Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.35734 of 2025
(In the matter of an application under Article 226 & 227 of the
Constitution of India)
Chief Engineer (Roads-1),
Bhubaneswar
…
Petitioner
…
Opposite Party
-versus-
M/s.NKC
Haryana
Projects
Pvt.
Ltd.,
Advocate(s) appeared in this case:For Petitioner
: Mr.U.R.Jena, AGA
For Opposite Party
: Mr.S.Dwibedi, Advocate
CORAM: JUSTICE B.P. ROUTRAY
JUDGMENT
16th April 2026
B.P. Routray, J.
1.
Present writ petition is directed against the order dated 8th July
2025 of the learned Commercial Court passed in ARBP No.76 of
2024.
2.
The facts of the case is that the present Petitioner, i.e. Chief
Engineer, DPI and Roads, Government of Odisha, while challenging
the arbitration award dated 8th May 2024 under Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act in ARBP No.76 of 2024, filed a
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
petition under Section 36(2) of the said Act for stay of enforcement of
the award pending application under Section 34 of the Act. Learned
Commercial Court granted stay of enforcement of the arbitration
award pending disposal of ARBP No.76 of 2024 subject to deposit of
the entire award amounting to Rs.26,97,43,880/-.
3.
The Chief Engineer, being the Petitioner in the present writ
petition, has challenged said order of the Court regarding direction for
deposit of the award amount as a condition for stay of enforcement of
the arbitration award. According to the Petitioner, he being an
authority under Government of Odisha, is not required to deposit
100% of the award amount on the ground that such award passed by
the arbitrator is erroneous one and in conflict with the public policy.
4.
In course of hearing, Mr.Jena, learned Additional Government
Advocate relies on a decision of this Court dated 9 th March 2026
passed in W.P.(C) No.30361 of 2025 to contend that, the Petitioner
being an authority under the Government of Odisha can be considered
under such exceptional cases as not mandatory on its part to deposit
the entire award amount keeping in view the nature of its solvency as
a Government authority. Mr. Jena further takes recourse to Rule 8-A
of Order 27 of the CPC in such matters for the purpose of Rule 5 of
Order 41 of the CPC.
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
5.
It is true that the Petitioner is the Chief Engineer (Roads-1) and
an authority of Government of Odisha. It is also true that taking such
position of the Petitioner as a Government Authority, he cannot be
considered as insolvent at any point of time requiring to deposit the
decreetal amount. But at the same time by looking to the writ petition,
it is seen that nothing has been mentioned in the writ petition in this
regard leading exemption of the Petitioner from depositing the award
amount as per the direction of learned Court. Rather it is mentioned at
paragraph-8 of the writ petition that for lack of budget provision, it is
not possible on the part of the present Petitioner to deposit the entire
award amount as directed by the learned Court. The relevant
averments made in the writ petition at paragraph-8 are reproduced
below:
“8.
That it is humbly submitted that the ARBP No.76
of 2024, which has been filed against the award dated
08.05.2024 (under Annexure-2) is pending for final
disposal and due to sanction of funds and the same not
being in the outcome budget 2025-26, it could not
possible on the part of the present petitioner to comply
the impugned award dated 08.05.2024 (under Annexure2). .. .. ..”
6.
It is thus clear from such averment taken in the writ petition that
the Petitioner is unable to deposit the award amount despite the
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
direction of learned Court. In such situation, it cannot be contended on
the part of the Petitioner that he being a Government authority is not
required to be directed to deposit the award amount as a condition to
stay enforcement of arbitration award in terms of Section 36(2) of the
Act. As seen from the aforesaid statements made by the Petitioner, it
is impossible on his part to deposit the award amount as per the
direction of the learned Court.
7.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Hindustan
Construction Co. and another vs. Union of India and others, (2020)
17 SCC 324, have observed that, the language of Section 36 of the
Arbitration Act does not warrant an automatic stay on the enforcement
of an arbitral award due to mere filing of Section 34 petition.
8.
Section 36(3) of the Arbitration Act prescribes that the court
may grant stay, upon such an application being filed, subject to such
conditions as it may deem fit. So in terms of Section 36(3), the court
is conferred with the discretionary power to grant stay of an arbitral
award. Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pam Developers Private Limited
vs. State of West Bengal, (2019) 8 SCC 112, had the occasion to
consider the nature of applicability of provisions of the Code of Civil
Procedure vis-à-vis the proceedings under the Arbitration Act and
specifically, the interpretation of the phrase “due regard” appearing
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
in the first proviso. The Respondent therein had preferred an
application seeking an unconditional stay of the arbitral award on the
strength of Order 27 Rule 8-A of the C.P.C and the Calcutta High
Court allowed the prayer for unconditional stay. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court allowed the appeal and directed for deposit of the
award amount as a condition for continuing the stay and reasoned that
the exemption from furnishing the security as per the provisions in
Rule 8-A of Order 27 of the C.P.C. could not be strictly applied to the
arbitration proceeding and further stated that even if the exemption
from furnishing the security was made applicable to the arbitration
proceeding, such exemption would not extent from making deposit of
the award amount. The Hon’ble Supreme Court have observed as
follows:“22. Even otherwise a plain reading of Order 27 Rule 8-A CPC
would make it clear that the same is only regarding security as
mentioned in Rules 5 and 6 of Order 41 CPC, which is not to
be demanded from the Government while considering the stay
application filed by the Government. It, however, does not
provide that the decretal amount cannot be required to be
deposited in the appeal against a money decree.
xx
xx
xx
24. Further, it is to be noticed that Order 27 Rule 8-A CPC was
inserted in 1937 when the British Crown was ruling our
country. The same was brought in during the period of British
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
Raj to protect the interest of the then Government (Crown).
While considering a case where the State of West Bengal was
carrying on trade as owner and occupier of a market in
Calcutta (now Kolkata) without obtaining a licence as required
under Section 218 of the Calcutta Municipal Act, 1951, a
Constitution Bench of this Court in Supt. and Remembrancer
of
Legal
Affairs
v. Corpn.
of Calcutta [Supt.
and
Remembrancer of Legal Affairs v. Corpn. of Calcutta, (1967) 2
SCR 170 : AIR 1967 SC 997 : 1967 Cri LJ 950] considered the
question as to whether this Court should adopt the rule of
construction accepted by the Privy Council in interpreting
statute vis-à-vis the Crown and held that: (AIR p. 1001, para
23)
“23. … There are many reasons why the said rule of
construction is inconsistent with and incongruous in
the present set-up where we have no Crown, the
archaic rule based on the prerogative and perfection
of the Crown has no relevance to a democratic
republic; it is inconsistent with the rule of law based
on the doctrine of equality.”
25. In our considered view, the provision which was
incorporated in the year 1937 during the British Raj, giving
certain safeguards to the Government (which was then the
British Crown) would not be applicable in today's time, when
we have a democratic Government.
26. Arbitration proceedings are essentially alternate dispute
redressal system meant for early/quick resolution of disputes
and in case a money decree — award as passed by the
arbitrator
against
the
Government
is
allowed
to
be
automatically stayed, the very purpose of quick resolution of
dispute through arbitration would be defeated as the decreeWPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
holder would be fully deprived of the fruits of the award on
mere filing of objection under Section 34 of the Arbitration
Act. The Arbitration Act is a special Act which provides for
quick resolution of disputes between the parties and Section 18
of the Act makes it clear that the parties shall be treated with
equality. Once the Act mandates so, there cannot be any
special treatment given to the Government as a party. As such,
under the scheme of the Arbitration Act, no distinction is made
nor any differential treatment is to be given to the Government,
while considering an application for grant of stay of a money
decree in proceedings under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act.
As we have already mentioned above, the reference to CPC in
Section 36 of the Arbitration Act is only to guide the court as
to what conditions can be imposed, and the same have to be
consistent with the provisions of the Arbitration Act.
27. It may be true that CPC provides for a differential
treatment to the Government in certain cases, but the same
may not be so applicable while considering a case against the
Government under the Arbitration Act. For instance, Section
80 CPC provides for a notice of two months to be given before
any suit is instituted against the Government. Further, it also
provides that no ex parte injunction order can be passed against
the Government. Whereas on the other hand, under the
Arbitration Act no such special provision has been made with
regard to arbitration by or against the Government. There is no
requirement under the Arbitration Act for a notice of two
months to be given to the Government before invoking
arbitration proceeding against the Government. Further,
Sections 9 and 17 of the Arbitration Act also provide for grant
of ex parte interim orders against the Government.
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
28. Section 36 of the Arbitration Act also does not provide for
any special treatment to the Government while dealing with
grant of stay in an application under proceedings of Section 34
of the Arbitration Act. Keeping the aforesaid in consideration
and also the provisions of Section 18 providing for equal
treatment of parties, it would, in our view, make it clear that
there is no exceptional treatment to be given to the
Government while considering the application for stay under
Section 36 filed by the Government in proceedings under
Section 34 of the Arbitration Act.
29. Although we are of the firm view that the archaic Rule 8-A
of Order 27 CPC has no application or reference in the present
times, we may only add that even if it is assumed that the
provisions of Order 27 Rule 8-A CPC are to be applied, the
same would only exempt the Government from furnishing
security, whereas under Order 41 Rule 5 CPC, the Court has
the power to direct for full or part deposit and/or to furnish
security of the decretal amount. Rule 8-A only provides
exemption from furnishing security, which would not restrict
the Court from directing deposit of the awarded amount and
part thereof.
30. For the foregoing reasons, we are of the opinion that the
impugned order passed by the Calcutta High Court granting
unconditional stay of the arbitration award dated 21-1-2010,
cannot be sustained in the eye of the law. Accordingly, we
allow these appeals and quash the order dated 13-12-2018
[State of W.B. v. Pam Development (P) Ltd., 2018 SCC
OnLine Cal 14141] passed by the Calcutta High Court and
restore the order dated 3-10-2018 of the executing court passed
in Pam Development (P) Ltd. v. State of W.B. [Pam
Development (P) Ltd. v. State of W.B., 2018 SCC OnLine Cal
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
14139] As already directed by order dated 3-10-2018 [Pam
Development (P) Ltd. v. State of W.B., 2018 SCC OnLine Cal
14139] , it shall be open for the petitioner award-holder to pray
for release of the attached amount.”
9.
In Lifestyle Equities C.V. and another vs. Amazon
Technologies Inc., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2153, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court by taking note of various earlier decisions have held as
follows:“134. We summarize our final conclusion on the grant of
benefit of stay of execution of a decree by an appellate court in
term of Order XLI as under:—
(I) Order XLI Rule 5 contains the provision for the grant or
refusal of stay of execution of the decree by the appellate court
under the CPC. It categorically stipulates that mere filing of an
appeal against an order of execution, shall not ipso facto
operate as stay of proceedings. Any execution proceeding or an
order therein, shall be stayed only if a specific, reasoned order
granting such stay is passed by the appellate court, after proper
application of mind.
(II) For the grant of stay of execution of a decree in terms of
Order XLI, a prayer to such effect has to be specifically made
to the appellate court and the appellate court has the discretion
to grant an order of stay or to refuse the same.
(III) Order XLI Rule 5(3) of the CPC provides for satisfaction
regarding sufficient cause as a pre-condition for granting
benefit of stay of execution of decree, and it casts an obligation
upon the appellate court to record its satisfaction for stay of
execution such decree.
(IV) The power of the Appellate Court to order stay of
execution of the decree is circumscribed and made subject to
the existence of a “sufficient cause” in favour of the appellant
being shown. In order to ascertain whether a “sufficient cause”
exists for the grant of stay of execution of a decree under Order
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
XLI of the CPC, the appellate court as per sub-rule (3) of Rule
5 is required to examine:—
(i) Whether there will be substantial loss to the party
applying for stay;
(ii) Whether the application has been made without
unreasonable delay; and
(iii) Whether security has been given by the applicant for
due performance of the decree.
(V) For the grant of stay of execution of the decree, the
appellate court is required, after perusing the materials on
record, to assign reasons for its satisfaction regarding the
existence of a “sufficient cause”. Such reasons should be
cogent and adequate. The reasons assigned must indicate the
necessity for the status quo prevailing on the date of the decree
and/or the date of making of the application for stay, to
continue by granting stay, and not merely the reasons why stay
should be granted.
(VI) Although, Order XLI Rule 5 of the CPC, uses the word
“shall”, yet a combined reading of the sum and substance of
Rule(s) 1(3) and 5(5) would reveal, that for the grant of stay of
execution, it is not mandatory for the appellate court to impose
a condition for deposit of the amount in dispute. The aforesaid
provisions make it abundantly clear that the appellate court, for
the grant of stay of execution, has a discretion to impose a
condition of deposit of the amount depending on the facts and
circumstances of each case.
(VII) A deposit is not a condition precedent for an order of stay
of execution of the decree by the appellate court. The only
guiding factor and statutory mandate, for the grant of such stay
of execution as indicated in Rule 5, is the existence of
“sufficient cause” in favour of the appellant, on the availability
of which the appellate court would be inclined to pass an order
of stay.
(VIII) For the grant of benefit of an unconditional stay of
execution of a decree, an exceptional case has to be made out
before the appellate court. This discretion of the appellate court
to grant an unconditional stay of execution of decree must not
be exercised arbitrarily. It must be exercised sparingly and
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
only if an exceptional case is made out for such stay in view of
the peculiar facts and attending circumstances of the case
before it.
(IX) A lodestar for bringing a case within the purview of
“exceptional case” for the purpose of granting benefit of
unconditional stay of the execution of money decree by the
appellate court would be, if the money decree in question: (i) is egregiously perverse;
(ii) is riddled with patent illegalities;
(iii) is facially untenable; and/or
(iv) such other exceptional causes similar in nature.
(X) For the purpose of the grant or refusal of stay of execution
of the decree under Rule 5 of Order XLI, it is immaterial
whether the decree is a money decree or any other decree. The
language couched in the said provision is very clear. Order
XLI, Rule 5 of the makes no distinction between a money
decree and other decrees, and the said provision applies with
full rigour in both instances. Yet as a rule of prudence and
established practice evolved over a period of time, no stay of
execution of a money decree should be granted, except on the
condition that the decretal amount be deposited in the court.
However, such condition for deposit cannot be said to be
mandatory and non-prescription thereof does not operate as a
bar to staying the execution of a money decree.
(XI) There is no provision under Order XLI Rule 5 of the CPC
imposing a mandate to deposit cash security as the only mode
of security for execution of the decree. Security, for the
purpose of the said provision, can be in the shape of property,
bond and or in the form of an appropriate undertaking from the
appellant to abide by the decree, seeking stay of execution.”
10.
In the facts of present case as narrated above, nothing is found
to support the contentions of the Petitioner for his entitlement to an
unconditional stay. Apart from this, the facts of present case are quite
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
different from facts in W.P.(C) No.30361 of 2025 and judgment dated
9th March 2026, which is taken as a support by Mr. Jena, learned
counsel for the Petitioner to contend for exemption from depositing
the award amount. In the said case, the deposited amount was in
respect of the interest only of the award amount. But it is never shown
in the present case and thus keeping in view the averments made at
paragraph 8 of the writ petition (reproduced above), a series of doubt
is raised on the conduct of the Petitioner regarding his capacity to
deposit the award amount as per the direction of the learned court and
so it is required on the part of the Petitioner to comply the direction of
the learned court dated 8th July 2025. Further as discussed above, the
contention of the Petitioner to take benefits of the provisions of Order
27 Rule 8-A of the C.P.C. in its application to the provisions of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act does not bear any force in view of
the position of law settled in Pam Developers (supra). No such
exceptional case, in terms of the principles laid down in Lifestyle
Equities C.V. (supra), is found to support the contention of the
Petitioner for grant of unconditional stay of the execution proceeding
nor anything is found which is egregiously perverse or riddled with
patent illegality or facially untenable or such other exceptional cause
WPC No.35734 of 2025
Digitally Signed
Signed by: CHITTA RANJAN BISWAL
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack.
Date: 22-Apr-2026 17:41:24
of similar nature to exercise discretion of the court for grant of
unconditional stay without depositing the award amount.
11.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed and the direction for
deposit of 100% of the award amount as directed by the learned court
in the impugned order dated 8th July 2025 is confirmed.
( B.P. Routray)
Judge
C.R.Biswal, A.R.-cum-Sr.Seretary
WPC No.35734 of 2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review