Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010591372008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3560]
WEDNESDAY, THE FIRST DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 1197/2008
Between:
1. CHIGURUPATI MURALI, S/O. VENKATESWARA RAO, PRIVATE
EMPLOYEE R/O. PENAMALURU VILLAGE AND MANDAL, KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF AP REP BY ITS PP HYD, Represented by Public
Prosecutor L & O Patamata, High Court of A.P.,
...RESPONDENT
Revision filed under Section 397/401 of CrPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
CriminalRevisionCase, the High Court may be pleased toto present this
Memorandum of Crl.R.C., against the judgment made in Crl.A.No.105 of 2006
on the file of the Court of the II SessionsJudge, Mahila Court at Vijayawada,
dt.06-08-2008.
IA NO: 1 OF 2008(CRLRCMP 1611 OF 2008
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
dispense with the filing of the certified copy of the judgment in CC.No.
112/2000 dt. 13.06.2006 of 1st Addl. Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
Vijayawada in the above Crl.RC
IA NO: 2 OF 2008(CRLRCMP 1618 OF 2008
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the sentence and enlarge the petitioner on bail pending disposal of
the Crl.R.C.,
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SUNKARA RAJENDRA PRASAD
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
The Court made the following:
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 1197/2008
ORDER:
The instant Criminal Revision Petition has been preferred against order
of conviction and sentence passed by the learned trial Court, confirmed by the
learned Appellate Court against present petitioner, wherein and whereunder
the learned Courts below found the petitioner to be guilty for the offence
punishable under Section 408 IPC and directed him to undergo three (03)
years rigorous imprisonment and with fine of Rs.10,000/-.
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned order of
conviction recorded against the petitioner is illegal and improper. The
prosecution has miserably failed to bring home the charge against the present
petitioner beyond reasonable doubt. The alleged misappropriation by the
accused has never been proved, instead of which, the learned Court below
recorded conviction. He further submits that at the outset it would be revealed
that P.W.1 is the owner of Auto Agency situated at Vijayawada, P.Ws.2 to 4
are dealers. The accused/petitioner is one of the agents of P.W.1, who alleged
to have been collected some amount from P.Ws.2 to 4 and all amount was not
remitted to P.W.1. Thus, P.W.1 has reported the matter to the Police through
Ex.P1. Hence, the trial started.
3.
He submits that there are lacunae in the investigation of the Police. At
the closure of investigation, Police submitted charge sheet against petitioner
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
to the Court. Copy of charge sheet was handed over to the accused. Such
copy does not contain name of P.W.4 as a witness. When P.W.4 was called
for deposition, it was objected by the defence, but the learned Court has
directed the prosecution to hand over the copy of 161 Cr.P.C. statement of
P.W.4. Such procedure, as adopted by the learned trial Court is unwarranted
and cannot be accepted.
4.
He further submits that during evidence of P.W.1, for the first time, has
placed before the Court a letter alleged to have been written by accused,
which was alleged to have been typed by the P.W.1. The said document
contains alleged letter of accused admitting the guilt. In spite of objection, the
letter was marked as Ex.P9 by the learned trial Court. He further submits that
the learned trial Court, in spite of strong objection from the defence, has relied
upon Ex.P9 in recording the conviction of the petitioner. He submits that
learned trial Court as well as the learned appellate Court has gone through a
wrong notion of law in exhibiting Ex.P9 and making reliance upon Ex.P9 to
record the conviction. He further submits that it has been admitted by P.W.1
during his cross examination as well as by the investigating agency that Police
did not verify the account book and he did not furnish the account book as it
was not called for by the investigating agency. It is further contention of the
learned counsel for the petitioner that the order of conviction and sentence as
well as entire criminal proceedings has been vitiated, and that the petitioner,
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
being the accused, has falsely implicated in this case, and thereby the order of
conviction and sentence of imprisonment is liable to be set aside.
5.
Learned Assistant Public Prosecutor submits that the accused
admittedly one of the agent of P.W.1. He admittedly received amounts from
P.Ws.2 to 4 on the strength of invoices. Such invoices were marked as Exs.P3
to P7. P.Ws.2 to 4 has consistently stated before the Court as well as before
the Police during investigation that accused has collected entire amount of
money in terms of invoices. Ex.P1 has disclosed that in spite of receiving
entire amount of money, the accused has not remitted such amount to P.W.1.
The evidence of P.W.1 along with P.Ws.2 to 4 successfully proved the offence
committed by the accused under Section 408 of IPC. He further submits that
the learned trial Court as well as learned appellate Court have correctly
recorded the conviction of sentence on the basis of evidence of P.Ws.2 to 4.
There is no illegality or impropriety, and thereby revision has no merit.
Learned Assistant Public Prosecutor admits that Ex.P9 was filed during the
trial, though it was in possession of P.W.1 at the time of filing Ex.P1 and the
prosecution had no opportunity to verify the correctness of Ex.P9.
6.
Heard Sri Sunkara Rajendra Prasad, learned counsel for the petitioner
and Sri K.Sandeep, learned counsel for the respondent. Perused the entire
observation of the learned trial Court as well as learned appellant Court.
7.
At the outset, a distinct and separate practice and procedure is laid
down in Criminal Procedure Code for criminal investigation and trial. At the
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
time of investigation, it is the duty of the investigating officer to collect
evidences, both oral and documentary and after being satisfied that there is a
prima facie acquisition against the accused, the same would be submitted to
the Court through a final report. That final report shall contain the statements
collected by the Police during investigation and recorded by them under
Section 161 Cr.P.C., and also shall contain the way of investigation and the
documents collected, day to day, during course of investigation. In this case,
accusation against petitioner is under Section 408 IPC. The ingredients of
Section 408 of IPC are very specific. Prosecution has to substantiate that the
petitioner, being an agent of P.W.1, who reposed trust upon accused and
under the capacity of such trust, the accused has received some property and
after receiving such property, he misappropriated such property. To prove the
offence under Section 408 IPC, the prosecution has to prove firstly that the
accused is a clerk, servant or agent of P.W.1. In this particular case, it is
admitted as well as not denied by the accused that he was an employee/agent
of P.W.1. Secondly, the prosecution has to prove that under such capacity of
trust as an agent, the accused has received some property or amount and that
the same was misappropriated. At the outset of the fact of the case, it appears
that P.W.1 has filed Ex.P1 to the Police. Police started investigation on the
basis of Ex.P1. P.Ws.2 to 4 were examined during the investigation and their
statements were recorded. However, P.Ws.2 to 4, who are the dealers, have
stated before Court as well as the Police that they have given the entire
money to the accused but P.W.1 has stated before the Police through Ex.P1
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
that entire money was not remitted. In this case, the Police had submitted
charge sheet to the Court which is different to the charge sheet which was
supplied to the accused. Accused has a right in criminal trial to have the true
and full copy of the charge sheet along with all documents collected by the
Police during the course of investigation.
8.
In this case, supplying insufficient copy of charge sheet itself vitiates the
trial. During the course of trial, when P.W.4 appeared to depose, it was
objected by the defence that the name of P.W.4 is not appearing in the charge
sheet supplied by the police after investigation. The copy of charge sheet
which was supplied to the accused after investigation was placed on record
and marked as Ex.D1. Ex.D1 shows that it does not contain the name of
P.W.4. The learned trial Court should have not allowed P.W.4 to depose on
behalf of prosecution and the deposition of P.W.4 itself violates the right of the
accused to know what particular evidence prosecution intended to rely before
starting of trial. It led accused by surprise causing prejudices. The same
amounts to not a fair trial.
9.
Furthermore, it appears that the P.W.1 during the course of trial has
appeared before the Court to depose on 02.09.2004. He was examined in
chief on that day after closure of examination in chief the matter was posted
for cross examination. On 30.06.2005, on the prayer of the prosecution, the
witness was again recalled for further chief examination. On that day, P.W.1
has placed a letter alleged to have been written by accused to him, in which
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
some portion was typed by P.W.1, himself, showing amounts collected by the
accused but were not paid to P.W.1. Such document was marked as Ex.P9
with vehement objection.
10.
During cross examination, P.W.1 has admitted that at the time of filing
Ex.P1 i.e., complaint, the document was under his possession but it was not
filed. He also admitted that he has not placed Ex.P9 to the Police during his
examination under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and it was first time filed before the
Court during trial. The entire factum of submission of Ex.P9 as well as the
contents thereon appears and the recording of the learned trial Court proves
that Ex.P9, which alleged to have been written by the accused, was never
investigated by the Police during course of investigation. Ex.P9 is an alien
document to the criminal investigation as well as criminal trial of the instant
case which was filed suddenly during course of trial. In my view, learned Court
below had two options after receiving such document; either Court should not
mark the document as exhibit, Court may refer the document for further
investigation of the Police. The learned trial Court has not opted any option
but only marked the document as exhibit. Moreover, during passing the
Judgment and recording the conviction, the learned trial Court has placed
reliance upon the said Ex.P9 by holding that it was written by accused. The
hand writing of the accused was not admitted by the accused during trial.
Moreover, it was never proved that it was written by the accused. The
observation of the learned trial Court regarding Ex.P9 appears to me illegal
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
and faulty one. The learned trial Court without having proper investigating the
document Ex.P9 should not have relied it. On that, the procedure of trial
conducted by the learned trial Court appears to me caused prejudice to the
accused, so that he has no scope to defend against Ex.P9.
11.
Going through the merit of in this matter, it appears that the prosecution
has to prove in this case that the petitioner, being the accused and agent of
P.W.1, has misappropriated huge amount of money. P.Ws.2 to 4 have
deposed that they have given entire amount through invoices to accused but
such money was not remitted to P.W.1. It is admitted fact that transaction
between P.W.1 and accused was without receipt. When a transaction through
an agent or clerk of an employer is without receipt, for proving such
misappropriation account books and copy of relevant invoices are necessary
documents. Admittedly, in this case, account book of P.W.1 was not examined
or was not placed. Merely deposition or statement of P.W.1 is not sufficient to
prove the accusation against the accused that he has misappropriated the
huge amount of money. In this case, there are specific invoices which were
issued in favour of P.Ws.2 to 4 and if such invoices were issued, the accounts
should have mention regarding such invoices and if the investigation was
conducted over the account book, the payment of such invoices would be
revealed. Such investigation was not conducted. Reasons thereby, the mere
allegation of P.W.1, which was supported by P.Ws.2 to 4 against the accused,
does not itself prove misappropriation of money.
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
12.
Under the above observation, recording of conviction and sentence by
the learned trial Court as well as learned appellant Court appears to me not in
conformity with the practices and procedures of criminal trial as mentioned
herein above. Accordingly, the prosecution has failed to bring home the
charge against the present petitioner. Thus, the order of conviction and
sentence is hereby set aside.
13.
Accordingly, the instant criminal revision case is allowed.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
_______________________
SUBHENDU SAMANTA, J
Date:01.04.2026
JLV
SS,J
Crl.R.C.No.1197 of 2008
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 1197/2008
Date:01.04.2026
JLV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review