pay as personal to them until they vacate the post or cease to draw
pay in the scale.
5. (a) A Typist who opts for the Grade System shall continued as such and
he/she shall not be eligible for promotion to the post of L. D. Assistant
irrespective of his/her Seniority in the Cadre/Service.
(b) The appointment to L. D. Cadre shall be open only to the Cadre of
Grade - III Typists until he/she is eligible for such promotion as per the
Provision of the Service Rules and on promotion to the post of L. D.
Assistant shall continue as such and shall not be eligible to the Grade
Scales in future.
(c) The Option once exercised in final.”
10.
From the above quoted Rules, it is seen that Rule 9(4)
provides for 10% of LDA’s to be selected from amongst Typists and by
application of this provision, the writ petitioner was granted promotion to
2024:MLHC:683
the post of LDA on 10.12.2020 on the recommendation by the DPC, but
however was reverted due to the stipulation contained in the Office
Memorandum dated 16.03.2006, which at 5(a) above provides that a
Typist who opts the Grade System shall continue as such and not be
eligible for promotion to the post of LDA, and further 5(c) providing that
an option once exercised is final. As noted earlier the petitioner had
undergone a Speed Test for promotion to Typist Grade-II as provided by
Rule 11(2) quoted above, but did not qualify and as such remained as
Typist Grade-III. A plain reading of Rule 11(2) clearly states that
placement in the Grade System as per Rule 11 was subject to passing the
Speed Test, and as such therefore the petitioner having not passed the
Speed Test cannot be said to have been placed in the Grade System. This
is further fortified by the Speed Test Notice dated 11.08.2015, wherein it
had been indicated that the same was to be conducted by the MPSC as
per Rule 11(2) of the Rules as amended in 2012.
11.
Coming to the Memorandum in question as mentioned above,
though Clause 2(b) is in line with Section 11(2) of the Rules, Clause 5(a),
however speaks of an option and stipulates that a Typist who opts for the
Grade System shall continue as such and not be eligible for promotion to
2024:MLHC:683
the post of LDA and by 5(c) makes the option exercised final. By
juxtaposing the Meghalaya Directorate Establishment (Ministerial)
Service Rules, 2010 as amended and the Office Memorandum dated
16.03.2006, in their application to the facts of the instant case, a clear
conflict has arisen, inasmuch as, Rule 11(2) stipulates that placement in
the Grade System shall be subject to passing the Speed Test whereas, the
Office Memorandum at Clauses 5(a) and 5(c) thereof, mandates that once
an option is exercised the same is final. To the mind of the Court, the
Rules nowhere have contemplated the aspect of an option being exercised
to take a Speed Test and being unsuccessful thereon, a Typist would be
considered to be in the Grade System, but the Rules have only provided
that placement in the Grade shall be subject to passing the Speed Test.
The conditions in the Office Memorandum, though stated to be
supplemental in nature on matters that are silent in the Rules, in fact
militates against the same, as instead of supplementing the Rules has
supplanted them. It is also important to note that the conditions in the
Office Memorandum as given in Clauses 5(a) & (c) except for Clause
2(b) though made in 2006, were never incorporated in the Rules in 2010,
or in the amendment thereto, made in 2012.
2024:MLHC:683
12.
As the Meghalaya Directorate Establishment (Ministerial)
Service Rules, 2010 as amended, are statutory Rules made under Article
309, though executive instructions such as the impugned Office
Memorandum can contain provisions not covered by the Rules, they
however, cannot override, supplant or substitute statutory Rules. The
judgments placed by the counsel for the petitioner lays down this settled
position of law and need no further elaboration or discussion. The
judgment placed by the learned AAG i.e. Union of India vs. Ashok
Kumar Aggarwal (supra) in fact, supports the case of the petitioner, as it
has been held that the Government can fill up gaps and supplement the
Rules, but the same should not be inconsistent with the Rules already
framed, and that the law laid down that has consistently been followed, is
that an authority cannot issue orders or executive instructions in
contravention of the statutory Rules.
13.
Clause 5(a) & 5(c) of the Office Memorandum as seen from
the discussions above being offensive to the statutory Rules as framed
therefore, are unsustainable in law, and as such are accordingly struck
down.
2024:MLHC:683
Consequently, the other orders also impugned in the writ
14.
petition namely; DPC dated 23.06.2021 as far as it relates to the
petitioner at Agenda No. 3 thereof, reversion order dated 02.07.2021 and
Office Order dated 14.06.2022, are also hereby set aside and quashed. It
is further directed that the petitioner be restored to the promotional post
of LDA forthwith and her service in the said post of LDA be counted
from the date of joining i.e. 10.12.2020, and further be allowed all
consequential benefits as admissible.
In view of the findings hereinabove, and the reliefs allowed
15.
to the petitioner, no other issue such as the respondents not affording the
petitioner any opportunity of hearing before being reverted is necessary
to be gone into, and the writ petition as ordered above is allowed and
disposed of.
16.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:683
31.07.2024
“V. Lyndem PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2024.07.31 17:28:15 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review