The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. One of the pleas as set up by the insurer is that the claimant has made a fictitious claim for delay of two days in lodging of FIR and nonexamination of eye witnesses, but when charge sheet has been submitted in this case, it is hardly material whether there is delay in lodging of FIR or not. Besides, it is not the rule that eye witnesses shall be required to be examined to prove the injuries to the claimant. Law only says about grant of compensation to a person suffering from injuries arising out of use of motor vehicles provided the other conditions are fulfilled. On the contrary, the insurer has not led any evidence to disclose that the claimant has not suffered any injuries in the motor vehicular accident nor had it proved about the accident not occurring. Further, no evidence has been tendered by the insurer to say that the claim advanced by the claimant is fictitious. Hence, MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025 the aforesaid plea of the insurer about claimant making fictitious claim is rejected.
8. Reverting back to the core issue of challenge to quantum of compensation which is advanced by both the parties, it appears that the learned Tribunal has taken into consideration Exts. 19, 20, 23 & 26 which are the pharmacy bills of the claimant revealing expenditure of expenses for the treatment of claimant at Rs.5,29,371/-, but the learned Tribunal thereafter has proceeded to grant a lump sum amount of Rs.9,00,000/- which includes the aforesaid expenditure of Rs.5,29,371/- which according to this Court is erroneous inasmuch as, there must be justification of granting the additional amount of Rs.3,70,629/- under the heading of medical treatment of the claimant, but the learned Tribunal has granted Rs.40,000/- towards the special diet and conveyance charges for the treatment of the claimant in the hospital for about 53 days which is considered to be on lower side inasmuch as, the claimant was MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025 immediately shifted to MCH, Cuttack and thereafter to Ashwini Hospital, Cuttack and he was treated as indoor patient therein for around 53 days which is never disputed and, therefore, the claimant is entitled to Rs.10,000/- towards conveyance charges and granting Rs.750/- per day towards cost of special diet, the aforesaid amount would come to Rs.39,750/-. It is appropriate to state here that no amount has been granted to the claimant for loss of earning d…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
(In the matter of application under Section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988).
MACA No.154 of 2024
…
Naman Kumar Goel @ Goyal
Appellant
Mr. B.N. Samantaray, Advocate
-versusBibekananda Behera & Another
…
Respondents
Mr. P.K. Mahali, Advocate (R-2)
MACA No.151 of 2025
The D.M., Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd., Khurda
…
Appellant
Mr. P.K. Mahali, Advocate
-versusNaman Kumar Goel @ Goyal &
…
Respondents
Another
Mr. B.N. Samantaray, Advocate (R-1)
CORAM:
JUSTICE G. SATAPATHY
DATE OF HEARING : 12.05.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT:15.05.2026
G. Satapathy, J.
1.
These two instant appeals U/S. 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short, the “Act”),
assail the same and one judgment dated 09.10.2023
passed in MAC Case No.924 of 2019 by which the
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
learned 3rd Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Cuttack (in
short, “the Tribunal”) directed the Divisional Manager,
M/s. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (in short, “the
insurer”) to pay a sum of Rs.16,71,800/- to Mr.
Naman Kumar Goel @ Goyal (in short, “the claimant”)
together with simple interest @ 7% per annum with
effect from 13.08.2019 within two months thence
failing which to pay penal interest @ 12% per annum.
2.
Briefly stated, on 21.07.2019 at about
8.00 AM, the claimant while proceeding to Kendrapara
on a motorcycle bearing Regd. No.OD-33-H-6207 as a
pillion rider met with an accident near Bhatapada,
Sabar Sahi on Jaunli Road located on CuttackChandabali Road, when one Mahindra Bolero Maxi
truck bearing Regd. No.OD-05-AK-3931 (hereinafter,
referred to as “the offending vehicle”) dashed against
the motorcycle resulting in serious injury to the
claimant and death of the rider of the motorcycle.
According to the claimant, the accident occurred due
to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
offending vehicle and as a consequence of such
accident, he was shifted to hospital for treatment and
accordingly,
he
undergone
treatment in different
hospitals incurring huge expenditure, but the accident
was reported to police with registration of Salepur PS
Case No.184 of 2019, which ultimately resulted in
submission of charge-sheet. The claimant further
claims that he was 20years old at the time of the
accident and was pursuing a Bachelor of Business
Administration
(BBA)
and
was
also
earning
Rs.10,000/- per month from a private job and due to
accident, he could not do his normal work and
thereby, lost a substantial amount due to the accident.
On the aforesaid averments, the claimant approached
the learned Tribunal in an application U/S.166 of the
Act for grant of compensation of Rs.20Lakhs for his
injuries in the motor vehicular accident by impleading
the owner and insurer of the offending vehicle and his
such application for compensation was registered by
the learned tribunal as MAC No.924 of 2019.
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
2.1
In response to the notices of MAC No.924
of 2019, the owner of the offending vehicle did not
choose to contest the claim and was accordingly set
ex-parte by the learned tribunal on 09.09.2021, but
the insurer contested the claim by filing written
statement denying the averments of the claim and
disowning its liability to pay the compensation to the
claimant on the ground that the claimant was rash and
negligent in the accident and there was violation of
policy conditions by the owner of the offending vehicle
for not having valid Route permit and for handing over
the vehicle to a driver not holding valid DL.
3.
On the inter-se pleadings of the parties,
the learned tribunal struck with five issues and allowed
the parties to lead evidence, but only the claimant
adduced
evidence
by
examining
two
witnesses
including himself as PWs.1 and 2 and exhibiting police
papers and other documents under Ext.1-17 and
identifying 20 X-Ray plates under MO-I to MO-XX.
After
appreciating
the
evidence
on
record
upon
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
hearing the parties, the learned tribunal passed the
impugned judgment directing the insurer to pay
compensation indicated (supra). Being dissatisfied
with the impugned judgment, the insurer and the
claimant have approached this Court in these two
separate
appeals
challenging
the
quantum
of
compensation, in addition the insurer challenging the
liability to pay the compensation to the claimant.
4.
Heard,
Mr.
Bijayananda
Samantaray,
learned counsel for the claimant and Mr. Prasanta
Kumar Mahali, learned counsel for the insurer in the
present two appeals and perused the record, but none
appears for the Respondent-cum-owner in both the
appeals at the time of hearing of the appeals despite
valid service of notice.
5.
On
a
careful
consideration
of
rival
submission, it appears that the claimant challenges
the
impugned
judgment
on
the
quantum
of
compensation, whereas the insurer challenges the
impugned judgment for not only on quantum of
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
compensation, but also the claimant filing fictitious
claim for delay of 2 days in lodging of FIR for the
accident, in addition to challenging the impugned
award for non-examination of the eye witness and
granting exorbitant compensation to the claimant by
taking temporary disability of the claimant at 40% in
relation to right leg as permanent disability and loss of
earning for the same extent of disability of the
claimant and the disability certificate being not proved
in accordance with law.
6.
It is, however, claimed by the insurer that
the disability certificate has not been proved in
accordance with law, but the learned Tribunal has not
granted any compensation under the heading of loss
of future earning to the claimant for the extent of
disability suffered by the claimant by observing inter
alia that since the disability suffered by the claimant is
not in permanent in nature, it cannot be regarded to
hold that the claimant has suffered any loss of future
earning and, therefore, the extent of disability even if
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
found to be otherwise proved without any objection by
the insurer had lost its significance for the Tribunal not
granting any compensation by taking into account the
extent of disability of the claimant. In this regard, this
Court is in fact guided by the law laid down in Raj
Kumar Vrs. Ajay Kumar; (2011) 1 SCC 343,
wherein the Apex Court in Paragraph-12 has held that
if the Tribunal concludes that there is no permanent
disability, there is no question of proceeding further
and determining loss of future earning capacity. In this
case, in view of the guidelines laid down by the Apex
Court in Raj Kumar(supra), the learned Tribunal of
course has assessed the compensation rightly by
taking into consideration the expenses relating to
treatment, hospitalization, medicine, transportation,
nourishing food and miscellaneous expenditure; and
damages
for
pain,
suffering
and
trauma
as
a
consequence of injuries, but it has not granted any
amount under the heading of loss of earning during
the period of treatment which will be discussed while
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
examining
the
quantum
of
compensation
as
challenged by both the parties.
7.
One of the pleas as set up by the insurer
is that the claimant has made a fictitious claim for
delay of two days in lodging of FIR and nonexamination of eye witnesses, but when charge sheet
has been submitted in this case, it is hardly material
whether there is delay in lodging of FIR or not.
Besides, it is not the rule that eye witnesses shall be
required to be examined to prove the injuries to the
claimant. Law only says about grant of compensation
to a person suffering from injuries arising out of use of
motor vehicles provided the other conditions are
fulfilled. On the contrary, the insurer has not led any
evidence to disclose that the claimant has not suffered
any injuries in the motor vehicular accident nor had it
proved about the accident not occurring. Further, no
evidence has been tendered by the insurer to say that
the claim advanced by the claimant is fictitious. Hence,
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
the aforesaid plea of the insurer about claimant
making fictitious claim is rejected.
8.
Reverting
back
to
the
core
issue
of
challenge
to quantum of compensation which is
advanced by both the parties, it appears that the
learned Tribunal has taken into consideration Exts. 19,
20, 23 & 26 which are the pharmacy bills of the
claimant revealing expenditure of expenses for the
treatment of claimant at Rs.5,29,371/-, but the
learned Tribunal thereafter has proceeded to grant a
lump sum amount of Rs.9,00,000/- which includes the
aforesaid
expenditure
of
Rs.5,29,371/-
which
according to this Court is erroneous inasmuch as,
there must be justification of granting the additional
amount of Rs.3,70,629/- under the heading of medical
treatment of the claimant, but the learned Tribunal
has granted Rs.40,000/- towards the special diet and
conveyance charges for the treatment of the claimant
in the hospital for about 53 days which is considered
to be on lower side inasmuch as, the claimant was
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
immediately
shifted
to
SCB
MCH,
Cuttack
and
thereafter to Ashwini Hospital, Cuttack and he was
treated as indoor patient therein for around 53 days
which is never disputed and, therefore, the claimant is
entitled to Rs.10,000/- towards conveyance charges
and granting Rs.750/- per day towards cost of special
diet, the aforesaid amount would come to Rs.39,750/-.
It is appropriate to state here that no amount has
been granted to the claimant for loss of earning during
the aforesaid period, but the claimant had advanced
claim that he was earning Rs.10,000/- per month from
a private job during the relevant time and thereafter,
the loss of earning during the period of treatment and
sometime thereafter for around four months, it would
be just and proper to grant Rs.60,000/- towards the
loss of earning during the relevant time for the
treatment of the injuries sustained by him. In addition,
the claimant is also entitled to attendant charges for
the period of treatment of 53 days @ Rs.600/- per day
and, therefore, it would come around Rs.31,800/-. The
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
learned
Tribunal
has
rightly
granted
a
sum
of
Rs.5,00,000/- towards pain suffering and loss of
amenities to the claimant as well as Rs.2,00,000/towards future medical treatment inasmuch as, the
claimant’s medical document reveals that he had
undergone surgery and treatment for crushed injuries
of right lower limb with fracture of both bone of right
leg, compound grade III B with compound open
fracture of patella(right), fracture of lateral femoral
condyle (Hoffa) and this medical procedure would
definitely
require
future
treatment.
The
learned
tribunal has also rightly granted a sum of Rs.
1,00,000/- towards loss of amenities which is a
reasonable amount keeping in view the nature of
injuries sustained by the claimant and his future
sufferance. In the result, the claimant is entitled to
following
amount
under
different
heads
as
compensation towards injuries sustained by him in the
motor vehicular accident.
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
Sl.No. Heads
Amount
(i)
Rs.5,29,371/-
Expenses relating to
treatment, hospitalization & medicine
(ii)
Expenses relating to transportation
Rs.49,750/-
(Rs. 10,000/-) & Special diet(Rs. 39,750)
(iii)
Expenses relating to attendant
Rs.31,800/-
charges
(iv)
Loss of earning during treatment & Rs.60,000/an
recovery
(v)
Pain, suffering & trauma
Rs.5,00,000/-
(vi)
Loss of amenities
Rs.1,00,000/-
(vii)
Future medical expenses
Rs.2,00,000/-
Total
Rs.14,70,921/-
In addition, the claimant is also entitled to
simple interest @ 7% per annum as awarded by the
learned Tribunal, but the penal interest @ 12% per
annum as imposed on the award, if the same is not
satisfied
within
two
months
of
passing
of
the
impugned judgment is not being in conformity with
law is hereby set aside.
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
9.
In the result, the appeal filed by the
insurer stands allowed on contest, but the appeal filed
by the claimant is hereby dismissed on contest,
however,
without
any
costs.
Accordingly,
the
impugned judgment is modified to the extent indicated
above and the insurer is hereby directed to pay the
aforesaid
amount
of
Rs.14,70,921/-
(Rupees
Fourteen
Lakhs Seventy Thousand Nine Hundred
Twenty One) together with interest @ 7% per annum
w.e.f 13.08.2019 till its actual realization to the
claimant within eight weeks hence. In case of deposit
of the aforesaid modified compensation amount before
the learned Tribunal, the same shall be disbursed to
the claimant proportionately in terms of the impugned
judgment and the statutory deposit with accrued
interest thereon be refunded back to the insurer on
proof of deposit of the modified compensation amount
before the learned Tribunal.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: JAYAKRUSHNA DASH
Reason: AuthenticationOrissa High Court, Cuttack,
Location: High Court ofDated
Orissa, Cuttack
the 15th May, 2026/Jayakrushna
Date: 15-May-2026 19:10:39
(G. Satapathy)
Judge
MACA Nos.154 of 2024 & 151 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review