Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 32e6 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE C.V. BHASKAR REDDY
MOTGR ACCIDEN T CIVIL MISCELLANEOU S APPEAL NO:22OF 2020
Appe:ll filed Under section 173 of Motor Vehicles Act,1988 against the order
and deciee in M.V.O.P.No.2B4 of 2014 daled. O2lOBl20'19 on the file of the Court of
the chairman, Motor Accident claims Tribunal-cum- I Additional District Judge,
Mahabubnagar.
Between:
D.Yella Svramy, S/o Chinna Balaih, Age 3gyears, Occ: Mason and Agriculture,
r/o Allrpur village, Mahabubnagar Mandal and District
...AppellanUClaimant
ANI)
1. Koonda Balaiah Sio Kistaiah, Age. Maior, Occ. Owner of TATA Ace, bearing
regrstration No. AP-22-X-7412, rlo H No 4-45, Telugu Gudem' Jamisthanpur
village, Mahabubnagar Mandal.
.2. Shrir.am General lnsurance co.Ltd., Represented by its Branch Manager, First
Flo,rr Backside of ING Vysya Bank, New Town, Mahabubnagar
...Respondents
Counsel for the Appellant : Sri K Venkatesh Gupta
Counsel for the Respondent No'2 : Sri A Ramakrishna Reddy
The Court delivered the following: Judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT ITYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.BHASKAR REDDY
M.A.C.M.A.No.22 of 2O2O
DATE:25.06.2026
Between:
D. YelLa Swamy
Appellartt
AND
Konda Balaiah and another
Respondents
JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed by the appellant/ claimant u:rder Section
173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, aggrieved by the .\ward and
Decree dated 02.08.2019 passed in M.V.O.P.No.284 of 2014 by the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum I Additional District Judge,
Mahabubnagzr (for short "the Tribunal"), whereby the claim petition
filed b1' the appellant seeking compensation of Rs. 10,00,tr00/- for the
injuries sustained by him in a motor vehicle accident was dismissed.
2.
The case of the appellant before the Tribunal v.'as that on
),4.O3.2014 at about 7.30 p.m., while he u,as proceeding rn his Luna
Moped along with his wife from Mahabubnagar towz,rds Allipur
Village, a Tata Ace vehicle bearing No.AP-22-X-7 4).2, drivcn in a rash
and negligent manner, came from the opposite direction and dashed
against their vehicle, resulting in grievous injuries to him including
fracture of the right humerus. It was pleaded that he underwent
surgery and suffered permanent disability affecting his avocation as a
mason and agriculturist. On that basis, compensation of
Rs. 10,0O,0O0/- was claimed. The Tribunal, upon appreciation of the
evidence on record, dismissed the claim petition mainly on the
ground that there were discrepancies regarding the date of accident.
The Tribunal observed that the date of accident was mentioned at
different places as '14.O3.2O14, 15.03.2014 and 19.03.2014 ard held
that the claimant failed to establish that the rnjuries were sustained
in the accident involving the offending vehicle Consequently, the
claim petition was dismissed. Aggrieved by the same, the present
appeal is hled by the aPPellant.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the Tribunal
adopted a hyper-technical approach in appreciating the evidence. It is
submitted that the appellant admittedly suffered a fracture injury
and underwent surgery. The FIR, charge sheet and conviction of the
driver in the criminal case were brought on record. The discrepancies
regarding the date of accident were minor in nature and could not
have been made the sole basis for dismissing the entire claim
petition. It is further contended that the claimant and his wife are
illiterate villagers and the delay in lodging the complaint and
variation in dates ought to have been viewed in the background of the
circumstances under which the complainl came to be lodged.
4.
On the other hand, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
respondent No.2-lnsurance Company supported the impr,rgned award
of the Tribunal and submitted that the claimant failerl to establish
the very occurrence of the accident on the pleadt d date and,
therefore, the Tribunal rightly dismissed the claim petitirrn.
5.
This Court has carefully considered the rival submissions and
perused the material on record.
6.
A perusal of the impugned award discloses that the Tribunal
found that the claimant had suffered a fracture injury and underwent
treatment including surgery. The wound certificate, discharge
summa-ry and medical records were marked as Exs.A2, A5 and X1
respectively. The Tribunal itself observed that the claimeLnt sustained
a fracture of the right humerus and remained as an irrpatient. The
Tribunal further observed that had negligence been est;rblished, the
claimant would have been entitled to compensation urder various
heads. Thus, the factum of injuries and treatment is not seriously in
dispute.
7.
The dismissal of the claim petition is founded substantially
upon inconsistencies relating to the date of accident. The record
reveals that the accident date was referred to as 14.03.2014,
15.03.2014 and 19.03.2014 in different documents. The claimant
attritruted such discrepa,ncies to mistakes committed while lodging
the complaint ald recording particulars in the medical records. The
Tribunal, however, proceeded to reject the entire claim petition solely
on that basis without undertaking a comprehensive examination of
the surrounding circumstances and the documentary evidence
available on record.
8.
It is well settled that proceedings under the Motor Vehicles Act
are summary in nature and the Tribunal is expected to adopt a
pragmatic approach while appreciating evidence. Minor discrepancies
or inconsistencies, particularly in cases involving illiterate villagers
and delayed reporting of accidents, should not ordinarily result in
rejection of a genuine claim without a thorough examination of the
entire material available on record.
9.
A further perusal of the impugned award shows that though
the Tribunal discussed the discrepancies regarding the date of
accident, it did not comprehensively analyse the evidentiary value of
the charge sheet, the judgment in the criminal case marked as Ex.A4,
the medical records and the surrounding circumstances in their
proper perspective. The Tribunal also did not afford adequate
consideration to the effect of the conviction recorded in lhe criminal
proceedings arrd its bearing on the claim petition.
10. Having regard to the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this
Court is of the view that the Tribunal was not justified in dismissing
the claim petition solely on the ground of discrepancies :elating to ttre
date of accident without undertaking a comprehensive evaluation of
the entire evidence available on record. Since the mllter requires
fresh consideration on all aspects, including the occu rrence of the
accident, rash and negligent driving of the offending vehicle and the
entitlement of the claimant to compensation, this Col-trt deems it
appropriate to remit the matter to the Tribunal for fresh adjudication
after affording reasonable opportunity to both parti3s to adduce
further oral and documentary evidence, if any.
.
Accordingly, this appeal is allowed and the im;ru gned Award
and Decree dated 02.08.2019 passed by the Tribunal are set aside.
The matter is remanded to the Tribunal for fresh consideration and
disposal in accordance u,'ith 1aw. The Tribunal shall affr'rd reasonable
opportunity to both parties to adduce additionaL oral and
documentary evidence, if any, and thereafter decide the claim petition
afresh on all issues, uninfluenced by any observations rnade in this
judgment. Considering that the claim petition pertair s to the year
2014, the Tribunal shall make every endeavour to clispose of the
matter as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of six
(06) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Both
the parties shall appear before the Tribunal on 24.07.2026.
As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall
stand closed
SD/. M.OSMAN ALI BAIG
T REGISTRAR
ASSIST
//TRUE COPY//
SE CT
OFFICER
To,
1. The 'llhairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-
I Additional District
Judge, lVlahabubnaga(With records, if any)
? One CC to SRI K VENKATESH GUPTA, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One i-iC to SRI A RAMAKRISHNA REDDY' Advocate IOPUCI
.4. Twr i.;D CoPies
ADI( /K,'\
\q.
HXGH COURT
D,ATED 2510612026
oe
'Jq
o
t)
1HE S14 14:
/00 JUI2m6
or\
),\
7t
.1
j-
-\
JUDGMEhIT+DECREE
MACMP'.N o.22 ot 2020
ALL.OWING THE MACMA
G.d'b
w
#o)u
,. !.-l
*
t 32s6I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWENry FIFTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE C.V, BHASKAR REDDY
MOTCR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCEL LANEOUS APPEAL NO:22OF 202O
Between:
D.Yella Sivarry, S/o Chinna Balaih, Age.39years, Occ: Mason and Agriculture, r/o
Allipur villagr, Mahabubnagar Mandal and District.
...AppellanUCla imant
AND
1. Koor:la Balaiah S/o Kistaiah, Age. Major, Occ. Owner of TATA Ace, bearing
reg slration No. AP-22-X-7412, rlo H.No. 4-45, Telugu Gudem, Jamisthanpur
village, Mahabubnagar Mandal.
2. Shriram General lnsurance Co.Ltd., Represented by its Branch Manager, First
Floor Backside of ING Vysya Bank, New Town, Mahabubnagar
...Respondents
Appeal filed Under Section 173 of Motor Vehicles Act,'1988 against the Order
anddecreerrM.V.O.P.No.284ot2014dated O2108120'19onthefileof theCourtof
the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum- I Additional District Judge,
lt/la habubnagai'.
This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal'
the Judgnrent arrd Decree of the Lower Court and the material papers in the Case
anri upon .-rearing the arguments of Sri K Venkatesh Gupta, Advocate for the
Appellant ard ot Sri A Ramakrishna Reddy, Advocate for the Respondent No.2 and
none appea r-ed for the respondent No.'1 .
This Coun doth Order and Decree as follows:
1. That rne Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal be and hereby is allowed;
2. That ihe impugned Award and Decree dated 02.08.2019 passed by the
Trii.runal are set aside,
3. That the matter is remanded to the Tribunal for fresh consideration and
disposai in accordance with law;
4. Thert :re Tribunal shall afford reasonable opportunity to both parties to adduce
adoitional oral and documentary evidence, if any, and thereafter decide the
claim petition afresh on all issues, uninfluenced by any observations made in
this lrCgment;
5. That Considering that the claim petition pertains to the year 2014, lhe Tribunal
shall nake every endeavour to dispose of the matter as expeditiously as
poss;:le, preferably within a period of six (06) months from the date of receipt
of ai {.opy of this ludgment; and
6. That ,roth the parties shall appear before the Tribunal on 2a.07 .2026.
SD/- M.OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\\
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum- | Additional District
Jucige, Mlahabubnagar
2. Two [;D Copies
ADKTKi\
\qr
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2510612026
DECRET
MACMA.N o.22 ot 2020
ALLOWING THE MACMA
u
or5
crc?*
\a-
/b
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review