The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. 2. Since without following the provisions contained that under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 and without conducting any enquiry, the proceeding has been disposed of vide the impugned order dtd.23.05.2018 and Petitioner is going without his retiral benefits for the last 15 (fifteen) years, this Court is inclined to quash the impugned order. While quashing order dtd.23.05.2018 so passed by Opposite Party No.1 under Annexure-6, this Court directs Opposite Party No.1 to release all the retiral // 10 // benefits as due and admissible to the Petitioner within a period of four (4) months from the date of receipt of this order. However, it is observed that failure to pay the retiral benefits as directed within the aforesaid period will entail the Petitioner to get interest @ 6% p.a. on his entitlements all through.
8. Accordingly, the Writ Petition stands disposed of. (Biraja Prasanna Satapathy) Judge Orissa High Court, Cuttack Dated the 25th February, 2026/Subrat Reason: Authentication Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.37227 of 2023
In the matter of an application under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India.
………………
….
Chhabi Behera
Petitioner
-versus….
State of Odisha & Others
For Petitioner
:
For Opp. Parties :
Opposite Parties
Mr. S. Mallik, Advocate
Mr. P.P. Behera, ASC
PRESENT:
THE HONBLE JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
----------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing:25.02.2026 and Date of Judgment:25.02.2026
----------------------------------------------------------------------------Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1.
This
matter
is
taken
up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties.
3.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer:“Under the aforesaid facts and circumstances the
petitioner humbly prays that this Hon’ble Court may
graciously be pleased to,
1. Quash the impugned order dtd.23.05.2018 as at
Annexure-6.
// 2 //
2. Direct/order that the pension and gratuity shall be
released in favour of the petitioner within a stipulated
period with admissible interest thereon.
3. Pass such other order(s) / direction(s) as may be
deemed fit and proper in the bona fide interest of
justice”.
4.
It is contended that Petitioner while in service, the
proceeding under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962
(in
short
‘Rules’)
was
initiated
against
him
vide
Memorandum dtd.06.05.2003 under Annexure-1 with the
following charges:ANNEXURE-I
“Article of Charges:- During the incumbency of Sri
Chhabi Behera as COD, Nuapada, it is revealed from
the report of the Collector, Nuapada and aporoved
special aduit report on the accounts of Sri Nrusingha
Charan Jena, Ex-M.I. of Sinapali Block of Nuapda
District Departmental Storage Centre, Sinapli for the
period from September, 2001 to August 2002, that Sri
Nrusingha Charan Jena, Marketing Inspector, Sinapali
Block have misappropriated Q.14661.50 of B.P.L. rice
Q.1434.87 of Levy Sugar Q.201.30 of Annapurna rice
and Q.2462.25 of Antyodaya Anna Yojana rice amount
to Rs.15316241.85. Thus he is charged with negligence
in duty and lack of supervision.
ANNEXURE-II
Statement of Imputation of charges
Charge No.1 That during his incumbency of CSO-cumD.M. OSCSC Ltd.. Nuapada for the Period from
18.12.2001 to 18.7.2002 he did not submit tour
programme of tour diary regarding his toura. But on
verification of the log book of the office jeep it is seen
that he has visited Sinapali Block six times on dated
13.2.2002. 21.3.2002. 31.3.2002, 3.4.2002, 2.5.2002,
and 13,6,2002, but he has never submitted any report
or compliance regarding his visit and supervision of PDS
in Sinapalli. He has also not appraised his higher
authority regarding the function-ing of PDS in Sinapali
nlock, as he has not submitted his tour diaries, the very
purpose of visiting Sinapali Block by office Jeep does not
serve the interest of public.
// 3 //
He has mis-utilised the office vehicle for unprodu-ctive
works in abuse of powers, supervising negligence
failure the detect and prevent misappropriation of FDS
stock by M.I.
Charge No.2 The during his incumbency as c.5.0.-cumD.M..OSCSC Ltd.. Nuapada Sri N.C. Jena, M.I. Sinapali
got wide scope to misappropriate Q.14661.30 of BPL
rice Q.1434.02 of levy Sugar. 4.201.30 of Annapurna
rice Q.2462.25 Antyodaya Yojana 'rice amounting
3.15316241.85 dụe to his negligence and lack of supervision. As CSO-cum-D.M. he has never tried to review
and supervise the working of PDS in Sinapali Block for
months together. Because of his negligence in duty Sri
Jena Ex-M. I. continued his nefarious activities
unbatedly and misappropriated essential commodities
causing dislocation of the PDS in entire Sinapali Block.
This shows his gross supervisory
discharging Government duties.
negligence
in
Charge No.3
That, the Collector Nuapada has passed marginal order
on the report of the Sub-Collector, Nuapada to ask the
Sub-Collector, Nuapada to submit the draft charges
against Sri N.C. Jena, M.I., Sinapali Block and he has
perused the letter on 11.6.2002. But being a responsible
Government servant he did not by their to take any
action in the matter. It tentamounts to disobedience of
orders of higher authority, in contravention of rule-4, of
Government servant conduct Rules 1962.
Charge No.4
That during his tenure as CSO-cum-D. M. Nuapda
he is not conducted monthly physical verification of
storage events, D.S. Depot, Kerosene wholesalers/subwholesaler, Miller events which is his first and for most
duties, particularly, in checking of storage go down at
Sinapali led
to
misappropriation
of
essential
commodities and dislocation of public distribution
system for which highly subsidized rice stock by not at
all reached to the poor beneficiaries.
This shows his gross of negligence in duties and
misconduct.
ANNEXURE-III
Memo of Evidence
// 4 //
1. Log Book of the office Jeep bearing No. OR02K-2924
for the period from 13.2.2002 to 13.6.02.
2. Audit Report No. 28640 dt. 20.12.2002.
3. Letter No.175 dated 3.6.2002 of the Collector,
Nuapada. Eye of Witness
1.
Sri Bishnu Charan Das, Auditor, F.S. & C.W.
Department”.
4.1.
It is contended that Petitioner filed his written
statement of defence to the charges on 05.12.2003 under
Annexure-2.
4.2.
a
It is also contended that prior to initiation of such
proceeding,
Petitioner
who
was
placed
under
suspension vide order dtd.25.09.2002 under Annexure-3
was
reinstated
vide
order
dtd.30.09.2004
under
Annexure-4.
4.3.
It is further contended that after such initiation of
the
proceeding
on
06.05.2003,
vide
office
order
dtd.24.09.2003, Commissioner of Departmental Enquiry
of the G.A Department was appointed as the enquiry
officer to enquire into the charges so framed against the
Petitioner. However on the face of such appointment of
the enquiry officer vide order dtd.24.09.2003, no enquiry
was ever conducted.
Accordingly, after about 12 years
and vide office order dtd.28.04.2016, Officer on Special
Duty-cum-Deputy Secretary of the Department was
appointed as the Enquiry Officer by Opposite Party No.1
to be the disciplinary authority.
// 5 //
4.4.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
Petitioner
contended that on such appointment of a fresh Enquiry
Officer vide office order dtd.28.04.2016, Petitioner at no
point of time was issued with the notice to appear before
the Enquiry Officer.
However, the enquiry officer so
appointed vide office order dtd.28.04.2016, submitted the
enquiry report on 19.12.2016 and basing on such report,
Petitioner was issued with the 1st show cause vide notice
dtd.31.12.2003. It is however fairly contended that
Petitioner could not make any reply to the 1st show cause
so issued on 31.12.2016.
4.5.
It is however contended that without issuing the
2nd show cause proposing the punishment in terms of the
provisions contained under Rule-15(10)(i)(b) of the Rules,
Petitioner was imposed with the punishment vide the
impugned order dtd. 23.05.2018 under Annexure-6. Vide
the said order, punishment so proposed in the 2nd show
cause was imposed on the Petitioner.
4.6.
While assailing the impugned order of punishment,
learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended
that since after appointment of the 2nd enquiry officer
vide
order
conducted
dtd.28.04.2016,
prior
to
no
submission
enquiry
was
ever
of
report
on
the
19.12.2016, basing on such report, Petitioner could not
have been issued with the 1st and thereafter the 2nd show
cause under Rule-15(10)(i)(a) &(b) of the Rules proposing
the punishment, if any. Rule-15(10)(i)(b) of the Rules
reads as follows:Page 5 of 10
// 6 //
“15(10)((i)(b)- On receipt of the representation referred to
in Sub-clause (a) the disciplinary authority having regard
to the findings on the charges, is of the opinion that nay
of the penalties specified in Clauses (vi) to (ix0 of Rule 13
should be imposed, he shall furnish to the delinquent
Government servant a statement of its findings along
with brief reasons for disagreement, if any, with the
findings of the inquiring officer and give him a notice by
Registered post or otherwise stating the penalty proposed
to be imposed on him and calling upon him to submit
within a specified time such representation as he may
wish to make against the proposed penalty.
Provided that in every case in which it is necessary to
consult the Commission under the provision of the
Constitution of India and the Orissa Public Service
Commission (Limitation of Functions) Regulation, 1989
the record of Inquiry together with a copy of the notice
given under Sub-clause(1) and the representation if any,
received within the specified time in response to such
notice shall be forwarded by the disciplinary authority to
the Commission for its advice”
4.7.
It
is
accordingly
contended
that
since
after
appointment of the 2nd enquiry officer vide office order
dtd.28.04.2016, no enquiry was ever conducted, relying
on the enquiry report dtd.19.12.2016 punishment in
question
could
impugned
order
not
have
been
dtd.23.05.2018
imposed,
under
vide
the
Annexure-6.
Hence the same is not sustainable in the eye of law and it
requires interference of this Court.
4.8.
It is further contended that because of the
pendency of the proceeding since 06.05.2003, Petitioner
though has retired from his services on attaining the age
of superannuation on 30.04.2008, but till date he has not
yet been released with his retiral benefits, save and
except the provisional pension.
// 7 //
4.9.
It is also contended that Petitioner because of such
un-due harassment, has lost his mental balance and is
not in a position to give any further instruction in the
matter.
5.
Mr. P.P. Behera, learned Addl. Standing Counsel
basing on the stand taken in the counter affidavit when
supported the impugned order, this Court passed the
following order on 08.09.2025:“1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2.
Heard.
3.
Considering the nature of order passed by this
Court on 06.03.2025, learned Addl. Government
Advocate is directed to produce the proceeding file on
the next date positively.
4.
As requested, list this matter in the week
commencing 13.10.2025”
6.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order, learned ASC
produced the relevant proceeding file of the Petitioner in
Court. This Court after going through the proceeding file
finds
that
after
initiation
of
the
proceeding
vide
Memorandum dtd.06.05.2003, Petitioner filed the written
statement of defence on 05.12.2003. But prior to filing of
the
written
statement
of
defence,
vide
order
dtd.24.09.2003, Commissioner for Departmental Enquiry
was appointed as the Enquiry Officer to enquire into the
charges and submit his report. However, no enquiry
report was submitted by the Enquiry Officer so appointed
vide order dtd.24.09.2003. Opposite Party No.1 being the
disciplinary authority appointed Officer on Special duty –
// 8 //
cum-Deputy Secretary of the Department as Enquiry
Officer vide order dtd.28.04.2016.
6.1. This Court after going through the file finds that
after his appointment as the Enquiry Officer vide order
dtd.28.04.2016, Petitioner has not been issued with any
notice for his appearance before the Enquiry Officer. But
basing
on
the
enquiry
report
so
submitted
on
19.12.2016, Petitioner was issued with the 1st show
cause on 31.12.2016, which was served on him on
07.02.2017.
6.2.
Since Petitioner could not any reply to the 1st show
cause, 2nd show cause was issued to him vide notice
dtd.27.05.2017,
proposing
the
punishment
of
withholding of pension permanently, withholding of
gratuity in full and to treat the period of suspension as
such. Such 2nd show cause issued on 27.05.2017
proposing the punishment after being confirmed by the
Orissa
Public
dtd.13.03.2018,
Service
Commission
Petitioner
was
imposed
vide
with
letter
the
punishment so proposed in the 2nd show cause vide the
impugned order dtd.23.05.2018 under Annexure-6.
7.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
Parties and considering the submissions made, since this
Court after going through the proceeding file finds that
after appointment of the 2nd enquiry officer vide order
dtd.28.04.2016, Petitioner was never noticed to appear
before the Enquiry Officer nor any enquiry was held to
// 9 //
prove
the
submitted
charges,
basing
on
by
Enquiry
Officer
the
the
enquiry
on
report
19.12.2016,
Petitioner could not have been issued with the 1st and
thereafter the 2nd show cause proposing the punishment,
if any.
Since no enquiry was never conducted in
accordance with law, basing on the enquiry report
dtd.19.12.2016 under Annexure-5, Petitioner could not
have been imposed with any punishment vide the
impugned order dtd.23.05.2018 under Annexure-6.
7.1.
Even though learned ASC made a submission to
remit the matter for fresh disposal from the stage of
appointment of the enquiry officer so made vide order
dtd.28.04.2016, but this Court taking into account the
fact that the proceeding is of the year 2003 and Petitioner
has since retired w.e.f. 30.04.2008 is not in favour of
remitting the matter for fresh disposal in accordance with
law.
Not only that the enquiry of the matter has not yet
commenced, even though the proceeding has been
initiated since 06.05.2003.
7.2.
Since without following the provisions contained
that under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 and
without conducting any enquiry, the proceeding has been
disposed of vide the impugned order dtd.23.05.2018 and
Petitioner is going without his retiral benefits for the last
15 (fifteen) years, this Court is inclined to quash the
impugned order.
While quashing order dtd.23.05.2018
so passed by Opposite Party No.1 under Annexure-6, this
Court directs Opposite Party No.1 to release all the retiral
// 10 //
benefits as due and admissible to the Petitioner within a
period of four (4) months from the date of receipt of this
order.
However, it is observed that failure to pay the
retiral benefits as directed within the aforesaid period will
entail the Petitioner to get interest @ 6% p.a. on his
entitlements all through.
8.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition stands disposed of.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated the 25th February, 2026/Subrat
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBRAT KUMAR BARIK
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Mar-2026 11:02:34
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review