Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC. App. No.65 of 2022
Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Ltd.
.....Appellants
V_E_R_S_U_S
Manju Debnath & 4 Others.
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. R. Saha, Advocate.
Mr. D. C. Roy, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
28/04/2023
Heard Mr. R. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellant.
Also heard Mr. D. C. Roy, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 read with Section-168 of the Act, by the appellant, insurance
company challenging the judgment and award dated 02.03.2022 passed by the
learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, No.4, West Tripura, Agartala, in
connection with T.S.(MAC)176 of 2018.
[3]
Brief facts leading to this case is that on 20.06.2017 at about
7.15 p.m. Swapan Debnath (deceased) was returning home at Radhanagar
from Karaiban Chowmuhani Ration Shop by riding his bicycle and while
reached at Karaiban Chowmuhani at that time a Tipper Truck bearing
registration No. TR-01-AB-1641 coming from Mohonpur side with high
speed in rash and negligent manner suddenly dashed him. As a result, the
deceased sustained grievous injuries on various parts of his body and died
on the spot. Thereafter, the body of the deceased was taken to the AGMC
& GBP Hospital on that night and on the next day post mortem
examination
was
dependents
of
done.
Hence,
deceased
Swapan
the
claimant
Debnath
petitioners
filed
this
being
suit
the
seeking
compensation to the tune of Rs.90,00,000/-. It has been further contended
that the accident occurred due to reckless and irresponsible driving of the
vehicle by its driver. That the deceased was of the age of 49 years and
being an agriculturist earned about Rs.15,000/- per month.
[4]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
after looked into the material evidence on record, the learned Court bellow has
observed as under:
“(i) Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of
Rs.19,69,000/-(Nineteen lacs sixty nine thousand) only along with
9% simple interest per annum from the date of registration of claim i.e,
w.e.f. 23.11.2018 till the date of realization thereof.
The amount of compensation shall be divided in equal share.
(ii) 50% of the share of the claimant petitioner Nos.1 and 2 each
and 25% of the share of claimant-petitioner No.4 in the award be invested
by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit certificates from any Nationalized
Bank at least for the next 5 years with a liberty to the claimant petitioner
Nos.1, 2 and 4 to withdraw the monthly interest from their own accounts
and no loan or advance or pre-mature withdrawal shall be allowed without
prior sanction of this Tribunal.
Entire share of claimant petitioner No. 3 (minor daughter)
shall be invested by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit certificate from
any
Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5 years or upto the age of 21 years
of claimant-petitioner No.3 whichever is later and no loan or advance or
pre-mature withdrawal shall be allowed without prior sanction of this
Tribunal.
However, the claimant petitioner No.1 shall have the liberty
to withdraw the monthly interest from the account of her minor daughter.
Needless to say that the amount so ordered to be paid to the
minor claimant petitioner shall be incurred only for her welfare and
benefit.
The OP No.2 , i.e., the Cholamandalam MS General Insurance
Company Limited shall deposit the awarded amount along with interest
thereon within one month from this day with this Tribunal.
Supply a copy of this award free of cost to the parties by not
later than 15 days from the date of the award.
The case stands disposed off on contest.”
[5]
Mr. R. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the learned Court below erred in law by putting the liability ot
pay compensation to the claimant respondents upon the appellant insurance
company and as such, the impugned judgment and award of the learned
tribunal dated 02.03.2022 is unsustainable and is not tenable in the eye of law
and is liable to be set aside. He has further contended that the learned tribunal
has miserably failed to consider the argument advanced by the learned counsel
for the appellant. The tribunal cannot consider the purported monthly income
of the deceased. The claimants had totally failed to submit any documents from
a competent authority in support of the income of the deceased. In spite of that
the learned tribunal bellow had considered the monthly income @ 12,000/which is not at all tenable in the eye of law.
[6]
The learned tribunal has committed a grave error of law by giving
25% towards future prospect of the deceased. as because the claimant had
failed to prove the profession of the deceased nor able to give any valid
evidence regarding his profession as well as him monthly income. The learned
tribunal has most arbitrarily and erroneously has allowed the interest @9% per
annum on the entire award of compensation as granted in favour of the
claimant-respondents which is absolutely inconsistent in terms of the law laid
down by the Apex Court on the issue of granting rate of interest.
[7]
Mr. Saha, learned counsel has averred that the learned Court
below wrongly arrived at the quantum of award of Rs.19,69,000/- along with
an interest of 9% P.A. from the date of filing i.e. from 23.11.2018 till the date
of realization at the Court without applying judicial mind properly since the
same is absolutely inconsistent with the prevailing bank interest rate. The
impugned judgment and award dated 02.03.2022 is bed in law since the same
has been passed by the learned tribunal below inconsistently in terms of the
established provisions of law as well as the law laid down by the Apex Court.
[8]
Though the respondent No.5, the owner of both the vehicles, had
exhibited the insurance policy but there is some violation of condition of the
insurance policy as such the present appellant is not liable to pay any
compensation amount to the claimant-respondents and on this score only the
impugned judgment and award is required to be interfered with by this Court
for fair ends of justice.
[9]
In view of above submissions advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant, for ends of justice, let us re-visit the reasons upon
which the Court below has decided the case.
[10]
On perusal of the record it is found that the claimant-
petitioners submitted certified copy of orders dated 31.7.2019, 20.8.2019
and 15.11.2019 passed in PRC (SP) 208 of 2017 from which it appears that
the driver of the offending vehicle on the fact in issue of this case pleaded
guilty in the criminal trial and was convicted by the Court for committing
such offence under Sections 279/304A of IPC and Section 187 of M.V. Act.
Thus, there is no doubt in holding that deceased Swapan Debnath died due
to the road traffic accident occurred on 20.06.2017 for rash and negligent
driving of the vehicle bearing No. TR-01-AB-1641 (tipper truck) by its
driver.
[11]
It has been established by the claimant petitioners that the
death of deceased was caused due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of offending vehicle. Therefore, the claimant petitioners being the
wife, son, daughter and mother of the deceased are entitled to have the
compensation under the beneficial legislation, namely the M.V. Act as the
claimant petitioners were dependent on the income of the deceased as
stated in their claim petition and the fact was not disputed by any party.
Moreover, Ext.8 i.e. the survival certificate issued on the occasion of death
of Lt. Swapan Debnath supports such contention of the claimantpetitioners.
[12]
In the claim petition the age of the deceased was mentioned
as 49 years. As per Ext.6 i.e. transfer certificate issued by School
Education Department, Govt. of Tripura, his date of birth was 26.2.1968.
As per death certificate he died on 20.6.2017 at the age of 49 years. Thus,
from all those documents it is clear that at the time of death deceased Swapan
Debnath was at the age of 49 years.
[13]
The learned Court below has decided the monthly income of the
deceased as Rs.12,000/- on the basis of an certificate issued by the SDM which
has no evidentiary value and cannot be relied upon. The Court below has
considered the purported monthly income of the deceased without proper
evidence let in by the claimant before. The claimants had totally failed to
submit any documents from a competent authority in support of the income of
the deceased. Thus, the same may be reduced from Rs.12,000/- to Rs.10,000/The
deceased
was
being
at
his
age
group
of
to 50 years there should be 25% addition in his income as future prospect
having self employment.
[14]
In view of the law laid down in Sarla Varma's case (AIR
2009 SC 3104) for the age group of 46 to 50 the appropriate
multiplier is M-13. Besides where the number of dependent family
members is 4 to 6, deduction would be 1/4th (one fourth) towards
personal and living expenses of deceased. In the present suit there
are four dependents and so the deduction will be 1/4th.
[15]
Now, in view of the aforesaid principles of law the amount of
compensation can be calculated in the following manner:
(I) Income
per
month
=
Rs.10,000/only.
(II) 25% of above to be added as future prospect 10,000 X 25% =
Rs.2500/- only.
(III) Total of Sl. Nos. (I) and (II) above comes to Rs.10,000/- + Rs. 2500/= Rs. 12,500/-.
(IV) One fourth (1/4) of above to be deducted as personal and living
expenses of deceased:- Rs.12,500/- minus Rs.3,125/- = Rs.9375/only.
(V) Compensation after applying multiplier of 13: Rs.9375 X 12 X 13 =
Rs.14,62,500/- only.
(VI) Loss of Estate = Rs.15,000/-only.
(VII) Funeral expenses = Rs.15,000/- only.
[16]
Now,
regarding
granting
of
compensation
for
loss
of
consortium is not only limited to the spouse but also it extends to the
parents and children of the deceased and each of the parents and children
is entitled to get compensation for loss of consortium besides the spouse
at the rate of Rs.40,000/-.
[17]
In this respect, the Hon'ble Supreme Court (a two judges
Bench) in Civil Appeal No.9581 OF 2018 (Arising out of SLP
(Civil) No. 3192 of 2018) between Magma General Insurance Co.
Ltd. -vs- Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram & Ors., 2018 SCC OnLine SC
1546, (2018) 18 SCC 130 dated 18.09.2018 held as under:
“8.7 A Constitution Bench of this Court in Pranay Sethi (supra) dealt with
the various heads under which compensation is to be awarded in a death
case, one of these heads is Loss of Consortium. In legal parlance,
“consortium” is a compendious term which encompasses „spousal
consortium‟, „parental consortium‟, and „filial consortium‟. The right to
consortium would include the company, care, help, comfort,
guidance, solace and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his
family. With respect to a spouse, it would include sexual relations
with the deceased spouse. Spousal consortium is generally defined as
rights pertaining to the relationship of a husbandwife which allows
compensation to the surviving spouse for loss of “company, society, cooperation, affection, and aid of the other in every conjugal relation.”
Parental consortium is granted to the child upon the premature death of a
parent, for loss of “parental aid, protection, affection, society, discipline,
guidance and training.” Filial consortium is the right of the parents
to compensation in the case of an accidental death of a child. An
accident leading to the death of a child causes great shock
and agony to the parents and family of the deceased. The greatest agony
for a parent is to lose their child during their lifetime. Children are
valued for their love, affection, companionship and their role in the
family unit. Consortium is a special prism reflecting changing norms
about the status and worth of actual relationships. Modern
jurisdictions world-over have recognized that the value of a child‟s
consortium far exceeds the economic value of the compensation
awarded in the case of the death of a child. Most jurisdictions
therefore permit parents to be awarded compensation under loss of
consortium on the death of a child. The amount awarded to the
parents is a compensation for loss of the love, affection, care and
companionship of the deceased child. The Motor Vehicles Act is a
beneficial legislation aimed at providing relief to the victims or their
families, in cases of genuine claims. In case where a parent has lost their
minor child, or unmarried son or daughter, the parents are entitled to be
awarded loss of consortium under the head of Filial Consortium. Parental
Consortium is awarded to children who lose their parents in motor vehicle
accidents under the Act. A few High Courts have awarded
compensation on this count. However, there was no clarity with
Rajasthan High Court in respect to the principles on which compensation
could be awarded on loss of Filial Consortium. The amount of
compensation
to
be
awarded
as
consortium
will
be
governed by the principles of awarding compensation under
„Loss of Consortium‟ as laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra).
In
the
present
case,
we
deem
it
appropriate
to award the father and the sister of the deceased, an
amount of Rs.40,000 each for loss of Filial Consortium.”
[18]
Thus, in this suit the claimant petitioner No.1 being the wife,
claimant petitioner No.2 being the son, claimant-petitioner No.3 being the
daughter and claimant petitioner No.4 being the mother of the deceased
are entitle to get compensation at the rate of Rs.40,000/- each as loss of
consortium. Thus, the calculation will be loss of consortium Rs. 40,000/- each
dependent i.e. 40,000 X 4 = Rs.1,60,000/-.
[19]
But in view of Pranay Sethi case as mentioned above, the
reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs.15,000/-, Rs.40,000/- and
Rs.15,000/- respectively. The aforesaid amounts should be enhanced
at the rate of 10 percent in every 3 years. The judgment was passed
in the year 2017 and so three years has already been elapsed from the
date of passing judgment of Pranay Sethi case. Thus, reasonable
compensation which is to be given under the conventional heads shall
increase 10%.
[20]
In this case under conventional heads (loss of estate,
funeral expenses and loss of consortium) the compensation amount
is (15,000/- + 15,000/- + 1,60,000/-) = Rs. 1,90,000/- X 10% =
Rs.2,09,000/-. Transportation cost = Rs. 5,000/- (A lump sum amount is
awarded as there is no document submitted in this respect). Hence, total
compensation stands at Rs.14,62,500+2,09,000/- + 5000/- = Rs.16,76,500/only.
[21]
Now coming to the question of liability, it appears that the
O.P. No.1 being owner of the offending vehicle claimed that his vehicle was
insured with the O.P. No.2. In support of such claim he has proved the policy
of insurance (Ext.A) which was valid at the time of accident. It is also
not the case of the O.P. No.2 that the vehicle was not insured with them. It
is, therefore, held that the O.P. No.2 being insurer is liable to satisfy the
award.
[22]
In view of above modification, the present appeal stands partly
allowed. The appellant-insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount
within a period of one month from the date of receipt of the copy of this order,
if not already deposited. Consequently, the claimants are at liberty to withdraw
the same unconditionally as per procedure as decided by the learned Court
below.
[23]
In the result, the appeal stands partly allowed to the extent as
indicated above. Draw the award accordingly.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review