Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010269972025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7131/2025
CN-234 ABUL KALAM AZAD
S/O- HURMAT ALI, R/O VILLAGE - PUTLARTARI, P.O. JARABARI, P.S.
BARPETA, DISTRICT- BARPETA, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY, HOME
DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006.
2:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
ASSAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI- 781007
3:THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE (T AND AP)
ASSAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI- 781007
4:THE COMMANDANT
28TH ASSAM POLICE BATTALION
HOWLY
DISTRICT- BARPETA
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
HUSSAIN
: MR. R ALI, N PERVIN,MR H A AHMED,MR. MUSTAFA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM,
Page No.# 2/13
–B E F O R E –
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
Advocate for the petitioner
: Mr. R. Ali, Advocate
Advocate for the respondents
: Ms. M. Battacharjee,
Addl. Sr. Govt. Advocate
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 23.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 14.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
: No.
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes.
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. R. Ali, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. M.
Bhattacharjee, learned Addl. Senior Government Advocate for the respondents.
2]
The petitioner before this Court has assailed the order dated 06.03.2025
passed by the Commandant-cum-Disciplinary Authority, 28th Assam Police
Battalion, Howly, Barpeta dismissing the petitioner from service and the order
dated 29.07.2025 passed by the Appellate Authority-cum-Inspector General of
Police (T&AP) Assam, Ulubari, Guwahati rejecting the appeal filed by the
petitioner and upholding the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority
dismissing the petitioner from service. The petitioner also seeks a direction to
Page No.# 3/13
the respondent authority to reinstate him in service with all consequential
service benefits including back wages.
3]
The writ petitioner was initially appointed as A.B. Constable and posted at
4th Assam Police Task Force Battalion, Howly vide order dated 10.04.2008.
During the course of his service period he was undergone several training and
had posted at different places. He had rendered his services with sincerity to the
satisfaction of all concerned.
4]
The petitioner’s first wife was living separately from the petitioner since
02.09.2019 by leaving behind their minor son and the writ petitioner. The first
wife filed a complaint before the Commandant on 16.08.2024 alleging inter alia
that she submitted a petition seeking her name to be entered as a nominee in
the service record of the writ petitioner. In the said complaint, it was alleged
that the first wife of the petitioner got married to the petitioner in the year 2010
and one child has born out of the marriage between the petitioner and the first
wife. However, he married another woman in the year 2019 without her consent
and from the nominee form and the particulars submitted by the petitioner, the
first wife came to know that the name of the second wife is Khalisa Khatun,
daughter of Kafiur Rahman. The first wife therefore, alleged that being a
Government servant the petitioner cannot marry another woman during the
lifetime of his spouse or without a formal divorce from the competent Court of
law.
5]
On the basis of the complaint, the Commandant-cum-Disciplinary
Page No.# 4/13
Authority issued a show cause to the petitioner dated 22.08.2024, whereby the
petitioner was called upon to show cause as to why the act of second marriage
which tantamount to gross indiscipline and brings bad name to the department
shall not render him unfit to remain in service, and asking him to submit his
written statement within a period of 10 days. The petitioner thereafter,
submitted his written statements denying the charges levelled against him. The
departmental authority thereafter, initiated the departmental proceedings
against the petitioner being DP.08/2024. An enquiry officer was appointed to
complete the enquiry. Upon completion of the enquiry the enquiry officer
submitted his report. In conclusion, the enquiry officer held that the delinquent
Government servant, namely the writ petitioner had entered into a second
marriage without taking proper consent of his first wife and/or without being
divorced the second marriage was performed as per Mohammedan law. The
enquiry officer therefore, concluded that the charge of gross indiscipline on the
part of the petitioner is proved beyond reasonable doubt. The disciplinary
authority thereafter, issued another show cause notice on the writ petitioner
serving him a copy of the enquiry report and asking him to submit his statement
in his defence. As in view of the enquiry report the disciplinary authority was of
the view that there is a likelihood of inflicting major penalty on him. The writ
petitioner thereafter, submitted his reply to the second show cause notice.
However, the respondent authority did not accept the explanations furnished by
the petitioner and by the impugned order dated 06.03.2025 the petitioner has
been dismissed from service. Being aggrieved, the petitioner filed an appeal
before the appellate authority which however, came to be dismissed by order
dated 29.07.2025.
Page No.# 5/13
6]
It is submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
petitioner's first wife had deserted him and his minor son therefore, he had no
option but to marry the second wife. Under such circumstances, when the
enquiry officer had accepted his explanations, the disciplinary authority ought
not to have imposed a major penalty of dismissal from service. In support of his
contentions, the learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to the judgment
of the Division Bench of this Court that rendered in Writ Appeal No. 357/2022.
7]
The respondents have contested the matter by filing their affidavit. The
affidavit was filed by the Inspector General of Police. The respondent authority
disputed the contentions of the writ petitioner that because of personal and
family hardship, the punishment of dismissal is inappropriate. The respondent
authority contended that the punishment must commensurate with the gravity
of misconduct.
8]
It was further submitted by the State Counsel that there is an Office
Memorandum dated 20.10.2023 which was issued under the provisions of Rule
26 of the Assam Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1965. By the said OM, it was
provided that in case of any Government servant contracting another marriage
without obtaining the permission of the Government, notwithstanding that such
subsequent marriage is permissible under personal law for that time being in
forced then the disciplinary authority may initiate departmental proceedings
under the provisions of the Assam Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules,
1964 for imposition of major penalty including compulsory retirement against
those Government Servants found to have violated Rule 26 of the Assam Civil
Page No.# 6/13
Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and which itself is a gross misconduct on the
part of the Government Servant having large bearings on the society.
9]
As per the said OM, the disciplinary authorities besides initiating
departmental proceedings shall take necessary steps for inflicting legal penal
action by the Court of law as per the provisions of law. It is submitted that this
particular OM having been issued by the respondent authorities, the department
had to initiate the disciplinary proceedings as contemplated under the OM and
punishment as required. It is submitted that there is no infirmity in the enquiry
proceedings and therefore, there being no merit in the writ petition the same
should be dismissed. It is also submitted that the punishment imposed is
appropriate and it commensurate the misconduct which has been proved in the
enquiry and therefore, does not call for any interference.
10] The learned counsel for the parties have been heard and the pleadings
available on record have been carefully perused.
11] The writ petitioner does not challenge the departmental proceedings. The
writ petitioner in fact, in his pleadings has admitted the second marriage with
Khalisa Khatun on the ground that his first wife deserted the matrimonial home.
There is also no quarrel with the fact that the Assam Civil Services (Conduct)
Rules prohibit second marriage during the lifetime of the existing spouse. The
Government of Assam by OM dated 20.10.2023 has issued instructions with
regard to bigamous marriages. The said OM is extracted below:
Page No.# 7/13
“GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL ::: PERSONNEL (B)
DISPUR ::: GUWAHATI-6
No.ABP.122/2023/7
Dated Dispur the 20th October, 2023
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Sub: Bigamous marriages.
It is hereby reiterated that as per the provisions of Rule 26 of The Assam Civil Services (Conduct) Rules
1965“1) No Government servant who has a wife living shall contract another marriage without first obtaining
the permission of the Government, notwithstanding that such subsequent marriage is permissible under
the personal law for the time being applicable to him.
2) No female Government servant shall marry any person who has a wife living without first obtaining the
permission of the Government."
In the context of the above provisions, the Disciplinary Authority may initiate immediate Departmental
Proceeding under the provision of the Assam Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules 1964, for imposition
of major penalty including compulsory retirement against those Government Servants found to have
violated Rule 26 of the Assam Civil Services (Conduct) Rules 1965, which itself is a gross misconduct on
the part of a Government Servant having large bearings on the society.
The Disciplinary Authorities besides initiating Departmental Proceedings shall also take necessary steps
for inflicting legal penal action by the Court of law, as per provisions of law whenever such cases are
detected.
The above instructions shall come into force with immediate effect and the instructions may be brought to
the notice of all concerned.
Sd/- Shri. Niraj Verma, IAS
Additional Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Assam
Personnel Department
Dated Dispur the 20th October, 2023
Мemo No. ABP.122/2023/7-A
Copy forwarded to:
1. All Additional Chief Secretaries to the Government of Assam, Dispur.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary to the Chief Minister, Assam, Dispur.
3. All Principal Secretaries/Commissioner and Secretaries/Commissioner & Special
Secretaries/Secretaries to the Government of Assam.
4. All the Heads of Departments.
5. All District Commissioners.
6. Principal Secretaries, KAAC, Diphu/ Bodoland Territorial Council, Kokrajhar/ Dima Hasao
Autonomous Council, Haflong
7. The Secretary, Co-ordination, Office of the Chief Secretary, Assam, Dispur.
8. PS to the Ministers/ Minister of State, Assam, Dispur.
9. The Superintendent, Assam Government Press, Bamunimaidan, Ghy-2l for favour of publication of the
above Notification in the extraordinary Assam Gazette and submit 50 (fifty) copies to this Department.
By order etc.
Joint Secretary to the Govt. of Assam
Personnel (B) Department”
Page No.# 8/13
12] Since there is no quarrel with the fact that the petitioner entered into a
second marriage during subsistence of his marriage with first wife and since
they did not challenge essentially to the departmental proceedings initiated or
the manner of conducting the departmental proceedings, it is not necessary to
embark on these questions as no challenge has been made in the departmental
proceedings, save and except the quantum of punishment.
13] A Writ Court is not required to examine the quantum of punishment which
is imposed by the authorities unless it sought for any other justifiable reason.
The disciplinary authority is best suited to determine the imposition of quantum
of punishment. Where the Court finds any lacuna in the departmental
proceedings then it is open to the Court to invoke its power of judicial review
and pass appropriate orders for interference either with the proceedings and/or
with the quantum of punishment imposed. As discussed above, in the present
proceedings there is no challenge made to the departmental proceedings by the
petitioner. There is no necessity to examine whether the respondent authorities
have been able to prove sufficiently the conduct of the second marriage by the
writ petitioner inasmuch as it is specifically admitted by the petitioner in the
present proceedings.
14] In Trilok Singh Rawat vs. Union of India reported in 2000 (3) GLT 558, in a
similar matter the Division Bench of this Court interfered with the order of
dismissal and remanded the matter to the disciplinary authority for imposing
any other penalty other than the penalty of dismissal. The Division Bench of this
Court in The Union of India and Ors. vs. Pranab Kumar Nath in Writ Appeal
Page No.# 9/13
No.357/2022 in a similar matter held in the facts of that case that the
respondent therein who was the sole bread earner and on whom besides his
first wife and second wife, his minor daughter was also dependent. Therefore,
the Division Bench held that dismissal from service is the most extreme form of
punishment which can be imposed on a Government employee and which has
the effect of not only cutting out of the source of income and depriving him and
his dependents in the means of sustenance. The Division Bench held that an act
of conducting second marriage during the subsistence of the first marriage can
be said to be in violation of the Rules and is therefore, an act of indiscipline, it
cannot be said that it is one of the most heinous form of misconduct for which
the delinquent employee must be necessarily visited with the punishment of
dismissal from service. The Division Bench therefore, considered that the
imposition of dismissal from service will amount to disproportionately harsh
punishment and thereby will interfere with the order of dismissal and dismiss
the writ appeal by upholding the order of the learned Single Judge in interfering
with the order of dismissal. The relevant paragraphs of the said judgment are
extracted below:
“7. It is true that Courts while dealing with penalty imposed on a delinquent normally does not
interfere with the quantum of punishment, unless it shocks the conscience of the Court. However, there
are no clear criteria laid down in this regard to define as to what shocks the conscience of the Court,
inasmuch as, it would depend on facts of each case.
8. In the present case what comes from the records is that the writ petitioner has a child from the first
marriage who is about 15 years and if the said penalty of dismissal is to be upheld, it will cut off the
only source of income not only for him but also for his first wife, her daughter and his second wife. The
writ petitioner appears to be the sole bread earner, on whom his first wife, his daughter and his second
wife appear to be dependent upon. It can be observed from the records that in course of the inquiry the
first wife of the petitioner, Smt. Chandana Nath had made a request to the authority to look after her
and her child who would be about 15 years by now, which clearly shows the sense of dependency on the
Page No.# 10/13
writ petitioner which she can legitimately demand from her husband.
9. Dismissal is the most extreme form of punishment which can be imposed upon a Government
employee, which has the effect of not only cutting off the source of income, thus depriving him and his
dependents of the means of sustenance. Apart from it, he will be not eligible for reemployment in a
public sector. Thus, the civil consequences it entails are of extreme nature which in our opinion, should
not be ordinarily invoked unless the misconduct is of such nature that there is no other option but to
impose such a punishment. There can be various other serious misconducts for which this most severe
form of punishment can be imposed.
10. In the present case, in our opinion though this act of conducting of second marriage can be said to
be an act of indiscipline, inasmuch as, contracting a second marriage during the subsistence of the first
marriage was in violation of rules, yet, it cannot be said that it is one of most heinous form of
misconducts for which he must be necessarily visited with the punishment of dismissal. The records also
do not indicate of any serious physical violence perpetrated upon the first wife or the daughter of the
writ petitioner or any other act of cruelty, though there is allegation that the writ petitioner had beaten
his first wife and daughter. The writ petitioner appears to have contracted the second marriage on
account of not being happy in the marital life with his first wife.
11. Under the circumstances and taking a holistic view of the entire circumstances as reflected in the
records, this Court, without condoning the said act of misconduct, is of the view that imposing the
punishment of dismissal to the writ petitioner would cause serious economic hardships not only to the
petitioner himself but also to his first wife and his daughter and also to the other woman. The
punishment of dismissal imposed on the writ petitioner will deprive the family members of financial
support and also may drive them to penury. In our opinion devastation which may be caused, more
particularly, the financial hardships which may be caused by the penalty imposed to the family
members can be one of the parameters for judging as to whether the penalty imposed is disproportionate
or shocking. In our view, keeping in mind the misconduct proved, if a lesser penalty could have been
also imposed for the same misconduct, the authorities must examine the impact which will have not
only to the employee concerned, but also to all of his family members who are entirely dependent on
him, before taking the severest and ultimate form of punishment under the rules.
12. Accordingly, for the reasons discussed above, we are of the view that dismissal of the writ petitioner
from service in this case will amount to be disproportionately harsh punishment and accordingly, we
uphold the order passed by the learned Single Judge in setting aside the order of dismissal, however, for
different reasons as discussed above. We accordingly direct that the Disciplinary authority may pass any
other lesser penalty on the petitioner other than the penalty of dismissal.”
15] Having examined the judgment pressed into service rendered in Pranab
Page No.# 11/13
Kumar Nath (supra) and also Trilok Singh Rawat (supra), it seen that two
Division Bench of this Court have held that second marriage entered into by the
delinquent Government servant during the subsistence of the first marriage
although is an act of indiscipline, the order of dismissal from service being the
extreme form of punishment was considered to be disproportionately harsh and
accordingly, necessary orders were issued by the Division Bench of this Court.
16] Coming to the facts of the present case it is seen from the pleadings that
the first wife had initiated proceedings for payment of maintenance before the
competent Court being CR Case No.732 of 2018 and there was an order for
payment of maintenance by the competent Court which the learned counsel for
the petitioner submits before the Court that he had regularly paid the
maintenance till his order of dismissal was passed. It is also the pleaded case of
the petitioner that his mother expired due to illness and his minor son was
suffering from severe neurological ailments and was treated in AIIMS, Delhi and
the father of the petitioner is also suffering from various ailments and the
petitioner being the eldest son, there is no other person to look after the minor
son of the petitioner and his aged father. In the affidavit filed by the
respondents, there is no averment disputing the contentions of the petitioner
that he is required to pay maintenance to his first wife under order of the
competent Court. While the Office Memorandum dated 20.10.2023 has issued in
terms of Rules of the Assam Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1965 and necessary
proceedings are required to be initiated, the authorities are duty bound to
examine each and every case on the facts and circumstances of the case for the
imposition of major penalty in the form of dismissal as prescribed under the
Rules of 1964. From the orders passed by the disciplinary authority as also by
Page No.# 12/13
the appellate authority, there is nothing to indicate that the respondent
authorities have examined the case from that perspective and imposed a
punishment of dismissal from service for the alleged misconduct of the
petitioner for entering into a second marriage during the subsistence of his first
marriage.
17] Considering the facts and circumstances urged before this Court and also
considering the judgment of the Division Bench in Pranab Kumar Nath (supra)
and Trilok Singh Rawat (supra), this Court is of the view that the imposition of
punishment of dismissal of the petitioner is disproportionate for more than one
reason. Under the provisions of Rule 7 of the Rules of 1964, there are several
punishments listed which are major penalties which could have been imposed
by the disciplinary authority. There is no discussion in the order of the
disciplinary authority and/or the order passed by the appellate authority as to
why any other punishment as prescribed under Rule 7 would not be appropriate
in the facts and circumstances of this case. The OM dated 20.10.2023 also does
not specifically provide for imposition of a penalty such as dismissal from service
in cases where an employee is found guilty of contracting a second marriage
during the subsistence of the first marriage. Rather, the OM dated 20.10.2023
permits the disciplinary authority to initiate departmental proceedings under the
provisions of the Rules of 1964 for imposition of major penalty including
compulsory retirement against those Government servants who were found to
have violated Rule 26 of the Assam Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1965. What
is equally necessary to note is that there is competent Court which had directed
payment for maintenance to the first wife and which the petitioner claims to
have been paid in terms of such orders of the Court. There is no averment in
Page No.# 13/13
the affidavit filed by the respondent disputing the same. There is also no
discussion in the impugned order of the dismissal passed by the respondent
authority and also by the appellate authority as to the consequences that may
follow in the event of the petitioner being dismissed from service and as to how
the Court's order can be complied by the petitioner in the event he does not
receive any salary or pension. Under such circumstances this Court is of the
considered view that the imposition of punishment or dismissal from service of
the petitioner requires interference and therefore, the matter is remanded back
to the concerned authority for imposition of any other major penalty other than
dismissal from service keeping in view the order passed by the competent Court
towards payment of maintenance to the first wife namely Jesmina Ahmed and
which the petitioner claims that he has been making such payments regularly.
The respondent authority will examine this matter and pass appropriate orders
within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this
order.
18] This writ petition accordingly stands allowed to the extent indicated above.
19] Pending interlocutory application, if any, is also disposed of.
20] Interim order, if any, stands merged.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review