Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
APHC010663022009
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3397]
THURSDAY, THE 6th DAY OF AUGUST 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA
KRISHNA RAO
APPEAL SUIT NO: 32/2009
Between:
Chinnam Venkata Rama Reddy and Others
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
Nallamilli Satyanarayana Reddy
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. GVVSR SUBRAHMANYAM
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. T V JAGGI REDDY
The Court made the following:
...RESPONDENT
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO
APPEAL SUIT No.32 of 2009
JUDGMENT:
This Appeal, under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure [for short
‘the C.P.C.’], is filed by the Appellants/Defendants challenging the Decree and
Judgment, dated 29.10.2008, in O.S.No.133 of 2004 passed by the learned
Senior Civil Judge, Ramachandrapuram [for short ‘the trial Court’].
2.
The appellants herein are the defendants and the respondent herein is
the plaintiff in O.S.No.133 of 2004, on the file of the Senior Civil Judge,
Ramachandrapuram.
3.
Originally, the plaintiff in O.S.No.133 of 2004 filed the suit against the
defendants, seeking for recovery of Rs.9,99,500/- being the amount of
principal and interest due on a mortgage debt dated 27.11.1999, executed by
the defendants in favour of the plaintiff for Rs.3,00,000/- with subsequent
interest and for costs.
4.
Both parties in the appeal will be referred to as they were arrayed
before the trial Court.
5.
The case of the plaintiff as per the plaint averments in O.S.No.133 of
2004, in brief, is as follows:
I.
The plaintiff pleaded that the defendants borrowed an amount of
Rs.3,00,000/- from the plaintiff for the purpose of business investment
of the defendant No.5 and also for family expenses of the defendant
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
Nos.1 to 5 on 27.11.1999 and executed the suit mortgage bond dated
27.11.1999, undertaking to pay the same together with interest @ Rs.
2.50 Ps per month per hundred. The plaintiff further pleaded that the
defendants have to pay interest for every half year and if the defendants
failed to do so, they have to pay compound interest till payment. The
plaintiff further pleaded that the defendants did not pay the interest for
every six months as per the contract, i.e. the conditions stipulated in the
suit mortgage bond, and the plaintiff is entitled to recover the principal
amount by adding the interest calculated for every six months and
cumulating the same with the principal amount. The plaintiff further
pleaded that the defendant No.1 is an Advocate by profession, the
defendant No.5 is a businessman and the other defendants are also
businessmen, and the purpose of borrowing the amount is also to invest
the same in the business. The plaintiff further pleaded that he is entitled
to recover the interest as per the contract rate with half-yearly
compound interest.
II.
The plaintiff further pleaded that the defendants failed to pay any
amount towards the mortgage debt till now, despite the expiry of three
yearly installments for discharge of the debt and, as such, the plaintiff
got issued a notice on 21.11.2001 to all the defendants through the
defendant No.1 demanding to discharge of the mortgage debt. The
defendants issued a reply notice dated 25.11.2001, stating that they will
take a loan from the Cooperative Bank and discharge the debt if the
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
plaintiff furnishes the pattadar pass book and title deed. The plaintiff
further pleaded that even after handing over the title deeds and pass
book, the defendants did not pay or discharge the debt due under the
mortgage bond, and then the plaintiff again issued a notice dated
01.10.2002, and the defendant No.1 received the said notice and issued
a reply dated 18.10.2002 through his counsel stating that he will repay
the loan as early as possible immediately after the sanction of the loan
from the Bank. The plaintiff further pleaded that the defendants did not
discharge the debt and subsequently, handed over the original title
deed and pass book to the plaintiff. The plaintiff further pleaded that all
the defendants are not agriculturists and they are not entitled to the
benefits of Act No.4 of 1938 or Act No.7 of 1977 or Act No.45 of 1987 or
Act No.02 of 1990, or any other Act applicable to the agriculturists,
which will not be applicable to the defendants, and the defendants are
not entitled to any benefits and that the plaintiff was constrained to file
the suit.
6.
The defendant No.5 filed the written statement and the same was
adopted by defendant Nos.1 to 4 and the case of the defendants as per the
written statement is as follows:
The defendant No.5 pleaded that the plaintiff obtained the mortgage
bond with an interest of 30% per annum with false and incorrect recitals in the
mortgage bond and subsequently, after borrowing the amount from the
plaintiff, the defendant No.5 sustained a loss in the business and could not
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
repay the same immediately. The defendant No.5 further pleaded that he and
the plaintiff got into a mutual understanding and the plaintiff agreed to receive
an amount of Rs.18,000/- per month towards monthly installments
commencing from November, 2002. Accordingly, the defendants regularly
paid Rs.18,000/- per month on the 7th day of every month and the defendant
No.5 paid monthly installments of Rs.18,000/- to the plaintiff till 07.05.2004,
thus the defendant No.5 paid an amount of Rs.3,42,000/- towards part
payment of the principal and interest till 07.05.2004. The defendant No.5
further pleaded that the suit was filed only to harass the defendants and the
plaintiff with a malafide motive got mentioned incorrect recitals in the
mortgage bond and basing on those recitals, the present suit was filed and the
defendants requested for dismissal of the suit.
7.
Based on the above pleadings, the trial Court framed the following
issues:
1) Whether the mortgage bond dated 29.11.2009 (sic. 27.11.99?) is true,
valid and binding on the defendants?
2) Whether the discharge of Rs.2,28,000/- is true and valid?
3) To what relief?
On 18.07.2007, the trial Court framed the following additional issues:
1) Whether the interest claimed by the plaintiff is agreed rate of interest
and is payable at compound rate with half yearly rests?
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
2) Whether the interest claimed by the plaintiff is usurious and required to
be scaled down?
3) Whether the defendants are entitled for the benefits of Act IV of 1938?
4) Whether the calculation of suit amount is correct?
On 19.08.2008, the trial Court framed the following additional issues:
1) Whether the defendants discharged Rs.3,42,000/- due under suit
mortgage?
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover the entire suit amount?
3) To what relief?
8.
During the course of trial in the trial Court, on behalf of the plaintiff,
P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.A-1 to A-8 were marked. On behalf
of the defendants, D.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B-1 to B-19 were
marked and the evidence of D.W.2 and D.W.3 was eschewed.
9.
After completion of the trial and on hearing the arguments of both sides,
the trial Court decreed the suit with costs vide its judgment, dated 29.10.2008,
against which the present appeal is preferred by the appellants/defendants in
the suit.
10.
Learned counsel for the appellants would contend that the judgment
and decree passed by the trial Court are contrary to law and against the
weight of the evidence, he further contended that the trial Court failed to
consider that an amount of Rs.2,28,000/- was paid under receipts under
Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19, and the trial Court also failed to consider the aforesaid
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
receipts issued towards part discharge of the amount. He would further
contend that the learned trial Judge failed to appreciate the evidence on
record in a proper manner and decreed the suit, and the appeal may be
allowed by setting aside the decree and judgment passed by the trial Court.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff would contend
that, on appreciation of the entire evidence on record, the learned trial Judge
rightly decreed the suit and there is no need to interfere with the findings
arrived at by the learned trial Judge, and that the appeal may be dismissed by
confirming the decree and judgment passed by the trial Court.
12.
Heard Sri GVVSR. Subrahmanayam, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants and Sri T.V. Jaggi Reddy, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent.
13.
Now, in deciding the present appeal, the points that arise for
determination is as follows:
1. Whether the recitals in Ex.A-1 registered mortgage deed are true
and Ex.A-1 is proved?
2. Whether the alleged discharge of part-payments of amounts under
Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 pleaded by the appellants is proved by the
appellants?
3. Whether the trial Court is justified in decreeing the suit?
14.
Point No.1:
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
Whether the recitals in Ex.A-1 registered mortgage deed are true and
Ex.A-1 is proved?
The undisputed facts are that the defendant Nos.1 and 2 are husband
and wife and the defendant Nos.3 and 4 are the children of the defendant
Nos.1 and 2 and the defendant No.5 is none other than the husband of the
defendant No.4 and son-in-law of the defendant Nos.1 and 2. It is also
undisputed
that
the
defendant
No.1
is
a
practicing
advocate
at
Ramachandrapuram. The borrowing of Rs.3,00,000/- and the execution of
Ex.A-1 registered mortgage deed before the Sub-Registrar is undisputed by
the defendants. The defendant No.5/D.W.1 admitted in his evidence in crossexamination itself about the relationship of the parties. He further admits that
all the five defendants borrowed Rs.3,00,000/- from the plaintiff and executed
a registered mortgage deed under Ex.A-1. He also further admits that, as per
the recital in Ex.A-1, they have to pay the interest @ 30% per annum for every
six (06) months. Another crucial admission made by D.W.1 in his evidence in
cross-examination itself is that, as per Ex.A-1, they have to repay the principal
amount also within three installments @ Rs.1,00,000/- within one (01) year
from the date of Ex.A-1, and another sum of Rs.1,00,000/- in another one (01)
year period, and the balance amount is to be paid in another one (01) year.
He also further admits that, as seen from Ex.A-1, they have to pay the entire
principal amount with compound rate of interest payable for every six (06)
months. If they fail to pay the interest as agreed upon expiry of six (06)
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
months, the interest will be added to the principal and the interest will be
calculated on the said total sum.
15.
The suit is based on the registered mortgage deed said to have been
executed by all the defendants. To discharge his initial burden, the plaintiff
relied on his self-testimony as P.W.1. P.W.1 narrated in his evidence about
the borrowing of the amount and execution of Ex.A-1 registered mortgage
deed by all the defendants in favour of the plaintiff. P.W.2 is one of the
attestors to Ex.A-1 registered mortgage deed. P.W.2, in his evidence,
specifically stated about the borrowing of Rs.3,00,000/- by all the defendants
and execution of Ex.A-1 mortgage deed and also registration of the same
before the Sub-Registrar, and he further asserted that the defendants also
agreed to repay the same along with interest @ Rs.2.50 Ps per month per
hundred, repayable within three installments on or before 26.11.2000. It is not
at all suggested to P.W.2 in cross-examination by the learned counsel for the
defendants before the trial Court that they have not agreed to repay the same
with interest @ Rs.2.50 Ps per month per hundred repayable on or before
26.11.2000, 26.11.2001 and 26.11.2002 as stated in the chief-examination
affidavit. As seen from the evidence of P.W.2, no suggestion was given to
P.W.2 in cross-examination by the learned counsel for the defendants that the
defendants agreed to repay the amount with interest @ Rs.2.00 Ps per month
per hundred and not with interest @ Rs.2.50 Ps per month per hundred.
16.
The learned counsel for the appellants would contend that the agreed
rate of interest between both the parties is Rs.2.00 Ps per month per hundred,
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
but it was got manipulated as Rs.2.50 Ps per month per hundred by the
plaintiff before the document was presented with the Sub-Registrar for
registration. As seen from the written statement filed by the defendants as well
as the evidence of D.W.1, it is not at all pleaded by the defendants either in
the written statement or in the evidence of D.W.1 that the agreed rate of
interest between both the parties is Rs.2.00 Ps per month per hundred only,
but it was manipulated as Rs.2.50 Ps per month per hundred by the plaintiff
before the document was presented with Sub-Registrar. For the first time, the
appellants have taken the aforesaid stand of manipulation of interest in the
document at the stage of arguments. Therefore, in the absence of any
pleading and oral evidence as narrated supra, the aforesaid contention of the
appellants cannot be taken into consideration.
17.
The plaintiff, to prove the recitals in Ex.A-1, examined one of the
attestors of Ex.A-1 as P.W.2. To disprove the recitals of Ex.A-1 mortgage
deed, the defendants did not adduce any cogent evidence except examining
one of the borrowers, defendant No.5, as D.W.1. D.W.1 himself admitted
about the execution and registration of the mortgage deed under Ex.A-1. As
stated supra, no such suggestion was given to P.W.2 in cross-examination by
the learned counsel for the defendants before the Court below that the recitals
in Ex.A-1 are not true and the agreed rate of interest is @ Rs.2.00 Ps per
month per hundred. As stated supra, the defendants are not illiterates and the
defendant No.1 is a practicing advocate at Ramachandrapuram, at which
place the suit is filed. For the reasons best known to the defendant Nos.1 to 4,
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
they did not enter into the witness box to disprove the evidence produced by
the plaintiff and to prove the defence put forth by the appellants in the written
statement. The defendants also relied on the evidence of D.W.2 and D.W.3.
The evidence of D.W.2 and D.W.3 is eschewed by the learned trial Judge by
narrating reasons in the judgment. In view of the aforesaid reasons, this Court
is of the considered view that the recitals in Ex.A-1 registered mortgage deed
are true and Ex.A-1 is proved.
Accordingly, Point No.1 is answered against the appellants.
18.
POINT No.2:
Whether the alleged discharge of part-payments of amounts under
Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 pleaded by the appellants is proved by the appellants?
It was contended by the appellants that they made part-payments under
Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 to the plaintiff. Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 are vouchers said to have
been issued by one Siva Reddy Computerized Weighbridge. The receipts
under Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 are strongly disputed by the respondent/plaintiff. The
defendants are individuals and they are not the Siva Reddy Computerized
Weighbridge. There is no mention in Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 that those receipts are
part-payment receipts to discharge part of the debt covered under Ex.A-1.
D.W.1/defendant No.5, who is one of the borrowers, admitted in his evidence
itself that there is a recital in Ex.A-1 that if any payment is made, it shall be
endorsed on the back of Ex.A-1 mortgage deed only. He further admits that in
none of Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 receipts is it found that the alleged payments were
made by any one of the five defendants. He further admits that there is no
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
recital in Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 that the alleged payments under them are for
discharge of the debt due under Ex.A-1 mortgage transaction.
19.
The alleged Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 are vouchers in the name of Siva Reddy
Computerized Weighbridge. It has to be explained by the appellants how
Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 are to be connected with Ex.A-1 mortgage transaction, in
view of the aforesaid admission made by the D.W.1 in his evidence in crossexamination. Therefore, Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 cannot be treated as part-payment
receipts to discharge Ex.A-1 mortgage debt. Moreover, as stated supra, Ex.B1 to Ex.B-19 alleged receipts are strongly disputed by the respondent/plaintiff,
therefore, the burden heavily casts upon the appellants to prove the same.
The said Ex.B-1 to Ex.B-19 receipts shown are said to have been issued by
Siva Reddy Computerized Weighbridge and one clerk by the name of Rajesh
signed the said receipts, and the said Rajesh was examined as D.W.3 before
the trial Court. But the evidence of D.W.3 was eschewed by the trial Court by
assigning reasons in its judgment. As stated supra, the execution and
borrowing are admitted by the appellants, therefore, it is for the
defendants/appellants to prove the alleged part-payment receipts under Ex.B1 to Ex.B-19. But, they have failed to prove the same; therefore, Ex.B-1 to
Ex.B-19 alleged receipts are not at all proved by the appellants.
19.
POINT No.3:
Whether the trial Court is justified in decreeing the suit?
VGKR, J.
AS_32_2009
In view of my findings on Point Nos.1 and 2, there is no illegality in the
decree and judgment passed by the learned trial Judge in its judgment dated
29.10.2008.
20.
In the result, the present Appeal Suit is dismissed, confirming the
decree and judgment dated 29.10.2008, in O.S.No.133 of 2004 passed by the
learned Senior Civil Judge, Ramachandrapuram, East Godavari District. On
considering the facts and circumstances of the case, each party shall bear its
own costs in the appeal suit.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the Appeal shall
stand closed
__________________________
V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO, J.
Date: 06.08.2026
SRT
Whether the order is:
Speaking
Reportable
☑
Reasoned
Non-reportable
☑
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review