Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010373842026
2026:CGHC:42553-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 7206 of 2026
D.K. Mishra S/o Shri B.D. Mishra Aged About 64 Years Retired As Helper Ii, Under
SSE/ Signal/ SECR, Bhatapara, R/o Shanti Nagar, Sant Kanwar Ram Ward,
Bhatapar, Post Bhatapara, Tehsil And Distt. Baloda Bazar Bhatapara, Chhattisgarh.
459004.
... Petitioner
versus
1 - Union Of India Through The General Manager, S.E.C. Railway, Bilaspur Zone,
Headquarters Office, Bilaspur, 495004 Chhattisgarh.
2 - The Sr. Divi, Signal And Telecom Engineer S.E.C. Railway Raipur Division,
DRM's Office, Raipur 492004 (Appellate And Revisionary Authority)
3 - The Asstt. Divisional Signal And Tele Engineer S.E.C. Railway, Raipur Division,
DRM's Office, Raipur 492004 (Disciplinary Authority)
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. AV Shridhar, Advocate
For Respondents /UOI
:
Mr. Ramakant Mishra, Deputy Solicitor General
Hon’ble Mr. Krushna Ram Mohapatra, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Santosh Sharma, Judge
Order on Board
Per : Krushna Ram Mohapatra, Chief Justice
30/09/2026
1.
The Petitioner, in this writ petition, assails the Order dated 06 th January,
2026 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench,
Jabalpur
BINI
PRADEEP
Digitally
signed by
BINI
PRADEEP
Date:
2026.10.05
10:24:33
+0530
(for
brevity
‘the
Tribunal’)
in
Original
Application
No.203/00631/2018. By virtue of the impugned order under Annexure-
P/1, the learned Tribunal dismissed the Original Application, holding
that the judicial review with regard to punishment imposed on the
petitioner in disciplinary proceedings is not permissible when due
procedures have been followed in conducting the disciplinary
proceedings.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that based on certain
allegations, disciplinary proceeding was initiated against the petitioner
on five charges. An Enquiry Officer was appointed, who submitted his
enquiry report on 28.4.2011, recommending transfer of the petitioner to
avoid any untoward incident in future. The Disciplinary Authority, not
being satisfied with the report, directed for fresh enquiry and
accordingly an enquiry report was submitted by the Enquiry Officer
with following findings:-
"गः जाँच प्राधिकरी का निष्कर्ष* मेरा निष्कर्ष है कि श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा, अपने अनुपस्थिति
को देख कर क्षणिक आवेश में आकर ही इस तरह की हरकत किया होगा।
अन्यथा उसके सहकर्मियों के बयान से स्पष्ठ है कि वह उसके बाद इस तरह
की हरकत नही किया है और अपना काम लगन और निष्ठा से करता है।
अतः आरोप गलत साबित होता है।
* मेरा निष्कर्ष है कि श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा का श्री के .ए. मधु,
सिगनल अनुरक्षक, गुन्डरदेही के साथ काम काम को लेकर कु छ बहस हो
गया होगा, उसके ड्यूटी के दौरान शराब पीने का कोई डाक्टरी रिपोर्ट नही
हैं। मारपीट का भी कोई प्रमाण नही है। के वल ड्यूटी को लेकर बहस करने
का आरोप साबित होता है। जिसके लिए उसे छोटा मोटा दण्ड दिया जा
सकता हैं।
* मेरा निष्कर्ष है कि श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा पर लगाया गया
आरोप सत्यापित नही होता हैं। यदि कोई प्राईवेट डाक्टर से मेडिकल रिपोर्ट
ले कर आता हैं तो उसका रेलवें डाक्टर से मेडिकल परिक्षण करवाने के वाद
ही ड्यूटी में लेना चाहिए था, लेकिन ऐसा नही किया गया और श्री एस.एन.
बोस, अनुभाग अभियंता, संके त, भिलाई द्वारा अनुपस्थित कर दिया गया
जो कि एक गम्भीर त्रुटि है। दिनांक: 24.06.2011 को भी जाँच प्राधिकारी
के सामने ही मरोदा में उपस्थिति को ले कर बहस करते हुए देखा गया और
पता चला की वहाँ पर चतुर्थ वर्ग के कर्मचारी को उपस्थिति रजिस्टर में
हस्ताक्षर नही करने दिया जाता तथा मास्टर रोल में अनुरक्षक द्वारा ही
उपस्थिति दर्ज किया जाता हैं, जो की समय पर नही किया जाता, यह एक
गम्भीर त्रुटि है। उपस्थिति रजिस्टर का अनुरक्षण नही किया जा रहा हैं।
* मेरा निष्कर्ष है कि श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा पर लगाया गया
आरोप सत्यापित नही होता हैं। यदि कोई किसी को जान से मारने की
धमकी देता है तो यह स्थानीय पुलिस के जाँच का विषय हैं, और शराब पीने
का कोई डाक्टरी परिक्षण नही करवाया गया हैं। इस के स फाईल के पेज
क्रमांक: 11 के पत्र से पता चलता है, कि श्री जे. कृ ष्णा राव, उप स्टेशन
प्रबंधक, गुन्डरदेही, का श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा के साथ पुरानी
रंजिश हो सकती है, जिसके कारण श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा का
एक बार पहले भी परिचालन विभाग से बर्खास्तगी हो चुकी हैं।
* मेरा निष्कर्ष है कि श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा पर लगाया गया
आरोप सत्यापित नही होता हैं। श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा का
बयान इस के स फाईल के पेज क्रमांक: 11 के पत्र से सही प्रतीत होता है।
चूँकि गुण्डरदेही की महिलाओं को प्रतिपरिक्षा के लिए महिला होने के कारण
नही बुलाया जा सका। वैसे भी किसी 12 वर्षीया बालिका का हाथ छेड़छाड के नियत से पकड़ना संगीन जुर्म है, जिसे स्थानीय पुलीस जाँच की
होगी और जाँच करने के बाद ही श्री डी. के . मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा को
छोडी होगी। शराब पीने का कोई डाक्टरी रिपोर्ट नही हैं। अतः आरोप पुरी
तरह गलत सिद्ध होता है।
* उपरोक्त तथ्यो को ध्यान में रखते हुए मेरा निष्कर्ष है कि श्री डी. के .
मिश्रा, हेल्पर-II, मरोदा को वहाँ से स्थानांतरण (किसी इकाई कार्यालय में)
कर दिया जाय जिससे उसे यह कहने का मौका भी न मिले की कोई उसके
खिलाफ षणयंत्र कर रहा हैं, तथा सिगनल अनुरक्षण कार्य में लगे
कर्मचारियों को किसी प्रकार का कोई व्यवधान भी ना हो, क्योंकि उसके
वहाँ रहने से प्रत्येक दिन कोई ना कोई विवाद होता रहेगा।"
(emphasis supplied)
3.
The Disciplinary Authority taking into consideration the observation
made in the enquiry report, passed order of punishment on
16.08.11/19.09.11. By virtue of order of punishment, the Disciplinary
Authority directed stoppage of three annual increments of the petitioner
with cumulative effect. The petitioner being not satisfied with the order
of punishment, preferred an appeal before Senior Divisional Signal and
Telecom Engineer, SEC/Raipur, but the appellate authority confirmed
the order of punishment of the Disciplinary Authority. In revision, the
revisional authority reduced the punishment directing stoppage of two
annual increments of the petitioner with cumulative effect vide Order
dated 03.11.2017. Being aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner
moved the learned Tribunal in OA No.203/00631/2018 and vide Order
dated 06.01.2026, the impugned order was passed by the learned
Tribunal.
While adjudicating the matter, the learned Tribunal relied
upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India Vs.
Parma Nanda reported in (1989) 2 SCC 177 and B.C. Chaturvedi Vs.
Union of India reported in (1995) 6 SCC 749 and came to a
conclusion that power of interference by the Tribunal in an order of
punishment imposed by the Disciplinary Authority in a disciplinary
proceedings is very limited. The Tribunal cannot sit over the order of
punishment as an appellate authority. The interference is permissible
only when there is arbitrariness and perversity in the order of
punishment or the punishment imposed is shockingly disproportionate
to the charges established. Holding that the disciplinary proceeding
was conducted in accordance with the procedure, giving opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner, it was held by the learned Tribunal that the
judicial review of the finding of the Disciplinary Authority is not
permissible and dismissed the Original Application. Being aggrieved,
the petitioner filed this writ petition.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the punishment
of stoppage of two annual increments with cumulative effect has been
imposed on the petitioner only on the basis of surmises and
conjectures. When the benefit of doubt was given to the petitioner by
the Disciplinary Authority, he should not have been imposed with major
punishment. It is his submission that save and except the fact that the
petitioner was argumentative with the colleagues and creates
disturbance in the official course of business, no charge is proved
against him. Thus, the vital charges, being not proved against the
petitioner, he should not have been imposed with the punishment and
should have been exonerated from the charges. This material aspect
was lost sight of by the learned Tribunal while adjudicating the matter.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also drew attention of the Court to
the findings of the Enquiry Officer, who submitted the first enquiry
report and submitted that only the petitioner was suggested to be
transferred to avoid any untoward incident in future. The report of the
second enquiry officer also suggests that the petitioner should be
transferred from the place of posting to avoid any further controversy.
However, without accepting the same, the Disciplinary Authority
imposed major punishment. When the Disciplinary Authority was in
disagreement with the observations of the Enquiry Officer, the reasons
of such disagreement should have been mentioned in the order of
punishment which is conspicuously
absent therein.
It is further
submitted that the imposition of punishment of stoppage of two
increments with cumulative effect is shockingly disproportionate to the
charge proved.
As such, the entire process of imposition of
punishment is vitiated and both the order of punishment as well as the
order of the learned Tribunal are liable to be set aside.
5.
Mr. Ramakant Mishra, learned Deputy Solicitor General, vehemently
object the same and submits that the disciplinary proceeding was
conducted in accordance with the rules, providing due opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner. Since the petitioner has not challenged the
initiation of the second enquiry and participated with the same, which
was conducted observing all the formalities in accordance with law, he
should not have raised any objection with regard to the finding therein.
The Enquiry Officer should not have suggested any punishment.
However, the Disciplinary Authority was not in disagreement with the
finding of the second enquiry report and relied upon charge proved.
Further, the punishment imposed by the Disciplinary Authority was
subsequently modified by the revisional authority. Thus, the petitioner
should not have any complaint against the order of punishment. It
cannot also be said that the order of punishment is shockingly
disproportionate to the charges proved.
Since the petitioner was
argumentative and creating disturbance in the official course of
business, which has been proved in the second enquiry report, the
Disciplinary Authority relying upon the same, imposed punishment. In
addition to the above, there is no illegality and perversity in the process
of imposition of punishment. He, therefore, submits that the learned
Tribunal has committed no error in dismissing the Original Application.
As such, the order impugned under Annexure-P/1 should not be
interfered with.
6.
Taking note of submission made by learned counsel for the parties and
on perusal of the record, it appears that the Disciplinary Authority was
not in disagreement with the second enquiry report submitted by the
Enquiry Officer. In the first enquiry report the Enquiry Officer, giving
benefit of doubt to the petitioner, suggested for his transfer.
The
Disciplinary Authority not being satisfied with the enquiry report,
directed for a second enquiry and the second enquiry report was
submitted holding the petitioner guilty of only one charge; holding that
the charge of creating disturbance in the official course of business and
quarreling with the colleagues has been proved. The Disciplinary
Authority taking note of the same, held it to be serious one and
imposed major penalty.
The Disciplinary Authority was never in
disagreement with the observation made in the second enquiry report.
He has also discussed the observation of the second enquiry report
and said that the petitioner was given benefit of doubt by the second
Enquiry Officer in respect of rest of the charges. It also reveals that the
imposition of the punishment was interfered by the revisional authority
by reducing it to two increments with cumulative effect. Thus, we find
no perversity either in the process of enquiry or in the process of
imposition of punishment. When the Disciplinary Authority was not in
disagreement with the observation made by the Enquiry Officer, no
reason is required to be assigned by the Disciplinary Authority. We
also find that the order of punishment is not shockingly disproportionate
to warrant interference by this Court. Further, this Court should not
interfere with the order of punishment and/or the order passed by the
Tribunal, only because a second view may be possible on reassessment of materials on record.
7.
We perused impugned order under Annexure-P/1 meticulously and
found that there is no perversity in it. The same is well discussed one
relying upon the settled principle of law. Thus, the impugned order
under Annexure-P/1 warrants no interference. Accordingly, this writ
petition, being devoid of any merit, is dismissed.
Bini
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Santosh Sharma)
(Krushna Ram Mohapatra)
Judge
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review