Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010216022025
2026:GAU-AS:2835-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/616/2026
DALIMA KHATUN
W/O- SAIDUR RAHMAN, (D/O- LT. BARKAT ALI), R/O- VILL- BALIGAON,
P.S. ORANG, DISTRICT- UDALGURI, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE MINISTRY OF HOME
AFFAIRS, GOVT. OF INDIA, SHASTRI BHAWAN, TILAK MARG, NEW DELHI1
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM
HOME DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER OF ODALGURI
P.O. AND DIST. UDALGURI (BTR)
ASSAM
PIN- 784509
4:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (BORDER)
UDALGURI
P.O. AND DIST. UDALGURI
ASSAM
PIN- 784509
5:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NEW DELHI-1
Page No.# 2/11
6:THE STATE CO-ORDINATOR OF NRC
ASSAM
HOUSEFED COMPLEX
2ND FLOOR
BANPHOOL NAGAR
DISPUR
GUWAHATIAdvocate for the Petitioner
: MR. M AHMED, MR. M M ZAMAN
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., GA, ASSAM,SC, ECI,SC, F.T,SC, NRC
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
ORDER
Date : 25.02.2026
(K.R. Surana, J)
Heard Mr. M. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Ms. A. Gayan, learned CGC for respondent no.1; Mr. G. Sarma, learned
standing counsel for the respondent nos. 2, 4 and 6; Mr. A.I. Ali, learned
standing counsel for respondent no.5; Mr. P. Sarmah, learned Addl. Senior Govt.
Advocate for respondent no.3.
2.
By filing this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the petitioner, namely, Dalima Khatun, has assailed the impugned
opinion dated 06.07.2021, passed by the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal2ND, Darrang, Mangaldai, in F.T. 2ND Case No. 1039/2011, arising out of Ref.
F.T. Case No. 48/2011, by which she was declared to be a foreigner or illegal
migrant of stream of post 25.03.1971.
3.
This writ petition was filed on 18.09.2025, to assail the opinion
dated 06.07.2021, i.e. after there has been an extraordinary delay of 4 years, 2
Page No.# 3/11
months, 13 days (or 1535 days). Moreover, at the time of filing the writ petition,
certain defects were noted, which were belatedly rectified only on 04.02.2026,
i.e. after 4 months, 14 days. Hence, the matter was heard on delay and laches
on part of the petitioner to assail the impugned opinion.
4.
The learned counsel had submitted that in paragraph 18 of the
writ petition, the petitioner has taken a stand that due to extreme financial
hardship, she could not file the writ petition on time.
5.
Per contra, the learned standing counsel for the FT, Border
matters and NRC had submitted that the explanation given for the inordinate
delay is vague and insufficient and not supported by any documents or any
other cogent and reliable material.
6.
The learned CGC and the learned Addl. Senior Govt. Advocate
for the other appearing respondents have adopted the submissions made by the
learned standing counsel for the FT, Border matters and NRC.
7.
The petitioner, on receipt of notice, has appeared and filed her
written statement, wherein it has been stated that she was born on 20.07.1985
and born and brought up at village Singimari, in Bongaigaon District. Later, after
she got married with Sahidul Rahman, she is now residing at village- Baligaon in
Udalguri District with her husband and two children. The name of her father
appeared in the voters list of 1966 and 1970 of 71 No. Rangamati LAC of
village- Kharpari Chapari, as Barkat Ali, son of Abdul Hoque. In the year
1963/1964, one annual khiraj patta no. 38 was issued in the name of her father,
Barkat Ali, son of Abdul Hoque. One voters identity card and PAN card has been
issued in her name. The name of her father appeared in the voters list of 1997
of 72 No. Barsala LAC of village- Singimari Bangaligaon, as Barkat Ali, son of
Page No.# 4/11
Abdul Hoque. Therefore, it was prayed that the petitioner be declared as an
Indian.
8.
The petitioner had examined herself as DW-1 and in her
evidence-on-affidavit, the petitioner had reiterated the statements made in her
written statement and in support of her statement, the petitioner had exhibited
the following documents, viz., (i) certificate issued by the Gaonburah of VillageSingimari Bangaligaon (Ext.1); (ii) certificate issued by the Gaonburah of
Village- Baligaon (Ext.2); (iii) photocopy of voters list of 1966 (Ext.3); (iv)
annual khiraj patta no. 38 of the year 1963/64 (Ext.4); (v) copy of her PAN card
(Ext.5). It may be stated that without exhibiting the voters list of 1970 and
1997, copied the said documents were annexed as Annexure-A and Annexure-B
respectively. In her cross-examination, she had stated that they were 12
brothers and sisters and she was the 11 th girl. Her denial of the suggestion that
voters list of 1966 was a photocopy and not admissible was recorded under
objection. She had stated that the annual khiraj patta (Ext.4) was in the name
of Barkat Sheikh and she had denied that Barkat Sheikh was not related to her.
She had also denied that she was not an Indian citizen.
9.
The learned Tribunal, vide impugned opinion, by referring to the
exhibited documents, had held that mere filing of documents and picking some
similar names from such documents so as to establish her link with the said
person as father does not amount to proof. Accordingly, it was held that the
petitioner had failed to discharge her burden of proof under Section 9 of the
Foreigners Act, 1946 that she is not a foreigner but an Indian. Resultantly, the
opinion was passed against the petitioner, thereby declaring her to be a
foreigner or an illegal migrant of stream of post 25.03.1971.
Page No.# 5/11
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner had submitted that the
evidence of the petitioner was discarded because of some discrepancies in the
name of her projected father in those documents. It was further submitted that
the petitioner has more documents to show that she was an Indian. Hence, it
was submitted that the matter be remanded back for a fresh adjudication after
giving the petitioner one more opportunity to prove other documents so as to
establish her Indian citizenship.
11.
It ex facie appears that the statement made by the petitioner in
her written statement, in so far as it concerns the name of the person in whose
name annual khiraj patta was issued is not true. In the written statement it has
been stated in paragraph 7 that in the year 1963/1964, one annual patta no. 38
was issued in the name of Barkat Ali, whereas, as per the photocopy of the
document annexed at Annexure7, the name of the person in whose name the
patta was issued is Abdul Seikh, father- Abdul. It is not the pleaded case of the
petitioner in her written statement that Barkat Seikh, in whose name the annual
patta (Ext.4) was issued in 1963/1964 and Barkat Ali, the person whose name
appears in the purported voters list of 1966, 1970 and 1997 and projected as
father of the petitioner in the PAN card (Ext.5) are the same persons. Moreover,
the petitioner has not exhibited the voter lists of 1970 and 1997.
12.
It may be stated that the photocopy of the said annual khiraj
patta, which is annexed as Annexure-7 to the writ petition does not contain the
description and other particulars of the land for which the said patta was issued.
The person whose name appears in the voter list of 1966 (Ext.3) is a voter of
village- Kharpari Chapari. As per Gaonburah’s certificate (Ext.1), the petitioner is
a resident of Singimari Bangali. As per Gaonburah’s certificate (Ext.2), the
petitioner is a resident of Baligaon. In the PAN card, the date of birth of the
Page No.# 6/11
petitioner is 20.07.1985, but the petitioner has not mentioned the date of birth
in her written statement or in her evidence-on-affidavit. She had stated in her
cross-examination that they are 12 brothers and sisters, but such disclosure has
not been made in her written statement and evidence-on-affidavit. The entire
family is not there in the exhibited voters lists. Thus, except for a mere
statement in the written statement and evidence-on-affidavit filed by the
petitioner, there is no cogent, admissible and reliable document to establish the
link of the petitioner with her projected father, whose existence in India must be
established prior to the cut-off date of 25.03.1971, but except for the annual
khiraj patta (Ext.4), no other document is prior to the said cut-off date of
25.03.1971.
13.
Therefore, on examination of the pleadings and evidence, as
discussed hereinbefore, the Court is of the considered view that the petitioner
has failed to demonstrate that she has discharged her burden of proof, as
required under Section 9 of the Foreigners Act, 1946 that she is not a foreigner
but an Indian citizen. Thus, the impugned opinion expressed by the learned
Foreigners Tribunal is not found to be perverse or untenable on any count.
14.
The petitioner, in order to explain the inordinate delay in
assailing the impugned opinion, has projected that she is extremely poor. The
said statement cannot be ex facie believed because unless the petitioner has a
taxable income, she has no requirement of a PAN card. Moreover, a PAN Card
does not contain the address and therefore, it does not serve the purpose of
being carried as an identity card.
15.
In respect of inordinate delay and laches in assailing the
impugned opinion after a lapse of 4 years, 2 months, 13 days (or 1535 days), it
may be stated that there is no period of limitation prescribed for filing a writ
Page No.# 7/11
petition, but unless the petitioner demonstrates good and cogent reason, delay
and laches would disentitle the petitioner to equitable relief on the principle that
delay defeats equity. If one needs any authority on the point, the decision of the
Supreme Court of India in the case of Mrinmoy Maity v. Chhanda Koley, 2024
INSC 314: (2024) 0 Supreme(SC) 351, and Chairman/Managing Director, U.P.
Power Corporation Ltd. V. Ram Gopal, (2020) 13 SCC 225: (2020) 0
Supreme(SC) 93 (Full Bench). In the later case, while approving the decision of
the Supreme Court of India in the case of P.S. Sadasivaswamy v. State of Tamil
Nadu, (1975) 1 SCC 152 and S.S. Balu v. State of Kerala, (2009) 2 SCC 479 , it
was held to the effect that limitation does not strictly apply to a proceeding
under Articles 32 and 226 of the Constitution of India, nevertheless, such rights
cannot be enforced after an unreasonable lapse of time and the High Courts
were cautioned by observing that prolonged delay of many years ought not to
have been overlooked or condoned. Paragraph 16 thereof [as extracted from
(2020) 0 Supreme(SC) 93 ] is quoted below:16. Whilst it is true that limitation does not strictly apply to proceedings under
Articles 32 or 226 of the Constitution of India, nevertheless, such rights cannot be
enforced after an unreasonable lapse of time. Consideration of unexplained delays
and inordinate laches would always be relevant in writ actions, and writ courts
naturally ought to be reluctant in exercising their discretionary jurisdiction to
protect those who have slept over wrongs and allowed illegalities to fester. Fencesitters cannot be allowed to barge into courts and cry for their rights at their
convenience, and vigilant citizens ought not to be treated alike with mere
opportunists. On multiple occasions, it has been restated that there are implicit
limitations of time within which writ remedies can be enforced. In SS Balu vs.
State of Kerala, (2009) 2 SCC 479 this Court observed thus:
"17. It is also well-settled principle of law that "delay defeats equity". ...It
is now a trite law that where the writ petitioner approaches the High
Court after a long delay, reliefs prayed for may be denied to them on the
ground of delay and laches irrespective of the fact that they are similarly
situated to the other candidates who obtain the benefit of the
judgment."
Page No.# 8/11
16.
Thus, except for an absolute vague statement that the petitioner
is poor, no reason has been assigned for the petitioner’s failure approach this
Court within a reasonable time of passing of the impugned opinion. The opinion
was passed on 06.07.2021, but the petitioner had applied for and received the
certified copy on 17.05.2023. However, she has filed this writ petition on
18.09.2025. The Filing Section had notified 5 (five) defects, which was rectified
only after 4 months, 14 days. Thus, the petitioner, despite full knowledge of the
consequences of being declared as a foreigner, has allowed the said opinion to
attain finality for over four years. Thus, the delay is found to be not properly
explained.
17.
The Supreme Court of India, in paragraph 46 of the case of Urban
Improvement Trust v. Vidhya Devi, 2024 INSC 980: (2024) 0 Supreme(SC)
1189, has reiterated the law that undue delay in approaching the Court can be a
ground for refusing relief and it has been expressed that only in exceptional
cases, delay can be condoned. The said paragraph 46 [extracted from (2024) 0
Supreme(SC) 1189 ] is quoted below:“46. As regards the appellant’s challenge to the inordinate delay of 21 years in
filing of the writ petitions by the respondents, we are of the view that the same
needs to be considered in the facts and circumstances of the case. While it is true
that the courts have consistently held that undue delay in approaching the court
can be a ground for refusing relief, the courts have also recognized that in
exceptional cases, where the impugned action is patently illegal or affects
fundamental rights, the delay must be condoned.”
18.
In respect of the legal proposition that delay and laches is fatal to a
belated challenge to the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunals, it may be relevant
to refer to the decision of this Court in the case of Jonali Das v. Union of India,
2018 (5) GLT 492: (2018) 0 Supreme (Gau) 1186. Paragraph 9 thereof is as
Page No.# 9/11
follows:“9. In Azmat Ali @ Amzad Ali Vs. Union of India [W.P.(C) No.4971/2018, disposed
of on 01.08.2018], this Court had observed as follows:"It is more than three decades that the issue of influx of foreign nationals has
been in public domain in the State of Assam and has engaged the attention
of the people. Interest of the State is of paramount importance in that
unabated influx has the potential to affect the integrity and sovereignty of
the country. Citizenship of a person, no doubt, is a very valuable right and
should be zealously guarded. There is no gainsaying the fact that a person
who is alleged to be a foreigner must be given due and reasonable
opportunity to establish that he is a citizen of India. However, if a person
does not take steps for safeguarding his interest, he does so at his own risk
and peril as grant of opportunity cannot be an endless exercise. Right to a
fair hearing or principles of natural justice cannot be permitted to lead to a
farcical situation and to be an engine for defeating the very object of
identification and deportation of foreigners."
19.
The Supreme Court of India, in the case of Shivamma (Dead) by
LRs v. Karnataka Housing Board & Ors., 2025 INSC 1104: 2025 Supreme(SC)
1679, while dealing with the provision of Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963
has laid down certain guidelines. Though Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963
does not apply to a writ petition, but in the considered opinion of the Court,
when a writ petition is filed to assail the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunals,
under certiorari jurisdiction, the same principles should apply, requiring the
petitioner to provide at least some cogent and acceptable explanation for the
inordinate delay in assailing the opinion.
20.
Moreover, this Court, in the case of Ajbahar Ali v. Union of India,
(2025) 0 Supreme (Gau) 763, had held to the effect that the plea of compliance
with the principles of natural justice cannot be permitted to lead to a farcical
situation and to be an engine for defeating the very object of identification and
deportation of foreigners. A similar opinion has also been expressed by this
Page No.# 10/11
Court in the case of Abu Bokkor Siddique v. Union of India, 2019 (1) GLT 813 .
21.
It must be taken note of the fact that the Supreme Court of
India, in the case of Sarbananda Sonowal (supra), in paragraph 73, has held to
the effect that the procedure under the Foreigners Act, 1946 and the Foreigners
(Tribunals) Order, 1964 is just, fair and reasonable and does not offend any
constitutional provision. In paragraph 63, the Supreme Court of India had
observed that there can be no manner of doubt that the State of Assam is
facing external aggression and internal disturbance on account of large-scale
illegal migration of Bangladeshi nationals and that it, therefore, becomes the
duty of the Union of India to take all measures for protection of the State of
Assam from such external aggression and internal disturbance as enjoined in
Article 355 of the Constitution of India. In paragraph 70, it was observed that
the influx of Bangladeshi nationals who have illegally migrated into Assam pose
a threat to the integrity and security of the North Eastern region and that their
presence has changed the demographic character of that region and the local
people of Assam have been reduced to a status of minority in certain districts.
22.
Be that as it may, as the issue of citizenship has been raised,
notwithstanding the delay and laches, the Court has carefully examined the
materials available in the writ petition and on merit, the opinion expressed by
the learned Tribunal cannot be faulted with on any count. Thus, the challenge to
the impugned dated 06.07.2021, passed by the learned Member, Foreigners
Tribunal- 2nd, Darrang, Mangaldai, in F.T. 2ND Case No. 1039/2011, arising out
of Ref. F.T. Case No. 48/2011, by which she was declared to be a foreigner or
illegal migrant of stream of post 25.03.1971, fails.
23.
Resultantly, this writ petition is dismissed on merit as well as on
Page No.# 11/11
account of delay and laches at the “motion stage” without issuing notice upon
the respondents. The consequences of the said opinion shall follow.
24.
There shall be no order as to cost.
25.
The learned standing counsel for the FT, Border matters and
NRC shall communicate a downloaded copy of this order to the Home and
Political (B) Department, so as to send a copy of this order to be made a part of
the record of the learned Foreigners Tribunal for future reference.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review