Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR-9530-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CR-9530-2025
Date of decision : 24.02.2026
CHARAN SINGH
....Petitioner
Versus
MAHABIR SINGH ETC.
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PANKAJ JAIN
Present :
Mr. Ritesh Aggarwal, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Naveen S. Panwar, DAG, Haryana.
Mr. Rakesh Dhiman, Advocate for
respondents No.10, 23 and 24.
Mr. Amit Jain, Advocate
for the respondent(s).
PANKAJ JAIN, J. (ORAL)
Present revision petition is directed against orders passed by the
Courts below dismissing the application filed under Order XXXIX Rules 1
and 2 CPC by the petitioner/plaintiff.
2.
The plaintiff filed suit seeking partition with the consequential
relief of permanent injunction and mandatory injunction. Along with the
suit, an application was filed under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC
seeking interim injunction against defendants No.1 to 25 in form of restrain
order to injunct them from raising construction during the pendency of the
suit.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
3.
Defendants No.1 to 9, 11 to 18, 22, 26 and 27 contested the suit.
In reply to the application filed under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 CPC, it
was claimed that the estate already stands partitioned in the year 1999. All
co-sharers including the plaintiff are in possession of their respective shares.
Plaintiff has already raised construction over his share in the suit property
and thus he has no locus to seek injunction against the defendants.
4.
Defendants No.10, 23 to 25 suffered statement pleading no
objection to grant of status quo.
5.
Trial Court dismissed the application filed under Order XXXIX
Rule 1 and 2 CPC holding that as per the pleaded case of the plaintiff, the
parties are co-sharers. The jointness of the property being admitted, the
plaintiff has failed to prove prima facie case and the same is covered against
him in view of the Division Bench judgment of this Court rendered in the
case of Bachan Singh vs. Swaran Singh, 2000 (3) RCR Civil 70.
6.
The aforesaid findings and the order passed by the Court of the
First Instance stand affirmed by the Appellate Court.
7.
Mr. Aggarwal, counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff has assailed
the orders passed by the Courts below. He submits that even though the
partition proceedings are pending before the Revenue Court as well as in the
present suit, yet in order to derive unlawful benefits, the defendants are
trying to construct the frontal portion of land which is of more value and the
same would cause irreparable loss to the plaintiff. He further submits that
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
defendants have leased out portion of their land in favour of defendants
No.26 and 27. Under the garb of lease deed, the lessees are being allowed to
raise construction. He submits that the Courts below have wrongly relied
upon dictum of law laid down in Bachan Singh’s case (supra) and have
ignored the ratio of law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of
Maharwal Khewaji Trust (Regd.), Faridkot vs. Baldev Dass, (2004) 8
SCC 488.
8.
Mr. Aggarwal further submits that the principle of law that
injunction cannot be granted against a co-sharer, is not absolute. If the acts
of a co-sharer are prejudicial or detrimental to the interest of other co-sharer
and the same has an effect of diminishing the value and utility of the
property, the other co-sharer is entitled for injunction. Reliance is being
placed upon ratio of law laid down in Mohan Lal vs. Preet Kumar,
2008(3) LandLR 41. He further submits that balance of convenience is in
favour of plaintiff. Granting liberty to raise construction to one of cosharers, shall create multiple litigation. He places reliance upon ratio of law
laid down in the case of Avtar Singh vs. Sukhwinder Singh and others,
2019(1) PLR 134. Further reliance is being placed upon Jaspal Kaur and
another vs. Harbans Singh and others, 2020 AIR CC 2933, Balbir Singh
vs. Lamber Singh, 2004(2) RCR(Civil) 843 and Ved Paul vs. Prakash
Chand and others – RSA-294-2007 decided on 28.09.2016.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
9.
Per contra, Mr. Jain submits that earlier the part of the suit
property in possession of the plaintiff, comprised in Khasra No.25/1, was
the only portion of joint land abutting the road.
The plaintiff raised
construction over his portion and was enjoying fruits of the construction.
Later on, subsequent to the acquisition of the land sector-road was carved
out. A a result thereof, portion of the land comprised in Khasra No.4/1/1
and 5/1/2/1 which was in possession of the defendants/respondents has now
abuts sector road. Defendants raised construction. Plaintiff under the garb
of the present suit, is trying to obstruct the fruits of the land belonging to the
defendants. He further submits that even as per the case of the plaintiff the
partition proceedings are pending before the Revenue Court. Thus, any
construction raised during the pendency thereof has no effect on the rights of
the parties.
So has been observed by the Appellate Court. In order to
hammer-forth his contention, he relies upon ratio of law laid down in the
case of Vinod Kumar vs. Rajesh and others, 2024(3) PLR 425, Bachan
Singh vs. Swaran Singh, 2000(3) PLR 416, Mandali Ranganna vs. T.
Ramachandra, 2008 A.I.R. (SC) 2291, Gurnek Singh vs. Manjit Kaur
and others, 2000(3) PLR 154, Kehar Singh and others vs. Joginder Kaur
alias Jogindero and others, 2004 (3) R.C.R. (Civil) 37 and Sapna and
another vs. Phool Kumar and others, 2024(1) PLR 452.
10.
I have heard counsel for the parties and have carefully gone
through records of the case.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
11.
In order to decide upon application under Order XXXIX Rule 1
& 2 CPC, the case of applicant needs to be tested applying Tripod Test. The
Court is required to see:
(i)
whether the applicant has made out a prima facie case;
(ii)
balance of convenience of the parties; and
(iii)
whether denial of injunction would cause irreparable loss
to the applicant.
12.
The present case relates to dispute between co-sharers. Before
adverting to the facts of the present case, the settled legal proposition needs
to be perused.
13.
The Division Bench of this Court in the case of Sant Ram
Nagina Ram v. Daya Ram Nagina Ram, AIR 1961 Punjab 528, while
dealing with the rights of the co-owners in the joint property laid down the
following principles:
“(1)
A co-owner has an interest in the whole property and also in
every parcel of it.
(2)
Possession of the joint property by one co-owner is, in the
eye of law, possession of all even if all but one are actually out of
possession.
(3)
A mere occupation of a larger portion or even of an entire
joint property does not necessarily amount to ouster as the
possession of one is deemed to be on behalf of all.
(4)
The above rule admits of an exception when there is ouster
of a co-owner by another. Butt in order to negative the presumption
of joint possession on behalf of all, on the ground of ouster, the
possession of a co-owner must not only be exclusive but also
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
hostile to the knowledge of the other, as, when a co-owner openly
asserts his own title and denies that of the other.
(5)
Passage of time does not extinguish the right of the co-
owner who has been out of possession of the joint property except
in the event of ouster or abandonment.
(6)
Every co-owner has a right to use the joint property in a
husband-like manner not inconsistent with similar rights of other
co-owners.
(7)
Where a co-owner is in possession of separate parcels under
an arrangement consented to by the other co-owners, it is not open
to any one to disturb the arrangement without the consent of others
except by filing a suit for partition.
(8)
The remedy of a co-owner not in possession, or not in
possession of share of the joint property, is by way of a suit for
partition or for actual joint possession, but not for ejectment. Same
is the case where co-owner sets up an exclusive, title in himself.
(9)
Where a portion of the joint property is, by common
consent of the co-owners, reserves for a particular common
purpose, it cannot be diverted to an inconsistent user by a coowner; if he does so, he is liable to be ejected and the particular
parcel will be liable to be restored to its original condition. It is not
necessary in such a case to show that special damage has been
suffered.”
14.
The aforesaid principles were approved by Full Bench of this
Court in Bhartu vs. Ram Sarup, 1981 PLJ 204 observing as under:
“4.
The inter se rights and liabilities of the co-sharers were
settled by a Division Bench of this Court in a very detailed
judgment in Sant Ram Nagina Ram v. Daya Ram Nagina Ram,
AIR 1961 Pb. 528, and the following propositions, inter alia, were
settled :-
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
(1) A co-owner has an interest in the whole property and
also in every parcel of it.
(2) Possession of joint property by one co-owner, is in the
eye of law, possession of all even if all but one are actually
out of possession.
(3) A mere occupation of a larger portion or even of an
entire joint property does not necessarily amount to ouster
as the possession of one is deemed to be on behalf of all.
(4) The above rule admits of an exception when there is
ouster of a co-owner by another. But in order to negative
the presumption of joint possession on behalf of all, on the
ground of ouster, the possession of a co-owner must not
only be exclusive but also hostile to the knowledge of the
other as, when a co-owner openly asserts his own title and
denies that of the other.
(5) Passage of time does not extinguish the right of the coowner who has been out of possession of the joint property
except in the event of ouster or abandonment.
(6) Every co-owner has a right to use the joint property in a
husband like manner not inconsistent with similar rights of
other co-owners.
(7) Where a co-owner is in possession of separate parcels
under an arrangement consented by the other co-owners, it
is not open to any body to disturb the arrangement without
the consent of others except by filing a suit for partition.”
15.
The precise issue w.r.t. injunction against construction being
raised by a co-sharer was evaluated and analysed by Division Bench of this
Court in Banchan Singh case (supra) applying the approved test as laid
down in Sant Ram Nagina’s case (supra). The Division Bench observed as
under:
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
15. On a consideration of the judicial pronouncements on the
subject, we are of the opinion that :
(i) a co-owner who is not in possession of any part of the
property is not entitled to seek an injunction against another
co-owner who has been in exclusive possession of the
common property unless any act of the person in
possession of the property amounts to ouster, prejudicial or
adverse to the interest of co-owner out of possession.
(ii) Mere making of construction or improvement of, in, the
common property does not amount to ouster.
(iii) If by the act of the co-owner in possession the value or
utility of the property is diminished, then a co-owner out of
possession can certainly seek an injunction to prevent the
diminution of the value and utility of the property.
(iv) If the acts of the co-owner in possession are
detrimental to the interest of other co-owners, a co-owner
out of possession can seek an injunction to prevent such act
which is detrimental to his interest.
In all other cases, the remedy of the co-owner out of possession of
the property is to seek partition, but not an injunction restraining the coowner in possession from doing any act in exercise of his right to every
inch of it which he is doing as a co-owner.”
16.
Mr. Aggarwal is right in contending that a co-sharer cannot seek
injunction against the other co-sharer is not absolute rule and is subject to
just exceptions. The exceptions have been carved out by Division Bench in
the case of Bachan Singh (supra). Thus, the issue arises is:
“Whether raising of construction by a defendant amounts
to ouster of the plaintiff?”
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
17.
The issue has been answered by the Division Bench in Bachan
Singh’s case ibid against the plaintiff. There is no plea w.r.t. diminishing of
value or utility of property in the plaint. Thus, plaintiff has no prima facie
case in his favour.
18.
During the course of arguments, counsel for the petitioner has
admitted that the plaintiff is in possession of the construction raised over
Khasra No.25/1.
The same is in exclusive possession of the plaintiff.
Granting injunction against defendants will lead to a situation where a cosharer has been deprived from enjoying his estate even though the plaintiff
who seeks injunction is enjoying constructed portion in un-partitioned land
to the detriment of the other co-sharers.
In such a situation, it is hard to
hold that the balance of convenience lies in favour of the plaintiff. Rather, it
is a case where granting injunction against the defendants shall cause them
irreparable loss. Accordingly, this Court finds that the case of the plaintiff
fails on the touchstone of ‘Tripod test’. The Courts below thus rightly
declined to grant injunction in his favour.
18.1.
The only apprehension raised by Mr. Aggarwal is w.r.t. vesting
of right in the defendant if he is allowed to raise construction during the
pendency of the partition proceedings.
19.
In order to allay the said fear, this Court deems it appropriate to
observe that any construction raised shall not have an effect of vesting any
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CR-9530-2025
right in the parties. This observation shall operate qua whole construction
raised on joint land including that on Khasra No.25/1.
20.
With the aforesaid observation, the present petition is disposed
off.
February 24, 2026
Dpr
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.03.05 17:31
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether speaking/reasoned
:
Yes
Whether reportable
:
Yes
(Pankaj Jain)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review