Civil
Dargah Hazarat Khalifat vs Syeda Ahmedia Banu
Add to a compilation
Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index.
It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence.
Sign in · See the plans
Cite this judgment
Citation
Copy citation
Link for your website or blog
Copy link code
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0 ).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
%
!
!
# !
#
"$
!
!
&&
'
!(
)
!
!
!
" " #$%!
&
Digitally signed
by LUCYGRACE
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
'
(
$!
)
(
"$
!
!
)
!**
" " $+*!
*!
,
!
'
-2-
- " + +"*!
#!
+
!
'
(
!
!
" " *.*!
&
! !
'
*(
'
$/
#
.(
)
*+ $* *+*"
)
'
!$+ *+$%
)
!
)
'
!
! !
#
$!
123 455647 23 58696886: ;< =16 5742>=299 2>
?!$+ *+$% ?> =16 9276 ?9 =16
48>4=4@4 )4A9
82;B>47
-3-
474;B84C2
2D232?> 4=
474;B84C2
G14776>C2>C
=16
:4=6:
82;B>47
8:68
9?8 31?8= E=16 =82;B>47F(
*+!$*!*+*"
H16862>
477?H6: =16 I6I? 9276: ;< :696>:4>=
=16
?!$ 4>:
:23I2336: =16 3B2= 1?7:2>C =14= =16 5742>=299 23 >?= 6>=2=76: =?
G?>=2>B6 43 4
B=4H4772 49=68 =16 6J528< ?9 =16 ?8:68 :4=6:
*.!+ !*+*K 54336: ;< =16 G?I56=6>=
*!
=14= =16
676D4>= 94G=3 9?8 4:LB:2G4=2?> ?9 =123 455647 486
48C41
B>>2(
4M484=
47@16:
G68=42> 58?568=263!
2=3
4LL4:4
B4:82
?!
474;B84C2!
H2=1
?48:!
147294=
416I4>
B=4H4772 -
B4:82
<6:
668 4314
B3=494
B4:82 8632:6>= ?9
16 5742>=299 143 9276: 3B2= 366@2>C :6G7484=2?>
G?>36AB6>=247
867269
?9
56856=B47
:696>:4>=3! = 23 4D6886: 4= 5484C8451
<6:
16 5742>=299 2>3=2=B=2?> 23 8658636>=6: ;<
4>:
2>LB>G=2?> 2> 86356G= ?9 =16 3B2= 58?568=263
=14=
414I4=
G742I3 =? ;6 4> 2>3=2=B=2?> 14D2>C
4312> 4>:
B8=BM4
B3=494
5742>=299F3 2>3=2=B=2?>
4LL4:4
2>1682=4;76 82C1= 2> 86356G= ?9 =16
I6>=2?>6: 2> =16 5742>=!
4C42>3= =16
?!K ?9 =16 5742>=
B4:82 23 >?= ?>7< 4
;B= 473? 4
I4>:4=?8<
B=4H4772 ?9 =16
4312>
G742I2>C
3G16:B76: 58?568=<
B82>C =16 56>:6>G< ?9 =16 3B2= =16
-4-
:696>:4>=
?! $ 143 9276: I6I? :4=6: *K!+%!*+*" 3=4=2>C
=14=
<6:
=16
455?2>=6: ;< =16
B3=494
=4=6
B4:82
?48: ?9 )4@9
H1?
;66>
4>C47?86 43
B=4H4772 H43 9?8 4 5682?: ?9 ?>6 <648 4>: 34I6 H43
G?>G7B:6: ;< 6997BJ ?9 =2I6 ?> * !+ !*+*" 4>: =16869?86 =16
342:
<6:
B3=494
B4:82 G4>>?= ;6 568I2==6: =?
G?>=2>B6 =16 58?G66:2>C3 2> =16 3B2= 4>: 143 =16869?86
3?BC1= 9?8 :23I23347 ?9 =16 3B2=!
#!
16 342: I6I? 9276: ;< :696>:4>=
?55?36: ;< =16 5742>=299!
?! $ H43
82;B>47 49=68 G?>32:682>C =16
I4=68247 ?> 86G?8: ;< 2=3 ?8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*" 477?H6:
=16 I6I? 9276: ;< :696>:4>=
?! $ 4>: 43 3BG1 :23I2336:
=16 3B2= 9276: ;< =16 5742>=299 2>3=2=B=2?> ?> =16 C8?B>: =14=
=16
<6:
B3=494
B4:82
H1? 143 8658636>=6: =16
5742>=299 2>3=2=B=2?> 23 >? I?86 4
B=4H4772 ?9 =16 >3=2=B=2?>
43 =16 34I6 H43 G?>G7B:6: ;< 6997BJ ?9 =2I6!
6672>C
4CC826D6: ;< =16 2I5BC>6: ?8:68 :4=6: *+!$*!*+*"
5742>=299 143 58696886: =123 455647!
=16
-5-
K!
648:
4G12>
!
414L4>
4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>=
82!
I66=@BI48
7648>6:
82!
6>2?8
8B>@BI48
?B>367
4556482>C
I48CB>:4554
7648>6: G?B>367
?>
;61479
9?8 8635?>:6>=
?9
82!
?!$ 4>:
82!
! ! 47254=27 7648>6: G?B>367 9?8 =16 8635?>:6>=
"!
82!
4G12>
!
414L4>
63154>:6
?!*!
7648>6:
4556482>C 9?8 =16 5742>=299 48CB6: =14= =16
G?B>367
82;B>47 143
G?II2==6: 4> 688?8 2> :23I2332>C =16 6>=286 3B2= ?> I682=3! =
23 G?>=6>:6: =14= =1?BC1 =16 AB63=2?> ;69?86 =16 82;B>47 43
=? G454G2=< ?9 =16 342:
=16869?86 =16
4LL4:4
4312> 4>:
B=4H4772 4>:
82;B>47 ?BC1= >?= =? 14D6 :23I2336: =16 3B2=
H2=1?B= G?>32:682>C =16 94G=B47 4356G=3 ?> 86G?8: ?> I682=3!
= 23 473? 48CB6: ;<
82!
4G12>
!
414L4> 7648>6: G?B>367
;< 8696882>C =? =16 58?D232?> G?>=42>6: B>:68
=16 )4@9
G=
$.."
6G=2?> # @( ?9
16862>49=68 8696886: =? 43 E G=F(
H16862> =16 :692>2=2?> 43 =? =16
N5683?> 2>=6863=6: 2> 4
O)4@9PF
4312>!
2>G7B:63
G?>=6>:6: =14= =16
B3=494
=16
4LL4:4
16869?86
82;B>47 ?BC1= =? 14D6 477?H6:
<6:
B4:82 =? ;6 8658636>=6: 43 4
4LL4:4
4312>
-6-
4>:
B=4H4772 9?8 =16 5742>=29903 2>3=2=B=2?> 4>: =16869?86
3?BC1= 9?8 2>=689686>G6 ?9 =123
!
?B8=!
= 23 473? 48CB6: ;< =16 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C
9?8 =16 4556774>= ;< 8696882>C =? =16 58?D232?> G?>=42>6:
B>:68
6G=2?>
# *( ?9 =16
G= H16862> 2= 23 3=4=6: =14= 4><
B=4H4772 ?8 5683?> 2>=6863=6: 2> =16 )4@9 G4> I42>=42> =16
3B2= =? 58?=6G= =16 2>=6863= ?9 =16 2>3=2=B=2?> 43 3BG1 4>: =?
=14= 6J=6>= =16 82;B>47 143 6886: 2> 4882D2>C 4= 4 G?>G7B32?>
=? G7?36 =16 3B2= 2=3679 4>: =16869?86 3?BC1= 9?8 2>=689686>G6
?9 =16 3B2=!
%!
82!
4556482>C
9?8
48>4=4@4
=4=6
4G12>
=16
!
414L4>
4556774>=
9B8=168
?48: ?9 )4@9
7648>6:
48CB6:
<6:
=14=
=16
4>C7?86 ;< ?8:68 :4=6:
#+!$+!*+*" 6J=6>:6: =16 5682?: ?9 ?>6 <648 ?9
=16 4556774>= >3=B=2=2?>
G?B>367
B3=494
B=4H4772 ?9
B4:82 4>: 3BG1
?=168 32I27487< 574G6: 2>3=2=B=2?>3 H1?36 =68I 23 =? 6J5286 ?>
?8 49=68 +$3=
BCB3= *+*" 4>: =16869?86 2= 23 G?>=6>:6: =14=
=16 2I5BC>6: ?8:68 54336: ;< =16 =82;B>47 86AB2863 =? ;6
2>=689686: H2=1 2> =123 455647!
-7-
!
6>2?8
68 G?>=84
82!
I66=@BI48
63154>:6 7648>6:
?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 8635?>:6>=
?!$ ;<
8696882>C =? =16 ?8:68 :4=6: *.!+ !*+*K 54336: ;< =16
48>4=4@4
=4=6
?48: ?9 )4@9
=14= =16 5682?: ?9
B3=494
B4:82 H43
9?8 4 5682?: ?9 ?>6 <648 4>: 43 3BG1 2> =68I3 ?9
B76 "K "(
?9 =16
B=4H4772
4>C47?86 4>: G?>=6>:6:
48>4=4@4 )4@9
E B763F( =16 342:
<6:
<6:
B763
B=4H4772 4>: =16869?86
16862>49=68 8696886: =? 43
B3=494
B4:82 23 >? I?86 4
3?BC1= =? LB3=29< =16 2I5BC>6:
?8:68 54336: ;< =16 =82;B>47!
.!
> 86356G= ?9 =16 G?>=6>=2?>3 84236: ;< =16
7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= 43 =? =16 ?8:68
:4=6: #+!$+!*+*" 54336: ;< =16
48>4=4@4
7648>6:
=4=6
6>2?8
?48: ?9 )4@9
J6GB=2D6
2= 23 G?>=6>:6: ;< =16
?B>367 9?8 =16 8635?>:6>=
6>AB28< 23 ;62>C 2>2=24=6: 4C42>3= =16 342:
B4:82 4>: =16869?86
992G68
?!$ =14= 43 =16
<6:
B3=494
=16 6J=6>32?> ?9 =16 5682?: 43 568
?8:68 :4=6: #+!$+!*+*" G4>>?= ;6 I4:6 45572G4;76 =? =16
342:
B=4H4772 ?9 =16 5742>=299 4556774>=
9B8=168 16 G?>=6>:6: =14=
=16
>3=B=2=2?> 4>:
992G68 ?9 =16
?48:
-8-
31477 =4@6 G486 ?9 =16 9B>G=2?>2>C ?9 =16 5742>=299 4556774>=
>3=2=B=2?> 4>: 4GG?8:2>C7< 3?BC1= 9?8 :23I23347 ?9 =16
455647!
$+!
82!
! ! 47254=27 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8
?!*
?48: 48CB6: ?> 32I2748 72>63 ?9 =16 7648>6:
8635?>:6>=
6>2?8
?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 8635?>:6>=
9B8=168 G?>=6>:6: ;< =16 8635?>:6>=
?!$ 4>: 2= 23
?!* =14= 2> D26H ?9
6G=2?> # @( ?9 =16
G= 4>:
<6:
B4:82 G4>>?= ;6 :286G=6: =? G?>=2>B6 43
B3=494
B76 "K "( ?9 =16
B763 =16 342:
G486 =4@68 ?9 =16 5742>=299 4556774>= >3=2=B=2?> 43 4
B=4H4772
4>: 4GG?8:2>C7< 3?BC1= 9?8 :23I23347 ?9 =16 455647!
$$!
> =16 72C1= ?9 =16 3B;I2332?> I4:6 ;< =16
7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 548=263
14D6 G4869B77<
6J4I2>6: =16 4D68I6>=3 I4:6 2> =16 5742>= H16862> =16
>3=2=B=2?> 23
B774
B4:82!
48C41
BB>2(
4M84=
147294= B8
47@16: 8658636>=6: ;<
= 5484C8451
416I4>
<6:
414I4=
B3=494
?!K ?9 =16 5742>= C6>647?C< ?9 =16
B=4H4772 23 3=4=6:! = 23 473? >?= 2> :235B=6 =14= 8635?>:6>=
?!*
?48: 23 6I5?H686: =? 455?2>=
B=4H4772 =? =16
-9-
5742>=299 4556774>= >3=2=B=2?>!
16 3B2= 2>
! ! ?!$+ *+$% 23
9276: ;69?86 =16 =82;B>47 366@2>C 867269 ?9 :6G7484=2?> =14= =16
3B2= 58?568=263 43 :63G82;6: 2> =16 5742>= H686 )4@9
58?568=263 4>: =16 5742>=299 >3=2=B=2?> 23 4;3?7B=6 ?H>68 ?9
=16 342: 58?568=263! = 23 =? ;6 >?=6: 2> =16 584<68
?!# 2> =16
5742>= H16862> =16 5742>=299 143 3?BC1= 9?8 :286G=2?> 4C42>3=
:696>:4>=
?!* 8635?>:6>=
?!* 16862> =? 5B;7231 =16 3B2=
58?568=263 43 )4@9 58?568=263!
= 23 9?8=1G?I2>C 98?I =16
H82==6> 3=4=6I6>= 9276: ;< =16 :696>:4>=
<6:
=16
B3=494
::2=2?>47
B4:82 143 9276:
2D27
B:C6 4=
?!$ =14= =16 342:
! ! ?!K.K *++" ;69?86
477482 366@2>C 2>LB>G=2?>
4>: =16 342: 3B2= G4I6 =? ;6 :23I2336:! = 23 >?= 2> :235B=6
=14=
<6:
=? =16 5742>=299
B3=494
?>
B=4H4772
>3=2=B=2?> 9?8 4 5682?: ?9 ?>6 <648 43 568
?8:68 :4=6: *.!+ !*+*K!
I4=68247
B4:82 H43 455?2>=6: 43
86G?8:
9B>G=2?>2>C ?9 =16
16 =82;B>47 49=68 G?>32:682>C =16
143 4882D6: 4=
B=4H4772
<6: 3141
G?>G7B32?> =14=
B3=494
B4:82 G4I6
=? 4> 6>: ;< #+!+ !*+*K 4>: 43 3BG1 54336: =16 2I5BC>6:
?8:68!
- 10 -
$*!
> G4869B7 G?>32:684=2?> ?9 =16 ?8:68 :4=6:
*.!+ !*+*K 54336: ;< =16
4>C47?86
H16862>
58?D232?>3 ?9 =16
B3=494
48>4=4@4
=4=6
?48: ?9 )4@9
B=4H4772 31477 9B>G=2?> 43 568 =16
G= 4>: =16 =6>B86 ?9 =16
<6:
B4:82 G?I6 =? 4> 6>: ;< 6997BJ ?9 =2I6!
> =123
86C48: 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= 8696886:
=? 4> ?8:68 :4=6: #+!$+!*+*" 54336: ;< =16
48>4=4@4
?48:
?9
?9
?II2==663
)4@9
H16862>
=16
=68I
=277
#$!+$!*+* !
#+!$+!*+*" =16 5682?: ?9
=? =16 G?>:2=2?> =14=
>
BCB3=
=16
B=4H477263
2> =16 6D6>=
4>: 43 3BG1
=16
9B>G=2?>2>C ?9 3BG1 >3=2=B=2?> 43 568
= 23 =16 3B;I2332?> ?9
*+*" 23 ;62>C
342:
?8:68
82!
4556482>C 9?8 =16 :696>:4>=
29 4>< 6>AB28< 23 2>
4>4C2>C
?II2==663
?48: 31477 433BI6 =16
B76 "K "( ?9 =16
! ! 47254=27
B763!
7648>6: G?B>367
?!* 8635?>:6>=
6>AB28< 143 ;66> 2>2=24=6: 4C42>3= =16 342:
B3=494
:4=6:
B=4H477263 31477 G?>=2>B6 3B;L6G=
58?C8633 4>: G?>G7B:6: 4C42>3= 3BG1
?8
4>4C2>C
B=4H477263 H1?36 =68I 23 G?I2>C =? 6J5286 ?8
47864:< 6J5286: ?> ?8 49=68 $3=
G?>=2>B6:
=4=6
?!* =14= 4>
<6:
B4:82 4>: 58?G66:2>C3 486 56>:2>C G?>32:684=2?>
- 11 -
;69?86 =16
?48: 4>: 2> =123 86C48: 7648>6: G?B>367
4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= :2: >?= G?B>=68 =16 3B;I2332?>
43 =? =16 56>:6>G< ?9 =16 6>AB28< 4C42>3=
B3=494
B4:82! > =14= D26H ?9 =16 I4==68
=14= =16 342:
<6:
B3=494
82!
<6:
4I ?9 =16 D26H
B4:82 23 >? I?86 4
B=4H4772 4>: G4>>?= ;6 568I2==6: =? ;6 G?>=2>B6: =?
8658636>= =16 5742>=299 >3=2=B=2?> 43
B=4H4772! > =123 86C48:
?> G4869B7 6J4I2>4=2?> ?9 =16 92>:2>C 86G?8:6: ;< =16
=82;B>47 43 568 5484C8451
?3!$$ =? $K
4I ?9 =16 D26H
=14= =16 92>:2>C 86G?8:6: ;< =16 =82;B>47 23 LB3= 4>: 58?568
2>3?948 43 1?7:2>C =14=
82!
<6:
B3=494
B4:82 31477
>?= ;6 G?>=2>B6: 43 4
B=4H4772 ?9 =16 5742>=299F3 >3=2=B=2?>
;< 6997BJ ?9 =2I6!
$#!
?H6D68
8658636>=6: ;< 2=3
=16 3B2= 23 9276: ;< =16
4LL4:4
4312> 4>:
>3=2=B=2?>
B=4H4772!
> =14=
D26H ?9 =16 I4==68 =16 =82;B>47 143 G?II2==6: 4> 688?8 2>
:23I2332>C =16 6>=286 3B2=
H16862>
=16 3B2= 9276: ;< =16
>3=2=B=2?> 3B8D2D63 :6352=6 =1686 ;62>C G14>C6 ?9
;< =16 )4@9
?48:!
? =14= 6J=6>=
B=4H4772
=16 2I5BC>6: ?8:68
:4=6: *+!$*!*+*" 54336: ;< =16 =82;B>47 86AB2863 =? ;6
- 12 -
2>=689686: H2=1 4>: =16869?86
92>: 9?8G6 2> =16 3B;I2332?>
I4:6 ;< =16 7648>6: G?B>367 4556482>C 9?8 =16 4556774>= 43
=? G?>=2>B4=2?> ?9 =16 3B2= 9276: 2> =16 >4I6 ?9 =16 >3=2=B=2?>!
?H6D68
2> D26H ?9 =16 455?2>=I6>= ?9 )4@9
9B>G=2?> 43
992G68 =?
B=4H4772 43 H677 43 =? G488<?B= :4< =? :4< 4994283
?9 =16 5742>=299F3 >3=2=B=2?>
9?8 =16 342: )4@9
4I ?9 =16 D26H =14= 2= 23 ?56>
992G68 455?2>=6: ;< =16
?48: =? G?>=2>B6
=16 58?G66:2>C3 ;69?86 =16 =82;B>47 =? 58?=6G= =16 2>=6863= ?9
=16 5742>=299 >3=2=B=2?>!
$K!
> =16 863B7=
5433 =16 9?77?H2>C
2(
16 455647 23 477?H6: 2> 548=/
22(
?8:68
:4=6:
*+!$*!*+*"
! ! ?!$+ *+$% ?> =16 9276 ?9 =16
82;B>47
474;B8C2
2D232?>
2>
48>4=4@4 )4@9
474;B8C2
23 36=
432:6 43 =? :23I2332>C ?9 =16 3B2= ?9 =16 5742>=299
>3=2=B=2?>
2>
6>=286=<
4>:
=1686;<
! ! ?!$+ *+$% 31477 3B8D2D6 9?8 G?>32:684=2?> 43
- 13 -
=? =16 584<68 I4:6 2> =16 3B2= 4>: =16 342: 3B2=
143 =? ;6 G?>=2>B6: 2> =16 >4I6 ?9 =16 >3=2=B=2?>
I6>=2?>6: 2> =16 G4B36 =2=76 8658636>=6: ;< =16
)4@9
992G68/
222(
<6:
= 23 ?56> 9?8 =16 683=H1276
B3=494
B=4H4772
B4:82 =? 2I5764: 2> =16 3B2=
43 ?>6 ?9 =16 :696>:4>=3 29 3? :632863 43 =? =4@6
4D4274;76 G?>=6>=2?>3 9?8 58?=6G=2>C =16 2>=6863= ?9
=16 5742>=299 >3=2=B=2?>/
2D(
> D26H ?9 =16 4556484>G6 ?9 =16
548=263 4>: =? 4D?2: 9B8=168 :674< 2> =16 I4==68
=16 548=263 =? =16 3B2= 486 568I2==6: =? 455648
;69?86
=16
474;B84C2
48>4=4@4
2D232?>
=4=6
)4@9
82;B>47
474;B84C2 ?> +*!+*!*+*
$$!++ 4!I!
!*+
'
!
! (
#
'
23=
?! $
?! K*
4=
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review