Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
APHC010633922022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY,THE TENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 508/2022
Between:
1. CHOLAMANDALAM MS GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
REPRESENTED BY ITS BRANCH MANAGER, 302,ESWAR PLAZA,
2ND FLOOR, DWARAKA NAGAR, VISAKHAPATNAM.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SANAPALA LEELAVATHI, W/O LATE GOVINDARAO, AGED ABOUT
41 YEARS,KALINGA BY CASTE,HINDU, HOUSEHOLD DUTIES,
RESIDENT
OF
DUSIPETA
VILLAGE,
DOOR
NO.1-79,
AMADALAVALASA MANDALAM, SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
2. SANAPALA SANTHOSH KUMAR, S/O.LATE GOVINDARAO, AGED
ABOUT 18 YEARS,KALINGA BY CASTE,STUDENT, RESIDENT OF
DUSIPETA
VILLAGE,DOOR
NO.1-79,
AMADALAVALASA
MANDALAM,SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
3. SANAPALA RAJESWARI, ,D/O.LATE GOVINDARAO, AGED ABOUT
20 YEARS,KALINGA BY CASTE,STUDENT, RESIDENT OF
DUSIPETA
VILLAGE,
DOOR
NO.1-79,
AMADALAVALASA
MANDAL,SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
4. SANAPALA
LAKSHMI
NARAYANAMMA,
WIFE
OF
LATE
LATCHANNA,
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS,KALINGA BY CASTE,
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
HOUSEHOLD DUTIES,RESIDENT OF DUSIPETA VILLAGE, DOOR
NO.1-79, AMADALAVALASA MANDAL, SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
5. TAMMINENI TRINADHARAO, SRIKAKULAM
6. THAMMINENI SATYAM, SRIKAKULAM
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased tobegs to present this Memorandum of Civil Miscellaneous Appeal
under Section 173 of M.V. Act . aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed
in M.V.O.P. no. 384/2018 on the file of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal cum- I Additional District Judge, Srikakulam dt. 31-01-2022
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 175 days in filing the MACMA against the
decree and judgment passed in MVOP No. 384 of 2018 on the file of Motor
Accidents claims Tribunal - cum - I Addl. District Judge, Srikakulam dt. 31-012022
IA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant sty of all further proceedings pursuant to the decree and
judgment dated the 31th day of Jay, 2022 passed in MVOP No. 384/2018 on
the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal - cum- I Addl. District Judge,
Srikakulam
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to permit the petitioner to withdraw the deposited amount in MVOP
384/2018 before the Hon'ble MACT cum I ADJ Court, Srikakulam district as
deposited by the appellant as per directions of this Hon'ble court orders dt
6.12.2022 in MACMA.N0508/2022 Srikakulam district and pass
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
IA NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the Interim orders dt 06.12.2022 in the above
MACMA.N0.508/ 2022 and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. TOTA TEJESWARA RAO
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
JUDGMENT:This appeal is filed by the appellant – Insurance company challenging
the award dated 31.01.2022 passed by the Chairman, Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal – cum – I Additional District Judge, Srikakulam in
M.V.O.P.No.384 of 2018 filed by the respondent Nos.1 to 4/claimants
seeking compensation of Rs.18,00,000/- for the death of one Sanapala
Govinda Rao (hereinafter referred to as ‘deceased’) in an accident that
occurred on 09.03.2018 at Dusipeta village fields, Amadalavalasa
mandal, Srikakulam district.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referredto as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The claimant Nos.1 to 4 are the wife, children and mother of the
deceased. The respondent Nos.1 to 3 are the driver, owner and insurer of
the tractor bearing No. AP30TZTR3147 attached with thrashing machine,
respectively. On 09.03.2018, while the deceased along with others was
attending coolie works in the tractor attached with a thrashing machine
mentioned hereinabove, at about 04.00 p.m., as the thrashing machine
got struck, the 1st respondent, arranged an iron flat and started the engine
of the vehicle without covering the top, as a result of which, it lost control,
welding was broken and the iron flat hit the deceased on the right side of
his ribs and he also sustained several other injuries. He was shifted to
RIMS General Hospital, Srikakulam, where he succumbed to injuries at
about 05.30 p.m. The incident was reported to Station House Officer,
Amadalavalasa police station, who registered a case in crime No.20 of
2018 and a charge sheet was also filed on the file of the Judicial
Magistrate of 1st Class, Amadalavalasa in CC.No.76 of 2018.It is the case
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
of the claimants that the deceased used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month by
attending daily labour works.
4.
Respondent No.2 contested the claim petition by filing a written
statement denying the material allegations and contending that the 1st
respondent is not responsible for the accident and that the deceased was
not attentive at the time of accident. The 3rd respondent also contested
the case by filing a detailed counter affidavit contending that the tractor
belonging to the 2nd respondent was not involved in the accident and that
it caused mainly due to the thrashing machine, which was not insured by
the 3rd respondent. It further contended that the 1st respondent had no
valid driving license as on the date of the accident and that the 2 nd
respondent willfully violated the terms and conditions of the policy. The 3rd
respondent further contended that it is not liable to pay compensation to
the claimants in any way and hence, requested the Tribunal to dismiss
the claim petition.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues for trial:
1)
Whether the deceased/SanapalaGovinda Rao, S/o late Latchanna
died due to rash and negligent driving of Respondent No.1 – Driver of
Tractor bearing No.AP 30 TZ-TR 3147?
2)
Whether the petitioners are to claim any compensation for the death
of the deceased-SanapalaGovinda Rao, S/o late Latchanna? If so, to what
amount and from which of the respondents 1 to 3?
3)
To what relief?
6.
During the course of trial, P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and
Exs.A1 to A5 were marked on behalf of the claimants. On behalf of the
respondents, the 1st respondent-driver was examined as R.W.1, Deputy
Manager of respondent No.3 was examined as R.W.2 and Senior
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
Assistant of RTA office was examined as R.W3. They got marked Exs.B1
to B3 and Ex.X1 to X3.
7.
The Tribunal, after considering all the facts and material
available before it, came to a conclusion that the 1st respondent was
holding a valid driving license as on the date of accident, that the
deceased is a third party to the accident and that the 3rd respondent is
entirely and severally liable to pay the compensation to the claimants.
Thus, the Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs.10,15,000/- to the claimants as
compensation towards the death of the deceased in the accident
occurred on 09.03.2018. Challenging the award dated 31.01.2022, the 3rd
respondent filed this Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal.
8.
Heard Sri. Gudi Srinivasu, learned Standing Counsel for the
appellant and Sri. T. Tejeswara Rao, learned counsel for the
respondents.
9.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the
appellant/respondent No.3 strenuously contended that the Tribunal has
awarded the compensation of Rs.10,15,000/- erroneously. He further
contended
that
the
tractor
alone
was
insured
with
the
appellant/respondent No.3 and that no premium was paid towards the
insurance of the thrashing machine which is used only for agricultural
purposes. He further contended that the Tribunal grossly erred by
fastening the liability on the appellant/respondent No.3 though the
insurance policy does not cover the risk of the deceased who died
because of the thrashing machine. In the absence of any documentary
proof, the Tribunal considered the monthly income of the deceased as
Rs.5,500/- which is untenable. Thus, requested to set-aside the impugned
award passed by the Tribunal.
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
10.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents
supported the award passed by the Tribunal in all aspects and contended
that the Tribunal has rightly awarded the compensation of Rs.10,15,000/to the claimants and that the same need not be interfered with by this
Court.
11.
Perused the entire material available on record. A perusal of
the evidence adduced by P.W.2 – eye witness to the accident, it is clear
that on the fateful day, the 1st respondent attached a thrashing machine
with the tractor and while the thrashing machine was functioning, it
suddenly got struck, subsequently, the 1st respondent placed an iron flat
(inupabadda) as an interim arrangement and started the engine of the
tractor with high speed without covering the top cover, resulting in loss of
control and breakage of the welding, the iron flat which was placed by the
1st respondent hit the deceased on right side of his ribs and forehead. The
deceased sustained several blood injuries and died in the hospital while
undergoing treatment. The same version can also be witnessed from the
accident report relied on by the claimants which is marked as Ex.A3.
Thus, the Tribunal has rightly held that the deceased died due to the rash
and negligence of the respondent No.1. Accordingly, the Tribunal has
answered issue No.1 infavour of the claimants and the same need no
interference by this Court.
12.
Now, a perusal of Ex.B1, it can be seen that the 1st respondent
was holding a valid driving license as on the date of accident and Ex.B2
discloses that the subject vehicle was insured with the 3rd respondent and
the same is in force as on the date of accident. Insofar as the contention
of the 3rd respondent that the thrashing machine was not insured by it is
concerned, time and again, the Apex Court, in catena of judgments held
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
that no separate insurance is contemplated for a trailer or any machine
attached to a tractor and when such machine is attached to the tractor
that is insured, it becomes the part of the tractor. The principle of claim for
compensation in accidents arising out of the use of the motor vehicle is
based on tortuous liability and the negligence of the driver of the motor
vehicle is sine quo non for maintaining a claim under the provisions of the
Motor Vehicles Act. Inasmuch as the thrashing machine by itself cannot
be driven or functioned and it has to be carried or towed with a tractor, the
question of insuring the thrashing machine would not arise. It is only the
prime mover or the motor vehicle which controls movement of the
thrashing machine and in case of negligence driving of the tractor, the
owner of the vehicle and its insurer alone will be made liable for payment
of compensation. Moreover, it is very clear that a thrashing machine
cannot run on its and it does not have a separate engine, it has to
function with the help of a tractor. Thus, the Tribunal has rightly fixed the
liability of paying compensation on the appellant/respondent No.3 and the
same is on reasonable basis.
13.
Now, coming to the quantum, though the claimants contended
that the deceased was earning Rs.15,000/- per month, no documentary
proof was filed by the claimants in support of the same. Further, the age
of the deceased as per inquest report was 45. In the absence of any
documentary proof, the Tribunal has fixed the daily income of the
deceased as Rs.200/- as he was attending daily labour; thus the monthly
income of the deceased was computed as Rs.6,000/-. As per the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in National Insurance Company
Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors., 25% of the monthly income was
added towards future prospects, thus the monthly income is computed to
Rs.7,500/- [Rs.6000/- + 25% of Rs.6000/-]. Thus, the annual income of
VS,J
MACMA_508 of 2022
the deceased would become Rs.90,000/- and after deducing 1/4th of the
same towards personal expenses, the amount the deceased would be
contributing to his family would become Rs.67,500/- [Rs.90,000/- Rs.22,500/-]. As per the decision Sarla Verma and Ors. Vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation and another 1 , considering the age of the
deceased, the relevant multiplier is ‘14’. Thus, the total amount of
compensation liable to be paid to the claimants under the head of loss of
dependency would become Rs.9,45,000/- [Rs.67,500/- X 14]. In addition,
the Tribunal has awarded Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.40,000/towards loss of consortium and Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses. In
all, the Tribunal awarded a total sum of Rs.10,15,000/- [Rs.9,45,000/- +
Rs.15,000/- + Rs.40,000/- + Rs.15,000/-] to the claimants. The quantum
of compensation awarded by the Tribunal vide the impugned award is
neither excessive nor deficient, it is on reasonable basis and the same
need not be interfered.
14.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the award passed by the
Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal – cum – I Additional District
Judge, Srikakulam in M.V.O.P.No.384 of 2018 is on reasonable basis and
the same need not be intervened by this Court. Accordingly, this Motor
Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed. There shall be no
order as to costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date:10.03.2026.
Gss
AIR 2009 SCC3104
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review