Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Contempt Case (Criminal) No. 3 of 2025
The Court on its Own Motion
Versus
Mahesh Tewari, son of late Sudhanshu Sekhar Tewari, R/o D/4, 3G,
SAIL CITY P.O- SAIL CITY, P.S- New Pundag, District- Ranchi,
Jharkhand, having his chamber at 2C/60, Block-II, Jharkhand High Court,
Ranchi arrayed as O.P. in the present Contempt Case (Criminal) No. 03
…
of 2025.
…
...
Opposite Party
----CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RONGON MUKHOPADHYAY
SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the Opposite Party:
Party-in-Person
--------Reserved on: 10.02.2026
Pronounced on: 16 .02.2026
Per M.S. Sonak, C.J.
1.
Heard Mr. Mahesh Tewari, the contemnor, who appears in person.
2.
On 16.10.2025, in Court Room No. 24, presided over by Hon’ble
Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar, the contemnor made some statements. A video
clip that captured this interaction between the contemnor and the
Presiding Judge went viral on the Internet and other social media
platforms.
3.
The then Hon’ble Chief Justice, Mr. Tarlok Singh Chauhan, and
four other Hon’ble Judges of this Court took cognisance of the incident as
captured in the video clip and ordered the registration of this Contempt
Case (Criminal) No. 3 of 2025, titled “The Court on its own Motion Vs.
Mahesh Tewari”.
4.
On 17th October 2025, the Full Bench made the following order:-1 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
“1. A video relating to the Court proceedings of
this Court has gone viral on the Internet and other
social media. Therefore, we have called for the
original of the video through the Central Project
Coordinator (CPC) who has submitted the same in
a pen-drive.
2. We also have the transcript of that video. The
video was played in the open Court.
3. Having perused the video, we find that the same
relates
to
the
Court’s
proceedings
dated
16.10.2025 of Court No.24 held by Justice Rajesh
Kumar where the Opposite Party had his case at
Serial No.2 of the cause-list and we further find
that some orders were passed in that case.
However, when the case at Serial No.4 was called
and where none of the parties were being
represented by the Opposite Party, yet, the
Opposite Party stood up in front of the Dais and
interrupted the Court’s proceedings. He not only
used intemperate language, but also tried to brow
beat threaten and bully the learned Judge Justice
Rajesh Kumar. Further, the Opposite Party has
tried to scandalize the Court by stating that, “the
country is burning with the judiciary” and
persisted that “he would argue in his own way”
and rather asked the learned Judge “not to cross
his limits,” while going out of all limits insofar as
he alone was concerned thereby undermining the
majesty and Authority of law.
4. The Opposite Party is present in person and
states that he has no remorse or regret whatsoever
for whatever he has done or said in the Court.
5. Prima facie we are of the considered view that
the utterances of the Opposite Party amounts to
criminal contempt and while invoking our power
-2 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
under Article 215 of the Constitution of India and
the Contempt of Courts Act, we direct the Registry
to register a suo motu criminal contempt case
against the Opposite Party.
6. Issue notice.
7. The Opposite Party waives notice and prays for
three weeks’ time to file his reply-cum-Statement
of Defence.
8. List on 11th of November 2025.”
5.
On 25.11.2025, the contemnor, who is a practising advocate of this
Court, appeared and filed an I.A. seeking extension of time to file replycum-statement of defence. The Full Bench granted four weeks’ time to
the contemnor to file reply-cum-statement of defence. The Registry was
also directed to supply the contemnor with a copy of the video transcript
and the Pen Drive.
6.
On 23.12.2025, the contemnor once again filed an I.A. seeking
further extension of time. The Full Bench, once again, extended the time
to file a response by six weeks and listed the matter on 10 th February
2026. Within this period, the contemnor filed his interim reply to the
contempt notice.
7.
In the meantime, the contemnor also filed Criminal Appeal No. 430
of 2026 before the Hon’ble Supreme Court, challenging the Full Benchs’
order dated 17.10.2025, which took cognisance of the incident of
16.10.2025, registered a suo motu contempt case, and issued notice to the
contemnor.
-3 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
8.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, by order dated 23.01.2026, disposed
of the contemnor’s Criminal Appeal No. 430 of 2026, by making the
following order: “1. Delay condoned.
2. The appellant is a practising lawyer in the High
Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi. An untoward
incident unfurled in Court No. 24 of the High Court
on 16.10.2025, which was widely circulated and
reported on social media. Taking cognizance
thereof, a five-Judge Bench led by Hon'ble The
Chief Justice of the High Court suo motu initiated
criminal
contempt
proceedings
against
the
appellant. Aggrieved by that notice, the appellant is
before us.
3. While explaining at length that the appellant
never meant to cause disrespect to the Hon'ble
Judge or obstruct the judicial proceedings, learned
senior counsel for the appellant submits that the
appellant is extremely repentant of the incident and
is willing to tender an unconditional apology.
4. Having regard to the above-mentioned stand
taken by the appellant, we dispose of this appeal
with liberty to the appellant to submit an affidavit
of unconditional apology before the High Court.
We request the High Court to consider that
apology sympathetically and pass an appropriate
order.
5. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
closed.”
9.
On 5th February 2026, the contemnor filed a supplementary
affidavit, together with a copy of the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order
dated 23.01.2026 disposing of Criminal Appeal No. 430 of 2026.
-4 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
10.
In Paragraph 4 of the supplementary affidavit, the contemnor stated
that the incident which took place on 16.10.2025 in the Court presided
over by Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar “was unfortunate and
regretful”. In paragraphs 5 and 6 of the supplementary affidavit, the
contemnor stated as follows: “5. That the answering opposite party tenders an
unconditional apology for the incident which took
place on 16.10.2025 in the court of Hon'ble Mr.
Justice Rajesh Kumar.
6. That as such the answering opposite party
humbly prays that the present contempt proceeding
be dropped as against the answering opposite
party.”
11.
The contemnor, in his supplementary affidavit, also stated that he
has been a practising Advocate of this Hon’ble High Court for the last 40
years and “as such can never even imagine lowering the prestige and
decorum of this institution and more so the contempt of this institution.”
12.
On 10th February 2026, when the Full Bench assembled to take up
this matter, the contemnor appeared in person and, after referring to
paragraph 5 of his supplementary affidavit dated 5th February 2026, stated
that he was tendering an unconditional apology for the incident which
took place on 16.10.2025 in the Court presided over by Hon’ble Mr.
Justice Rajesh Kumar. Upon the Court’s query as to whether he had
anything else to say in this matter, the contemnor replied that he was
tendering his unconditional apology and that he had already filed his
interim reply to the show cause notice issued by this Court.
-5 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
13.
In the context of paragraph 3 of the Full Benchs’ order dated
17.10.2025 the contemnor, in his interim reply stated that his statement
“Don’t try to humiliate any Advocate” or “Please Don’t try to humiliate
any person” was a spontaneous reaction and momentary to the
humiliation caused to me through the personal remarks made by the
Hon’ble Mr. Justice and was a human plea for dignity and not a threat”.
Further, he submitted that his statement “Aap bahut zyada jaante hain,
aap Judge ho gaye, hum log nahi jaante hai, hum log Wakeel hai" in no
way insults the bench. He proceeded to state that “It is with humility that I
stated that Hon'ble Judges had more knowledge than Advocates. No part
of my conduct constituted browbeating or bullying the Hon'ble Mr.
Justice.”
14.
As regards the prima facie observation in the Full Benchs’ order
dated 17.10.2025 that the contemnor tried to scandalise the Court by
stating that the country is burning with the judiciary, the contemnor stated
as follows: “I would like to clarify that the statement made by
me was in the heat of the moment, under emotional
distress
and
was
unintentional
and
not
a
considered view. I regret using this expression,
retract it fully and unconditionally and state that it
does not reflect my belief and views regarding the
institution of the judiciary. I wish to reiterate I
should have chosen my words more carefully and
there was no ill intention to either scandalize the
court or undermine the majesty and authority of the
law.”
-6 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
15.
Regarding the observation in the Full Benchs’ order dated
17.10.2025 that the contemnor persisted in arguing in his own way and
asked the learned Judge not to cross his limits, the contemnor stated that
his statement had been misinterpreted and that he made it because he felt
humiliated by the remarks of Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rajesh Kumar on his
arguments in the previous case. The contemnor further submitted that he
has the highest regard for the judiciary and reiterates his unconditional
respect for this Hon’ble institution. He also stated that if any part of his
conduct or expression has caused discomfort or appeared disrespectful to
this Hon’ble Court, he has expressed his sincere regret. He stated that he
has been practising in this Court for over 40 years and has never, in his
long career, attempted to scandalise or lower the authority of the
judiciary.
16.
In paragraph 7 (xiv) of his interim reply, the contemnor has made
the following plea:“7(xiv) I respectfully pray that this Hon’ble Court
may view the incident in the correct factual context,
emotional circumstances that prevailed, my long
unblemished
career,
and
the
unconditional
retraction of the objectionable expression and may
be pleased to drop the proceedings in the interest
of justice and pass any further order(s) that this
Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper. I reaffirm
my highest respect for this Court and remain
committed to maintaining the decorum of the Bar
and the Bench, and accept the interim show-cause cum- statement of fact and drop the Contempt Case
(Criminal) No. 03 of 2025 initiated against the
deponent and pending final hearing of the interim
-7 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
show cause- cum statement of defence and extend
the date by another six weeks for hearing.”
17.
We have perused the transcript of the video recording of the
incident of 16.10.2025 and have also watched the video clip of the
incident of 16.10.2025. We have perused and considered the contemnor’s
interim reply dated 19.12.2025 and the supplementary affidavit dated 5 th
February 2026, in which the contemnor has expressed regret for the
incident of 16.10.2025 and tendered an unconditional apology. Even in
his interim reply, the contemnor, after referring to his “emotional
circumstances”,
unconditionally
retracted
those
objectionable
expressions. The contemnor has also reaffirmed his respect for this Court
and given an assurance of his commitment to maintaining the decorum of
the Bar and the Bench.
18.
Further, we have, as we are bound to, considered the order of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 23rd January 2026, which records that the
contemnor was extremely repentant of the incident and was willing to
tender an unconditional apology. The Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order
disposes of the contemnor’s criminal appeal with liberty to the contemnor
to submit an affidavit of unconditional apology before the High Court.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has also requested the High Court to
consider the contemnor’s apology sympathetically and pass an
appropriate order in the matter.
19.
Upon due consideration of the pleas, transcript, the video clip and
the law on the subject, we are inclined to accept the contemnor’s
unconditional apology to this Court. However, this is not because we
-8 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
regard the contemnor’s conduct and utterances in the Court as not being
contumacious or tending to scandalise or lower the authority of the Court.
The petitioner’s utterances and his conduct in the Court were indeed
regrettable, as was accepted by him in his interim reply and the
supplementary affidavit.
20.
An Advocate with over 40 years of legal practice is expected to
show greater restraint, if not circumspection. He is as much an Officer of
the Court as the Judge presiding over it. His utterances and conduct in the
Court are not directed only to the presiding officer but to the institution
itself. Therefore, he cannot afford to exhibit disrespect or speak words or
otherwise conduct himself to scandalise or tend to lower the authority of
any Court.
21.
Besides, we note that on 17.10.2025, the contemnor stated to the
Full Bench that he had no remorse or regret whatsoever for whatever he
had done or said in the Court on 16.10.2025. In the lengthy interim reply
filed by the contemnor, there is no explanation about this statement,
which was noted in paragraph 4 of the Full Bench’s order dated
17.10.2025. His statement that he has no remorse or regret whatsoever for
anything he has done or said in Court hurts us. More than it hurts us, it
harms the institution, which is far greater than the judges and lawyers
who are but a part of it. It suggests a kind of bravado that may appeal to
some galleries or quarters. But there is a thin, though well-marked line
between arrogance and forthrightness that, at least, a seasoned Lawyer
with over four decades of practice can afford neither to miss nor to cross.
-9 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
22.
By 17 October 2025, the “heat of the moment” or “single
momentary lapse” plea was no longer a legitimate defence. By then, at
least, tempers should have cooled, and wiser counsel should have
prevailed. Some grace and repentance, at least on that day, from the
contemnor might have prevented the issue from being precipitated. At the
same time, we note that, in his interim reply, the contemnor expressed
regret and even offered an apology for his conduct and utterances in the
Court on 16.10.2025. He has explained that certain statements that he
ought not to have made were made by him in the heat of the moment, but
without intending any disrespect to the Court. He explained that he had
no hand in recording the clip or its becoming viral.
23.
Moreover, in his supplementary affidavit of 5th February 2026, the
contemnor, after stating that the incident of 16.10.2025 was unfortunate
and regrettable, has tendered his unconditional apology for it. He has
unconditionally retracted the objectionable utterances. While we do not
condone or overlook the contemnor’s conduct and utterances, our
institution’s shoulders are broad enough not to be unduly affected by
them. Therefore, we are satisfied that this is a matter in which, while we
do not approve of the contemnor’s utterances and conduct in the Court on
16.10.2025, we must take a sympathetic and lenient view of the matter.
24.
Furthermore, as judges, we are never eager to invoke our contempt
jurisdiction to shield judicial prestige or uphold our own dignity. We are,
as was so elegantly expressed by Lord Denning in R v Metropolitan
Police Commissioner, ex parte Blackburn, reported in (1968) 2 QB
150, confident that “such dignity must rest on surer foundations, and that
-10 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
courts must therefore endure fair, even outspoken, criticism in the
broader interest of free speech, leaving judges, who cannot engage in
public controversy, to rely solely on the integrity of their conduct and
decisions for vindication”.
25.
In the case of Delhi Judicial Service Association v. State of
Gujarat, reported in (1991) 4 SCC 406, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that it is the people who have a vital stake in the fair and effective
administration of justice, and the Court, therefore, has the duty to protect
its authority and dignity by exercising the power to punish for contempt.
This power is to be exercised sparingly, not to vindicate the dignity of the
Court against insult or injury, but to safeguard the proper administration
of justice and to prevent any obstruction, interference, or impediment
thereto.
26.
In Ram Partap Sharma and Ors v. Daya Nand, reported in
AIR 1977 SC 809, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the elementary
basis for accepting an apology is a finding of committal of contempt.
Here, as noted by us, hereinabove, we are satisfied that the utterances and
conduct of the contemnor were contemptuous. Nevertheless, the
contemnor has tendered his unconditional apology. He has pleaded that
his utterances on 16.10.2025 were the result of a single momentary lapse
and were made in the heat of the moment. He has also referred to his long
legal career spanning more than four decades and to the responsible
positions he has held in the Bar Association and the Bar Council. He has
further expressed deep regret for the incident that occurred on
-11 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
16.10.2025. Additionally, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has requested this
court to consider the contemnor’s apology sympathetically.
27.
The apology in this case has been tendered at a sufficiently early
stage of the contempt proceedings. Even in the interim reply, the
contemnor has expressed his regrets and acknowledged that some of his
utterances must have crossed the limits expected of an officer of the
Court.
28.
In re: Anil Panjwani, arising out of Civil Appeal No. 7919 of
2001, the Hon’ble Supreme Court did not condone or overlook the
contemnor’s
objectionable
conduct,
namely,
the
scurrilous
and
scandalous statements made in his affidavit. However, the Hon’ble Apex
Court took a sympathetic and lenient view towards him. This was because
he offered a genuine, albeit belated, apology with folded hands,
expressing sincere remorse.
29.
Furthermore, in Vineeta Srinandan v. High Court of Judicature
at Bombay, reported in 2025 INSC 1408, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
reaffirmed that the power to punish for contempt inherently includes the
power to forgive where the contemnor shows genuine remorse. The
Hon’ble Court observed that contempt jurisdiction is neither a “personal
armour” for judges nor a “sword to silence criticism,” and emphasised
that mercy must remain an integral part of judicial conscience. Referring
to the proviso and Explanation to S. 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act,
1971, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that an apology may be accepted
if it is bona fide, and that it shall not be rejected merely because it is
-12 of 13-
2026:JHHC:4155-FB
qualified or conditional. Thus, where sincere repentance is shown, the
Court is empowered to discharge the contemnor or remit the punishment.
30.
Therefore, having considered the facts, circumstances and the dicta
of the Hon’ble Apex Court, we accept the contemnor’s apology and drop
the contempt proceedings. We do so in the fond hope and expectation that
the contemnor, a legal practitioner in this Court who has practised for
more than four decades, will, in future, display restraint and not indulge
in any misadventure of scandalising or lowering the authority of this
institution, or otherwise interfere with or obstruct the administration of
justice in any manner.
31.
The suo motu contempt petition is disposed of in the above terms.
32.
Interim applications, if any, do not survive and are disposed of.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Rongon Mukhopadhyay, J.)
(Ananda Sen, J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
February 16, 2026
N.A.F.R.
VK
Uploaded on
16.02.2026.
-13 of 13-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review