Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.07
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.122/2019
Date of Order: 05.03.2024
….. Petitioner
Smti. Dakanishwapaia Sumer
Vs.
1. The State of Meghalaya represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Meghalaya.
2. The Director of Health Services (MI) Department, Meghalaya,
Shillong.
3. The Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department, Government
of Meghalaya, Shillong.
4. The Superintendent of Tura Civil Hospital, Tura, West Garo Hills
District, Meghalaya.
5. The Senior Treasury Officer, Tura, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
6. The Accountant, Tura Civil Hospital, Tura West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya.
7. The Chairman, Meghalaya Public Service Commission (MPSC),
Shillong.
….. Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. H. Nongkhlaw, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
Mr. B. Khyriem, Adv for R/7
i) Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
ORDER
The present writ petition has been filed challenging the order
dated 28.09.2018 in which the pay scale of the petitioner was fixed at
Rs.11300-22000/-. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner is before this
Court.
2. Pursuant to the advertisement dated 26.06.2012 for the post
of Prosthetist and Orthesist under the Health Department in the pay scale
of Rs.14100-27510/-pm, the petitioner had applied for the same and was
successful in the selection and on the recommendation of the Meghalaya
Public Service Commission (for short MPSC) vide letter dated
03.04.2013, the petitioner was temporarily appointed to the post of
Prosthetist and Orthesist at Civil Hospital, Tura in the pay scale of
Rs.11300-22000/-. Since the pay scale of the petitioner has been reduced
from Rs.14100-27510/- pm to Rs.11300-22000/- pm, the petitioner on
20.08.2013 has submitted a representation to the Respondent No.2 to
rectify her pay scale from Rs.11300-22000 pm to Rs.14100-27510 pm as
per the advertisement of the MPSC. The respondents, after considering
the representation submitted by the petitioner, had issued a Corrigendum
stating therein that the scale of pay appearing in the letter dated
24.05.2013 may be read as Rs.14100-27510/- pm instead Rs.1130022000/- pm.
3. Consequent thereto, the petitioner has been drawing the
scale of pay of Rs.14300-27510/- pm from the date of joining i.e.
03.06.2013 till date and the respondents, vide letter dated 28.09.2018,
which is impermissible and without notice, directed the petitioner to
refund the excess amount of pay drawn w.e.f. the date of her joining in
service onwards, as the scale of Prosthetist and Orthotist carries the pay
of Rs.11300-22000/- pm as mentioned in her appointment order dated
24.05.2013. The case of the petitioner is that after having successfully
selected in the recruitment process and duly appointed, she has been
drawing the pay scale of Rs.14100-27510/- pm and after a lapse of five
years, the respondent No.2 issued the impugned order dated 20.09.2018
by which her pay scale was reduced to Rs.11300-22000/- pm.
According to the petitioner, the Corrigendum issued on 26.08.2013 will
bind on her and the internal communication dated 09.08.2012 with
regard to wrong fixation of pay was not given effect to even prior to the
joining of the petitioner in services. According to the petitioner, the
action of the respondents in reducing the pay structure amounts to
discrimination and contrary to the advertisement based on which the
petitioner has made an application. The arbitrary action of the
respondents needs to be interfered with and the petitioner is entitled to
pay scale of Rs.14100-27510/- pm and that there shall be no recovery of
the excess amount drawn.
4. Learned counsel for the State respondents vehemently
contended that it is true that there was an advertisement on 26.06.2012
for the post of Prosthetist and Orthesist mentioning the scale of pay of
Rs.14100-27510/- pm and subsequently, though a Corrigendum was
issued on 26.08.2013 by fixing the scale of pay as Rs.14100-27510/- pm,
such wrong fixation in the scale of pay was modified to Rs.1130022000/- pm the letter impugned herein. The petitioner has also given an
undertaking dated 28.11.2017, stating that the petitioner is willing to
return the excess payment received on account of wrong fixation. When
the erroneous advertisement was sought to be rectified by means of
internal communication dated 09.08.2012, the petitioner would not be
entitled to any amount other than the scale of pay applicable to the post
of Prosthetist and Orthesist, viz., Rs.11300-22000/- pm and demand of
Rs.14100-27510/- pm is illegal. That apart the petitioner has given an
undertaking to repay the amount received in excess. The respondents has
drawn the attention of this Court to the judgments of the Apex Court in
the case of State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (Whitewasher) reported in
(2015) 4 SCC 334 and High Court of Punjab and Haryana v. Jagdev
Singh reported in (2016) 14 SCC 267 in support of the order of
recovery. He also relied upon the judgment of the Madras High Court in
the case of V. Geeta v. State of Tamil Nadu reported in 2017 SCC
OnLine Mad 4509. The Apex Court in the case of High Court of
Punjab and Haryana v. Jagdev Singh (supra) held that recovery can be
made, if it is not beyond five years. For the sake of convenience,
relevant Paragraph No.10 of the said judgment is extracted hereunder:
“10. In State of Punjab and Ors. v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer)
(2015) 4 SCC 334 this Court held that while it is not possible to
postulate all situations of hardship where payments have mistakenly
been made by an employer, in the following situations, a recovery by
the employer would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class-III and ClassIV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D' service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due
to retire within one year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess payment has
been made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion,
that recovery if made from the employee, would be iniquitous or
harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh the
equitable balance of the employer's right to recover.
(Emphasis supplied).”
5. A reading of the judgments referred to by the respondents
unveils that the recovery can be effected, when there was a wrong
fixation at the time of initial entry into service or at the time of
fixation of pay while granting promotion or if there is an undertaking
or the employee was put on notice of such recovery. Moreover, as per
the dictum laid down, no recovery can be made, if it is within a
period of five years. In this case, more than five years have gone by
from the date of joining the service, namely, 24.05.2013 and the
revised fixation was done only on 28.09.2018, which is beyond five
years. Nothing prevented the respondents in fixing the pay at
Rs.11300-22000/- pm, when a Corrigendum was issued on
26.08.2013 and no such undertaking was obtained at that point of
time. When there was an internal communication dated 09.08.2012
with regard to wrong fixation of pay, the petitioner should have been
informed that there is an error crept in and he would be appointed
only in the pay scale of Rs.11300-22000/- pm. After the
communication dated 09.08.2012 and issuance of Corrigendum dated
26.08.2013, the respondents slept over the matter and allowed the
petitioner to draw the pay scale of Rs.14100-27510/- pm and
undertaking was obtained only in the year 2017 after much water has
flown. Probably, the Officials, in order to escape from their mistake,
would have obtained the undertaking. In any event, the decision
quoted by the respondents may not be applicable to the case on hand,
as the facts are completely different. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of Padmasundara Rao (Dead) & others vs. State of Tamil
Nadu and others, reported in (2002) 3 SCC 533 observed that if it is
found that the facts of the cited judgment of the Higher Forum totally
differs with the one on hand, then there is no compulsion for the
subordinate courts to blindly rely on the same to arrive at a
conclusion. It is appropriate to extract the relevant paragraph of the
said judgment, which reads as follows:
"Courts should not place reliance on decisions
without discussing as to how the factual situation fits in
with the fact situation of the decision on which reliance is
placed. There is always peril in treating the words of
speech or judgment as though they are words in a
legislative enactment, and it is to be remembered that
judicial utterances are made in the setting of the facts of a
particular case, said Lord Morris in Herrington vs. British
Railways Board (1972) 2 WLR 537. Circumstantial
flexibility, one additional or different fact may make a
world of difference between conclusions in two cases."
6. In this case, though a wrong fixation was made, there was no
undertaking obtained initially. The Apex Court, in State of Punjab and
Ors. v. Rafiq Masih (supra) categorically held that payment made
erroneously Class-III and Class-IV employees cannot be recovered, even
though they are no entitled to the excess amount. Therefore, in the light of the
judgment of the Supreme Court in Padmasundara Rao (Dead) & others
vs. State of Tamil Nadu and others, the decision quoted by the
respondents are justifiable one and may not be applicable to facts of this case.
It does not mean that the recovery cannot be permissible and that the petitioner
can endlessly get the scale of pay at Rs.14100-27510/- pm, in view of the
fact that the mistake has been subsequently identified and the same has
been informed to the petitioner and that the petitioner has also given an
undertaking dated 28.11.2017, expressing her willingness to return back
the amount received in excess on account of wrong fixation.
7. For the foregoing discussions, this Court is of the view that there is
no infirmity in the action of the respondents in fixing the scale of pay of
the petitioner at Rs.11300-22000/- pm. as on the date of joining, namely,
24.05.2013 and she is not entitled to the scale of pay at Rs.14100-27510/pm, which has been erroneously fixed. Insofar as recovery alone is
concerned, an interference is required by this Court and the respondents
cannot recover the amount paid excessively. Accordingly, while holding
that the order with regard to fixation of pay is perfectly valid, the
respondents are directed not to effect any recovery from the petitioner in
respect of the amount paid in excess.
8. With the above observation and direction, W.P. (C) No.122 of
2019 is disposed of.
(S.Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
05.03.2024
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review