Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWPIL No. 97 of 2025
Decided on : 10.09.2026
Contractors Welfare Association
...Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. and others
…Respondents.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Ganesh Barowalia, Advocate.
For the respondents :
Mr. Rakesh Dhaulta, Additional Advocate
General, for respondents No. 1 to 6/State.
:
Mr. Suneet Goel, Sr. Advocate, with Mr.
Vivek Negi and Mr. Vishwas Kaushal,
Advocates, for respondent No.7.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice (Oral)
The present Public Interest Litigation seeks initiation of
vigilance/penal proceedings against Sanjeev Kapoor, subsequently
impleaded as respondent No. 7, for forgery and falsification of official
records and for removal/blacklisting, apart from other prayers.
2.
In the petition, it has been mentioned that the petition has
been filed by the Association through its President, Shri Satish Kumar
Vij, who has no personal interest in the litigation and is not guided by
self-gain. It has also been mentioned that the Association agrees to pay
the costs, if any, imposed by the Court, and undertakes to abide in that
respect. A specific prayer has been made for setting aside the office
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-2-
order dated 3rd of April, 2025 (Annexure P-4), whereby short-term
debarment had been done by the official respondent No. 5, and to take
action against the said respondent.
3.
When the petition came up before the Court on 24.09.2025,
from the perusal of pleadings, we had directed that an appropriate
application be filed to implead the contractor against whom action was
sought to be taken, since the order dated 3rd of April, 2025 (Annexure P4) pertained to the work which had been done by Sanjeev Kumar,
contractor, who had been debarred from participating in the tender
process for three months on account of wrong uploading of documents
for the tender process, and which allegations had been found to be
substantiated.
4.
Resultantly, the application was filed and the said person
was impleaded as respondent No. 7. We had, on 15 th October, 2025,
also directed the petitioner to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- with the
Chief Justice Disaster Relief Fund to show its bona fides. The said
amount was duly deposited. On account of that, notice was issued and
the parties had put in appearance.
5.
Counsel for respondent No. 7 has raised a preliminary
objection regarding the maintainability of the writ petition on account of
personal rivalry in question, and in view of the Himachal Pradesh High
Court Public Interest Litigation Rules, 2021, notified on 4th of October,
2021, which had been framed in pursuance of the judgment of the Apex
-3-
Court in State of Uttaranchal v. Balwant Singh Chaufal and others,
(2020) 3 SCC 402.
6.
In the reply filed by respondent No. 7, it is specifically
averred that the President of the petitioner-Association had issued a
cheque of Rs. 20,00,000/- dated 4th of April, 2024, which was the subject
matter of litigation initiated on a complaint under Section 138 filed by the
son of the private respondent, namely Himanshu Kapoor. Copy of the
complaint, (Annexure R-7/1), dated 20th of July, 2024, under Section 138
read with Section 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, has been
placed on record.
7.
Thus, it was pleaded that the Public Interest Litigation is
nothing but a ploy on the part of the said President to pressurize the
private respondent to withdraw the complaint, and that the President of
the Association cannot use Public Interest Litigation to settle his personal
scores. Justification had been given that when the tender in question
was issued, the respondent's mother had passed away and staff
members had uploaded the bid, due to which a wrong work-done
certificate had been issued, on the basis of which the order was passed
on 3rd of April, 2025 (Annexure R-7/6). It is accordingly pleaded that the
Court cannot be used as a tool to settle personal scores or business
rivalries amongst contractors by filing Public Interest Litigation.
8.
An interim application bearing CMP No. 31088 of 2025 was
also filed, seeking that the private respondent/non-applicant be permitted
to participate in two tenders and relief was sought that his financial bid
-4-
be not opened during the pendency of the present case. We had
directed on 18th December, 2025 to file an affidavit as to which of the
members of the petitioner-Association had applied for the tenders
mentioned in the said paragraph of the application.
9.
As per the affidavit filed, it has now transpired that for the
two tenders in question, for one of the tenders, Lov Vij and Naresh Vij
are also applicants, and for the other tender, Lov Vij is an applicant, who
are apparently close relatives of the President of the petitionerAssociation, apart from the fact that the private respondent was also an
applicant in both the tenders. It is thus apparent that it is a classic case
of professional rivalry which is sought to be settled through the process
of the Court, and by way of Public Interest Litigation, which cannot, as
such, be countenanced in any manner.
10.
The Apex Court in Janata Dal v. H.S. Chowdhary and
others, (1992) 4 SCC 305, has held that Public Interest Litigation is for a
class or community who cannot approach the Court and for the
betterment of the public, and cannot be used for vindicating personal
grievances. In Ashok Kumar Pandey v. State of W.B., (2004) 3 SCC
349, the Apex Court held that PIL is a weapon to be used with great
care, and in appropriate cases, exemplary costs are to be imposed.
Relevant extract whereof reads as under:“12. Public interest litigation is a weapon which has to be
used with great care and circumspection and the judiciary
has to be extremely careful to see that behind the beautiful
veil of public interest an ugly private malice, vested interest
and/or publicity seeking is not lurking. It is to be used as an
effective weapon in the armory of law for delivering social
justice to the citizens. The attractive brand name of public
-5-
interest litigation should not be used for suspicious products
of mischief. It should be aimed at redressal of genuine public
wrong or public injury and not publicity oriented or founded
on personal vendetta. As indicated above, Court must be
careful to see that a body of persons or member of public,
who approaches the court is acting bona fide and not for
personal gain or private motive or political motivation or
other oblique consideration. The Court must not allow its
process to be abused for oblique considerations. Some
persons with vested interest indulge in the pastime of
meddling with judicial process either by force of habit or from
improper motives. Often they are actuated by a desire to win
notoriety or cheap popularity. The petitions of such busy
bodies deserve to be thrown out by rejection at the
threshold, and in appropriate cases with exemplary costs.
13…………...x………...x……………...x………..x……
14. The Court has to be satisfied about (a) the credentials of
the applicant; (b) the prima facie correctness or nature of
information given by him; (c) the information being not vague
and indefinite. The information should show gravity and
seriousness involved. Court has to strike balance between
two conflicting interests; (i) nobody should be allowed to
indulge in wild and reckless allegations besmirching the
character of others; and (ii) avoidance of public mischief and
to avoid mischievous petitions seeking to assail, for oblique
motives, justifiable executive actions. In such case, however,
the Court cannot afford to be liberal. It has to be extremely
careful to see that under the guise of redressing a public
grievance, it does not encroach upon the sphere reserved by
the Constitution to the Executive and the Legislature. The
Court has to act ruthlessly while dealing with imposters and
busy bodies or meddlesome interlopers impersonating as
public-spirited holy men. They masquerade as crusaders of
justice. They pretend to act in the name of Pro Bono Publico,
though they have no interest of the public or even of their
own to protect.
15. ……...x………...x………….x…………...x……..x…..
16 As noted supra, a time has come to weed out the
petitions, which though titled as public interest litigations are
in essence something else. It is shocking to note that Courts
are flooded with large number of so called public interest
litigations where even a minuscule percentage can
legitimately be called as public interest litigations. Though
the parameters of public interest litigation have been
indicated by this Court in large number of cases, yet
unmindful of the real intentions and objectives, Courts are
entertaining such petitions and wasting valuable judicial time
which, as noted above, could be otherwise utilized for
disposal of genuine cases. Though in Dr. Duryodhan Sahu &
others Vs. Jitendra Kumar Mishra & others, (AIR 1999 SC
114), this Court held that in service matters PILs should not
-6-
be entertained, the inflow of so- called PILs involving service
matters continues unabated in the Courts and strangely are
entertained. The least the High Courts could do is to throw
them out on the basis of the said decision. The other
interesting aspect is that in the PILs, official documents are
being annexed without even indicating as to how the
petitioner came to possess them. In one case, it was noticed
that an interesting answer was given as to its possession. It
was stated that a packet was lying on the road and when out
of curiosity the petitioner opened it, he found copies of the
official documents. Whenever such frivolous pleas are taken
to explain possession, the Court should do well not only to
dismiss the petitions but also to impose exemplary costs. It
would be desirable for the Courts to filter out the frivolous
petitions and dismiss them with costs as aforestated so that
the message goes in the right direction that petitions filed
with oblique motive do not have the approval of the Courts.”
11.
The Apex Court being aware of the misuse by busybodies
for extraneous and ulterior motives, in Balwant Singh Chaufal and
others (supra), issued direction to the High Courts to frame rules, which
have accordingly been done.
12.
Apparently, under Part III and Rule 9(1)(b), a specific
averment had to be made that the petitioner had no personal interest.
The necessary averments had been made that they are not guided by
self-gain or gain for any person, institution, or body, and that there is no
motive. It is thus apparent that the said averments were made solely for
the purpose of ensuring that the petition is listed, as the Registry would
not list the writ petition without the requisite averments. In such
circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that this is a frivolous
litigation, and the jurisdiction of PIL has been grossly misused to settle
personal scores by rival contractors for professional rivalries.
13.
A perusal of the order dated 3rd of April, 2025 would
further go on to show that the objections had been raised by Lov Vij and
-7-
Satish Vij, on the basis of which action was initiated against respondent
No. 7.
Accordingly, we do not find the present petition to be
maintainable and dismiss the same with exemplary costs of Rs.
2,00,000/- (Rupees Two Lakhs); Rs. 1,00,000/- be deposited in the High
Court Employees Welfare Association Fund and Rs. 1,00,000/- in the
IGMC Poor Patients Fund out of the money deposited by the petitionerAssociation. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stands
disposed of.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
10th September, 2026
(Tarun Singh)
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review