Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC040012472024
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/423/2024
Ciachin Mai and 15 Ors
resident of Village Taflagam, Chaglagam, Anjaw District, Arunachal Pradesh.
Mapikam Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tegamma
Chaglogam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Nihali Mai
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Taflagam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Jaflolum Mai
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Taflagam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Rathalum Mai
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Taflagam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
2:
Page No.# 2/11
6: Duhilum Taflap
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Taflagam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Smti Jaijusai Taflap
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Taflagam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8: Beglelum Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Katemaro
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
9: Kinamso Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tegamma
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
10: Smti Kimilu Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tegamma
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
11: Maku Taflap
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Taflagam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 3/11
12: Gorotho Tabronyu
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Abhugam
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
13: Sonamso Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tegamma
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
14: Smti Gohiya Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tegamma
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
15: Smti Palisai Tega
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tegamma
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh.
16: Sinsolum Awailiang
Age:
Occupation :
resident of Village Tablaiko
Chaglagam
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The State of AP and 4 ors
represented by the Commissioner, Land Management Department, Govt of Arunachal
Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Page No.# 4/11
Anjaw District
Hawai
Arunachal Pradesh.
3:The Union of India
Age: 0
Occupation :
represented by the Secretary
Ministry of Defence
Room No.234
South block
New Delhi- 1
4:The Director General
Age: 0
Occupation :
Border Roads Organization
Master Banwar
Lal Tanwar Road
New Delhi 10
5:The Commanding Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
116 RCC (GREF) 116 Road Const. Coy (GREF) Pin 930116
C/o 99 APO
Hayuliang
Anjaw District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: H K Jamoh, Tony Pertin,Eddie Payeng
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), DSGI,Marto Kato
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
ORDER
Date : 10.06.2026
Heard Mr. T. Pertin, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. N.
Ratan, learned Addl. AG for the respondent nos. 1 and 2, and Mr. M. Kato,
Page No.# 5/11
learned DSGI for respondent nos. 3, 4 and 5.
Case of the petitioners:
2)
In brief, the case of the petitioners is as follows: a.
That for the construction of the proposed defence road from
Chaglogam to Kapapu was undertaken in two separate packages. One
package was for the area from 0.00 km to 6.5 km, referred to as
Package-1 to Rocham point. The second package was from 6.5 km to
16 km, referred to as Package-2. The subject matter of this writ
petition is regarding assessment of compensation of land of the
petitioners, falling within Package-1 (i.e. 0,00 km to 6.5km), that were
acquired by the Government of Arunachal Pradesh under the provisions
of Section 10 of the Balipara/Tirap/ Sadiya Frontier Track Jhum Land
Regulation, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as 1947 Regulation for
brevity).
b.
Vide order dated 24.12.2018, a Three-Member Board was
constituted for valuing the land including horticultural crops standing
thereon, which was being acquired. The said Committee, by its Joint
Survey and Property Assessment Report/ Board Proceeding dated
06.03.2020, highlighted its opinion to the effect that horticulture fields
of 186 (one hundred eighty six) beneficiaries were newly created for
claiming compensation and estimated bills for Rs.2.14 Crore in respect
of such beneficiaries was separately enclosed and (a) as per the details
of valuation as per data collected from the field in department wise
including new cultivation was assessed at Rs.35,94,01,935/- (Rupees
Thirty five crore ninety four lakh one thousand nine hundred thirty five
Page No.# 6/11
only); and (b) as per the details of valuation as per data collected from
the field in department wise excluding new cultivation was assessed at
Rs.33,79,36,210/- (Rupees Thirty three crore seventy nine lakh thirty
six thousand two hundred ten only).
c.
Thereafter, a public notice dated 26.10.2020, was issued by the
Addl.
Deputy
Commissioner,
Hayuliang,
Anjaw
District,
fixing
03.11.2020, at 10.00 am as date and time fixed for scrutinizing claims
and objections in connection with the said Road Package-1.
d.
The petitioners have not disclosed in this writ petition as to whether
or not the compensation, as assessed by the competent authorities
pursuant to public hearing called on 26.10.2020 were disbursed to the
affected persons.
e.
It is projected that the rate of cardamom plants were fixed by the
Government at Rs.2,000/- per clump/plant and therefore, as the
authorities had previously calculated and paid compensation for
cardamom plant at the rate of Rs.900/- per clump/plant, the Circle
Officer, For Additional Deputy Commissioner, Anjaw District, Hayuliang,
forwarded a Rectified Joint Verification Report dated 14.09.2022, to the
Deputy Commissioner, Anjaw District, amongst others, on account of
left out cardamom clumps/ plants, civil structure items and land value,
amounting to Rs.50,21,463/- (Rupees Fifty lakh twenty one thousand
four hundred sixty three only). Accordingly, the Deputy Commissioner,
Anjaw District, vide letter dated 01.11.2023, submitted a bill for a sum
of Rs.50,21,463/- (Rupees Fifty lakh twenty one thousand four
hundred sixty three only) to the Officer Commanding, 116 Road
Page No.# 7/11
Construction Company, GREF, Hayuliang.
f.
As left out compensation was not paid, the petitioners had
submitted a joint representation dated 13.08.2024 before the Deputy
Commissioner, Anjaw District.
g.
As the left-out compensation was not paid, the present writ petition
was filed.
Submissions by the learned counsel for the petitioners:
3)
The learned counsel for the petitioner had submitted that the
petitioners had come to learn from the orders passed by this Court in (i) W.P.(C)
No. 175(AP)/2022- Manakso Taflap & Ors. V. State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors .,
(ii) W.A. No. 24/2022 – State of Arunachal Pradesh v. Manakso Taflap & Ors ., as
well as (iii) from order passed by the Supreme Court of India in S.L.P. No.
4873/2023, that to some other land affected persons, the respondents had paid
value of cardamom clumps/ plants at the rate of Rs.2,000/- for fruit bearing
plants and Rs.1,000/- for non-fruit bearing plants.
4)
It was submitted that neither the petitioners were privy to the
calculation of compensation by the authorities and nor the representatives of
the land affected families were made a part of such determination. Moreover, it
was submitted that solatium of amount equal to compensation and interest as
per the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred to as 2013 Act
for brevity). Therefore, only on coming to know that the petitioners were
unfairly deprived of fair compensation, they have filed this writ petition as the
actions on part of the respondent authorities were arbitrary and discriminatory
Page No.# 8/11
and therefore, illegal.
5)
It was submitted that the learned Addl. A.G. may take a plea
that the petitioners had accepted compensation amount without any protest and
owing to judgment passed by the Supreme Court of India, in Civil Appeal Nos.
11884-11888 of 2025 [arising out of S.L.P.(C) Nos. 9585-9589 of 2023] – The
State of Arunachal Pradesh & Anr. v. Mihin Laling & Ors., decided on 16.09.2025 ,
the petitioners would not be entitled to any relief. In the said context, it was
submitted that the order of the Supreme Court of India was passed on
16.09.2025, but the representation of the petitioner was submitted on
13.08.2024, which was pending and not disposed of and therefore, as the issue
was pending, the petitioners cannot be deprived of fair compensation.
Stand of the State respondents:
6)
The learned Addl. Advocate General for the State had submitted
that the land of the petitioners was acquired in the year 2017 under the 1947
Regulation, where there was no provision for solatium and interest and not
under 2013 Act. It was submitted that vide notification dated 26.11.2011, the
rates of big cardamom clumps/ plants between 8 to 25 years was fixed at
Rs.120/- each, but no rate was fixed for cardamom plants of under 8 years in
respect of Anjaw District and therefore, the Board, in its proceeding dated
08.03.2021, fixed the rate of large cardamon plant of less than 8 years as
hereinafter provided, viz., (i) rate per sucker/seedling – Rs.15/-; (ii) 12 suckers
per clump upto one year @ Rs.15/- = Rs.160/-; (iii) 24 suckers per clump in 2 nd
year @ Rs.15/- = Rs.360/-; (iv) 36 suckers per clump in 3 rd year @ Rs.15/- =
Rs.540/-; and (v) 60 suckers per clump in between 4 years and above @
Rs.15/- = Rs.900/-. Therefore, it was submitted that the rate of fruit bearing
Page No.# 9/11
large cardamom clump/plant at Rs.2,000/- and rate of Rs.1,000/- for non-fruit
bearing large cardamon clumps/ plants was not applicable for Anjaw District.
7)
It was submitted that the Supreme Court of India, in the case
of Mihin Laling & Ors. (supra), had held in paragraph 28 that in respect of
concluded acquisitions where compensation has been finally determined,
accepted and disbursed, no reopening shall be permissible. Accordingly, it was
submitted that the re-assessment of the compensation cannot be opened now.
8)
No submission was made by the learned DSGI.
9)
Perused the writ petition, affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
respondent no.2 and reply affidavit filed by the petitioners.
10)
It is seen that the Supreme Court of India, in the case of Mihin
Laling & Ors. (supra), had affirmed the approach of this Court that reasonable
compensation under Section 10 of 1947 Act must be harmonised with the
prevailing legislative standards of the time and solatium and interest were
integral components of fairness. However, in paragraph 28 it was ordered that in
respect of concluded acquisitions where compensation has been finally
determined, accepted and disbursed, no reopening shall be permissible.
11)
Thus, there is a clear mandate of the law laid down by the
Supreme Court of India in the case of Mihin Laling & Ors. (supra) , that the reassessment of the compensation cannot be opened after the concluded
acquisitions where compensation has been finally determined, accepted and
disbursed.
12)
In this case, the petitioners have not stated anywhere in the writ
petition as to the date when they had been paid the land acquisition
Page No.# 10/11
compensation and therefore, the petitioners are found to have suppressed
relevant material facts from this Court and therefore, the petitioners have not
approached this Court with clean hands.
13)
It appears from the copy of order dated 15.05.2024, passed by
the Supreme Court of India in the case of SLP(C) No. 4873/2023 - State of
Arunachal Pradesh v. Manakso Taflap & Ors. (supra) that the amount payable to
the land losers shall be deposited within a period of six weeks from the date of
the order and shall be disbursed within four weeks thereafter. Thus, in all
probability, the compensation is presumed to have been disbursed to the
petitioners before they had submitted their representation dated 13.08.2024, on
which date the petitioners had submitted their representation for re-visiting
assessment of compensation. The compensation was received and accepted by
the petitioners without any demur.
14)
Thus, it is not disputed at the Bar that only after receiving the
payment of compensation, the petitioners had submitted their representation on
13.08.2024, referred hereinbefore. The present writ petition has been filed
claiming re-calculating compensation on account of value of big cardamom
clumps/plaints; 100% solatium; and interest on compensation.
15)
Therefore, in light of the directions contained in paragraph 28 of
the order dated 16.09.2025, passed by the Supreme Court of India in the case
of Mihin Laling & Ors. (supra) , as in this case, the computation/ determination
of
land
acquisition
compensation
acceptance
of
compensation;
and
disbursement of compensation amount had all already happened prior to the
passing of the order dated 16.09.2025, passed by the Supreme Court of India in
the case of Mihin Laling & Ors. (supra) , this Court would be bound by the said
Page No.# 11/11
order dated 16.09.2025, whereby it was clearly laid down that the reassessment of the compensation cannot be opened after the concluded
acquisitions where compensation has been finally determined, accepted and
disbursed.
16)
In the present case in hand, no issue relating to acquisition,
acceptance and disbursement of compensation was pending before any
authority and thus, those issues were already brought to its logical conclusion.
It is the admitted case of the petitioners that only after they became aware of
judicial determinations, where higher value was computed for cardamon
clumps/ plants that the petitioners had submitted representation dated
13.08.2024.
17)
It may be mentioned that in this regard, the Court finds support
from the order dated 19.11.2025, passed by a co-ordinate Bench of this Court in
the case of W.P.(C) 475(AP)/2022- Neelam Sanjoy v. The State of Arunachal
Pradesh & Ors.
18)
As a result of the discussions above, this writ petition fails and
the same is dismissed on merit as well as the ground of suppression of material
fact referred to hereinbefore.
19)
Under the circumstances, the parties are left to bear their own
cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review