The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. 12.2018. From the evidence of MVI it appears that the aforesaid commender jeep vehicle had valid fitness and permit on the date of accident, i.e., on 16.06.2016 and his evidence gets corroborated by Exhibit-C/1, the vehicle history report. From the compared copy of driving license it appears that the driver Kamal Karmakar, i.e., the OP No.2 was authorized to drive LMV/NT, LMV/CAB types of vehicle and his driving license was issued on 17.08.2009 with validity up-to 19.08.2020 for Transport and 16.08.2029 for Non Transport vehicles. [22] Thus; it is held that the aforesaid Commander Jeep was having requisites fitness, permit on the date of accident and was also being driven by OP No.2 with valid driving license, so the liability to pay compensation for the death of the deceased Brajendra Jamatia, is shifted upon the insurer i.e. OP No.3. Thus, the Issue No.(2) was thus also decided partly in favour of the claimant-petitioners. [23] Finally, the tribunal by the order dated 17.06.2019 has observed in the following manner: “The instant application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 filed by the claimant-petitioners is hereby partly allowed and a sum of Rs. 6,75,000.00(Rupees Six Lakh Seventy Five thousand) only along with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of claim-petition, i.e., from
12. 04.2017 till the date of payment, is awarded in favour of claimant – petitioners in equal shares, as compensation for the death of their father late Brajendra Jamatia, in a Road Traffic Accident, as aforesaid, and this amount of compensation shall be paid by OP No.3, the insurer of vehicle bearing No.TR-01-2323(Commander Jeep), within a period of one month. In the event of deposit of Awarded amount with interest, 70% from the shares of each of the claimants shall be kept in a fixed deposit schemes in a Nationalized Bank for five years and the remaining 30% amount of the respective shares shall be released in favour of the claim-petitioners in their bank accounts for enabling them to meet necessary expenses. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted in the fixed deposit account nor joint name shall be allowed nor any cheque book, ATM card can be issued against fixed deposit account. However the interest to be credited in the fixed deposit may be released in favour of the claim-petitioners as per Bank's norms.” [24] Aggrieved by the said order dated 17.06.2019, the appellant insurance company has preferred this instant appeal before this court. [25] Heard. [26] Mr. R. Saha, counsel for the insurance-company has mainly argued on two points (1) loss of estate granted by court below Rs.1,20,000/- which according to him is excessive. He further submitted before this court that as per …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App 34 of 2020
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Ltd.
Repressented by its Authorized Signatory,
1st Floor, Abovw W Showroom, Mantribari Road,
Old RMS Chowmuhani, P.S. West Tripura,
District West Tripura
(Insurer of Vehicle bearing Registration TR-01-2323, Commander Jeep)
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Bhudda Kumar Jamatia
S/o. Late Brajendra Jamatia of Sourth Rani (ADC), Udaipur,
PS- Kakraban, District- Gomati Tripura.
2. Sri Hiranya Jamatia
S/o. Late Brajendra Jamatia of South Rani (ADC), Udaipur,
PS- Kakraban, Dist - Gomati Tripura.
3. Smti. Chandrabali Noatia,
W/o. Kshirod Noatia of Ranga Chandra Para, Garjee, Udaipur,
PS- Kakraban, District - Gomati Tripura.
4. Smti. Dhanapati Noatia,
W/o. Laxmi Kumar Noatia of North Taihandal, Melaghar,
PS- Kakraban, District- Gomati Tripura.
5. Smti. Chandra Laxmi Murashing,
W/o. Sri. Ramkrishna Murashing of Sourth Rani (ADC), Udaipur,
PS -Kakraban, District- Gomati Tripura.
6. Smti. Manmohini Murashing,
W/o. Krishnagopal Murashing of Sourth Rani (ADC), Udaipur,
PS- Kakraban, District-Gomati Tripura.
----Claimant Respondent
7. Shri Rajib Ghosh,
S/o. Late Rakhal Ghosh of Kushamara, Udaipur, PS- Kakraban,
District-Gomati Tripura,
(Owner of the vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-01-2323, Commander
Jeep)
---Owner Respondent
8. Sri Kamal Karmakar,
S/o. Sri Jitendra Karmamar,
At present of Surendra Nagar,
(Near Kakraban Post Office),
PS -Kakraban, Gomati Tripura
(Driver of vehicle bearing No. TR-01-2323, Commander Jeep)
-----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
and date of judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. R. Saha, Adv.
: Mr. A. Sengupta, Adv.
: 24.05.2022.
: No
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 read with Section 168 of the Act, by the appellant, Insurance
Company, challenging the judgment and award dated 17.06.2019 passed
by the Ld. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, No.2, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur, Tripura, on case No.T.S.(MAC) 18 of 2017.
[2]
For the sake of brevity the parties are referred to as in the
cause title of T.S.(MAC) 18 of 2017. The claim petition discloses the fact
that on 16.06.2016 at about 8.30 a.m deceased Brajendra Jamatia was
going to his house from Rani Panchayet Chowmohani on foot keeping left
side of the road and at that time, a Commander Jeep vehicle bearing
No.TR-01-2323 came from right side to left side and dashed the deceased
resulting to grievous injuries on his various parts of body and soon after
the accident the deceased was taken to Kakraban PHC and considering the
gravity of injuries he was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala where
he died due to multiple grievous injuries. In the claim petition it was
specifically pleaded that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the aforesaid Commander Jeep. It was again pleaded that the
deceased Brajendra Jamatia was 60 years old and used to earn
Rs.10,000/- per month and thus; the claimants claimed Rs.10,00,000/- as
compensation under various heads.
[3]
On receipt of summons, all the Opposite Parties appeared and
filed their written statements. The OP Nos.1 and 2 the owner and driver of
the aforesaid vehicle in their written statement denied all the averments of
the claim petition and pleaded that the OP No.1 was the owner of vehicle
bearing No.TR-01- 2323(Commander Jeep) and it was duly insured with
OP No.3 with policy bearing No. 3374/00318653/000/01 with validity from
15.05.2016 to 14.05.2017 and the vehicle was also driven by OP No.2
having valid driving license bearing DL No.TR-03200900005211. It was
also pleaded that there was no fault on the part of respondent Nos.1 and 2
and the accident also did not occur because of their fault and so they
denied their liability.
[4]
OP No.3, the alleged insurer, in its written statement denied
also denied all the averments made in claim petition and disputed the age,
profession, income, avocation, health condition, date, place and time of
accident, injuries, expenditure. It was also pleaded that the claim petition
did not disclose the manner in which the accident took place.
[5]
Thus; the OP No.3 also denied the liability and also prayed for
dismissal of the claim petition.
[6]
On the basis of pleadings following issues were framed:1. Whether Brajendra Jamatia, S/o. Late Nanda Dulal Jamatia
succumbed to injuries sustained in a road traffic accident on
16.06.2016 at about 8.30 a.m near Rani Panchayet Office
under Kakraban PS due to rash and negligent driving by the
driver of vehicle bearing No.TR-01-2323(Commander Jeep)?
2. Are the claimants entitled to be compensated under Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988. If so, to what extent and who shall be
liable to pay such compensation ?
[7]
To prove the claim claimant-petitioner No.1, the son of the
deceased, adduced his evidence by filing evidence in chief. In support of
his claim he produced the certified copies of FIR, ejahar(Exhibit-1), seizure
lists(Exhibits-2
and
3),
charge
sheet
(Exhibit-4),
Postmortem
Report(Exhibits5).
[8]
Claimant-Petitioners also adduced the evidence of one eye
witness namely, Bikram Murasing.
[9]
OPs did not adduce any evidence. However, the OP No.1
produced the original certificate of registration, certificate of insurance,
permit, pollution control certificate in respect of vehicle bearing No.TR-012323(Commander Jeep). Though photocopy of certificate of fitness was
produced but the original certificate of fitness was not produced and so
Motor Vehicle Inspector in compliance with summons appeared and was
cross-examined as CW.1 and on his examination the vehicle history report
in respect of vehicle bearing No.TR-01-2323(Commander Jeep) was
marked as Exhibit-C/1.
[10]
OP No.2 also produced the original driving license bearing DL
No.TR-0320090005211 and after comparison all the aforesaid documents
were returned.
[11]
While dealing with the issue No.1, the tribunal held that Even
though in the claim petition it was stated that the aforesaid Commander
Jeep was coming from right to left side but such averments cannot be said
to effect this claim because admittedly the claimant-petitioners were not
the eye witnesses and so naturally some variation in the information were
bound to be occurred. This Tribunal cannot ignore the evidence of the eye
witness , i.e., PW.2 who in his evidence clearly stated that the aforesaid
vehicle came from back side of the deceased and dashed him and as a
result he sustained injuries and was taken to hospital. Even the FIR
corroborates the evidence of PW.2.
[12]
Thus; there is no doubt in holding that the deceased Brajendra
Jamatia met an accident because of rash and negligent driving of the
driver of vehicle bearing No.TR-01-2323(Commander Jeep) and as a result
he sustained injuries and he also died of such injuries.
Thus; issue No.(1) is decided in affirmative in favour of the
claimant-petitioners.
[13]
Now to determine the compensation for loss of estate first
need to ascertain the age and income of the deceased. In the claimpetition
the age of the deceased was mentioned as 65 years but no document was
produced to show the exact age of the deceased at the time of death.
Insurer disputed the age of the deceased as 65 years on the date of death
and suggested the age of the deceased as 80 years. In the post-mortem
report the age of the deceased was mentioned as 75 years. The claimantpetitioners had opportunity to prove the age of the deceased when the
deceased was their father but they failed to do so. So in absence of any
other documentary proof the age of the deceased is taken as 75 years on
the date of death, as mentioned in the Postmortem report.
[14]
Though the claimant-petitioners in their claim petition claimed
that the deceased used to earn Rs. 10,000/- per month but they failed to
mention the source of such income. Again it was mentioned that the
monthly income of the deceased was Rs.6,000.00 per month. PW.1, the
son of the deceased, in his evidence stated that his father used to earn Rs.
10,000/- per month from cultivation. Thus there is much contradiction in
the version of the claim-petition as well as with the evidence of P.W.1
regarding monthly income of the deceased. In absence of any cogent proof
regarding monthly income of the deceased, the income of the deceased
can be taken as that of unskilled worker and so the monthly income of the
deceased is taken as Rs.6,000/- per month considering the prevailing
minimum wages and also considering the age of the deceased.
[15]
As the deceased was 75 years of age so naturally substantial
amount was required for his personal expenses and so the quantum of
savings for determining the loss to estate can be taken as 1/3 rd of the
income of the deceased i.e. Rs.2,000.00.
[16]
For loss of estate Rs.2,000.00 per month or Rs.2,000 x 12 =
Rs.24,000.00 per annum, which when multiplied by multiplier 5, stands to
Rs. 1,20,000.00.
[17]
As per the decision in the case National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs.
Pranay Sethi, AIR 2017 SC 5157 the claimants are also entitled to Rs.
15,000.00 for funeral expenses. The claimants are also entitled to
Rs.50,000.00
each
for
loss
of
care
and
attention
totaling
to
Rs.3,00,000.00.
15. In Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram, 2018 SCC OnLine
SC 1546, decided on 18-09-2018 it was held that as under:“8.7 A Constitution Bench of this Court in Pranay Sethi
(supra) dealt with the various heads under which
compensation is to be awarded in a death case. One of these
heads is Loss of Consortium. In legal parlance, “consortium”
is a compendious term which encompasses „spousal
consortium‟, „parental consortium‟, and „filial consortium‟.
The right to consortium would include the company, care,
help, comfort, guidance, solace and affection of the deceased,
which is a loss to his family. With respect to a spouse, it
would include sexual relations with the deceased spouse.
Spousal consortium is generally defined as rights pertaining
to the relationship of a husband-wife which allows
compensation to the surviving spouse for loss of “company,
society, cooperation, affection, and aid of the other in every
conjugal relation.”4 Parental consortium is granted to the
child upon the premature death of a parent, for loss of
“parental aid, protection, affection, society, discipline,
guidance and training.”
Filial consortium is the right of the parents to
compensation in the case of an accidental death of a child. An
accident leading to the death of a child causes great shock
and agony to the parents and family of the deceased. The
greatest agony for a parent is to lose their child during their
lifetime. Children are valued for their love, affection,
companionship and their role in the family unit.
Consortium is a special prism reflecting changing
norms about the status and worth of actual relationships.
Modern jurisdictions world over have recognized that the
value of a child‟s consortium far exceeds the economic value
of the compensation awarded in the case of the death of a
child. Most jurisdictions therefore permit parents to be
awarded compensation under loss of consortium on the death
of a child. The amount awarded to the parents is a
compensation for loss of the love, affection, care and
companionship of the deceased child.
The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial legislation
aimed at providing relief to the victims or their families, in
cases of genuine claims. In case where a parent has lost their
minor child, or unmarried son or daughter, the parents are
entitled to be awarded loss of consortium under the head of
Filial Consortium.
Parental Consortium is awarded to children who
lose their parents in motor vehicle accidents under the Act. A
few High Courts have awarded compensation on this count.
However, there was no clarity with respect to the principles
on which compensation could be awarded on loss of Filial
Consortium. The amount of compensation to be awarded as
consortium will be governed by the principles of awarding
compensation under „Loss of Consortium‟ as laid down in
Pranay Sethi (supra).”
[18]
Following the principles of awarding compensation under Loss
of Consortium as laid down in Pranay Sethi, the Court awarded a
compensation of Rs 80,000 as compensation towards loss of filial
consortium.
[19]
Thus Rs.2,40,000.00(Rs.40,000.00 each) is awarded to the
claimant-petitioners, being the sons and daughters of the deceased,
towards loss of „parental consortium‟.
[20]
Thus in view of the aforesaid discussion, it is held by the
tribunal that the claimants are entitled to get Rs.1,20,000.00(for loss of
estate) + Rs.15,000.00(for funeral expenses)+Rs.3,00,000.00(for loss of
care and attention)+ Rs.2,40,000.00(for loss of „parental consortium‟)
totaling to Rs. 6,75,000.00(Rupees Six Lakh Seventy Five thousand) only
as compensation.
[21]
To determine the liability, the tribunal observed that the
vehicle bearing No.TR-01-2323(Commander Jeep) is a public passenger
carrying vehicle and was duly insured with Chola M/S. General Insurance
having
policy
bearing
No.3374/00318653/000/01
with
validity
from
15.05.2016 to
14.05.2017. From the compared copy of permit it appears that the
aforesaid
vehicle
was
having
valid
permit
from
26.12.2013
up-to
26.12.2018. From the evidence of MVI it appears that the aforesaid
commender jeep vehicle had valid fitness and permit on the date of
accident, i.e., on 16.06.2016 and his evidence gets corroborated by
Exhibit-C/1, the vehicle history report. From the compared copy of driving
license it appears that the driver Kamal Karmakar, i.e., the OP No.2 was
authorized to drive LMV/NT, LMV/CAB types of vehicle and his driving
license was issued on 17.08.2009 with validity up-to 19.08.2020 for
Transport and 16.08.2029 for Non Transport vehicles.
[22]
Thus; it is held that the aforesaid Commander Jeep was having
requisites fitness, permit on the date of accident and was also being driven
by OP No.2 with valid driving license, so the liability to pay compensation
for the death of the deceased Brajendra Jamatia, is shifted upon the
insurer i.e. OP No.3. Thus, the Issue No.(2) was thus also decided partly in
favour of the claimant-petitioners.
[23]
Finally, the tribunal by the order dated 17.06.2019 has
observed in the following manner:
“The instant application under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 filed by the claimant-petitioners is hereby
partly allowed and a sum of Rs. 6,75,000.00(Rupees Six Lakh
Seventy Five thousand) only along with interest @ 6% per
annum from the date of filing of claim-petition, i.e., from
12.04.2017 till the date of payment, is awarded in favour of
claimant – petitioners in equal shares, as compensation for
the death of their father late Brajendra Jamatia, in a Road
Traffic Accident, as aforesaid, and this amount of
compensation shall be paid by OP No.3, the insurer of vehicle
bearing No.TR-01-2323(Commander Jeep), within a period of
one month.
In the event of deposit of Awarded amount with
interest, 70% from the shares of each of the claimants shall
be kept in a fixed deposit schemes in a Nationalized Bank for
five years and the remaining 30% amount of the respective
shares shall be released in favour of the claim-petitioners in
their bank accounts for enabling them to meet necessary
expenses. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted in the
fixed deposit account nor joint name shall be allowed nor any
cheque book, ATM card can be issued against fixed deposit
account. However the interest to be credited in the fixed
deposit may be released in favour of the claim-petitioners as
per Bank's norms.”
[24]
Aggrieved by the said order dated 17.06.2019, the appellant
insurance company has preferred this instant appeal before this court.
[25]
Heard.
[26]
Mr. R. Saha, counsel for the insurance-company has mainly
argued on two points (1) loss of estate granted by court below
Rs.1,20,000/- which according to him is excessive. He further submitted
before this court that as per Pranay Sethi (supra) compensation towards
loss of estate has been fixed at Rs.15,000/-only. The counsel for the
insurance company further argued that the court below has fixed
Rs.3,00,000/- towards the head of loss of care and attention. As per
Pranay Sethi (supra) and Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd (supra), there
is no compensation under the head of loss of care and attention. The
compensation awarded by the tribunal under the head of loss of care and
attention is unjust and he prayed to expunge these two amounts from the
compensation.
[27]
After perusing the entire records, this court has no hesitation
to accept the contention made by the counsel for the appellant insurance
on the ground of loss of estate at Rs.15,000/- as decided in Pranay Sethi‟s
case. Accordingly, the compensation awarded to the tune of Rs.1,20,000/under the head of loss of estate is hereby reduced to Rs.15,000/-. In so far
as the amount awarded under the head of care and attention, the amount
of Rs.3,00,000
is awarded, meaning each claimants is entitled to get
Rs.50,000/-.
[28]
On the contrary, Mr. A. Sengupta, counsel for the claimant-
respondents relying on a recent judgment of the apex court in M.H. Uma
Maheshwari & Ors vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr reported in
(2020) 6 SCC 400 has submitted that the apex court in M.H. Uma
Maheshwari (supra) considering Pranay Sethi and other judgments
towards the head “care and attention” has awarded the compensation. This
court finds that though there is no specific head as “care and attention” in
Pranay Sethi (supra) and in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. (supra).
[29]
After considering the documentary evidences so placed before
this court and also in the light of the apex court‟s latest judgment in M.H.
Uma Maheshwari (supra), this court feels that the tribunal awarding
Rs.3,00,000/- under the head of care and attention @ Rs.50,000/- each is
just and proper and needs no interference.
[29]
as
In view of the same, the appeal is allowed in part to the extent
indicate
Rs.6,75,000/-
above.
(Six
Accordingly
Lakh
the
Seventy
sum
Five
of
compensation
thousand)
is
reduced
Rs.5,70,000/- (Five lakh Seventy thousand).
JUDGE
Dipak
award
to
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review