Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1138
Serial No.29
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 148 of 2023
Date of Decision: 09.12.2024
Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Limited.
…Petitioner
-Versus1.
Union of India
Represented by the Secretary to the
Government of India, Ministry of
Commerce and Industry (Deptt. of
Industrial Policy and Promotion),
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi-110011.
2.
The Under Secretary to the
Government of India
Ministry of Commerce and Industry
(Deptt. Of Industrial Policy and Promotion),
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi-110011.
3.
The Deputy Secretary to the
Government of India,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry
(Deptt. Of Industrial Policy and Promotion),
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi-110011.
4.
Joint Secretary
Department for Promotion of
Industry and Internal Trade,
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi-110011.
5.
The State of Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:1138
Represented by the Commissioner
and Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Directorate of Commerce
and Industries, 2nd Floor, Lower Lachumiere,
Shillong, Meghalaya 793001.
6.
Principal Secretary (Industries)
Directorate of Commerce
and Industries, 2nd Floor, Lower Lachumiere,
Shillong, Meghalaya 793001.
7.
Director of Commerce and Industries
Directorate of Commerce
and Industries, 2nd Floor, Lower Lachumiere,
Shillong, Meghalaya 793001.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) :
Dr. A.Saraf, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N.Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. M.Myrchiang, Adv. for R 1-4.
Mr. A.Kumar, AG with
Ms. A.Thungwa, GA for R 5-7.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The writ petitioner by way of the instant writ petition has assailed
the action of the respondents in short sanctioning the claim of the
petitioner company on account of transport subsidy under the Transport
2024:MLHC:1138
Subsidy Scheme, 1971, for the period 01-11-2011 to 31-03-2013. Further
challenge is also made to the inaction of the Department of Industrial
Policy and Promotion, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government
of India in not issuing necessary clarification as sought for by the
Government of Meghalaya.
2.
It is the case of the petitioner that the short sanctioning of the claim
was on the basis of a letter dated 04-10-2013, which was subsequently
withdrawn and therefore, the petitioner was entitled to the full amount of
transport subsidy as per the claim submitted.
3.
Dr. A.Saraf, learned Sr. counsel on behalf of the petitioner has
submitted that the claim of the company for the period 01-11-2011 to 3103-2013 was considered by the 70th State Level Committee and vide letter
dated 30-09-2013, the claim of the petitioner was sanctioned, though with
a shortfall of ₹ 4.61 crores. The reason he submits, was ascribed to a letter
dated 04-10-2023, which had stipulated that subsidy is not admissible for
transportation cost incurred for interstate movement of finished goods
within the North Eastern States beyond the railway station nearest to the
destination. It is then submitted that the petitioner company had then vide
letter dated 05-12-2013, addressed to the respondent No. 7 pointed out that
the date of claim application as well as the date of the 70 th State Level
2024:MLHC:1138
Committee meeting was prior to the letter dated 04-10-2013 and as such,
there was no reason for the shortfall in payment.
4.
It is further submitted that vide letter dated 04-07-2014, the earlier
letter dated 04-10-2013, was withdrawn and the cost of transportation
beyond the railway head nearest to the destination point of delivery was
allowed. The petitioner company, it is then submitted on 04-05-2016,
addressed a letter to the respondent No. 7, requesting the sanction of the
balance amount and that on the basis of this representation, the respondent
No. 7 vide letter dated 28-02-2019, had written to the respondent No. 2
seeking response and clarification. The petitioner company he submits,
thereafter, pursued the matter as also the respondent No. 7 till the year
2022, which however, met with no response. It is contended that there
being no impediment to the sanctioning of the shortfall in payment, in
view of the changed circumstances brought about by the letter dated 0407-2014, the action of the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 in not issuing the
clarification for the same, amounts to the violation of the vested rights of
the petitioner company, which calls for interference by this Court in
exercising powers under Article 226 of the Constitution.
5.
Dr. N.Mozika, learned DSGI assisted by Ms. M.Myrchiang, learned
counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 to 4, has at the outset submitted that the
2024:MLHC:1138
writ petition is hopelessly delayed, and on this ground alone deserves no
consideration. The learned DSGI then submits that the writ petitioner has
preferred the instant writ petition only in 2023, when the matter in fact
relates to payments that were made in 2013 and had culminated in the
Notification dated 04-07-2014, wherein it had been given in para 5 thereof,
that the claims which had already been settled need not be reconsidered/reopened. Learned DSGI then contends that there is no
question of any further clarification as sought to be made out by the
petitioner and in fact, the instant case has been filed to circumvent the
inescapable delay that the petitioner would face if resort to civil remedy
was taken. It is submitted that the instant matter being a stale claim, it
deserves no consideration and is liable to be dismissed.
6.
Mr. A.Kumar, learned AG assisted by Ms. A.Thungwa, learned GA
for the respondent Nos. 5 to 7, has also concurred to the submissions made
by the learned DSGI and has further added that in the final analysis, no
relief would be admissible to the petitioner in view of the fact of the case
itself. With regard to the representation made by the petitioner and the
letters issued by the respondent Nos. 5 to 7, it is submitted that mere
representation will not amount to curing a delay in approaching the Court.
In this context, the learned AG has placed reliance on the case of Surjeet
2024:MLHC:1138
Singh Sahni vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. reported in (2022) 15 SCC
536.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, it is noted that the
points in issue for determination by the Court is only with regard to the
maintainability of the writ petition on the point of delay and right of the
petitioner to be allowed payment of the shortfall as claimed.
8.
Before deliberating on the issues in question, it may be stated herein
that the Transport Subsidy Scheme, 1971, was notified by the Government
of India for grant of subsidy on the transport of raw materials and finished
goods to and from selected areas with the view to promoting the growth of
industries in hilly, remote and inaccessible areas. For the North Eastern
States, subsidy was pegged at 50%, admissible on the inter-state movement
of finished goods, but however, there being uncertainties with regard to
the actual cost of transportation, or the cost of movement from the location
of the industrial units to the nearest destination by road, the same was
clarified vide letter dated 04-10-2013, that subsidy was not admissible for
the transportation cost incurred for inter-state movement of finished goods
within the North Eastern States beyond the railway station nearest to the
final destination. This restriction was however withdrawn by letter dated
04-07-2014, reconfirming the eligibility of the transportation cost by road
2024:MLHC:1138
from the railway station to the location where finished goods have been
received. A rider however was given in this letter which mentioned that
already settled claims need not be re-considered/reopened.
9.
Coming to the case at hand, it is first to be noted that the claim of
the petitioner pertains to the period from 01-11-2011 to 31-03-2013, and
the petitioner’s claims had been considered in the 70 th Meeting of the State
Level Committee held on 12th and 13th September, 2013, wherein the
petitioner’s claims amongst others, was then computed and approved for
sanction. As such, from a plain understanding, as the disbursement has also
happened, the claims of the petitioner would have been considered to be
settled in line with the letter dated 04-10-2013. The letter dated 04-072014, however, as observed earlier, had changed this position and allowed
the actual cost of transportation to be taken into consideration, which the
petitioner now seeks to take benefit of, which would entitle it to claim
payment for the alleged shortfall. This, in the considered view of this
Court, in view of the express direction contained in the letter dated 04-072014, would not be open for consideration. The letter dated 04-07-2014,
being relevant for the purposes of this discussion is reproduced herein
below:
2024:MLHC:1138
“No.15(7)2011-DBA-II/NER-Vol-II
Government of India
Ministry of Commerce & Industry
(Deptt. Of Industrial Policy & Promotion)
Udyog Bhawan, New Delhi-110 001
Dated: 04th July, 2014
To,
Principal Secretary (Industries),
Government of Meghalaya,
Myntdu (Additional Secretariat)
building,
Shillong-793 001, Meghalaya.
Subject: Transport Subsidy Scheme, 1971 –
applicability to North Eastern Region
(NER).
Sir,
The undersigned is directed to invite
reference to notification dated 24th May, 1988 on
TSS, 1971, thereby amending para 1 (i) of order
dated 17th March, 1987 and allowing Transport
Subsidy on inter-state movement of finished
goods within North Eastern Region and also to
this Department’s letter dated 04.10.2013
wherein it has been clarified that as per the
provision of Transport Subsidy Scheme, 1971,
subsidy is not admissible for the transportation
cost incurred for inter-state movement of finished
goods within North East States beyond the
railway station nearest to the final destination.
Subsequently, several representations have been
received in this Department, wherein requests
have been made to review the decision relating
to admissibility of finished goods for transport
subsidy under Transport Subsidy Scheme (TSS),
1971 on its inter-state movement within the NER.
2.
The matter has since been examined in
this Department in consultation with the
2024:MLHC:1138
Integrated Finance Wing (IFW) and the office of
Chief Controller of Accounts, DIPP and after
careful examination, it has now being clarified
that in case of inter-state movement of finished
goods within the NER, the cost of transportation
beyond the railway head nearest to the delivery
point, where finished goods is being delivered, is
also to be taken into account for subsidy under
Transport Subsidy Scheme, 1971.
3.
In such cases, the actual cost of
transportation, or the cost of movement from the
location of the industrial unit to the nearest
Railway Station by road and thereafter by rail to
the railway station nearest to the location where
the finished goods is to be received and
subsequently by road from that railway station to
the location where finished goods has been
received, whichever is less, will be taken into
account.
4.
Accordingly, this Department’s earlier
letter of even number dated 04.10.2013, stands
withdrawn.
5.
It has also been decided that the claims
which have already been settled need not be reconsidered/reopened.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/(Arun Kumar)
Under Secretary to the Government of India
Tel.No. 2306 3096.”
10.
As can be seen from the above quoted letter, though concessions had
been made and the earlier letter dated 04-10-2013 stood recalled and the
transport subsidy allowed in the manner provided above, the fact that the
2024:MLHC:1138
claims of the petitioner had been settled much before even both the letters
had been issued, the seeking of clarification on this aspect of the matter
therefore appears to be futile.
11.
The other aspect which had been strongly argued by the respondents
also proves disadvantageous to the petitioner’s case, inasmuch as, from the
materials present on record itself, the first representation had been
preferred only on 4th May, 2016, after considerable time had elapsed from
the issuance of letter dated 04-07-2014, and the instant writ petition had
been preferred only as recently as in 2023. The other communications
annexed to the writ petition which are letters by the respondents No. 5 to 7
seeking clarification, to the mind of this Court, in view of the laches and
delay on the part of the petitioner are of no consequence and are
disregarded.
12.
Accordingly, in view of the discussions made herein above, there is
no merit in the instant writ petition and the same is dismissed, however,
with no order as to costs.
Judge
SAMANTHA ANNA LIYA
RYNJAH
Date: 2024.12.09 17:12:50 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review