Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1103
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 112 of 2024
Date of Decision: 02.12.2024
Shri. Danialking Marwein,
S/o S. Wanniang,
R/o. Mawkhiat Village,
West Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
Union of India, represented by the
Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas,
Government of India, New Delhi.
2.
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited,
12/E&F, Maker Towers, Cuffe Parade,
Post Box No.19949, Mumbai – 400005.
3.
The Territory Manager (Retail),
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited,
Holding No-253, Ward No-2,
Lower Lachumiere, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya.
…Respondents
2024:MLHC:1103
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Mr. M.L.Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S.Jindal, Adv. with
Mr. I.Kharmujai, Adv.
Ms. T.Pohlong, Adv. for R 2 & 3.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner by way of the instant writ petition is before this Court
praying for setting aside of the impugned letters dated 06-01-2024 and 1603-2024, whereby the petitioner was declared not eligible for RO
dealership (Retail Outlet) due to the reason of mismatch of letters in the
hard copy of the Pan Card with the uploaded one.
2.
The brief facts are that the petitioner in response to an advertisement
for appointment of RO dealership was provisionally selected vide letter
dated 29-12-2023 and had paid the initial security deposit of ₹ 20,000/and had also submitted all requisite documents including the Pan Card.
2024:MLHC:1103
However, vide the impugned letter dated 06-01-2024, the respondent
company informed the petitioner that he was not eligible for RO dealership
due to the reason of mismatch in the uploaded number of the Pan Card,
where in the hard copy the number was BYJPD0795F, the uploaded
number was BJYPD0795F. Against the said rejection, the petitioner was
asked to submit a representation if aggrieved and on submission of the
same, vide the impugned letter dated 16-03-2024, the representation was
rejected.
3.
As the said disposal of the representation was not to the knowledge
of the petitioner initially, WP(C). No. 74 of 2024 was filed against the nondisposal of the representation and during the proceedings, the respondent
had informed this Court that with the Model Code of Conduct in place, the
RO dealership had not been settled with any other party. On an affidavit
filed by the respondent company, bringing on record the impugned order
dated 16-03-2024, rejecting the representation of the petitioner, WP(C).
No. 74 of 2024 was withdrawn on 12-04-2024 and the instant writ petition
was then filed on 17-04-2024.
4.
Mr. M.L.Nongpiur, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the mismatch of the petitioner’s Pan Card in the application form was
with regard to a single alphabet due to a bonafide typographical error and
2024:MLHC:1103
that the action rejecting the selection of the petitioner is against the
principles of reasonableness and violation of Articles 14 and 21 of the
Constitution of India. It is further submitted that Clause 23 of the Brochure
on Selection of Dealers, wherein a Pan Card number mismatch has been
listed in the list of non-rectifiable deficiencies in applications, is only but a
guideline, which does not have the force of law and cannot be held to be a
rigid mandatory requirement, considering the mismatch was only with
regard to one letter of the alphabet.
5.
In support of his case, the petitioner has placed reliance on an order
dated 25-07-2024, of the Karnataka High Court passed in Writ Petition.
No. 1771 of 2024, wherein the facts of the said case are similarly situated
and the case of the petitioner therein was allowed by holding that the
guidelines were neither mandatory nor binding, and that the mismatch was
neither intentional nor deliberate, but on account of bonafide reasons.
6.
On another limb of submission, the petitioner on the assertion by the
respondent company that the said RO dealership had since been awarded
to another person on 22-02-2024, before filing of the previous writ petition
that is WP(C). No. 74 of 2024, the learned counsel has contended that the
settlement with the third party is provisional, more so, with the Letter of
Intent / Award not being brought on record, and as such, no third party
2024:MLHC:1103
right has been created till date. It is also argued that if there is any
settlement with a third party, the same would amount to concealment/
misrepresentation and an act of contempt in violation of the orders passed
by this Court.
7.
Mr. S.Jindal, learned counsel for the respondents No. 2 & 3, in reply
has submitted that the petitioner cannot seek the reliefs as prayed,
inasmuch as, in the application for dealership, an undertaking had been
signed wherein the petitioner had agreed that if the information given in
the aforesaid application was found to be incorrect, the petitioner would be
declared ineligible for the RO dealership. There being a clear mismatch
between the uploaded Pan Card number and the hard copy, he submits, by
operation of Clause 23 (n) contained in the Brochure for Selection of
Dealers, the application therefore stood rejected. It is then submitted that
even before the first writ petition that is, WP(C). No. 74 of 2024 had been
filed in March 2024, one Shri. Lumborlang Wanswett had been allotted the
RO dealership on 22-02-2024, and that the representation of the writ
petitioner had been rejected on 16-03-2024, much before the interim order
dated 22-04-2024, was passed by this Court in the instant writ petition.
8.
The learned counsel submits that the application dated 25-09-2023
of the writ petitioner read with the guidelines governing the selection /
2024:MLHC:1103
allotment process for RO dealerships, constitutes a contract between the
parties. This being the case he contends, Clause 23 (n) of the guidelines
has to be adhered to and cannot be deviated from, and that the petitioner by
filing the instant writ petition is asking this Court to rewrite the contract
between the parties, by holding that the Pan Card mismatch is a rectifiable
defect, even when the guidelines provide that the same is non-rectifiable.
In support of this argument, the learned counsel has cited the case of Shree
Ambica Medical Stores & Ors. vs. Surat People’s Co-operative Bank
Limited & Ors. reported in (2020) 13 SCC 564, where it has been held
that the Court through its interpretive process cannot rewrite or create a
new contract between the parties.
9.
The learned counsel has then asserted that the petitioner has not
raised any challenge against Clause 23 (n) either in the pleadings or in the
prayer and as such, no relief can be forthcoming, notwithstanding the
power of the Court to mould the relief and further that a Pan Card
mismatch is not a ground for judicial interference. It is also submitted that
a typographical error is not a ground for relief and in this regard has placed
reliance on the following judgments:
(i)
IOCL vs. Raj Kumar Jha, 2011 SCC Online Pat 1529.
2024:MLHC:1103
(ii)
10.
Gaurav Gupta vs. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited &
Ors., judgment dated 07-05-2024 passed by Hon’ble High
Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in CWP-6000
of 2024.
It is further submitted that the decision of the respondents cannot be
said to be unreasonable as the same was based on the guidelines mandated
to be compulsorily followed by the respondents. The judgments placed by
the petitioner have also sought to be differentiated and distinguished by the
learned counsel, who submits that the judgment of the Karnataka High
Court in WPC No. 1771/2024, while setting aside the petitioner’s
application on the ground of Pan Card mismatch is without any reasoning
as to why the rejection was erroneous. It is then lastly submitted that the
RO dealership has already been allotted on 22-02-2024 and the new
allottee is not a party in the present proceedings, nor had the petitioner
sought to implead him even after coming to the knowledge of the same,
and that it is a well-established position of law that no order prejudicial to
a person can be passed in the absence of that person.
11.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, though the main issue
in question is the rejection of the application of the petitioner on account of
the mismatch of one alphabet in the uploaded Pan Card number, another
aspect that also deserves consideration, is the manner in which the
respondent company has conducted itself in the course of the proceedings.
2024:MLHC:1103
As it has been submitted, the first writ petition that is, WP(C). No. 74 of
2024 had been filed against the non-disposal of the representation of the
petitioner on 18-03-2024, which was then withdrawn on 12-04-2024 on
receipt of the order that the representation had been rejected by an order
dated 16-03-2024. The said information was contained in the affidavit filed
on 10-04-2024 by the respondent company in WP(C). No. 74 of 2024
which however, did not disclose the fact that the said RO dealership had
already been settled with another party on 22-02-2024. This is revealed
from the records of the disposed of WP(C). No. 74 of 2024 which had been
requisitioned by this Court in the course of hearing of the instant writ
petition.
12.
It was only in the affidavit filed by the respondent company in the
instant writ petition challenging the rejection of the representation, that it
was revealed that the RO dealership had been awarded to another party as
far back as on 22-02-2024. Interestingly, in the course of the proceedings
in the instant writ petition, this Court by order dated 22-04-2024, at the
motion stage itself, had directed in the interim that there shall be no
settlement of the RO dealership with any other party and this interim order
was then continued vide successive orders till the last extension on 22-082024 without any objection by the learned counsel for the respondents No.
2 & 3. The respondent company in spite of this fact did not deem it fit to
2024:MLHC:1103
apprise the Court at the initial stage itself that the dealership had been
awarded to another party and continued in the charade, as if the matter was
still available for consideration. This to the mind of the Court amounts to
suppression and misrepresentation which shall be dealt with later in the
order.
13.
Coming to the main aspect of the matter, it is noted that the
mismatch in the uploaded Pan Card number was of one alphabet, which at
Clause 23 (n) is listed as a non-rectifiable deficiency. Though in the
judgments placed by the respective counsels of different High Courts, there
has been divergent views, this Court in consideration of these
pronouncements and also the circumstances of the case would hold that the
petitioner while applying for the RO dealership was well aware as to the
undertaking which had been given at the time of application for the Retail
Outlet. At Clause 15 (a) of the application itself, it has been clearly spelt
out that if it was found that information given is incorrect, amongst other
conditions, then the candidature would stand cancelled and declared
ineligible for Retail Outlet dealership. Further, though is has been argued
that the Brochure for Selection of Dealers is only a guideline which does
not have the force of law, the fact that Pan Card number mismatch, being
listed at Sl. No. 23 (n) of the List of Non-rectifiable Deficiencies in
applications, in the considered view of this Court, this requirement which
2024:MLHC:1103
binds the petitioner in no unclear terms, despite the fact that the error was
of a single alphabet, will constitute an infraction of the agreed terms and
conditions. It is also to be noted that these guidelines have been framed
and are part of company policy which the respondent company is also
bound by. The decision placed by the petitioner of the Karnataka High
Court therefore, will not come to his aid more so, as the same has not
dwelt in detail as to the reasons and circumstances allowing that writ
petition.
14.
The other points that go against the writ petitioner is also the fact
that no challenge has been made to Clause 23 (n) and as such,
notwithstanding any other circumstances, the petitioner is bound by the
undertaking given in the application. The decisions placed by the counsel
for the respondent on this aspect and other points are deemed not necessary
to be elaborated upon, in view of the findings made herein above.
15.
However, reverting back to the suppression of material facts by the
respondent company which it appears has been made knowingly in judicial
proceedings before this Court, the same is deprecated and it is expected
that necessary appropriate disciplinary action be instituted against the
Officers concerned who are responsible for misleading this Court. It is
also further provided that the respondents No. 2 & 3, for such conduct
2024:MLHC:1103
shall pay a cost of ₹ 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) to be made over to the
Meghalaya State Legal Services Authority, Shillong, for the purposes of
legal aid within a period of four weeks from the date of this order.
16.
With the above noted directions, this writ petition is closed and
disposed of.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.12.02 17:18:39 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review