The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 08.2025 in connection with Criminal (Misc) Case No.31 of 2025 in connection with Irani PS Case No.27 of 2025 was pleased to reject the bail application filed by the accused-applicant. It was also submitted that the injury of the informant and others were simple in nature. But the police at the time of registration of this case has registered the case incorporating so many sections under Section 191(2)/190/132/121(1)/61(2)/109 of the BNS with a view to dismissal of the bail application of the accused persons. It was further submitted that on the alleged date and time the applicant was not present to the alleged P.O. rather he was undergoing treatment at Silchar and in this regard Learned Counsel Ms. S. Deb drawn the attention of the Court referring one prescription and cash memo of Silchar (Annexure-3) from which it appears that on 28.07.2025 he was at Silchar Assam and the present incident took place on 29.07.2025 at about 2320 hours then how the accused could come to Kailashahar from Silchar on that relevant point of time. So his presence was also doubtful to the alleged P.O. on that relevant point of time. However, considering the nature and gravity of the offence and the involvement of the applicant Learned Counsel urged for releasing him on bail in any condition. It was further submitted that although in the FIR the name has been mentioned as Daheem Mia but the present appl…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
AB No.68 of 2025
Daim Ali, aged 20 years,
Son of Shabaj Ali,
Resident of Lathiapura,
P.S. Irani, District: Unakoti, Tripura
---Applicant
-VsThe State of Tripura
Represented by the Ld. Public Prosecutor
---Respondent
For Applicant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sovan Mahajan, Adv.
Ms. Sarama Deb, Adv.
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
22/09/2025
This pre-arrest bail application under Section 482 is filed for
granting bail to the accused-applicant in connection with Irani P.S.
Case
No.27
of
registered
under
Section
191(2)/190/132/121(i)/61(2)/109 of BNS.
Heard Learned Counsel Ms. S. Deb and Mr. S. Mahajan,
Learned Counsel appearing for the accused-applicant and also
heard Learned Addl. P.P. Mr. R. Saha appearing for the Staterespondent.
Taking part in the hearing Learned Counsel appearing for the
applicant drawn the attention of the Court referring the contents
of the FIR. Referring the same she submitted that from the
contents of the FIR it will be clear that so many persons were
present to the alleged P.O. at the time of alleged occurrence. But
surprisingly prosecution could not satisfy the Court as to how the
accused could be identified. She also drawn the attention of the
Court that earlier the said applicant approached for bail to the
Court
of
Learned
Addl.
Sessions
Judge,
Unakoti
District,
Kailashahar and the Learned Addl. Sessions Judge by order dated
26.08.2025 in connection with Criminal (Misc) Case No.31 of 2025
in connection with Irani PS Case No.27 of 2025 was pleased to
reject the bail application filed by the accused-applicant. It was
also submitted that the injury of the informant and others were
simple in nature. But the police at the time of registration of this
case has registered the case incorporating so many sections under
Section 191(2)/190/132/121(1)/61(2)/109 of the BNS with a view
to dismissal of the bail application of the accused persons. It was
further submitted that on the alleged date and time the applicant
was not present to the alleged P.O. rather he was undergoing
treatment at Silchar and in this regard Learned Counsel Ms. S.
Deb drawn the attention of the Court referring one prescription
and cash memo of Silchar (Annexure-3) from which it appears
that on 28.07.2025 he was at Silchar Assam and the present
incident took place on 29.07.2025 at about 2320 hours then how
the accused could come to Kailashahar from Silchar on that
relevant point of time. So his presence was also doubtful to the
alleged P.O. on that relevant point of time. However, considering
the nature and gravity of the offence and the involvement of the
applicant Learned Counsel urged for releasing him on bail in any
condition. It was further submitted that although in the FIR the
name has been mentioned as Daheem Mia but the present
applicant is namely Daim Ali. But the police is constantly pursuing
to this residence for his arrest so he is apprehending that he may
be arrested in connection with this case. So Learned Counsel
urged for taking note of the said fact at the time of considering
the bail application.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. P.P. Mr. R. Saha appearing
on behalf of the State-respondent opposed the bail application and
submitted that there is sufficient material against the accusedapplicant showing his implication with the alleged offence and
furthermore he is FIR named. So considering the nature and
gravity of the offence he urged for rejection of the bail application
by producing the CD.
Considered.
In this case the prosecution was set into motion on the basis
of an FIR laid by one Inspector Vikas Kumar on 30.07.2025 to
O.C., Irani P.S. alleging inter alia that on 29.07.2025 on a specific
information regarding smuggling of some contraband items by the
border criminals of Border Fence Gate No.59, BOP Lathiapura all
ACPs were alerted. At about 2320 hours Inspection Vikas Kumar,
Coy 21C “C” Coy and HC, (G) Rishipal Singh left BOP Lathiapura
for performing motor cycle patrolling. On reaching border fence
they observed that some villagers were roaming in suspicious
manner near IBBR in contravention of Section 163 of BNSS
promulgated by DM, Unakoti. Being asked they could not give any
specific reply and out of those person a few of them were in
possession of sharp edged objects as well as lathis trying to
encircle and assault Inspector Vikas Kumar and HC (G) Rishipal
Singh. Analysing the situation both tried to maintain safe distance
from the mob. During that time the mob beaten up Head
Constable Rishipal Singh and pelted stones on them. Resultantly
both BSR personnel got minor injuries. Sensing danger to their life
both returned back to BOP Lathiapura at about 2345 hours which
was at a distance of approximately 200 meters away from the
spot. This incident was reported to Coy Commander C Coy and he
called the QRT. Meanwhile, Coy Commander departed along with
03 personnel for P.O. and when they reached at a distance of
approximately 50 meters from the BOP Lathiapura an unlawful
assembly of 30-35 villagers started pelting stones towards BSF
party led by Coy Commander and others. Sensing danger to their
life again they returned back to BOP. By that time QRT had
arrived
in
001BOP
at
about
hours
and
again
COY
Commander departed for P.O. to find out miscreants involved in
stone pelting on BSF troops. When they reached at a distance of
approximately 80-90 meters from BOP Lathiapura, an unlawful
assembly of 70/80 villagers including female who were in
possession of sharp edged objects in their hands with intention of
forceful entry into BOP Lathiapura by obstructing public servant in
discharging their duties and with an intention to cause grievous
injury assaulted and started pelting stone/bricks. Thereafter SHO
of PS Irani was approached and accordingly SI Abu Awal along
with 5 personnel of PS Irani reached BOP Lathiapura at about
0115 hours. Village Pradhan and Ward members of village
Lathiapura were also called upon to apprise them about the
incident of physical assault on BSF troops resulting which 3 BSF
personnel sustained injuries. It was further mentioned in the FIR
that Raju Mia, Javed Mia, Manohar Ali, Daheem Mis and Sakhan Ali
were involved with the alleged offence. Hence the FIR was laid.
On receipt of the FIR this present case was registered and
the investigation of the case is in progress. By this time the
present applicant and others approached to the Court of Learned
Sessions Judge, Unakoti District Kailashahar and their bail petition
was rejected. The present case is registered under Section
191(2)/190/132/121(1)/61(2)/109 of BNS. The investigation of
the case is in progress. I have also gone through the record of the
Learned Trial Court and also the CD produced by I.O. through
Learned Addl. P.P. By this time the I.O. has recorded the
statements of some of the witnesses of the prosecution who are
conversant with the facts and circumstances of this case. From the
statements of the BSF personnel recorded by I.O. it appears that
at the time of making their statements to I.O. they have
reiterated the same fact as mentioned in the FIR. I have also
perused the inquiry report of the victims. The injuries are also
simple in nature.
At the time of hearing Learned Counsel for the applicant first
of all submitted that the accused was at Silchar on that relevant
point of time. In this regard excepting one prescription other
documents could not be produced showing that on 29.07.2025 he
was
not
present
at
Kailashahar
to
the
alleged
P.O.
and
furthermore from Silchar to Agartala anybody can easily arrive at
any point of time. Moreso, if there is any other evidence remains
under the custody of the accused-applicant the same can only be
considered during trial of the case not during the stage of
investigation as opined by Learned Addl. Sessions Judge. I also
concur with the same proposition made by Learned Court below.
Furthermore, regarding name of the accused-applicant in the FIR
it is mentioned as Daheem Mia but the present applicant has filed
the petition mentioning his name as Daim Ali. But the father’s
name of the accused-applicant in the FIR and also in the petition
for bail is also same. So the plea taken by the Learned Counsel
appearing for the accused on the above two grounds cannot be
accepted at this stage as a valid ground. However, regarding
involvement of the present accused-applicant to the alleged
offence it is not disputed that the present accused-applicant is FIR
named. From the contents of the FIR it is clear that on the alleged
day initially some villagers were appeared near border fencing
Gate No.59. After that 70/80 villagers were present nearby BOP
who
according
to
the
prosecution
attacked
upon
the
BSF
personnel. From the statement of witnesses recorded by I.O. up to
the stage of investigation it cannot be ascertained how the present
accused-applicant
participated
in
the
commission
of
crime
although his involvement under Section 3(5) of BNS cannot be
ruled out. But at the same time how he participated in the
commission of crime was not clear. Furthermore, it is also not
cleared by the prosecution as to what was the role of the alleged
accused-applicant with the alleged crime whether he directly
participated in the commission of crime or he appeared to the P.O.
simply as a villager or not that could not be clearly explained by
the prosecution and I also do not find any sufficient materials in
the CD up to this stage showing the degree of involvement of the
accused person with the alleged offence. Furthermore, there is
also no such prayer from the side of I.O. regarding custodial
interrogation of the accused either to this Court or to the Learned
Court below. However, the investigation of the case is in progress.
At this stage it is not possible to give any specific observation
regarding innocence of the accused or regarding guilt of the
accused. So considering the nature and gravity of the case it
appears to this Court this is a fit case where the concession of
pre-arrest bail be granted to the accused-applicant. Accordingly
the application for granting pre-arrest bail filed by the applicant is
hereby allowed. In the event of arrest the accused-applicant may
be released on bail of his execution of bond of Rs.50,000/- (fifty
thousand) with one surety of like amount to the satisfaction of
O.C. of the concerned P.S. with the following terms and
conditions:
(i) that the accused-applicant shall make himself available
before I.O. as and when called for, for the sake of investigation.
(ii) the accused shall not leave the jurisdiction of the O.C. of
concerned P.S. without prior permission of O.C. of the concerned
P.S.
(iii) the accused-applicant shall not directly or indirectly
make any inducement threat or promise to any person acquainted
with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing
such facts to the Court or to any police officer i.e. the I.O. during
investigation of this case failing which the I.O. shall be at liberty
to approach to the concerned Court of jurisdictional Magistrate for
cancellation of the privilege of bail granted to the accusedapplicant.
Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court along with a
copy of this order.
Return back the CD to the I.O. through Learned Addl. P.P.
along with a copy of this order.
A copy of this order be supplied to Learned Counsel
appearing for the applicant in the course of the day.
In view of the above, this anticipatory bail application stands
disposed of.
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.09.22 05:47:19
+05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review