Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
ABHIGYA signed by
SAXENA ABHIGYA
SAXENA
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 2023 of 2018
Reserved On 18.11.2025
Delivered On15/01/2026
1 - Cholamandlam Ms General Insurance Copany Ltd. Raipur Simiran
Towers Opposite Lic Regional Office, Near Pandri Bus Stand, Pandri
Raipur, Tehsil And District Raipur Chhattisgarh............Insurer, District :
Raipur, Chhattisgarh
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Smt. Janki Bai Sahu W/o Late Shriram Sahu, Aged About 57 Years
R/o
Village
Banur,
P.S.
Benur,
District
Narayanpur
Chhattisgarh.............Claimant, District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Yogendra Sahu S/o Late Shriram Sahu, Aged About 31 Years R/o
Village
Banur,
P.S.
Benur,
District
Narayanpur
Chhattisgarh.............Claimant, District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Smt. Aasha Sahu W/o Yagendra Sahu Aged About 30 Years R/o
Village
Banur,
P.S.
Benur,
District
Narayanpur
Chhattisgarh.............Claimant, District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
4 - Ku. Kushi Sahu D/o Yogendra Sahu Aged About 1 Years Minor
Through Her Father Yogendra Sahu, R/o Village Banur, P.S. Benur,
District
Narayanpur
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh.............Claimant,
District
:
Chhattisgarh
5 - Aayatu Ram S/o Dasuram, Aged About 42 Years R/o Village
Gavanji, District Narayanpur Chhattisgarh.................Driver, District :
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
6 - Assistant Commissioner, Aadivasi Viksa Vibhag, Narayanpur,
District Narayanpur Chhattisgarh.............Owner, District : Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
7 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Collector Narayanpur, District
Narayanpur
Chhattisgarh,
District
:
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
8 - Secretary, Ramkrishan Aashram Mission Narayanpur, District
Narayanpur
Chhattisgarh,
District
:
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
9 - Bastar Travels, Narayanpur, District Narayanpur Chhattisgarh,
District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
MAC No. 1931 of 2018
1 - Cholamandalam Ms General Insurance Company Ltd. Raipur
Simiran Towers Opposite Lic Regional Office, Near Pandri Bus Stand,
Pandri Raipur, Tehsil And District Raipur, Chhattisgarh. ........Insurer.,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Gurudatt Nishad S/o Late Govardhan Nishad Aged About 50 Years
R/o
Forest
Colony
Bangalapara,
District
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh. ..........Claimant., District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Smt. Usha Bai Nishad S/o Gurudatt Nishad Aged About 45 Years
R/o Forest Colony Bangalapara, District Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh.,
District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
3 - Manoj S/o Gurudatt Nishad Aged About 18 Years R/o Forest Colony
Bangalapara, District Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh., District : Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
4 - Aayatu Ram S/o Dasuram Aged About 42 Years R/o Village Gavanji,
District Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh. ............Driver., District : Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
5 - Assistant Commissioner Aadivasi Vikas Vibhag, Nayaranpur, District
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh.
.........Owner,
District
:
Narayanpur,
Chhattisgarh
6 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Collector Narayanpur, District
Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh., District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
7 - Secretary Ramkrishan Aashram Mission Narayanpur, District
Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh., District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
8 - Bastar Travels Narayanpur, District Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh.,
District : Narayanpur, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
MAC No. 2023 of 2018
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Ghanshyam Patel, Advocate
For Respondents No.1 to 4 : Mr. Ashish Pandey, Advocate on behalf
of Mr. Shobhit Koshtha, Advocate
For Respondent No.6 & 7
: Mr. Rahul
Advocate
Tamaskar,
Government
For Respondent No.8
: Mr. Navoday Singh, Advocate on behalf
of mr. yashwant Thakur, Advocate
Respondent No.9
: Mr.Raza Ali, Advocate
Respondent No.5
: None.
MAC No. 1931 of 2018
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Ghanshyam Patel, Advocate
For Respondents No.1 to 4 : Mr. Shivendu Pandya, Advocate
For Respondent No.5 & 6
: Mr. Rahul
Advocate
Tamaskar,
Government
For Respondent No.7
: Mr. Abhishek Nirala, Advocate on behalf
of Mr. Pravin Kumar Tulsiyan, Advocate
For Respondent No.8
: Mr. Raza Ali, Advocate
For Respondent No.4
: None.
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
C A V Order
1. These appeals under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988,
have
been
preferred
by
the
Insurance
Company
challenging the awards dated 05.02.2018 passed by the
Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kondagaon, (C.G.) in
Claim Case Nos.06/2016 & 20/2016, whereby the learned
Tribunal
has
awarded
compensation
of
₹5,61,000/-
&
₹41,61,575/- respectively with interest @ 6% per annum from the
date of claim petition from the date of its filing.
2. Facts of MAC No. 2023 of 2018 :- in nutshell, are that on
23.11.2015 while travelling in Bus No. CG 04 E 1003. It was
alleged that when the bus reached near Shivni Road, Bus No. CG
02 4721, being driven in a rash and negligent manner, collided
with it, causing grievous injuries to the deceased and other
passengers, ultimately resulting in his death during treatment.
The claimants, being the deceased’s wife, married son, daughterin-law and granddaughter, asserted that the deceased, aged
about 61 years, was employed with CSPDCL and earning Rs.
67,025 per month, and that they were dependent on him;
accordingly, they sought compensation of Rs. 53,94,000 under
various heads. The appellant was granted permission under
Section 170 of the Act to contest the claim on all grounds
available to the owner and driver. The non-applicants Nos. 2 and
3 filed their reply denying all adverse allegations and contending
instead that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the
driver of Bus No. CG 04 E 1003, a stand also supported by nonapplicant No. 4, who denied negligence on the part of the driver
of Bus No. CG 02 4721. The appellant, in its reply, disputed the
claimants’ pleadings and asserted that the driver of the insured
vehicle lacked a valid and effective driving licence at the time of
the accident, amounting to a wilful breach of policy conditions; it
was further alleged that the vehicle was being plied in a public
place without a valid permit, constituting a violation of both the
policy terms and the Motor Vehicles Act, thereby absolving the
appellant of liability. It was additionally contended that the driver
of Bus No. CG 02 4721 was solely negligent and that a criminal
case had been registered against him, rendering the claim under
Section 166 unsustainable. However, the Tribunal, without
properly appreciating the pleadings, facts, documents and
evidence on record, held that the driver of the insured vehicle was
equally responsible for the accident and fastened 50% liability on
the appellant without cogent or reliable evidence, leading to the
present appeal.
3. Facts of MAC No.1931 of 2018 :- on 23.11.2015, alleging that
while the deceased was driving the insured Bus No. CG 04 E
1003 and had reached near Shivni Road, Bus No. CG 02 4721,
driven in a rash and negligent manner, collided with it, causing
grievous injuries to the deceased and other passengers, and
resulting in his death during treatment; asserting that the
deceased was employed as a driver of the insured bus earning
Rs. 310 per day and that they were dependent on him, the
claimants sought compensation of Rs. 23,87,000. The appellant
obtained permission under Section 170 of the Act to contest the
case on all grounds available to the owner and driver. Nonapplicants Nos. 2 and 3 filed their reply denying all allegations
and contending that the accident occurred due to the negligence
of the deceased driver of Bus No. CG 04 E 1003, a stand also
taken by non-applicant No. 4, who denied negligence on the part
of the driver of Bus No. CG 02 4721. The appellant, in its reply,
denied the claimants’ averments and asserted that the deceased
did not possess a valid and effective driving licence at the time of
the accident, amounting to a wilful breach of policy conditions; it
was further pleaded that the insured vehicle was being plied in a
public place without a valid permit, in violation of the policy and
the Act, and that the driver of Bus No. CG 02 4721 was solely
responsible for the accident, a criminal case having also been
registered against him, thereby rendering the claim under Section
166 unsustainable. The Tribunal, however, without properly
appreciating the pleadings, evidence and material on record, held
that the deceased driver was equally responsible for the accident
and fastened 50% liability upon the appellant despite the fact that
if the deceased himself was negligent, the appellant could not
have been held liable, leading to the filing of the present appeal.
4. Mr. Ghanshyam Patel, Advocate for the appellant in MAC
No.2023 of 2018 submits that the criminal case records clearly
establish that the driver of Bus No. CG 02 4721 was solely
negligent in the accident of 23.11.2015, as Crime No. 112/2015
was registered against him under Sections 279, 337 and 304A
IPC, yet the Tribunal erroneously held both drivers equally
negligent. It is further argued that the Tribunal committed serious
errors in computing compensation by applying a multiplier of 7
despite the deceased being 61 years old and only one year away
from superannuation, by treating all four claimants as dependents
though claimants Nos. 2 to 4 were major and not dependent on
the deceased, and by deducting only one-fourth for personal
expenses instead of one-half or one-third. Counsel also contends
that the Tribunal failed to deduct applicable income tax from the
deceased’s annual income of Rs. 7,80,300, contrary to the
principle laid down in Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 that
compensation must be assessed on income net of tax.
5. Mr. Ghanshyam Patel, Advocate for the appellant in MAC
No.1931 of 2018 submits that the criminal case records clearly
show that the driver of Bus No. CG 02 4721 was solely
responsible for the accident of 23.11.2015, as Crime No.
112/2015 was registered against him for offences under Sections
279, 337 and 304A IPC, yet the Tribunal wrongly held both drivers
equally negligent. It is further argued that the claim under Section
166 was not maintainable against the appellant once the Tribunal
itself found that the deceased driver, Jitendra Nishad, was 50%
negligent, as a tortfeasor’s legal heirs cannot maintain a faultliability claim against the insurer. Consequently, fastening 50%
liability upon the appellant despite attributing 50% negligence to
the deceased is perverse, and the apportionment of liability
recorded in Para 20 warrants interference.
6. Learned counsel for the claimants in both the appeal submits that
the the Learned Tribunal is erroneous, unjust, and contrary to the
settled
principles
governing
the
determination
of
just
compensation, inasmuch as the Tribunal has assessed an
unrealistically low income despite the evidence on record and has
failed to grant future prospects as mandated by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in binding precedents, thereby causing a
substantial reduction in the compensation legally payable to the
claimants. The Tribunal has further erred in applying an incorrect
multiplier and in awarding meagre amounts under various
pecuniary and non-pecuniary heads, including loss of consortium,
loss of estate, funeral expenses, pain and suffering, and loss of
amenities. It is therefore respectfully submitted that the
compensation awarded is grossly inadequate and falls short of
the statutory requirement of being just, fair, and reasonable.
Accordingly, the claimants humbly pray that this Court may be
pleased to enhance the compensation by reassessing the
income, applying the correct multiplier, granting future prospects,
and suitably revising all relevant heads in the interest of justice.
7. Learned counsel for the other respondents opposes the
submissions advanced by learned counsel for the appellant. He
further supports the findings and conclusions recorded in the
impugned judgment, submitting that the award passed by the
Tribunal is just, proper, and in accordance with law, and therefore
does not warrant any enhancement.
8. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents with utmost circumspection and particularly the order
impugned.
9. The Tribunal carefully examined the evidence regarding the
collision and the circumstances of the accident. While the
appellant relies on criminal case records, it is well settled that civil
liability under the Motor Vehicles Act is independent of criminal
liability, and the Tribunal is not bound by conclusions in a criminal
case. Evidence on record supports the Tribunal’s finding that both
vehicles contributed to the accident. Accordingly, there is no
reason to interfere with the Tribunal’s apportionment of 50%
liability to the appellant.
10. The appeals preferred by the appellant Insurance Company are
devoid of merit. There is no infirmity in the findings of the Tribunal
regarding liability and would justify interference under Section 173
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
11. So far as the issue of enhancement of compensation in MAC
No. 2023 of 2018 is concerned, it is observed that the income of
the deceased has been rightly considered by the Tribunal after
appreciating the documentary evidence. The deceased was
employed
as
a
Linesman
with
Chhattisgarh
Electricity
Transmission Company, Narayanpur, and the claimants’ claim
regarding his income is supported by proper documents. The
Tribunal correctly assessed the deceased’s monthly income at
Rs. 88,261/-, and after statutory and other deductions, the net
monthly income was Rs. 67,025/-. Applying the principles laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the Tribunal has rightly
awarded loss of dependency to the tune of Rs. 40,96,575/-.
However, the Tribunal has erred in the assessment of
compensation under other heads. In the opinion of this Court, the
claimants are entitled to compensation for loss of consortium at
Rs. 40,000/-, with an enhancement of 10% every three years as
per prevailing legal standards, amounting to Rs. 48,000/-. Further,
under the heads of loss of estate and funeral expenses, applying
the same principle of 10% enhancement every three years, the
compensation is computed at Rs. 18,000/- for each head.
12. Thus, the claimants are entitled for compensation in the
following manner:-
Sn.
Heads
Calculation
1.
Loss of Dependency
Rs.40,96,575/-
2.
Loss of Consortium (with
Rs.1,92,000/-
increase of 10% in every
three years) Rs.48,000/- x 4
3.
Loss of Estate
Rs.18,000/-
4.
Funeral Expenses
Rs.18,000/-
Total compensation
Rs.43,24,575/-
13. Accordingly,
Rs.43,24,575/-
the
total
from
compensation
Rs.41,61,575/-.
is
enhanced
to
Thus,
there
an
is
enhancement of Rs.1,63,000/-, which shall carry interest at the
same rate as awarded by the Tribunal (6% p.a.) from the date of
claim petition till realization.
14. So far as the issue of enhancement of compensation in MAC
No. 2023 of 2018 is concerned, it is observed that no witness was
examined to prove the income of the deceased through
documentary evidence. Therefore, the income claimed by the
claimants, based on the documents annexed, cannot be
accepted. The Tribunal rightly erred in assessing the income of
the deceased by applying the Minimum Wages Act, determining it
to be ₹4,500/- per month which has to be Rs.5,860/- as the date
of accident is 23.11.2015. Since the deceased was unmarried,
50% of the income is to be deducted towards personal expenses.
The Tribunal has also erred in not applying 40% of the future
prospects towards income of the deceased and also the
claimants are entitled for consortium compensation of ₹40,000,
with an increase of 10% every three years as per prevailing legal
standards, which amounts to ₹48,000. Additionally, under the
heads of loss of estate and funeral expenses, applying the same
10% increase every three years, the compensation is computed
at ₹18,000 each.
15.
Thus, the claimants are entitled for compensation in the
following manner:Sn.
Heads
Calculation
No.
1.
Annual Income of deceased
Rs.70,320/- (5,860 x 12)
2.
Future Prospect 40%
Rs. 70,320/- x 40% = Rs.28,128/-
3.
Total Income of the Deceased Rs.98,448/-
4.
Deduction
of
Personal Rs.98,448/- - Rs.49,224
(½) =
Expenses 1/2
Rs.49,224/-
5.
Multiplier of 18
Rs.49,224 x 18 = Rs.8,86,032/-
6.
Loss
of
Consortium
(with Rs.48,000/- x 3 = Rs.1,44,000/-
increase of 10% in every
three years)
7.
Loss of Estate
Rs.18,000/-
8.
Funeral Expenses
Rs.18,000/-
Total compensation :
16. Accordingly,
the
total
Rs.10,66,032/-
compensation
is
enhanced
to
from
Rs.10,66,032/-
Rs.5,61,000/-.
Thus,
there
is
an
enhancement of Rs.5,05,032/-, which shall carry interest at the
same rate as awarded by the Tribunal (6% p.a.) from the date of
claim petition till realization.
17. The cross-objections filed by the claimants in both appeals
(MAC No. 2023 of 2018 and MAC No. 1931 of 2018) are allowed
in part. The awards dated 05.02.2018 passed by the Additional
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kondagaon (C.G.) in Claim Case
Nos. 06/2016 and 20/2016 stand modified to the extent indicated
above. The appeals filed by the Insurance Company are
dismissed. All other terms and conditions of the Tribunal’s
awards remain unaltered.
18. The Registry is directed to intimate the claimants in writing
regarding the enhanced amount.
Sd/- Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
JUDGE
The date when The
date
when The date when the judgment is
the judgment is the judgment is uploaded on the website.
reserved
18/11/2025
Saxena
pronounced
15/01/2026
Operative
Full
15/01/2026
15/01/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review