Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:70-DB
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3rd JUNE, 2016
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------D.B. : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH KUMAR AGNIHOTRI, JUDGE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.A. No.25 of 2015
Appellant
:
Chuden Tamang,
Aged about 29 years,
S/o Bhim Bahadur Tamang,
R/O Pakshep Mangan,
North Sikkim.
[Presently in Central Prison,
Rongyek, East Sikkim]
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Appeal under Section 374(2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. B. K. Gupta, Advocate (Legal Aid Counsel) for the Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Additional Public Prosecutor with
Mr. S. K. Chettri and Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Public Prosecutors
for the State-Respondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
The following Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
1.
State of Sikkim
Aggrieved by the Judgment and Order on Sentence of
the Learned Sessions Judge, North Sikkim, at Mangan, dated 28-082014, in S.T. Case No.01 of 2013, convicting the Appellant under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”), and
sentencing him to undergo rigorous imprisonment and to pay a fine
of Rs.2,000/- (Rupees two thousand) only, the instant Appeal has
been preferred.
2.
While assailing the impugned Judgment and Order on
Sentence, it was contended by Learned Counsel for the Appellant
that, the Learned Trial Court failed to appreciate that as per the
evidence of P.W.2, the Appellant had slit the throat of the deceased,
to the contrary in the Autopsy Report, Exhibit 8, does not reveal this
aspect.
The FIR, Exhibit 2, does not disclose the name of the
Appellant and that evidence of P.Ws 2, 3 and 4 allegedly eyewitnesses, do not corroborate. It was urged that no finger prints
were lifted from M.O.IV, the alleged weapon of offence, to
substantiate that it was the Appellant who had used it for
committing the offence. That, for want of sufficiency of evidence,
the benefit of doubt ought to be extended to the Appellant hence the
impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence be set aside.
3.
Repudiating the stance of the Appellant, it was
submitted by Learned Additional Public Prosecutor that P.Ws 2, 3
and 4, the ocular witnesses to the offence have corroborated each
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
State of Sikkim
other’s evidence. Laying stress on the evidence of P.W.19, the CFSL
Expert, he contends that on examination of the blood sample of the
deceased, M.O.II, for blood grouping the sample was found to be of
the Blood Group ‘A’ thereby establishing the Blood Group of the
deceased. Blood Group ‘A’ was detected in Exhibit ‘C’ (M.O.IV) the
weapon of offence used by the Appellant to murder the victim. The
clothes of the victim M.O. VIII, M.O.IX and M.O.X also contained
blood of the Group ‘A’ confirming the fact that her Blood Group was
‘A’. The same blood was found not only on the weapon of offence
M.O.IV but also on the wearing apparels of the Appellant, being
M.O.V and M.O.VI, the Jeans and T-shirt worn by him at the time of
the incident, leading to the inevitable conclusion that the Appellant
had committed the offence. Hence, the impugned Judgment and
Order on Sentence brooks no interference.
4.
We have carefully considered the rival contentions
raised by Learned Counsel before this Court and have also carefully
perused the entire evidence and documents on record, including the
impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence.
What falls for
determination by this Court is whether the Appellant committed the
offence under Section 300 of the IPC, punishable under Section 302
of the IPC.
5.
In order to reach a finding on this aspect, it is necessary
to briefly state the Prosecution case, which is that P.W.1 Gazam
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
State of Sikkim
Lepcha, Panchayat Member of Kazor Ward, Mangan GPU, received
telephonic information from Yankee Lepcha, wife of P.W.10, on 1711-2002 at around 4.30 p.m., instructing her to verify as to whether
some person was being killed in her house. P.W.1 lived about 5/6
steps away from the house of Yankee Lepcha and accordingly went
to the place of occurrence (for short “P.O.”). Once at the P.O, she
found a familiar lady lying in a pool of blood, in the kitchen of
Yankee Lepcha’s house. While coming out from the P.O. she saw the
Appellant sitting near the shop of P.W.2, with his hand wrapped in a
piece of blood soaked cloth. Accordingly, at 5.10 p.m., she lodged a
written FIR, Exhibit 2, which was registered and taken up for
investigation.
6.
Investigation revealed that the Appellant on the same
afternoon, at around 1530 hours, saw the victim his wife, near
Pakshep View Point, coming with an unidentified person, who on
seeing the Appellant reportedly retracted his steps. This aspect,
however, could not be established by investigation. The Appellant
tried to persuade his wife to return to him, which she evidently
refused. The Appellant in a fit of rage picked M.O. IV from the
Butcher’s Shop belonging to P.W.4 and attacked his wife on her neck
in front of the “Pan Shop” of P.W.2. To protect herself the victim
ran into the kitchen of P.W.10 where the Appellant followed and
assaulted her, several times with M.O.IV, inflicting multiple incised
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
State of Sikkim
injuries on her head and upper limbs as a result of which she died in
a pool of blood at the P.O. The incident was witnessed by P.W.3 and
P.W.4 who by then had reached the P.O. on hearing the commotion.
P.W.3 pulled the Appellant out of the kitchen and dragged him to the
road side.
On completion of investigation, Charge-sheet was
accordingly filed under Section 302 of the IPC against the Appellant.
The Material Objects (MO’s) were forwarded to CFSL, Kolkata, for
examination
and
opinion
and
supplementary
Charge-sheet
submitted on its receipt.
7.
The Learned Trial Court after hearing the submissions
advanced by Learned Counsel for the opposing parties found prima
facie material to frame charge under Section 302 of the IPC to which
the Appellant pleaded “not guilty” and claimed trial.
The
Prosecution thereafter furnished nineteen witnesses.
After
considering and analysing the evidence, the Learned Trial Court
convicted the Appellant as detailed hereinabove.
8.
While carefully considering the evidence on record, it is
clear that P.W.1 on receiving information of the incident from the
wife of P.W.10 immediately went to the P.O. and thereafter lodged
the FIR. The lodging of the FIR is duly supported by the evidence of
P.W.18, the I.O. of the case, who submitted that P.W.1 lodged the FIR
around 5.10. p.m. P.W.2, is the first witness to the offence and
according to her, when the victim had come to her shop at around 4
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
State of Sikkim
p.m. on the same day and was enquiring from her about the price of
socks, the Appellant came and slit the throat of the victim. It is the
case of Learned Counsel for the Appellant that this witness had
admitted that she did not see any knife with the Appellant but still
she witnessed the Appellant slitting the throat of the deceased
which appears to be improbable. While giving this argument due
consideration and even if one is inclined to disregard the evidence of
P.W.2, in view of Exhibit 8 which does not list any cut injury on the
throat of the victim, there is no doubt that P.W.3 and P.W.4
witnessed the incident in the kitchen of the house of P.W.10. P.W.3
has testified that at the relevant time he saw some people running
towards the road and shouting, he followed them to verify the
reason. When he reached the Pan Shop of P.W.2, he was informed by
her that the Appellant had murdered his wife in the kitchen of the
house of P.W.10. On looking downwards, he saw that the door of the
said kitchen was open and the Appellant with blood stained hands
was emerging from the kitchen and again trying to re-enter the
same place. P.W.3 went towards the kitchen where he saw the dead
body of the victim lying on the floor. He rebuked the Appellant
telling him he ought not to have committed the offence to which the
Appellant responded by saying that he would not allow the deceased
to belong to anyone else as she could not belong to him either.
Saying so, he lifted the knife and in the presence of P.W.3 once again
assaulted the deceased with the knife, on her head. The knife, i.e.,
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
State of Sikkim
the weapon of offence was identified by P.W.3 as “M.O.IV”, which fell
off the hand of the Appellant when P.W.3 was dragging him out of
the P.O.
9.
The evidence of P.W.4 substantiates and supports the
evidence of P.W.3 since he too arrived at the P.O. where he saw the
Appellant chopping the deceased, using M.O.IV. According to him,
although he tried to intervene and pull the Appellant from the
scene, he was unsuccessful. Despite incisive cross-examination of
P.W.3 and P.W.4 by Learned Counsel for the Appellant before the
Learned Trial Court with regard to the identity of M.O.IV, both the
witnesses stood unwaveringly by their statements. The seizure of
M.O.IV by the Police was witnessed by P.W.4 in the presence of
P.W.6, who also identified M.O.IV as the same dagger seized by the
Police on the relevant day from the P.O. Apart from seizure of
M.O.IV, P.W.6 and P.W.1 also witnessed the seizure of M.O.I, the hair
strands of the deceased; M.O.II, the blood sample of the deceased
lifted by the Police from the kitchen of the house of P.W.10; M.O.III,
broken pieces of blood stained glass bangles of the deceased and
M.O.VII the amputated middle finger of the left hand of the
deceased. The fact of seizure of M.O.V, blue jeans pant and M.O.VI,
red coloured T-shirt, worn by the Appellant is vouched by the
evidence of P.Ws 5 and 8 and P.W.15 in whose presence the seizures
were made by the Police. Although P.Ws 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, the
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
State of Sikkim
villagers of the area did not witness the incident, nevertheless they
reached the P.O. after the incident had occurred. With the exception
of P.W.7, the others had seen the body of the deceased at the P.O.
and had also seen the Appellant at the P.O., thereby lending
credence to the Prosecution case.
10.
Having said that, it is not necessary to delve in detail
into the evidence of P.W.13, Dr. O.T. Lepcha who conducted the
Autopsy of the deceased and prepared Exhibit 8, the Autopsy Report.
Suffice it to say that he has opined that “the cause of death to the
best of his knowledge and belief was due to multiple homicidal
chopped wounds of severe nature”. The evidence of this Doctor also
supports the Prosecution case.
P.W.14 was the Consultant
Psychiatrist who examined the Appellant but found him to be of
sound mind. In consideration of this evidence, the Appellant cannot
claim the benefit of Section 84 of the IPC, which argument to be fair,
was not even put forth by Learned Counsel for the Appellant.
It
may be recorded here that the offence committed by the Appellant
does not fall within the ambit of the Exceptions to Section 300 of the
IPC. The evidence of P.W.19 on pain of repetition, points to the fact
that the wearing apparels of the Appellant, being M.O.V and M.O.VI,
contained blood of the Blood Group ‘A’, which has been established
to be the Blood Group of the deceased, thereby clinching the
Prosecution case.
2016:SHC:70-DB
Crl.A No.25 of 2015
Chuden Tamang vs.
11.
State of Sikkim
In the end result, we are of the considered opinion that
the Prosecution evidence put forth is clear, cogent, trustworthy and
inspires the confidence of this Court proving beyond a reasonable
doubt that the Appellant had committed the murder of his wife.
12.
Consequently, the impugned Judgment and Order on
Sentence passed by the Learned Sessions Judge calls for no
interference by this Court.
13.
The Appeal stands dismissed.
14.
No order as to costs.
15.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial
Court.
16.
Records of the Court below be remitted forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
03-06-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
( Satish Kumar Agnihotri )
Judge
03-06-2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review