Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3448 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3636 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the
order dated 06-10-2023 passed in lA.No. 274 o'f 2023 in A.S.No. 24 of 202'1 on the
file of the Court of the Principal District Judge, Peddapalli.
Between:
Choppari Anjaiah, S/o Rajaiah, Aged about 48 years, Occ: Agriculture, Rl/o H.no
2-238, Suthanabad Village and Mandal, Karimangar Diskicl.
...PETITIONER/PETITION ER/APPELLANT/PLAINTIFFS
AND
1. Vusthem Veeresham, S/o Rajaiah, (Aged about 48 years, Occ: Agriculture,
Rl/o Poosala Village, Sulthanabad Mandal, Peddapally District.
2. Vusthem Kanakamma, Wo Veeresham (died)
3. Vusthem Ganesh, S/o Kailasam, Aged about 32 years, Occ: Agriculture, Rl/o
Poosala Village, Sulthanabad [Vlandal, Peddapally District.
4. Ivlallojula Shankara Saharma, S/o Late Rajalingaiah, aged 47 years, Ryo
H.No.2-4-72, Brahmana Veedi, Peddapalli Village and Mandal.
5. Kundojula @ Ivlallojula Shyamala Bai, W/o Late Manohar Rao, aged 70 years,
R/o H.No. 1-4-127, Brahmanaveedhi, Karimnagar Town and District.
6. Vusthem Anjaiah, S/o Veeresham, Aged 35 years, Occ: Auto Owner, R/o
Poosala Village, Sulthanabad Mandal, Peddapally District.
7. Vusthem Raju, S/o Veeresham, Aged about 30 years, Occ: Auto Owner, Ryo
Poosala Village, Sulthanabad tvlandal, Peddapally District.
(Note: Respondents 3 to 5 are not necessary parties to this petition)
...RESPONDENTS/ RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS
lA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including hearing of Appeal in AS.No. 24 of 2021 on the file
of the Principal District Judge at Peddapalli, pending c sposal of the CRP No
of 2023 filed by the Petitioners in the interest of juslice.
Counsel for the Petitioners: Sri. Y Rama Rao and Asso( ates
I
I
:
I
t
t
)
i
l
Counsel for the Respondents 6 and 7: Sri. M/s T.p. Ach; rya
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
t
t
,
t
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B.R. MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIvIL REVISIoN PETITIoN No.3536 of 2023
DATED THE 23Td DAY OF JANUARY,2026
Between:
Choppari Anjaiah, S / o. Rajaiah
. Petitioner-petitioner-appellant
And
Vusthem Veeresham, S/o.Rajaiah and six others
Respondents-respondents
ORDER:
1.
This Memorandum of Civil Revision Petition is frled under
ArLicle 227 of the Constitution of India assailing the order dated
06.1O.2023 passedinl.A.No.274 of 2023 inA.S.No.24 of 2O2Ibyt-ne
learned Principal District Judge, Peddapalli.
2.
Petitioner is the petitioner-appellant and respondents are lhe
respondents in I.A
3.1 Petitioner has filed petition (1.A.No.274 of 2023) under Rule
129 of Civil Rutes of Practice to call for the documents i.e', original
plaint and vakalathnama o[ Mr.Vusthem Veeresham - plaintiff in
O.S.No.44 of 2OO5 on the file of the learned Junior Civil Judge,
Sulthanabad to the learned Principal District Judge, Peddapalli for
comparison of the signatures of Ex.A-1 in O.S.No.43 of 2012 on Lh.e
file of learned Senior Civil Judge, Peddapalli, for the purpose of
sending t{e same to handwriting expert opinion to Governmcnt
CFSL, HYderabad.
\
BRMR,J
CRP.No.3636 of 2023
3.2 It is stated in the afhdavi t that
appeai vide A.S.No.24 of
against the judgment and
the petitio::rr has preferred
2O2I before the lear: :d appeilate
decree in O.S.No.43 oI :Ol2passed
learned Senior Civil Judge, peddapa
No.
plaintiff has not taken steps
to send the docume I s for
signatures of defendant No.
signatures in O.S.No.43
45 of Indian Evidcn<:, Act
i.e., originai plaint and vakalathnama
Judge, Sulthanabad and
[r
in
Judge,
counter and cor_r t nded that
to file the petition to call
of
call for original
file of the learned .Jur or Civil
Respondents have filed
plaintiff in O.S.No.44 of
to send the
of Vusthem Veercsl ,rm _ plaintiff
Sulthanabad.
petitioners have no right
dated
1 (DW_2) on Ex.A_ 1 f r comparison
plaint copy and vakalathnama
4.
handwriting
r e16ls1 XLi Rule
ot 2Ol2.Therefore, prayed .r
O.S.No.44 of 2005 on the
observed in
on Ex.A-l (agreer ent of sale
has aiso hled petition unclr
27 (b) of C.p.C r/w Section
bv the
l0 of its judgmenr r :at the petitioner_
expert regarding the signatures
07.O7.2OO4l. petitioner
Court
i.
3.3 The learned Senior Civil Judge, pedd,r:alli
paragraph No 13 in page
an
the
I the documents
of Vusthe: Veeresham _
2005 on the fiie of the learr
prayed to dismiss the petitio
r:d Junior Civil
BRMR,J
CRP.No.3636 of 2023
5.
!
The learned trial Court after going through the material on
record has dismissed the said I.A. on 06.1O.2023, which is impugned
g
&
in the present C.R.P.
&
r
t
6.
f'
!
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned
trial court has dismissed the petition without going into the materiai
r
9.
&
&
on record. Petitioner has fi1ed 1.A.No.274 of 2023 under Rule 129 of
&
Civil Rules of Practicc by wrongly quoting the provision. In fact, Rule
x
x
n
&
:
128 of Civil Rules of Practice deals with production of record in the
II
custody of the Court. The suit is filed by the petitioner for specific
I
t1
performance of agreement of sale and for declaration of registered
I
I
I
I
I
documents to be declared as null and void. The order passed by the
learned trial Court is erroneous and it is apparent on the face of the
record. Counsel relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in the
case of Sanjay Kumar Singh v. State ofJharkhandr.
7.
The present CRP came to be dismissed for default on
23.02.2024 and the same was restored as per the orders passed by
this Court in l.A.No.O3 of 2024 on t7 .O9.2O25
8.
After restoration of the CRp notices were issued to the
respondents. Notice got issued to respondent No.l is returned as
expired and learned counsel for Lhe petitioner submitted that
respondent No.2 also expired ald her 1ega1 heirs are respondent
't
Qo2>t 7 scc 242
BRMR,J
CRP No.3636 of 2023
Nos.6 and 7. Respondent Nos.l and 2 are husbr.r d and wife ald
their legal heirs are respondent Nos.6 and 7. NotLr,:s got issued to
respondent Nos.6 and 7 are aiso served as per thc tr. rck consignment
after its restoration. Learned counsel for the 1; rtitioner further
submits that respondent Nos.3 to 5 are not necess. v parties to the
present CRP.
9.
Heard learned counsel on record and perused I .re material
10. Now the point for consideration is: Whether t '.e order passed
by the learned trial Court suffers from any perversr ,, or illegality, if
so, does it requires interference of this Court?
POINT:
11. Learned counsel for the petitioner during the course of
arguments contended that he is not pressing the r r ief to send the
documents to handwriting expert,s opinion to Gor
NrnCNI CFSL,
Hyderabad in view of the fact that the petitioner 1r rs already filed
I.A.No.378 of 2023 in A.S.No.24 of 2O2l under Order xLI Rule 27 (b)
of C.P.C r/r.r, Section 45 of Indian Evidence Ac to send the
signatures of defendant No.l therein on Ex.A_ 1 1br comparison of
signatures in O.S.No.43 of 2Ot2, which came to bt: rrllowed by the
learned appellate Court on 06.12.2023.
12. CRP is only to the extent of calling the docur rents from the
concerned Qourt
.t
\
BRMR,J
CRP.No.3636 of 2o23
lS.Petitionerhasfrledsuitvideo.S.No.43of2o|2underorderVII
Rule 1 r/w Section 26 of C.P.C. against the defendants (respondents
herein) for specifrc performance of contract in respect of agreement of
sale dated 07.07.2024 and also prayed for declaration to cancei the
registered documents bearing Nos.3589 of 2O)'l and 3590 of 2Oll'
both dated 28.12.2011 as null and void and not binding on the
petitioner-plaintiff, which were registered by defendant No' 1 therein
through his vendors defendant Nos'4 and 5 in favour of defendant
No.2 therein
14. Respondents have contested thc suit (O S'No'43 of 2Ol2\ and
the learned trial Court has dismissed the same vide judgment and
decree dated 18.04.2O 18.
15. It is observed in the judgmcnt and decree in O S No'43 of 2OI2
dated 18.04.2018 at paragraph No'13, which rcads as under:
*When the Defendant No.t has been claiming that he
did not execute trx.A- 1 (i.e., Agreement of sale dated
07.O7.2OO4l. The plaintiff ought to have irled the
application lor opinion of handu'riLing expert regarding
the signature in Ex.A1."
16. Petitioner has fi1ed appeal against the above said judgment
anddecreevideA.S.No.24of2o2landitisoneofthegroundsinthe
appeal that he is hling applications to send the signatures of
defendant No.1 on Ex.A-1 for comparison to do substaltial justice
\\
between the Parti&''-
\
BRMR,J
lRP.No.3636 of 2023
-
17. The learned appellate Court while dismissi: .t, I.A,.No.2T4 of
2023 on 06.10.2023 has also referred to the sarr t but uitimately
came to the conclusion that petitioner has not ma:.) out any case.
Expert opinion application filed by the petitioner car e to be allowed
on 06.72.2023. The order impugned in the CRp is cl: I ,:d 06.10.2023.
18. Learned trial Court has misread the materia placed by the
petitioner and wrongly arrived at a conclusion that t.t petitioner was
not diligent in prosecuting the case at the right time rhe documents
called for in I.A.No.274 ol 2023 are material docurc :nts for proper
adjudication of the appeal.
L9. Sanjay Kumar Singhl deals with under Order :(LI Rule 27 of
CPC, the order impugned in the C.R.p. is to call Jc . the plaint in
O.S-No.44 of 2OO5 ald vakalathnama of Mr.V. Veere s [ram. Thc ratio
of the abovc case would not apply to the case on halrl
2O.l The application filed by the petitioner in I.A.N,I 328 ol 2023 is
already allowed, wherein the learned appellate Court ras clirected to
send [he admitted signatures of respondent No.1-MI V. Vceresham
with that of trx.A- 1
.
2O.2 Corning to the case on hand the reasoning I the learned
appellate Court on the face of it is appear to be pr:: ,zerse and the
.a'
i
BRMR,J
CRP.No.3636 of 2023
petitioner has made out a case to interfere with the orders passed
[here on.
2L. In view of the reasons abovc, this Civil Revision Petitions is
partly allowed only to the extent of calling for the documents i.e.,
original plaint copy and vakalathnama of Vusthem Veeresham plaintiff in O.S.No.44 of 2005 on the hle of the learned Junior Civil
Judge, Sulthalabad. Rest of the claim is not pressed as indicated in
the order. There sha1l be no order as to costs.
Interim order/s if any sha1.l stand vacated. Miscellaneous
petition/ s shall stand closed.
sd/- s. MALLIKARJUNA RAO
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
6SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal District Judge, Peddapalli
2. The Junior Civil Judge, Sultanabad'
3. One CC to SRl. Y Rama Rao and Associates' Advocate [OPUC]
4. one CC to Sri. M/s T.P. Acharya, Advocate IOPUC]
5. Two CD CoPies
pr
,/
HIGH COURT
DATED:2310112026
:l\.\
,-; t ._t
ORDER
CRP.No.3636 of 2023
o
t(
PARTLY ALLOWING THE CRP
)0
a
\9
I tt8
O
\
I
I
.1
^Ji
,:i.')i.
t'^'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review