Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010684022025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3311]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Wednesday, the Eighth day of April
Two Thousand and Twenty Six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B.S.Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petitions Nos: 3762 and 3763 of 2025
Between:
...Petitioner
D.L. Narasimha Rao
and
Mangu Annapurna Devi (died) and others
Counsel for the petitioner:
1. Kristam Sakthi Niranjan Guptha
Counsel for the respondents:
1. Sai Manoj Reddy L.
2. B. Abhay Siddhanth Mootha
The Court made the following:
...Respondents
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
COMMON ORDER:
C.R.P.No.3762 of 2025 is filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India against the order dated 13.11.2025 dismissing
I.A.No.521 of 2025 in O.S.No.78 of 2007 on the file of the Court of Civil
Judge (Senior Division), Kadiri, filed by the plaintiff under Order VII, Rule
14(3) of C.P.C. to grant leave to the petitioner to file the following list of
documents:
Sl. Date of
No. Document
Name of Beneficiary / Purchaser
Pallepu Ramakrishna
S. Mumtaz
T. Mahaboob Basha
Rasaputra Kande Bai
Anke Rajyalakshmi
Anke Lakshmi Devi
Gujjala Venkatrayudu
Shaik Khaja Bi
C.S. Showkath Ali
P. Mumtaz
Attar Allabakash & others
S. Shahan
Sumiya
P. Anjana Reddy
P. Nageswara
Akkamma
T.S. Shazida
C.S. Sikandar
Shaik Mahaboob Jan
Jowhar Jan
B. Lakshmi Devi
P. Anjana Reddy
Raguri Gangulappa
S. Ramana Reddy
P. Chinna Obula Reddy
Bokula Rama Mohan
Shaik Rahamathunnisa
Shaik Baba Fakruddin Sab
Busannagari Uthama Reddy
P. Chinna Obula Reddy
25-12-2009
07-02-1994
31-08-2009
16-03-2002
12-05-2011
12-05-2011
01-10-2022
22-02-1994
19-02-2002
16-08-2002
19-02-2002
07-08-2003
21-02-2002
18-01-2008
01-10-2001
22-02-1994
05-02-1994
03-02-1994
Extent
(Acres / Sq. Yds.)
0-02.5 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-07.5 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-05.00 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-02.0 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-02.0 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-12.5 Acs.
121 sq. yds.
121 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
121 sq. yds.
62.2 sq. yds.
Door No. /
Asst. No. /
Remarks
D.No.2A/191
D.No.3A/501
D.No.3/137
D.No.3A/575
Asst. No.79
D.No.15/2
-
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
31-12-2001
19-02-2002
04-02-1994
22-12-2007
21-03-1994
07-02-1994
07-02-1994
05-02-1994
07-02-1994
15-03-2002
10-07-1998
S. Hussain Peeran
Patan Yusuf Khan
S.J. Allabakash
Sabavath Venkataramana Naik
S.J. Fakruddin
S. Sheeran Taj Begum
S.J. Fakruddin
B. Bhaskar Reddy
C.S. Abdul Rawoof
P. Ramanamma
Govt. of A.P. rep. by health
department
Govt. of A.P. rep. by Forest
department
Govt. of A.P. rep. by MPP
114.83 sq. yds.
116.16 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
114.66 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
120 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
121 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
0-07.5 Acs.
0-67
-
14-02-1996
0-05
-
06-01-1999
0-10
-
2.
C.R.P.No.3763 of 2025 is filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India against the order dated 13.11.2025 in I.A.No.522 of
2025 in the aforesaid O.S.No.78 of 2007, filed by the plaintiff under
Section 151 C.P.C. to reopen his evidence to produce the following
documents:
Sl.
Date of
No. Document
Name of Beneficiary / Purchaser
Pallepu Ramakrishna
S. Mumtaz
T. Mahaboob Basha
Rasaputra Kande Bai
Anke Rajyalakshmi
Anke Lakshmi Devi
Gujjala Venkatrayudu
Shaik Khaja Bi
C.S. Showkath Ali
P. Mumtaz
Attar Allabakash & others
S. Shahan
Sumiya
P. Anjana Reddy
P. Nageswara
Akkamma
T.S. Shazida
25-12-2009
16-03-2002
12-05-2011
12-05-2011
01-10-2022
22-02-1994
19-02-2002
-
Extent
(Acres / Sq. Yds.)
0-02.5 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-07.5 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-05.00 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
Door No. /
Asst. No. /
Remarks
D.No.2A/191
D.No.3A/501
D.No.3/137
D.No.3A/575
Asst. No.79
-
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
21-02-2002
18-01-2008
01-10-2001
22-02-1994
05-02-1994
03-02-1994
31-12-2001
19-02-2002
04-02-1994
22-12-2007
21-03-1994
07-02-1994
07-02-1994
05-02-1994
07-02-1994
15-03-2002
C.S. Sikandar
Shaik Mahaboob Jan
Jowhar Jan
B. Lakshmi Devi
P. Anjana Reddy
Raguri Gangulappa
S. Ramana Reddy
P. Chinna Obula Reddy
Bokula Rama Mohan
Shaik Rahamathunnisa
Shaik Baba Fakruddin Sab
Busannagari Uthama Reddy
P. Chinna Obula Reddy
S. Hussain Peeran
Patan Yusuf Khan
S.J. Allabakash
Sabavath Venkataramana Naik
S.J. Fakruddin
S. Sheeran Taj Begum
S.J. Fakruddin
B. Bhaskar Reddy
C.S. Abdul Rawoof
P. Ramanamma
0-02.0 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-01.75 Acs.
0-02.0 Acs.
0-02.5 Acs.
0-12.5 Acs.
121 sq. yds.
121 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
121 sq. yds.
62.2 sq. yds.
114.83 sq. yds.
116.16 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
114.66 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
120 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
121 sq. yds.
60 sq. yds.
0-07.5 Acs.
-
3.
The revision petitioner filed the suit against the respondent No.1 /
sole defendant for declaration of title and permanent injunction not to
alienate the following suit schedule properties:
Description of the properties situated within the Registration
District of Anantapur and Sub-Registration District of Kadiri, Gandlapenta
revenue village and mandalam:
Sl.
No.
Classification
Govt. Dry
-do-do-do-do-
Survey
No.
967-1
978-2
Extent.
Ac. Cts.
7-55
8-02 Paiki 4-01
0-03
0-31 Paiki 0-15½
0-84
Market value.
Rs.
2,49,150-00
92,230-00
1,230-00
3,565-00
19,320-00
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
Description of the properties situated within the Registration
District of Anantapur and Sub-Registration District of Kadiri, limits of
Somayajulapalli village and mandalam:
Sl.
No.
Classification
4.
The case of the plaintiff is, briefly stated, as follows:
a.
The suit schedule properties originally belong to Smt. K. Chinna
Govt. Dry
-do-do-do-do-
Survey
No.
200-2
Extent. Ac. Cts.
1-22
2-02 Paiki 1-01
0-93
4-30 Paiki 2-15
0-10
Market value.
Rs.
28,060-00
66,660-00
21,390-00
4,38,600-00
5,600-00
Narasamma wife of Lakshminarayana Rao. D.L.Narasinga Rao is the
grandfather of the plaintiff. Smt. K. Chinna Narasamma is neice of
D.L.Narasinga Rao. After marriage of K. Chinna Narasamma, she left for
Bukkapatnam and settled with her husband there. The grandfather of the
plaintiff looked after K. Chinna Narasamma and her properties on her
behalf. Her husband predeceased her.
b.
K. Chinna Narasamma also died on 24.11.1967 issueless. She
had love and affection for the plaintiff. When she was in sound and
disposing state of mind, out of her will and affection, she executed a will
dated 16.10.1967 bequeathing all her properties to the plaintiff. Thus, the
plaintiff became an absolute owner of the suit schedule properties on the
death of K. Chinna Narasamma. He continued to hold possession of the
properties through his father when he was minor and subsequently on
attaining majority, he himself came into possession and has been
exercising his right over the properties. The grandfather, father of the
plaintiff and subsequent to them, the plaintiff, have paid land revenue for
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
the schedule mentioned properties. Entries in the revenue records are
mutated to the name of the plaintiff with regard to the plaint schedule
properties.
c.
The defendants have no manner of right, title or possession over
any portion of the plaint schedule properties at any point of time. There
are ill-feelings between the plaintiff and the defendants. With a view to
harass the plaintiff, the defendant has been trying to interfere with
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the properties by the plaintiff. As
such, he filed O.S.No.296 of 1997 before the Court of Principal Civil
Judge (Junior Division), Kadiri against the defendant. The defendant
contested that suit on basis of „will‟ allegedly executed by K. Chinna
Narasamma
in
favour
of
the
defendant
and
questioned
the
maintainability of the suit in O.S.No.296 of 1997. So, this comprehensive
suit was filed seeking declaration of title.
d.
Due to intervention of the close relatives, the plaintiff and the
defendants came to an understanding and filed a memo not pressing the
suit for the time being by reserving right to file fresh suit in case of failure
to reach an amicable settlement of the disputes. Without considering the
memo, the Court, by its judgment dated 26.12.2003, dismissed the suit
with costs, without giving any permission to file a fresh suit. Aggrieved by
the judgment, the revision petition in C.R.P.No.3090 of 2004 was filed
before this Court. The judgment dated 26.12.2003 was set aside by the
order in the revision petition dated 28.04.2006 and directed the trial
Court to consider the matter afresh and pass appropriate order after
hearing both the parties.
e.
At the time of filing the plaint in this suit, when the matter is still
pending for consideration of the memo, taking advantage of the order
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
dated 26.12.2003, the defendant made a false representation before the
revenue authorities and tried to manipulate the revenue records. Without
affording an opportunity to the plaintiff by the revenue authorities,
mutations in the records were affected. Hence, they are illegal. The
plaintiff is entitled to ignore the same. Basing on such records, the
defendant is trying to lay false claims to the plaint schedule properties
and hastening to alienate the properties and create nominal collusive
documents. So, this suit was filed.
5.
The sole defendant filed a written statement with the averments,
briefly stated, as follows:
a.
It is true that the suit schedule properties originally belong to K.
Chinna Narasamma wife of K.L. Narayana Rao of Bukkapatnam Village.
It is not correct that K. Chinna Narasamma was the niece of the
grandfather of the plaintiff. K. Chinna Narasamma has Sthreedhana
properties at Gandlapenta, having acquired them from her parents being
the only daughter to her parents. She left for Bukkapatnam immediately
after her marriage. There is no nexus between the plaintiff‟s ancestors
and K. Chinna Narasamma. She lost her parents in and about 1925.
Since then, she was residing in Bukkapatnam with her husband till he
died in the year 1963. She died on 24.11.1967 without any issue is not
correct.
b.
It is not correct that out of love and affection she had executed
„will‟ dated 16.10.1967 in favour of the plaintiff with her free will, volition
and disposing state of mind. It is false that K. Chinna Narasamma was
under the care and protection of the grandfather, father of the plaintiff
and that the plaintiff enjoyed the properties after the death of K. Chinna
Narasamma and that the entries in the revenue records were mutated to
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
his name. It is utterly false that the defendant is stranger to the suit
schedule properties and that due to bitter differences between the
plaintiff and the defendant, the plaintiff was harassed and so the plaintiff
had filed O.S.No.296 of 1997.
c.
The pleadings regarding filing of memo are also denied. The
plaintiff suppressed all the material facts. The sole defendant is the only
daughter of the K.L. Narayana Rao. He had no male issue. K. Chinna
Narasamma is the first wife of K.L. Narayana Rao and she could not
begot any children. Therefore, he married Rama Lakshmamma. Thus,
the defendant is the daughter of K.L. Narayana Rao through Rama
Lakshmamma. Both the wives lived together till the death of K.L.
Narayana Rao. All the properties of the family, including suit schedule
properties, were in possession and enjoyment of K.L. Narayana Rao and
his wives and the defendant. K.L. Narayana Rao gave a declaration
before the Tahsildar, Penukonda that the defendant, her husband,
children have been living with him along with his two wives. Even after
his death, they continued to live together. K. Chinna Narasamma and
Rama Lakshmamma and the defendant executed a registered power of
attorney in favour of the husband of the defendant by name Mangu
Gopala Krishna Murthy Rao for the management of the family properties,
including the suit schedule properties. Thus, the properties of the family
were being managed by the husband of the defendant.
d.
Neither the plaintiff nor the father or grandfather was in possession
and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties. K. Chinna Narasamma
executed a will dated 24.11.1967 in favour of this defendant in a sound
and disposing state of mind bequeathing all her properties, including suit
schedule
properties,
in
the
presence
of
P.Chinnamma
and
C.Veeranjinappa of Bukkapatnam. She died on the very same day.
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
Immediately thereafter, the defendant became the owner of the suit
schedule properties. Thus, the defendant has been exercising the right
over the suit schedule properties and possessed them. The „will‟
executed in favour of the defendant is the only „will‟ executed by the
deceased.
e.
The plaintiff set up a forged will dated 16.10.1967. The deceased
had no love and affection for the plaintiff. The deceased had no occasion
to execute a will in favour of the plaintiff as K. Chinna Narasamma was
looked after by the defendant and her husband till her death. The plaintiff
is a veteran litigant and well versed in litigation. He has been demanding
the defendant and her husband to alienate the suit schedule properties.
As they refused, the plaintiff tried to fabricate the revenue records to set
up a false claim. The plaintiff is the landlord having extensive properties
at Gandlapenta and highly influential. The defendant could not resist the
influence of the plaintiff or the revenue officials. The plaintiff went upon
creating all types of problems to knock away the suit schedule
properties.
f.
The suit is barred under Order II, Rule 2 C.P.C. due to pendency
of the suit in O.S.No.296 of 1997. Having found that the plaintiff had no
case to prosecute, he wanted to not press the suit in O.S.No.296 of 1997
to avoid costs in the suit, however, again filed the frivolous suit. The
plaintiff sold away some properties pending litigation, out of certain
extent of properties covered by suit schedule items Nos.1 and 2, through
his power of attorney Poreddi Anjana Reddy in favour of Chinna Obula
Reddy, P.Mahammad Yusuf Khan, A. Inayathulla, A. Allabakash,
P.Mumtaj and A.Anwar Basha. All these persons are proper and
necessary parties to the suit, as such the suit is bad for their non-joinder.
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
6.
Pending the suit, since the sole defendant died, her legal
representatives were brought on record as defendants Nos.2 to 9.
7.
The defendant No.8 alone filed a separate written statement while
reiterating the facts already stated by the deceased defendant, with
further averments, stated briefly as follows:
a.
The sole defendant / Mangu Annapoorna Devi executed a will on
07.08.2012 in favour of this defendant in a sound and disposing state of
mind out of her will and love bequeathing her entire estate at N.P. Kunta
and Gandlapenta Mandals and the said will is her last testament. Mangu
Annapoorna Devi died on 15.08.2012. Thus, on her death, the will came
into existence. This defendant has been exercising his right of
possession of the property since the death of the defendant No.1.
Entries in the revenue records are under consideration.
b.
This defendant filed a suit in O.S.No.173 of 2014 on the file of the
Court of Principal Civil Judge (Junior Division), Kadiri against Poreddy
Anjana Reddy (power of attorney of the plaintiff and others) seeking
permanent injunction with regard to the lands in survey Nos.898 and
1267 of Gandlapenta Revenue Village, which are shown as items Nos.1
and 2 of the schedule properties in O.S.No.78 of 2007. The suit was
decreed on 03.11.2020. Hence, the suit is liable to be dismissed.
8.
At the stage of arguments, the plaintiff filed I.A.No.521 of 2025
stating that the evidence of the plaintiff was formally closed in the year
2001, however, the suit went on adjourned several times for various
reasons including the death of sole defendant and bringing on record her
legal representatives and that the list mentioned documents are
necessary as evidence in the suit. The petitioner executed them in
favour of the departments of the government and public bodies through
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
gift deeds and the sale deeds and that in the cross examination of the
witnesses for the defendants, the plaintiff attempted to confirm these
documents, but the witnesses declined to admit the truth and therefore, it
is necessary to grant leave to the petitioner to adduce evidence of these
documents to prove the transactions there-under. The petitioner further
pleaded that no prejudice would be caused to the respondents, if leave is
granted and that the petition was filed with bona fide intention and not to
protract the litigation.
9.
The petition was opposed by filing the counter of the respondents
denying the averments in the petition and further stating that there is no
need to grant leave to the petitioner as he had taken a lot of time to
adduce evidence since the year 2001 and that the documents were
brought into existence to buttress the case of false claim and these
documents are not valid and binding and moreover the petitioner filed
the suit on the basis of a „will‟ and witnesses of the defendants were
already examined at length and the suit is now ripe for arguments.
10.
Another petition in I.A.No.522 of 2025 is filed by the petitioner
under Section 151 C.P.C. to reopen his evidence to produce certified
copies of 40 documents mentioned above with the similar averments in
I.A.No.521 of 2025.
11.
The petition was opposed by the respondents as is opposed in
I.A.No.521 of 2025.
12.
After hearing both the parties, the trial Court dismissed the
petitions, mainly stating that no genuine reason was shown by the
petitioner for not producing 40 documents for a long period of 18 years,
though the evidence was completed in the year 2001 and the documents
sought to be filed are public documents and very much available.
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
13.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of the petitions, these revision petitions
are filed.
14.
The learned counsel for the petitioner vehemently contended that
the delay alone influenced the Court to dismiss the petition, but the delay
cannot be attributed solely to the petitioner as, after the death of the sole
defendant, it took long time for impleading the legal representatives
whose addresses were not known and for such other reasons, but the
petition was dismissed without considering the fact that the proposed
documents were very much necessary to establish that the plaintiff
exercised right and title over the plaint schedule properties and some
portion of the plaint schedule properties were alienated under these
documents, but the defendants have not challenged or questioned the
alienations. Therefore, he contends that it is the burden of the plaintiff to
establish a case for securing the relief for declaration of title not only
over the „will‟ but also the other facts relating to exercise of right and
possession over the plaint schedule properties. He further explained how
the delay occurred in bringing the legal representatives on record. It is
also submitted by him that the delay occurred further due to clubbing of
previous suit in O.S.No.296 of 1997 which was renumbered as
O.S.No.26 of 2010 after it was clubbed with suit in O.S.No.78 of 2007
and that after clubbing of the said suits, no further opportunity was given
to the petitioner / plaintiff to lead evidence on his behalf and it is just
before filing of the petition, there was an occasion to file the petition and
thus, the very long delay shown as a reason to oppose the petition is not
true. Therefore, he contended that for just and complete adjudication of
the dispute and to enable the plaintiff to place all the necessary evidence
on record it is just and necessary to allow the petition.
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
15.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent No.8
contended that the main requirement for grant of leave under Order VII,
Rule 14 C.P.C. have not been complied with by the petitioner and
moreover there was long delay in filing the petition and therefore, the trial
Court rightly dismissed the petition. He further submitted that since the
right of the plaintiff is mainly based on alleged will dated 16.10.1967,
these documents have no bearing more particularly they are not
supported by any pleading in the plaint. So, he requested to dismiss the
revision petition. He placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme
Court in K.K.Velusamy Vs. N.Palanisamy 1 , wherein at paragraphs
Nos.19 and 20 it was held as follows:
“19. We may add a word of caution. The power under Section
151 or Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code is not intended to be used
routinely, merely for the asking. If so used, it will defeat the
very purpose of various amendments to the Code to expedite
trials. But where the application is found to be bona fide and
where the additional evidence, oral or documentary, will assist
the court to clarify the evidence on the issues and will assist in
rendering justice, and the court is satisfied that non-production
earlier was for valid and sufficient reasons, the court may
exercise its discretion to recall the witnesses or permit the
fresh evidence. But if it does so, it should ensure that the
process does not become a protracting tactic. The court should
firstly award appropriate costs to the other party to compensate
for the delay. Secondly the court should take up and complete
the case within a fixed time schedule so that the delay is
avoided. Thirdly if the application is found to be mischievous,
(2011) 11 SCC 275
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
or frivolous, or to cover up negligence or lacunae, it should be
rejected with heavy costs.
20. If the application is allowed and the evidence is permitted
and ultimately the court finds that evidence was not genuine or
relevant and did not warrant the reopening of the case recalling
the witnesses, it can be made a ground for awarding
exemplary costs apart from ordering prosecution if it involves
fabrication of evidence. If the party had an opportunity to
produce such evidence earlier but did not do so or if the
evidence already led is clear and unambiguous, or if it comes
to the conclusion that the object of the application is merely to
protract
the
proceedings,
the
court
should
reject
the
application. If the evidence sought to be produced is an
electronic record, the court may also listen to the recording
before granting or rejecting the application.”
16.
He further placed reliance on the decision of the Supreme Court in
Bagai Construction Vs. Gupta Building Material Store 2 , wherein
previous decision of K.K.Velusamy (supra) was referred. He further
relied on the decision of this Court in Koruprolu Nagaraju (died) Vs.
Lanka Rambabu3, wherein at paragraphs Nos.11 and 12, it was held as
follows:
“11.On perusing the entire material available on record and in
the light of the judgments cited above, this Court observed
that, the present case is also similarly situated petitioners. The
suit is filed in the year 2008, thereafter, on several occasions,
(2013) 14 SCC 1
C.R.P.Nos.1380 and 1381 of 2016, dated 23.09.2023
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
the matter was adjourned. The simple reason mentioned in the
petition that the documents are not available at the time of
petitioner‟s evidence and he could trace them is not sufficient
to grant leave to the petitioner to file the said documents after
lapse of long time, without necessary details like when and
how they were traced and where they were traced. Further,
there is no explanation is submitted by learned counsel for the
petitioners / D1 to D6 how the proposed documents are
relevant to determine the issues on hand.
12. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case
and on hearing the submissions of both the counsels, this
Court observed that, the principles laid down in the judgments
cited by learned counsel for the respondents squarely
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present cases.
It is also settled principle of law that unless the order impugned
suffers from jurisdictional error or patent perversity, the power
of judicial review under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
cannot be pressed into service. Therefore, this Court has
absolutely no scintilla of hesitation nor any shadow of doubt to
hold that the orders under challenge do not warrant any
interference by this Court under Article 227 of Constitution of
India.”
17.
The learned counsel for the respondent No.9, though has not
contested before the trial Court, argued that the revision petition
deserves to be dismissed as the requirements of the Order VII, Rule 14
C.P.C. have not been complied. He further submitted that even after
adding the legal representatives and after completion of the defendant‟s
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
evidence, there was opportunity to the petitioner to immediately file a
petition, but no such step was taken. He further submitted that the
witnesses for defendants have been already cross-examined even with
regard to the proposed documents and therefore, there is no need to
allow the petition.
18.
In reply, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that after
filing of the written statement of the defendant No.8, the trial Court
directly posted the matter for the defendant‟s evidence and no further
opportunity was given to the plaintiff to lead evidence, in spite of framing
of additional issues. He further submitted that the respondent No.9 has
not opposed the petition before the trial Court, but argued before this
Court just to oppose the relief without having any right to oppose.
19.
Though the right of the plaintiff is based on the „will‟, the
documents proposed may have bearing on the right enforced which is
also a consideration to understand whether the „will‟ was acted upon and
for how long the exercise of the right in pursuance of the „will‟ was not
objected by the persons who are legal heirs in the absence of the „will‟
etc. It is to be noted that the affidavit filed in support of the petition is
inadequate about the details required to show the relevance of these
documents to the facts in issue with reference to each document.
Similarly, the affidavit is not completely disclosing the reasons required
to be assigned as per Order XIV, Rule 7 C.P.C. For the purpose of
adjudicating the case on merits, it is necessary to direct the petitioner to
file a better affidavit with all such needed information. When there is
enormous evidence relating to the genuine dispute between the parties,
shutting the doors of leading evidence on mechanical grounds would not
allow a Court to render justice on merits. As such, this Court is of the
view that the trial Court ought to have directed the petitioner to furnish all
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
such details before numbering the petition by directing to file better
affidavit, if required. Therefore, it is required to set aside the impugned
order and rehear the matter on merits.
20.
In the result, C.R.P.No.3762 of 2025 is allowed setting aside the
order, dated 13.11.2025, in I.A.No.521 of 2025 with a direction to the trial
Court to receive the additional affidavit of the petitioner, as aforesaid,
and decide the petition afresh after giving opportunity to the contesting
parties to file additional counter, if any requested.
21.
As a consequence of
order in C.R.P.No.3762 of 2025,
C.R.P.No.3763 of 2025 is allowed setting aside the order, dated
13.11.2025 in I.A.No.522 of 2025, with similar directions as in
C.R.P.No.3762 of 2025.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
B.S. BHANUMATHI, J
Dated: 08.04.2026
NSM / RAR
BSB, J
C.R.P.Nos.3762 and 3763 of 2025
The Honourable Ms. Justice B.S.Bhanumathi
Civil Revision Petitions Nos: 3762 and 3763 of 2025
Dated: 08.04.2026
NSM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review