Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.38226 of 2023
In the matter of an application under Articles 226 and 227
of the Constitution of India.
………………
….
Damodar Mishra
Petitioner
-versus….
State of Odisha & Others
For Petitioner
For Opp. Parties :
:
Opposite Parties
Mr. B. Routray, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. J. Biswal, Advocate
Mr. P.K. Panda, ASC
PRESENT:
THE HONBLE JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing:05.03.2026 and Date of Judgment:05.03.2026
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1.
Heard Mr. B. Routray, learned Senior Counsel
along with Mr. J. Biswal, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. P.K. Panda, learned Addl. Standing
Counsel for the State.
2.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer: -
// 2 //
“It is therefore, most humbly prayed that this
Hon'ble Court be graciously pleased to
i) Admit the writ application.
ii) Call for the record.
iii) Issue Rule Nisi calling upon 0pp. Parties more
particularly 0pp. Party No.1 and 2 to show cause as to
why the order No.11911 dtd. 11.12.2017 under
Annexure-8, Order No.5931 dtd. 23.10.2019 under
Annexure-10 and Order No. 6285 dtd. 01.09.2023
under Annexure-12 shall not be quashed.
iv) If the 0pp. Parties more particularly 0pp. Party No.2
and 3 fails to show cause or show insufficient cause
issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other
appropriate
writ/writs,
order/orders,
direction/directions by quashing the order No.11911
dtd. 11.12.2017 under Annexure-8, Order No.5931
dtd. 23.10.2019 under Annexure10 and Order No.
6285 dtd. 01.09.2023 under Annexure-12.
v) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus or any other
appropriate
writ/writs,
order/orders,
direction/directions directing the opposite party No. 2
to treat the period of suspension from 03.03.2011 to
25.12.2011 as duty and consequentially allow all the
service benefits and emoluments for the said period.
vi)
And/or
pass
such
other
order/orders,
direction/directions as the Hon'ble Court may deem fit
and proper for the ends of justice.”
3.
It is contended that in the proceeding initiated
against
the
petitioner
vide
Memorandum
dated
28.04.2012 under Annexure-2, after completion of
the enquiry under Annexure-4, petitioner was issued
with the 2nd show-cause on 17.08.2017 under
Annexure-6 by proposing the following punishment:“1. One increment
cumulative effect.
to
be
stopped
without
// 3 //
2. The period of suspension with effect from
03.03.2011 to 25.12.2011 to be treated as such.”
3.1. It is however contended that after consideration
of the reply made by the petitioner to the 2nd showcause under Annexure-7 and while disposing the
proceeding
vide
order
dated
11.12.2017
under
Annexure-8, the Disciplinary Authority-Opp. Party
No.2 imposed the following punishment on the
petitioner:“1. D.O. is warned not to commit such mistake in
future.
2. The period of suspension with effect from
03.03.2011 to 25.12.2011 to be treated as such.”
3.2. It
is
contended
that
while
disposing
the
proceeding, Opp. Party No.2 since imposed the
punishment of warning which is a minor punishment
as prescribed under Rule-13 of OCS(CCA) Rules, 1962
(in short Rules) in view of the decision in the case of
Bani Bhusan Dash Vrs. State of Odisha and
Others
(W.P.(C)
No.7635
of
decided
on
28.10.2021), the period of suspension could not have
been treated as such. This Court in Para 10 of the
// 4 //
decision in the case of Bani Bhusan Dash has held
as follows:“10. Coming to the 3rd punishment, as imposed in
the impugned order dated 15.09.2018 under
Annexure-8, i.e. treating the period of suspension
as leave due and admissible, no doubt the
authorities are empowered to place an employee
under suspension in contemplation or pending
drawal of a proceeding exercising their power
under Rule-12 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962.
Accordingly, they have to give a conclusion the
manner to treat the period of suspension at the time
of passing final order in the departmental
proceeding. The authorities are to keep the
suspension as such or to revoke the said
suspension order by revising the period of
suspension as duty, as because honouring
nonengagement certificate for the relevant period,
the authorities have sanctioned subsistence
allowance to the delinquent during the period of
suspension. In the instant case, the authority, after
taking a decision not to treat the period of
suspension as such, is not empowered to take a
decision to treat the period of suspension as leave
due and admissible, when the petitioner did not
ask for any leave during the said period of
suspension. Regularization of a particular period
treating as leave period of different kinds of leave,
as provided under Orissa Leave Rules, can be
considered only when the petitioner/employee
concerned seeks leave from the competent authority
for certain period under certain circumstances. The
authority cannot initiate a proposal from its side in
assumption of leave application from the delinquent
or employee concerned to treat the period as leave
due and admissible affecting the delinquent by way
of consuming accrued leave in favour of the
employee concerned without any fault on his part.
As the authority has come to a conclusion to punish
the petitioner only with a minor penalty, the
decision of the competent authority to place the
petitioner under suspension on the allegation of
grave misconduct does not appear to be
satisfactory, rather it seems that the order of
suspension was issued without application of mind
or in a routine or mechanical manner. As such, no
review of suspension was held, as per the
guidelines. Under such circumstances, after
// 5 //
concluding the departmental proceeding by
imposing minor penalty of stoppage of one
increment without cumulative effect, the authority
should not have treated the period of suspension in
any manner other than the duty affecting the
service condition of the petitioner.”
3.3. It is contended that challenging such order of
punishment, petitioner when moved Opp. Party No.1Appellate
Authority
by
filing
an
appeal
under
Annexure-9, the Appellate Authority vide order dated
23.10.2019 under Annexure-10, modified the order to
the following effect:“i. He is censured.
ii. The period of suspension from 03.03.2011 to
25.12.2011 may be treated as such.”
3.4. It
is
contended
that
Review
filed
by
the
petitioner against the order of punishment passed by
the Appellate Authority was also rejected vide order
dated 18.09.2023 under Annexure-12.
3.5. Learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioner contended that since while disposing the
proceeding so modified in appeal, punishment of
censure so imposed, is in the nature of a minor
punishment, in view of the decision in the case of
// 6 //
Bani Bhusan Dash so cited (supra) so followed by
this Court in various Writ Petitions, the period of
suspension could not have been treated as such and
instead the period of suspension is to be treated as
duty for all purposes.
3.6. This Court placing reliance on the decision in the
case of Bani Bhusan Dash has passed the following
order in W.P.(C) No.11038 of 2022. Para-7 and 7.1 of
the order reads as follows:“7. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
Parties and taking into account the materials available
on record, it is found that while disposing the
proceeding vide order dt.21.08.2015 under Annexure7, Petitioner was imposed with a minor punishment i.e.
stoppage of one increment without cumulative effect.
Appeal filed against such order of punishment was
rejected vide order dt.25.03.2022 under Annexure10.
7.1. On the face of such punishment imposed and in
view of the decisions as cited supra, the period of
suspension should not have been treated as such,
instead of treating the same as duty. Therefore, this
Court is inclined to quash the order so far as it relates
to treating the period of suspension as such. While
quashing the same, this Court directs Opp. Party No. 2
to treat the period of suspension as duty and extend
the financial benefit as due and admissible in favour
of the Petitioner. Such an exercise be undertaken and
completed by the O.P. No. 2 within a period of two (2)
months from the date of receipt of this order.”
3.7. It is accordingly contended that while imposing
the punishment of censure, which is a minor
// 7 //
punishment, period of suspension treated as such,
requires interference of this Court.
4.
Learned Addl. Standing Counsel on the other
hand made his submission basing on the stand taken
in the counter affidavit so filed. It is contended that
since in the proceeding in question, there is no
allegation that petitioner has not been provided with
due opportunity of hearing and there is violation of
any statutory rule, no illegality or irregularity can be
found with the impugned order.
4.1. It is also contended that since the order passed
by the Disciplinary Authority has been considered
and modified by the Appellate Authority vide order
under Annexure-10 so upheld in Review, challenge
made to the order of punishment is no more
entertainable.
5.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
considering the submission made, this Court finds
that in the proceeding initiated vide Memorandum
dated
28.04.2012
under
Annexure-2
and
while
// 8 //
disposing the proceeding vide order dated 11.12.2017
under
Annexure-8,
Disciplinary
Opp.
Authority
Party
No.2
imposed
the
being
the
following
punishment:“1. D.O. is warned not to commit such mistake in
future.
2. The period of suspension with effect from
03.03.2011 to 25.12.2011 to be treated as such.”
5.1. In the appeal so filed by the petitioner, Appellate
Authority imposed the following punishment:“i. He is censured.
ii. The period of suspension from 03.03.2011 to
25.12.2011 may be treated as such.”
5.2. The order passed in appeal has been confirmed
in
Review
vide
order
dated
18.09.2023
under
Annexure-12. This Court taking into account the
nature of punishment imposed by the Appellate
Authority
under
Annexure-10,
so
confirmed
in
Review, is of the view that since while disposing the
appeal, petitioner was imposed with the punishment
of censure, which is a minor punishment, in view of
the decision in the case of Bani Bhusan Dash so
cited (supra) and followed by this Court in W.P.(C)
// 9 //
No.11038 of 2023, while imposing such a minor
punishment, the period of suspension could not have
been treated as such.
5.3. Therefore, placing reliance on the aforesaid
decision
and
subsequent
decision
in
W.P.(C)
No.11038 of 2022, this Court is inclined to quash the
order so far as it relates to treating the period of
suspension as such. While quashing that part of the
order, this Court directs Opp. Party No.2 to treat the
period of suspension from 03.03.2011 to 25.12.2011
as duty for all purpose and extend the consequential
benefit as due and admissible in favour of the
petitioner. This Court directs Opp. Party No.2 to
complete the entire exercise within a period of 2 (two)
months from the date of receipt of this order.
6.
The Writ Petition stands disposed of.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated the 5th March, 2026/Basudev
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASUDEV SWAIN
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 07-Mar-2026 15:03:21
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review