Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
Dated : 10th July, 2023
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.32 of 2018
Petitioner
:
Karma Tshering Bhutia
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim and Others
Application under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Rachhitta Rai,
Advocate for the Petitioner.
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Additional Advocate General with Mr. Sujan
Sunwar, Assistant Government Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to
3.
Ms. Pubalee Bujarbaruah, Senior Advocate with Mr. Ganesh Man
Chettri, Advocate for the Respondent No.4.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022
Petitioner
:
College of Agriculture Engineering and
Post Harvest Technology
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim and Others
Application under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Ms. Pubalee Bujarbaruah, Senior Advocate with Mr. Ganesh Man
Chettri, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Additional Advocate General with Mr. Sujan
Sunwar, Assistant Government Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to
3.
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Rachhitta Rai,
Advocate for the Respondent No.4.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Both Writ Petitions involve the same facts and legal
questions concerning the interpretation of the provisions of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (the “Act of 1894”) and the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013 (the “Act of 2013”), relevant for the
present purposes, hence they have been heard together and are
being disposed of by this common Judgment.
2.
In WP(C) No.32 of 2018, the process of acquiring the
Petitioner’s land, situated at Marchak Block, Ranipool, East Sikkim,
for the purpose of constructing a Central Agricultural University
(CAU) commenced in the year 2013.
Notification under Section
4(1) of the Act of 1894, was published in the Government Gazette,
dated 18-05-2013, invoking Section 17(4) of the same Act to
specify that Section 5A of the Act would be inapplicable. On 2002-2013, the Respondent No.2, assessed the compensation for the
land and properties standing thereon for a total sum of ₹
6,70,09,931/- (Rupees six crores, seventy lakhs, nine thousand,
nine hundred and thirty one) only, which was communicated to the
Respondent No.4 by Respondent No.3, vide communication dated
31-05-2013, requesting Respondent No.4 to release 80% advance
payment i.e., ₹ 5,16,13,394/- (Rupees five crores, sixteen lakhs,
thirteen thousand, three hundred and ninety four) only, to the
Respondent No.3, for payment to the Petitioner. Notice under
Section 6 of the Act of 1894 was issued on 03-08-2013 and under
Section 9(1) on 25-11-2013.
The amount of ₹ 5,16,13,394/-
(Rupees five crores, sixteen lakhs, thirteen thousand, three
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
hundred and ninety four) only, was admittedly paid to the
Petitioner vide cheque bearing No.065584, dated 05-05-2014.
Another cheque bearing No.736862, dated 30-05-2015, was paid
as house compensation of ₹ 82,42,930/- (Rupees eighty two lakhs,
forty two thousand, nine hundred and thirty) only, for the building
standing on the land.
It is the Petitioner’s case that, no Award
under Section 11 of the Act of 1894 had been passed nor was
ownership of the property transferred to Respondent No.4. In the
mean time, the Act of 2013 came to be enforced w.e.f 01-01-2014
as a result of which proceedings under the Act of 1894 lapsed. On
09-08-2017,
the
Petitioner
filed
an
application
before
the
Respondent No.2 requesting for release of the remaining 20% of
compensation as per the Act of 2013, in vain. This was reiterated
on
21-11-2017,
specifying
the
remaining
amount
as
₹
17,80,29,535/- (Rupees seventeen crores, eighty lakhs, twenty
nine thousand, five hundred and thirty five) only, as per rectified
Award of 12-08-2017, upon which Respondent No.4 failed to act.
That, Respondent No.3, vide letter, dated 29-11-2017, made the
same request, to which Respondent No.4 failed to respond, hence,
the prayers in the Writ Petition;
“i)
To direct the Respondent no.4 to release the
compensation amount as per new act “LARR
Act, 2013” to the Petitioner.
ii)
To direct the Respondent no.4 to make
payment of interest @ 10% per annum on
balance compensation amount unpaid until final
payment of entire sum of money.
iii)
To direct the respondents for rehabilitation and
resettlement of the Petitioner and his family
member for displacement from their property
under Chapter V particularly under section
31(2) (a), (c), (d), (e), (f) of the new act
“LARR Act, 2013”
iv)
Cost of the proceedings or
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
v)
(i)
Any other order/orders which may deem fit and
proper in the interest of justice.”
The State-Respondent No.3 inter alia averred that, on
11-06-2015, Respondent No.3 informed Respondent No.4 that all
matters relating to land acquisition were kept on hold in view of
the enforcement of the Act of 2013 as the State rules under the
said Act were being finalised.
That, as the Award in the present
case was not passed before the commencement of the Act of 2013,
the compensation was rectified in terms of the new Act, on 12-082017 to ₹ 17,80,29,535/- (Rupees seventeen crores, eighty lakhs,
twenty nine thousand, five hundred and thirty five) only, on
finalization of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in
Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement, Sikkim (Rules),
2015 (hereinafter, the “Sikkim Rules of 2015”), and its notification
on 13-10-2015.
Vide communication, dated 13-04-2017, the
Respondent No.4 sought transfer of ownership of the acquired land,
to which Respondent No.3, on 11-05-2017, informed inter alia that
as the Award had not been passed under the Act of 1894, it had
been rectified.
On 26-08-2017, the Respondent No.4 requested
the Respondent No.3 to decide the matter in terms of Section
24(1)(b) of the Act of 2013 and on 14-12-2017, raised an
objection to the rectified compensation.
Admittedly, 80% of the
compensation amount of ₹5,16,13,394/- (Rupees five crores,
sixteen lakhs, thirteen thousand, three hundred and ninety four)
only, computed by Respondent No.3, under the Act of 1894, was
released to the Petitioner along with compensation for the building
standing on the land. That, the 20% remaining compensation i.e.,
₹ 1,54,86,137/- (Rupees one crore, fifty four lakhs, eighty six
thousand, one hundred and thirty seven) only, was forwarded to
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Respondent No.3 by the Respondent No.4 vide letter, dated 14-082015 but could not be processed for payment due to the
enforcement of the Act of 2013.
(ii)
The Respondent No.4 countered that the Writ Petition
suffers from a non-joinder of necessary parties due to nonimpleadment of the Agriculture Department, Union of India. That,
consequent upon the entire payment, compensation calculated
under the Act of 1894 along with compensation for two storeyed
building was made over to the Petitioner, the Petitioner handed
over the landed property and the building to the Respondent No.4
on 11-07-2015, in the presence of the officials of the Respondent
No.2 and construction of new buildings have taken place thereon.
That, in the said circumstances the Act of 2013, is not applicable.
Moreover, the Petitioner sought for 20% land compensation as per
the revised rate after a lapse of two years.
Hence, the Writ
Petition be dismissed.
3.
In
WP(C)
No.43
of
2022,
the
Petitioner’s
case
(Respondent No.4 in WP(C) No.32 of 2018) is that the Respondent
No.4 (Petitioner in WP(C) No.32 of 2018) ‘offered’ to sell his land,
adjacent to the land allotted to the Petitioner by the State
Government, @ ₹ 200 per square feet to enable expansion of the
Petitioner’s college. The Petitioner on 12-09-2012 accordingly,
sought necessary clarifications/guidelines and purchase procedure
of land from Respondent No.2, who instead initiated the process for
acquisition
of
the
land
and
forwarded
the
statement
of
compensation of land and other properties to the Respondent No.3
assessing the compensation at ₹ 6,70,09,931/- (Rupees six crores,
seventy lakhs, nine thousand, nine hundred and thirty one) only.
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
The
Petitioner
is
aggrieved
by
the
rectified
statement
of
compensation, dated 12-08-2017, purported to have been made
under the Act of 2013 and communicated to them by the
Respondent No.3, amounting to ₹ 25,33,71,996/- (Rupees twenty
five crores, thirty three lakhs, seventy one thousand, nine hundred
and ninety six) only, which after adjustment of earlier payment
would be ₹ 17,80,29,535/- (Rupees seventeen crores, eighty lakhs,
twenty nine thousand, five hundred and thirty five) only. Hence,
the prayers in WP(C) No.43 of 2022 viz;
“Issue a rule calling upon the respondents to
show cause as to why an appropriate writ,
order or direction may not be issued for setting
aside and quashing the
(i) Memo No.1748/LR&DMD/GOS/ACQ/317-318
dated 12.08.2017 (Annexure P─ 15)
(ii)
and
letter
issued
vide
No.1748/LR&DMD/ACQ/GOS/418
20.09.2017 (Annexure P─ 17)
Memo
dated
(iii)
and
Letter
issued
vide
Memo
No.1748/LR&DMD/2018/631 dated “NIL” 2018
(Annexure P─ 18).”
4.
Hereinafter
for
convenience
the
parties
shall
be
referred to in terms of their litigative status in WP(C) No.32 of
2018.
5.
While inviting the attention of this Court to Section
24(1)(a) of the Act of 2013, Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioner contended that where no Award under Section 11 of the
Act of 1894 has been passed, as in the instant case then, all
provisions of the Act of 2013 shall apply for determination of
compensation.
Drawing
succour
from
the
ratio
in
Indore
Development Authority vs. Manoharlal and Others , it was contended
that, only when an Award under Section 11 of the Act of 1894 has
(2020) 8 SCC 129
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
been made then such proceedings shall continue under the Act of
1894. That, the Respondent No.3 vide Memos, dated 11-06-2015
and 02-09-2015, informed Respondent No.4 that all matters
relating
to
land
acquisition
were
kept
on
hold
and
the
compensation was rectified on 12-08-2017, in terms of the Act of
2013, as no Award was made earlier by the Respondent No.2. That,
although Sikkim Rules of 2015 came to be enforced only from 1310-2015, the Rules do not regulate the Act as it is a Central Act.
That, the compensation issued on 12-08-2017, vide rectified
statement be ordered to be paid to the Petitioner in terms of the
prayers in the Writ Petition. That, as Section 31 of the Act of 2013
provides for rehabilitation and resettlement award for affected
families by the Collector, the Respondent No.4 also be directed to
pay towards the rehabilitation and resettlement of the Petitioner
and his family.
6.
Learned Additional Advocate General for the State-
Respondents No.1 to 3, endorsing the submissions made on behalf
of the Petitioner agreed that no Award under Section 11 of the Act
of 1894 had been prepared by the concerned authorities. That, the
document relied on by the Petitioner, dated 12-08-2017, is the
rectified
statement
of
compensation
amounting
to
₹
25,33,71,996/- (Rupees twenty five crores, thirty three lakhs,
seventy one thousand, nine hundred and ninety six) only, of which
₹ 17,80,29,535/- (Rupees seventeen crores, eighty lakhs, twenty
nine thousand, five hundred and thirty five) only, is outstanding.
That, the communication, dated 31-05-2013, is only a “Statement
of Compensation” and does not tantamount to an Award.
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
7.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent No.4
vehemently repudiating the stand taken by the Petitioner and
State-Respondents led this Court through the dates of the events
and urged that the compensation computed as ₹ 6,70,99,531/(Rupees six crores, seventy lakhs, ninety nine thousand, five
hundred and thirty one) only, on 31-05-2013, was an Award under
Section 11 of the Act of 1894 which was communicated to the
Respondent No.4. That, the Award is described as “Statement of
Compensation” and failure to mention Section 11 of the Act of
1894, does not divest the compensation of the characteristics of an
Award, which it bears as required under the Act.
The State-
Respondents by failing to insert Section 11 of the Act in the Award,
cannot interpret the document to the disadvantage of Respondent
No.4 after receiving the entire payment.
That, the State-
Respondents despite release of the 20% remaining payment by
Respondent No.4 on 14-08-2015, failed to release it to the
Petitioner. That, Section 16 of the Act of 1894, presupposes that
an Award has been made under Section 11, whereupon the
possession is handed over to the concerned party. Accordingly, on
deposit of the entire amount of the Award, the property was
handed over, and taken over on 11-07-2015, during which neither
the Petitioner nor the State-Respondents objected by raising
grounds of non-preparation of the Award. That, the request of the
Respondent No.4 made on 14-08-2015 to the Respondent No.3 for
mutation of the property has not been complied with.
That, the
fresh claim of the Petitioner under the Act of 2013 is for the
purpose of obtaining undue benefits, as in his first representation,
dated 09-08-2017, to the Respondent No.2, he had merely
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
requested that the new rates be applied for the remaining 20%
compensation. That, in the subsequent representation, dated 2111-2017,
the
Petitioner
laid
claim
to
an
amount
of
₹
17,80,29,535/- (Rupees seventeen crores, eighty lakhs, twenty
nine thousand, five hundred and thirty five) only, based on the
alleged rectified assessment under the Act of 2013 which itself is
not in conformity with law, as the market rate for computing the
compensation has not been disclosed. That, the proviso to Section
26 of the Act of 2013 requires the date of determination of market
value to be the date on which the notification under Section 4(1) of
the Act of 1894 was issued. Besides, the State-Respondents have
made contradictory statements regarding the rates of rectified
calculation.
As per their Counter-Affidavit, the revised statement
was prepared at the revised market rate of ₹ 319.94 per square
feet, (Memo, dated 12-08-2017), while, in their subsequent
Affidavit of 12-06-2023, (Annexure ─ A3), the assessment was
allegedly made @ ₹ 352.18 per square feet.
(i)
Advancing an alternative argument, it was contended
that, even assuming but not admitting that Section 24(1)(a) of the
Act of 2013 is applicable to the case, the first Notification under
Section 4(1) of the Act of 1894 is the base for determining the
market
rate,
consequently,
the
State-Respondents
erred
in
assessing the rectified statement as per the revised rates. That, as
the Award dated 31-05-2013 was passed and acted upon by all the
parties, the instant case will be covered by the ambit of Section
24(1)(b) and not Section 24(1)(a) of the Act of 2013.
That,
Section 25 of the Act of 2013 requires the Collector to make an
award within a period of 12 months from the date of publication of
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
the declaration under Section 19 of the Act of 2013 and if not done,
the entire proceedings for land acquisition shall lapse.
That,
Section 19 of the Act of 2013, corresponds to Section 6 of the Act
of 1894 regarding declaration. As Section 6 declaration under the
Act of 1894 was published on 03-08-2013, the time limit of 12
months would commence on 01-01-2014, the date of enforcement
of the Act of 2013. The rectified Award was made on 12-08-2017,
much beyond the period of limitation, which tantamounts to lapse
of the acquisition proceedings.
To buttress her submissions,
Learned Senior Counsel relied on Executive Engineer, Gosikhurd
Project
Ambadi,
Bhandara,
Maharashtra
Vidarbha
Development Corporation vs. Mahesh and Others .
Irrigation
That, in view of
the grounds advanced, WP(C) No.32 of 2018 be dismissed and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 be allowed.
8.
Heard rival contentions of Learned Counsel for the
parties, perused the pleadings, documents and citations made at
the Bar, the short question that falls for determination is;
“Whether Section 24(1)(a) as urged by the
Petitioner and the State-Respondents or
Section 24(1)(b) of the Act of 2013 as
contended by the Respondent No.4, is
applicable to the matters at hand.”
9.
Before embarking on this exercise, it is imperative to
refer to the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
Indore Development Authority (supra).
The issues for determination
referred to a Five Judge Bench of the Supreme Court, were as
follows;
“5.……………………………………………………………..
5.1. (i) Whether the word “or” in Section
24(2)
(2022) 2 SCC 772
of
the
Act
used
in
between
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
possession has not been taken or compensation
has not been paid to be read as “and”?
5.2. (ii) Whether the proviso to Section
24(2) of the 2013 Act has to be construed as
part thereof or the proviso to Section 24(1)(b)?
5.3. (iii) What meaning is to be given to
the word “paid” used in Section 24(2) and
“deposited” used in the proviso to Section
24(2)?
5.4. (iv) What are the consequences of
payment not made?
5.5. (v) What are the consequences of
the amount not deposited?
5.6. (vi) What is the effect of a person
refusing to accept the compensation?”
(i)
The answers to the questions extracted above were
summarised at Paragraph 366 as follows;
“366. In view of the aforesaid discussion,
we answer the questions as under:
366.1. Under the provisions of Section
24(1)(a) in case the award is not made as on
1-1-2014, the date of commencement of the
2013 Act, there is no lapse of proceedings.
Compensation has to be determined under the
provisions of the 2013 Act.
366.2. In case the award has been
passed within the window period of five years
excluding the period covered by an interim
order of the court, then proceedings shall
continue as provided under Section 24(1)(b) of
the 2013 Act under the 1894 Act as if it has not
been repealed.
366.3. The word “or” used in Section
24(2) between possession and compensation
has to be read as “nor” or as “and”. The
deemed lapse of land acquisition proceedings
under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act takes
place where due to inaction of authorities for
five years or more prior to commencement of
the said Act, the possession of land has not
been taken nor compensation has been paid. In
other words, in case possession has been
taken, compensation has not been paid then
there is no lapse. Similarly, if compensation
has been paid, possession has not been taken
then there is no lapse.
366.4. The expression “paid” in the main
part of Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act does not
include a deposit of compensation in court. The
consequence of non-deposit is provided in the
proviso to Section 24(2) in case it has not been
deposited with respect to majority of
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
landholdings then all beneficiaries (landowners)
as on the date of notification for land
acquisition under Section 4 of the 1894 Act
shall be entitled to compensation in accordance
with the provisions of the 2013 Act. In case the
obligation under Section 31 of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 has not been fulfilled,
interest under Section 34 of the said Act can be
granted. Non-deposit of compensation (in
court) does not result in the lapse of land
acquisition proceedings. In case of nondeposit with respect to the majority of
holdings for five years or more, compensation
under the 2013 Act has to be paid to the
“landowners” as on the date of notification for
land acquisition under Section 4 of the 1894
Act.
366.5. In case a person has been
tendered the compensation as provided under
Section 31(1) of the 1894 Act, it is not open to
him to claim that acquisition has lapsed under
Section 24(2) due to non-payment or nondeposit of compensation in court. The
obligation to pay is complete by tendering the
amount under Section 31(1). The landowners
who had refused to accept compensation or
who sought reference for higher compensation,
cannot claim that the acquisition proceedings
had lapsed under Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act.
366.6. The proviso to Section 24(2) of
the 2013 Act is to be treated as part of Section
24(2), not part of Section 24(1)(b).
366.7. The mode of taking possession
under the 1894 Act and as contemplated under
Section 24(2) is by drawing of inquest
report/memorandum. Once award has been
passed on taking possession under Section 16
of the 1894 Act, the land vests in State there is
no divesting provided under Section 24(2) of
the 2013 Act, as once possession has been
taken there is no lapse under Section 24(2).
366.8. The provisions of Section 24(2)
providing for a deemed lapse of proceedings
are applicable in case authorities have failed
due to their inaction to take possession and pay
compensation for five years or more before the
2013 Act came into force, in a proceeding for
land acquisition pending with the authority
concerned as on 1-1-2014. The period of
subsistence of interim orders passed by court
has to be excluded in the computation of five
years.
366.9. Section 24(2) of the 2013 Act
does not give rise to new cause of action to
question the legality of concluded proceedings
of land acquisition. Section 24 applies to a
proceeding
pending
on
the
date
of
enforcement of the 2013 Act i.e. 1-1-2014. It
does not revive stale and time-barred claims
and does not reopen concluded proceedings
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
nor allow landowners to question the legality
of mode of taking possession to reopen
proceedings
or
mode
of
deposit
of
compensation in the treasury instead of court
to invalidate acquisition.”
(emphasis supplied)
(ii)
On the bedrock of the law laid down (supra) the
question formulated for determination is taken up for consideration.
10.
The Notification under Section 4(1) of the Act of 1894
published in the Official Gazette by the Respondent No.3 on 18-052013 mentioned that as there was urgency to acquire the land in
terms of Section 17(4) of the Act of 1894, Section 5A of the same
Act would not apply. For ease of comprehension Section 5A(1) and
Sections 17(1) and 17(4) of the Act of 1894 are extracted below;
“5A.
Hearing
of
objections.─(1)
Any
person interested in any land which has been
notified under section 4, sub-section (1), as
being needed or likely to be needed for a public
purpose or for a company may, within thirty
days from the date of the publication of the
notification, object to the acquisition of the land
or of any land in the locality, as the case may
be.”
……………………………………………………………………………
17.
Special
powers
in
case
of
urgency.─(1) In cases of urgency, whenever
the appropriate Government, so directs, the
Collector, though no such award has been
made, may, on the expiration of fifteen days
from the publication of the notice mentioned in
section 9, sub-section (1), take possession of
any land needed for a public purpose. Such
land shall thereupon vest absolutely in the
Government, free from all encumbrances.”
(2)……………………………………………………………
(3)……………………………………………………………
(4) In the case of any land to which, in
the opinion of the appropriate Government, the
provisions of sub-section (1) or sub-section (2)
are applicable, the appropriate Government
may direct that the provisions of section 5A
shall not apply, and, if it does so direct, a
declaration may be made under section 6 in
respect of the land at any time after the date of
the publication of the notification under section
4, sub-section (1).”
(i)
Following the Notice under Section 4(1) on 18-05-2013,
declaration under Section 6 of the Act of 1894 was published on
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
03-08-2013, informing that the land was required for public
purpose. Section 9(1) Notice under the Act of 1894 was published
on 25-11-2013.
Prior to the said Notices, “Statement of
Compensation” was computed on 31-05-2013, as ₹ 6,70,99,531/(Rupees six crores, seventy lakhs, ninety nine thousand, five
hundred and thirty one) only, by the Respondent No.3 as per the
Act of 1894 and intimated to the Respondent No.4.
In fact,
records reveal that before the Notification under Section 4(1) was
issued the Respondent No.2, vide letter, dated 20-02-2013,
informed
the
Respondent
No.3
that
the
“Statement
of
Compensation” of land had been worked out at the market rate of
₹ 151.49 per square feet, with
a request to release the
compensation assessed.
(ii)
80% of the compensation computed was deposited by
Respondent No.4, on 01-05-2014 with a request to Respondent
No.3 to direct the Petitioner to hand over the possession of the
acquired property and building structures, within two months from
the date of deposit.
On 24-03-2015, the Respondent No.4
reiterated to the Respondent No.3, the request for mutation of the
land to enable deposit of the balance amount of 20%. On 14-082015, the Respondent No.4 communicated to Respondent No.3
that the possession of the land and building had been handed over
to them, by the State Government officials and the owner of the
land on 11-07-2015, but when mutation was sought Respondent
No.3 sought deposit of the 20% in the Revenue Department for
demarcation of the land and change of title. In compliance thereof,
remaining 20% compensation was forwarded to the Respondent
No.3 on 14-08-2015, vide a revalidated Bank Draft bearing
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
No.719159, dated 17-03-2015. On 09-12-2016 vide another
communication to the Respondent No.3, the Respondent No.4
again sought transfer of ownership of land.
(iii)
In the circumstances indicated above, it is apposite to
refer to Section 24(1)(a) and (b) of the Act of 2013 which are
extracted hereinbelow for reference;
“24. Land acquisition process under Act
No. 1 of 1894 shall be deemed to have lapsed
in certain cases.─(1) Notwithstanding anything
contained in this Act, in any case of land
acquisition proceedings initiated under the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 (1 of 1894),─
(a) where no award under section 11 of the
said Land Acquisition Act has been made,
then, all provisions of this Act relating to
the determination of compensation shall
apply; or
(b) where an award under said section 11
has been made, then such proceedings
shall continue under the provisions of the
said Land Acquisition Act, as if the said
Act has not been repealed.”
(iv)
Indore Development Authority (ibid) lays down lucidly at
Paragraphs 366.1 and 366.2 as to what Section 24(1)(a) and
Section 24(1)(b) of the Act of 2013 entails, which having been
extracted hereinabove, for brevity is not being reiterated here.
(v)
Section 11 of the Act of 1894 inter alia provides for
enquiry and award by Collector and requires the Collector to make
an award under his hand of viz;─(i) the true area of the land; (ii)
the compensation which in his opinion should be allowed for the
land; and (iii) the apportionment of the said compensation among
all the persons known or believed to be interested in the land, of
whom, or of whose claims, he has information, whether or not they
have respectively appeared before him.
(vi)
Section 15 of the Act of 1894 inter alia deals with
matters to be considered and neglected in determining the amount
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
of compensation and that the Collector shall be guided by the
provisions contained in Sections 23 and 24 of the same Act which
is concerned with matters to be considered in determining
compensation
and
matters
to
be
neglected
in
determining
compensation respectively.
(vii)
In light of requisites of the aforementioned legal
provisions, “Statement of Compensation”, dated 31-05-2013 and
that of 12-08-2017, are extracted hereinbelow and juxtaposed;
STATEMENT OF COMPENSATION AS PER THE ACT OF
1894, DATED 31-05-2013
“………………………………………………………………
Memo No:223/1784/GOS/LR&DMD/ACQ
Dated:31/5/2013
To,
STATEMENT OF COMPENSATION AS PER THE ACT OF
2013, DATED 12-08-2017
“…………………………………………………………………………………
Memo No.1748/LR&DMD/GOS/ACQ/317-318 Dated:12/8/2017
To,
The Dean,
College of Agriculture Engineering & Post Harvest
Technology,
Central Agriculture University Ranipool,
East Sikkim.
Sub: Statement of Compensation in relation to acquisition of
land for the construction of Central agriculture University
by College of Agriculture Engineering & Post Harvest
Technology Central Agriculture University, Imphal,
Government of India, at Marchak block East Sikkim.
Sir,
With reference to the above subject, I am directed to
forward herewith the statement of compensation for land &
other standing properties along with Govt. Gazette published
vide no.240, dated: 21st May, 2013. The cost of compensation
for land and other properties assessed by DC/East is as under:1. Cost of land area measuring 3.0260 hect. ₹ 4,93,43,117/2. Cost of standing properties
₹
2,85,146/3. 30% solatium
₹ 1,48,88,479/₹ 6,45,16,742/4. 4% Contg. Estb. Charges
₹
25,80,670/5. Capitalized value of LR
₹
2119/Total
₹ 6,70,99,531/-
The Dean,
College of Agriculture Engineering & Post Harvest
Technology,
(Central Agriculture University)
Ranipool, Gangtok.
Sub:
Sir,
Please refer to your letter no. CAEPHT/Estt92/Land/12-13/507 dated 28/06/2017 on the subject cited
above. In this regard, I am directed to inform you that payment
of Rs.1,54,86,137/- has been released to District Collector, East
vide cheque no. 357790 dated 29/07/2017.
The rectified
details of Compensation is reproduced as :
I
Total Land Compensation
including 100% solatium
4% Contg./Estb. Charge
Capitalized value of Land
Rent
TOTAL
Payment
released
to
DC(East) i.e. 80% of total
amount as per the L.A. Act,
vide
cheque
no.065584 dated
05/05/2014
Net payable
House compensation
including 100% solatium
4% Contg./Estb. Charge
₹ 23,14,31,196/-
₹ 1,26,81,433/₹ 82,42,930/-
11.
Total
Payment
released
to
DC/East vide cheque no
736862 dated 30/05/2015
Net payable
12.
Grand Total (I + II)
₹ 19,35,15,672/-
13.
Payment released to DC,
East i.e. 80% of total
amount as per the L.A. Act,
vide
cheque
No.357790
dated
29/07/2017
₹ 1,54,86,137/-
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
(Rupees Six crore seventy lakh ninety nine thousand five hundred
thirty one) only.
I am therefore, directed to request you to kindly release
the 80% advance payment of ₹ 5,16,13,394/- of ₹
6,45,16,472/- only, at the disposal of Secretary, Land
Revenue & Disaster Management Department for making
payment to the land owners.
Yours faithfully,
Rectified Statement of Compensation of bill as
per RFCTLARR Act, 2013, in connection with the
land acquired by College of Agriculture
Engineering & Post Harvest Technology Central
Agriculture University, Imphal, Government of
India at Marchak block East Sikkim.
II
6.
7.
8.
Sd/-(D.B.Yonzon)
RO-CUM-ASSTT. DIRECTOR,
LAND REVENUE & DM DEPARTMENT.
9.
10.
……………………….………………………………….”
III
14.
Net payable amount
₹
₹
92,57,248/2,119/-
₹ 24,06,90,563/₹ 5,16,13,394/-
₹ 18,90,77,169/-
₹ 1,21,93,686/₹
₹
4,87,747/-
44,38,503/-
₹ (19,35,15,672−
1,54,86,137)/₹ 17,80,29,535/-
I am therefore, directed to request you to release the
balance payment amounting to ₹ 17,80,29,535/-(Rupees
Seventeen Crore Eighty Lakh Twenty Nine Thousand Five
Hundred And Thirty Five) only, at the disposal of the
Secretary, Land Revenue & Disaster Management Department
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
for making payment to the land owners, please.
Thanking you,
Yours faithfully,
Sd/Revenue Officer,
Land Revenue & D.M. Department.
………………………………………………………………..”
(viii)
On perusal of both statements, there is no apparent
difference between the two, save the computed amount and details
of house compensation, added in the Award of 12-08-2017.
Nevertheless, despite house compensation not finding place in the
Award
dated
31-05-2013
admittedly
compensation
of
₹
82,42,930/- (Rupees eighty two lakhs, forty two thousand, nine
hundred and thirty) only, was computed as compensation for the
two storeyed building standing on the land and paid in entirety to
the Petitioner on 30-05-2015.
Needless to add that, the
percentage of solatium in the two computations supra differ in view
of the different provisions under the two Acts, with the Act of 2013
prescribing solatium of 100%. In Golden Iron and Steel Forging vs.
Union of India and Others , the High Court of Punjab and Haryana
observed that the word “solatium” draws its meaning from the
word “solace” that is comfort money, given as a statutorily
recognized gesture of conciliation for compulsorily depriving a land
owner of his property.
(ix)
It is pertinent also to refer to Section 11A of the Act
of 1894 which reads as follows;
“11A. Period within which an award
shall be made.─(1) The Collector shall make an
award under section 11 within a period of two
years from the date of the publication of the
declaration and if no award is made within that
period,
the
entire
proceeding
acquisition of the land shall lapse:
for
the
Provided that in a case where the said
declaration has been published before the
(2008) SCC OnLine P&H 498
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
commencement of the Land Acquisition
(Amendment) Act, 1894, the award shall be
made within a period of two years from such
commencement.
Explanation.−In computing the period of
two years referred to in this section, the period
during which any action or proceeding to be
taken in pursuance of the said declaration is
stayed by an order of a Court shall be
excluded.”
(emphasis supplied)
(x)
The various dates have already been extracted supra.
Suffice it to notice that close on the heels of the Section 4(1)
Notification (supra), the Award was made on 31-05-2013 thereby
revealing non-applicability of Section 11A of the Act of 1894 to the
facts of the Petitioner’s case, since the proceedings for the
acquisition do not lapse in the instant matters. It is also evident
from the records that on 31-05-2013 following the preparation of
the “Statement of Compensation”, it was communicated to
Respondent No.4 in due compliance to Section 12(2) of the Act of
1894.
(xi)
That, having been said necessary reference is made to
Section 114 of the Act of 2013 which reads as follows;
“114. Repeal and saving.─(1) The Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 (1 of 1894) is hereby
repealed.
(2) Save as otherwise provided in this
Act the repeal under sub-section (1) shall not
be held to prejudice or affect the general
application of section 6 of the General Clauses
Act, 1897 (10 of 1897) with regard to the effect
of repeals.”
(xii)
Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, which finds
reference above reads as follows;
“6. Effect of repeal.—Where this Act, or
any Central Act or Regulation made after the
commencement of this Act, repeals any
enactment hitherto made or hereafter to be
made, then, unless a different intention
appears, the repeal shall not─
(a) revive anything not in force or
existing at the time at which the
repeal takes effect; or
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
(b) affect the previous operation of any
enactment so repealed or anything
duly done or suffered thereunder; or
(c) affect any right, privilege, obligation
or liability acquired, accrued or
incurred under any enactment so
repealed; or
(d) affect any penalty, forfeiture or
punishment incurred in respect of
any offence committed against any
enactment so repealed; or
(e) affect
any
investigation,
legal
proceeding or remedy in respect of
any such right, privilege, obligation,
liability,
penalty,
forfeiture
or
punishment as aforesaid,
and any such investigation, legal proceeding or
remedy may be instituted, continued or
enforced, and any such penalty, forfeiture or
punishment may be imposed as if the repealing
Act or Regulation had not been passed.”
(emphasis supplied)
(xiii)
The ambit of the repeal and saving clause as given in
Section 114 of the Act of 1894 is to be gauged from the foregoing
extracted provision of the General Clauses Act, 1897, which is
explained in no uncertain terms.
11.
The arguments of the Petitioner and Respondents No.2
and 3 that the “Statement of Compensation” is not an Award
cannot be countenanced for the reason that it consists of all the
requisites of an Award. The Respondent No.2 has considered the
legal requirements of Section 11 of the Act of 1894, which includes
the true area of the land, the compensation which in his opinion
would be allowed for the land.
Compensation for the standing
building was also calculated. The compensation was calculated at
the market rate of ₹ 151.49 per square feet as already discussed.
Solatium of 30% was calculated in terms of Section 23(2) of the
Act
of
1894.
In
addition
to
which
4%
contingency
and
establishment charges were added and capitalized value of LR was
added.
Section 23(1A) of the Act of 1894 refers to the market
value of the land on the date of publication of the Notification
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
under Section 4(1) of the Act of 1894 as a relevant factor for
determining the amount of compensation to be awarded for land
acquired under the Act.
The rate at which compensation was
calculated as duly intimated to the Respondent No.4. Section 31 of
the Act of 1894 provides for payment of compensation or deposit
of the same in the Court. On making an Award under Section 11 of
the Act of 1894, the Collector shall tender payment of the
compensation awarded by him to the “persons interested entitled
thereto according to the award and shall pay it to them unless
prevented by some one or more by the contingencies mentioned in
the next sub-section”.
12.
The
fact
of
deposit
of
80%
on
01-05-2014
by
Respondent No.4 and due receipt of the amount by the Petitioner
sans demur is not contested. There was no dispute to the title and
the fact that the Petitioner was the sole owner of the property.
The remaining 20% compensation was admittedly made over to
the office of the Respondent No.3, vide letter dated 14-08-2015 of
Respondent No.4, consequent upon which vide a document, dated
11-07-2015, which bears the signatures of the Petitioner, the
‘Assistant Estate Officer’, presumably of the Respondent No.4 and
two officials of the Respondent No.2, the property was handed over
by the Petitioner and the physical possession thereof was taken
over by the Respondent No.4.
13.
On this facet it is beneficial to refer to Satendra Prasad
Jain and Others vs. State of U.P and Others ,
where the Supreme
Court, observed as follows;
“15. Ordinarily, the Government can
take possession of the land proposed to be
(1993) 4 SCC 369
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
acquired only after an award of compensation
in respect thereof has been made under
Section 11. Upon the taking of possession the
land vests in the Government, that is to say,
the owner of the land loses to the Government
the title to it. This is what Section 16 states.
The provisions of Section 11-A are intended to
benefit the landowner and ensure that the
award is made within a period of two years
from the date of the Section 6 declaration. In
the ordinary case, therefore, when the
Government fails to make an award within two
years of the declaration under Section 6, the
land has still not vested in the Government
and its title remains with the owner, the
acquisition proceedings are still pending and,
by virtue of the provisions of Section 11-A,
lapse. When Section 17(1) is applied by reason
of urgency, the Government takes possession
of the land prior to the making of the award
under Section 11 and thereupon the owner is
divested of the title to the land which is vested
in the Government. Section 17(1) states so in
unmistakable terms. Clearly, Section 11-A can
have no application to cases of acquisitions
under Section 17 because the lands have
already vested in the Government and there is
no provision in the said Act by which land
statutorily vested in the Government can revert
to the owner.”
(emphasis supplied)
(i)
Pausing here momentarily, it may be remarked that,
from the facts and circumstances before this Court, it is apparent
that although the urgency clause was invoked, it was not acted
upon by the State-Respondents.
14.
Rothak
In Raj Pal Singh vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Haryana,
, the Supreme Court, at Paragraph 32.5, observed as
follows;
“32.5. ……………. in the matter of compulsory
acquisition of land under the 1894 Act for
public purpose, the property was to vest
absolutely
in
the
Government
(thereby
divesting the owner of all his rights therein)
only after taking of possession in either of the
methods i.e. after making of award, as
provided in Section 16; or earlier than making
of award, as provided in Section 17. In other
words, the owner was divested of the property
and same vested in the Government in
absolute terms only if, and after, the
possession was taken by either of the
processes envisaged in Sections 16 and 17.
However, so long as possession was not taken,
(2021) 13 SCC 489
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
the mere fact of issuance of notification under
Section 4 of the 1894 Act or declaration under
Section 6 thereof, did not divest the owner of
his right in respect of the property in
question.”
(emphasis supplied)
(i)
Handing over physical possession of the required
property on 11-07-2015 is an admitted position.
(ii)
In The Fruit & Vegetable Merchants Union vs. The Delhi
Improvement Trust , the Supreme Court considered the term “vest”
and observed as follows;
“(11) ….. As will presently appear, the
term “vesting” has a variety of meaning which
has to be gathered from the context in which it
has been used. It may mean full ownership, or
only possession for a particular purpose, or
clothing the authority with power to deal with
the property as the agent of another person or
authority.
……………………………………………………………………………..
(19) That the word “vest” is a word of
variable import is shown by provisions of Indian
statutes also. .………………………. In the cases
contemplated by Ss. 16 and 17 the property
acquired becomes the property of Government
without any conditions or limitations either as
to title or possession. The legislature has made
it clear that the vesting of the property is not
for any limited purpose or limited duration. It
would thus appear that the word “vest” has
not got a fixed connotation, meaning in all
cases that the property is owned by the person
or the authority in whom it vests. It may vest
in title, or it may vest in possession, or it may
vest in a limited sense, as indicated in the
context in which it may have been used in a
particular piece of legislation. …………”
(emphasis supplied)
(iii)
In S. Appala Narasamma vs. Commissioner of Income-Tax7,
the Andhra Pradesh High Court, observed at Paragraph 6 as
follows;
“6. Vesting of title to the land is a
matter of law, not a matter of inference. This is
a case of transfer of property by operation of
law and the relevant statute clearly provides
the situations in which the land vests viz.,
Section 16, Section 17(1) and Section 17(2).
According to these provisions, the taking of
possession per se does not bring about
vesting; the taking of possession must be
AIR 1957 SC 344
(1986) SCC OnLine AP 317
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
consequent upon passing of an award (section
16) or an order contemplated by Section 17(1),
or in a situation contemplated by Section
17(2). The Act does not provide for taking of
possession before the passing of the award,
except in situations contemplated by Sections
17(1) and (2). ……………….. Since possession
taken before the award continues to be with
the Government, we must say that the moment
the award is passed, possession from that
moment onwards should be related to the
award. It is on that date that the land vests in
the Government.”
(emphasis supplied)
15.
In Indore Development Authority (supra), at Paragraph
366.7 already extracted (supra), the Court with clarity has
elucidated the mode of taking possession under the Act of 1894, as
contemplated under Section 24(2) of the Act of 2013 is by drawing
of inquest report/memorandum.
Only once an award has been
passed under Section 11 of the Act of 1894, on taking possession
under Section 16 of the 1894 Act, the land vests in the State and
there is no divesting provided under Section 24(2) of the Act of
2013, as once possession has been taken there is no lapse under
Section 24(2) of the Act of 2013. The Memo, dated 11-07-2015,
stands sentinel to the possession of the land handed over by the
Petitioner and taken over by the officials of the Respondent No.2
and Respondent No.4.
In Paragraph 366.4 Indore Development
Authority (ibid) extracted (supra), it is provided that non-deposit of
compensation (in court) “does not result in the lapse of land
acquisitions proceedings”. In light of the legal precedents referred
to hereinabove, possession is handed over only on preparation of
Award.
16.
It is also settled law that, in case a person has been
tendered the compensation as provided under Section 31(1) of the
Act of 1894, it is not open to him to claim that the acquisition has
lapsed under Section 24(2) of the Act of 2013 due to the non-
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
payment or non-deposit of compensation in Court. Section 24(2)
of the Act of 2013 does not give rise to new cause of action to
question the legality of concluded proceedings of land acquisition
as culled out from the decision (supra). Section 24 of the Act of
2013 applies to a proceeding pending on the date of enforcement
of the 2013 Act i.e. 01-01-2014. It does not revive stale and timebarred claims and does not reopen concluded proceedings nor
allow landowners to question the legality of mode of taking
possession
to
reopen
proceedings
or
mode
of
deposit
of
compensation in the treasury instead of the court, to invalidate
acquisition.
(i)
The
arguments of the
Petitioner
and the
State-
Respondents that the Award was not prepared is erroneous,
misleading and made for the purpose of obtaining unlawful gain for
the Petitioner when all parameters prescribed in the Act of 1894
had
been
followed
by
the
concerned
Authority.
If
the
compensation computed on 31-05-2013 is not an Award then the
State-Respondents have failed to explain the basis and law under
which such compensation was prepared.
(ii)
can
It is unfathomable as to how the State-Respondents
make
a
u-turn
regarding
their
own
Award
or
what
inconceivable magnanimity would drive the Petitioner to hand over
possession of his landed property to the Respondent No.4 without
preparation of an Award. I also deem it appropriate to remark that
the word “rectified” has been utilised in the Award of 12-08-2017.
If the compensation of 31-05-2013 was not an Award, was there a
necessity to “rectify” it on 12-08-2017? The words “Statement of
Compensation” has been evidently employed for the reason that
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Section 11 of the Act of 1894 itself mentions that the Collector
shall compute the ‘compensation’ which in his opinion should be
allowed for the land. Section 15 of the Act of 1894 also does not
employ
the
word
‘Award’
but
requires
determination
of
compensation as also Sections 23 and 24 of the Act of 1894. In
any event both the Awards nowhere invoke the provision under
which the Award was prepared.
17.
The anomalies in the market rates quoted by the State-
Respondents are also revelatory of their inconsistent stand raising
doubts about the authenticity of their contentions. Besides,
Respondent No.3 claims to have informed Respondent No.4 on 1106-2015 that all proceedings for land acquisition were on hold due
to the Act of 2013. Records however reveal that by 05-05-2014,
80% of the compensation was already paid by Respondent No.4
and the house compensation made good on 30-05-2015. Despite
information of Respondent No.3 referred to supra, dated 11-062015, the possession of the land was made over to the Respondent
No.4 vide handing-taking document dated 11-07-2015 and this
circumstance has gone unexplained by the State-Respondents.
There is also no explanation offered as to why Petitioner would
seek 20% remaining compensation, calculated as per the Act of
2013 only in 2017, when it was already deposited by Respondent
No.4 with Respondent No.3 on 14-08-2015 as per the Act of 1894.
It is only in case of non-deposit for five years or more that
compensation under the Act of 2013 has to be paid to the
Petitioner, calculated as on the date of Notification under Section 4
of the Act of 1894 (Paragraph 366.4 of Indore Development
Authority (supra).
Once possession is taken there is no lapse under
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
Section 24(2) of the Act of 2013 (Paragraph 366.7 of Indore
Development Authority (ibid).
Section 24 of the Act of 2013 applies
to proceedings pending on the date of enforcement of 2013 Act i.e.,
01-01-2014.
18.
Before concluding the matter, it may appositely be
noticed that, the Award dated 12-08-2017, reflects 100% solatium
for land and 100% solatium for house compensation, while Section
30(1) of the Act of 2013 provides for imposition of solatium
equivalent to one hundred percent of the compensation amount.
Section 30(1) of the Act of 2013 and the ‘Explanation’ thereto is
extracted below;
“30. Award of solatium.─(1) The
Collector
having
determined
the
total
compensation to be paid, shall, to arrive at the
final award, impose a "Solatium" amount
equivalent to one hundred per cent of the
compensation amount.
Explanation.─ For the removal of doubts
it is hereby declared that solatium amount shall
be in addition to the compensation payable to
any person whose land has been acquired.”
(i)
Section
of
the
Act
of
provides
for
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Award as per the Second Schedule,
where there is no mention of solatium for the second time.
19.
In R.B. Dealers Private Limited vs. Metro Railway, Kolkata8,
the Supreme Court at Paragraph 4.1 held that;
“4.1.………………... Sub-section (3) of
Section 30 further provides that in addition to
the market value of the land provided under
Section 26, the Collector shall, in every case,
award the amount calculated at the rate of
12% p.a. on such market value for the period
commencing on and from the date of the
publication of the notification under sub-section
(2) of Section 4, in respect of such land, till the
date of the award of the Collector or the date of
taking possession of the land, whichever is
earlier. Therefore, on a conjoint reading of the
(2019) 20 SCC 658
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
aforesaid provisions and the scheme of the Act,
it is to be seen that before the final award is
passed by the Collector, the Collector has to
determine the market value of the land as
provided under Section 26 of the Act. That,
thereafter, after determination of the market
value of the land as provided under Section 26
of the Act, the Collector has to determine the
amount of compensation as per Section 27 of
the Act, which includes the market value of the
land as well as the value of all assets attached
to the land. Therefore, the amount of
compensation determined shall be including
the market value of the land to be acquired (as
per Section 26 of the 2013 Act) and the value
of all assets attached to the land. The
determination of the value of the things
attached to the land or building shall be as per
Section 29 of the 2013 Act. Over and above the
amount of compensation so determined by the
Collector as per Sections 26, 27 and 28 of the
2013 Act, at the time of the final award, the
Collector has to impose a “solatium” amount
equivalent to one hundred per cent of the
compensation amount, as per Sections 29 and
30 of the 2013 Act. …………….”
(emphasis supplied)
(i)
Although, the above observation is not relevant for the
present purposes, as the Award dated 31-05-2013 is being taken
into consideration, however, it is a tangential observation made for
the purpose of clarification regarding addition of solatium to the
compensation under the Act of 2013.
20.
In view of the foregoing discussions, the answer to the
question formulated hereinabove is that Section 24(1)(b) and not
Section 24(1)(a) of the Act of 2013 is applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the matters under discussion.
21.
It thus concludes that, WP(C) No.32 of 2018 deserves
to be and is accordingly dismissed.
22.
The prayers in WP(C) No.43 of 2022, are allowed.
Consequently, (i) the letter bearing Memo No. 1748/LR&DMD/GOS/
ACQ/317-318 dated 12-08-2017;
(ii) Letter bearing No.1748/LR&DMD/ACQ/GOS/418 dated
20-09-2017; and
WP(C) No.32 of 2018 : Karma Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.43 of 2022 : College of Agriculture Engineering and Post Harvest Technology vs. State of Sikkim and Others
(iii) Letter bearing No.1748/LR&DMD/2018/631 dated “NIL”
2018, all stand quashed.
23.
Pending applications, in both the Writ Petitions stand
disposed of accordingly.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10-07-2023
Approved for reporting : Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review