Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
Crl. A. No. 13 of 2018
1.
Smt. Chandrawati Devi,
Wife of Late R.R. Prasad,
Resident of Bhanu Park Turning,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Santosh Prasad,
Son of Late R.R. Prasad,
Resident of Bhanu Park Turning,
Singtam, East Sikkim.
…
Appellants
…
Respondents
Versus
1.
Smt. Sharda Gupta,
Daughter of Shri Chandrika Sah,
Resident of Quarter No. 206,
Sector 3, R.K. Puram, New Delhi.
2.
Smt. Laxmi Sah,
Wife of Shri Chandrika Sah,
Resident of Quarter No. 206,
Sector 3, R.K. Puram, New Delhi.
3.
The State of Sikkim,
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
For the Appellants
:
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Ms. Panila Theengh,
Advocates.
For Respondents No. 1 :
and 2
Mr. N.B. Khatiwada, Senior Advocate and Ms.
Gita Bista, Legal Aid Counsel.
For Respondent No. 3
:
Mr. Santosh Kumar Chettri, Assistant Public
Prosecutor for the State of Sikkim.
Date of hearing
:
23.10.2019
Date of judgment
:
13.11.2019
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
JUDGMENT
(Arup Kumar Goswami, CJ)
Heard Mr. Jorgay Namka, learned counsel for the appellants,
Mr. N.B. Khatiwada, learned Senior Counsel for respondents nos.1 and
2 and Mr. Santosh Kumar Chettri, learned Assistant Public Prosecutor,
Sikkim for respondent no. 3.
2.
This
appeal
is
preferred
against
the
judgment
dated
03.04.2017 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class,
Chungthang
Sub-Division,
North
Sikkim
at
Gangtok
in
Private
Complaint Case No.08 of 2013 dismissing the complaint filed by the
appellants against the present respondents nos.1 and 2. Shri Chandrika
Sah, father of respondent no.1 and Shri Ankit Gupta, who is brother of
respondent no. 1 and son of respondent no.2, were also arrayed as
accused persons in the complaint. However, they were discharged by an
order dated 19.10.2015. Appellant no.1 is the mother of appellant no.2,
her son.
3.
The case set out in the complaint petition, in short, is that the
marriage between appellant no.2 with the present respondent no.1 was
solemnized on 30.04.2012 at Siliguri, West Bengal and marriage
reception function was held on 03.05.2012 at Singtam, East Sikkim. The
marriage was an arranged marriage and the process was initiated by
ShRi Chandrika Sah. The appellants had enquired about the education,
health and other related issues of respondent no.1 before finalizing the
engagement and they were informed that the respondent no.1 does not
suffer from any ailment and is in good health.
However, soon after
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
marriage, it became apparent that the respondent no.1 was not a
physically and mentally fit person even to undertake day to day chores
as a result of which they felt let down and betrayed at the concealment of
various ailments such as extreme case of Thyroid and Abscess from
which the respondent no.1 was suffering from prior to marriage. It also
came to light that the respondent no.1 was under regular supervision of
doctors at New Delhi. When confronted with the above revelation, the
respondent no.1 informed the appellant no.2 over telephone that the fact
of her true medical condition was not divulged as she had feared that if
the disclosure was made, the appellant no.2 would not marry her. It is
also stated in the complaint that the said conversation was recorded.
When questions were raised about the health issues pertaining to
respondent no.1, Shri Ankit Gupta came down to Singtam and took away
the respondent no.1 stating that she would be taken to New Delhi for her
treatment. Immediately on reaching New Delhi, the respondent no.1,
along with the other accused persons named in the complaint, started
threatening the complainants with dire consequences and not only that,
the respondent no.2 and the maternal aunt of the respondent no.1, with
the objective of ruining the marital relationship of the sister of appellant
no.2, namely, Smt. Asha Prasad, went to the place of her in-laws at
Chapra, Bihar and started complaining about the appellants to the
father-in-law of Smt. Asha Prasad. When Smt. Asha Prasad tried to
intervene in the matter, she was threatened, abused and insulted in
presence of her father-in-law and others. It is stated that a complaint
was also lodged against the accused persons before the Officer inCharge, Singtam Police Station as well as State Women Commission at
Gangtok, besides issuing a legal notice dated 13.02.2013.
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
4.
On
the
basis
of
the
said
complaint,
Complaint
case
No.08/2013 was registered. Thereafter, on perusal of the complaint
petition along with the documents as well as considering the evidence
adduced by appellants as well as a witness, namely, Shri Sushil Lepcha,
under Section 202 Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, Cr.P.C),
the learned Magistrate took cognizance of the offences under Sections
406/418/506/34 of Indian Penal Code,1860 (for short, IPC) against all
the persons named in the complaint petition.
5.
Subsequently, after hearing the learned counsel for the
complainants as well as the accused persons, by an order dated
19.10.2015, while discharging accused no.2 and 4, namely, Shri
Chandrika Sah and Shri Ankit Gupta, substance of accusation was
prepared against accused Nos.1 and 3, namely, Smt. Sarada Gupta and
Smt. Laxmi Saha, who are respondents Nos.1 and 2 herein, under
Section 417/506/34 IPC.
6.
During trial, appellants examined four witnesses, namely,
appellant no.1, appellant no.2, Shri Sushil Lepcha and Smt. Asha
Prasad. In their examination under Section 313 Cr. P.C., the respondents
no.1 and 2 denied the allegations made against them. They also
examined themselves along with Shri Chandrika Sah and Shri Ankit
Gupta.
7.
On consideration of the materials on record and after hearing
the learned counsel for the parties, the learned trial court opined that the
complainants had failed to establish the ingredients of the offences under
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
Section 417/506/34 IPC against the respondents and accordingly, had
acquitted them.
8.
Mr. Jorgay Namka, learned Counsel for the appellants has
submitted that the learned Trial Court below erred in law as well as in
facts in acquitting the respondents and therefore, the impugned
judgment of acquittal is liable to be set aside and quashed. He has
submitted that the respondents had dishonestly concealed material facts
and intentionally deceived the appellant by not divulging the fact of the
respondent no.1 suffering from serious illness before the engagement
had taken place, that too, despite the fact that the appellants had sought
for details with regard to health conditions of the respondent no.1, and it
was only because of the fact that it was made to believe that the
respondent no.1 was not having any illness, the appellants had agreed to
solemnize the marriage of appellant no.2 with respondent no.1. He has
submitted that Exhibit-13, a legal notice issued on behalf of respondents
by way of a reply, clearly demonstrates that the respondent no.1 had a
pre-existing condition of Hypothyroidism. It is contended that respondent
no.1 had admitted vide Exhibit-A11 that before the marriage also she
had undergone test for Thyroid and therefore, the learned Trial Court
was clearly in error in acquitting the appellants of the offence of
cheating. He has also contended that learned Trial Court did not even
consider Exhibit-11, which is a CD, wherein conversation between the
appellant no.2 and respondent no.1, in which the respondent no.1 had
admitted that the pre-existing condition of Hypothyroidism had not been
disclosed on the apprehension that if the same had been disclosed the
appellant no.2 would not have consented to marry the respondent no.1,
was recorded. He also submitted that the respondent no.1 had also
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
disclosed to Dr. S. Sen about being under medication for Hypothyroidism
prior to marriage. However, this aspect of the matter was also not
considered by the learned Trial Court, he submits. He relies on a
decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India in the Case of Shafhi
Mohammad versus State of Himachal Pradesh, reported in (2018) 5 SCC
311.
9.
Mr. N.B Khatiwada, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
respondent no.1 & 2, on the other hand, contends that the appellants
had miserably failed to establish the ingredients of the offences alleged
and therefore, the learned Trial Court was wholly justified in acquitting
the respondents. He submits that no documentary evidence had been
placed on record by the appellants to demonstrate that respondent no.1
was suffering from Hypothyroidism prior to marriage. While admitting
that issues relating to education, health, etc. were discussed prior to
formalizing the engagement, as respondent no.1 was not suffering from
any disease including Hypothyroidism, it was so stated and therefore,
there was no suppression of any material fact. Appellants had merely
exhibited the CD without giving any transcription of the same and
therefore, the contents and authenticity of the CD are not proved and in
that view of the matter, there is no merit in the contention advanced that
non consideration of Exhibit-11 has vitiated the impugned judgment, he
submits. He also contends that there is no admission in Exhibit-13 that
the respondent no.1 was suffering from various illnesses prior to
marriage. With regard to Exhibit-A11, he has contended that a receipt for
thyroid test does not in any way establish that the respondent no.1 had
been suffering from Hypothyroidism. He has also submitted that no
reliance can be placed on the alleged disclosure of pre-existing medical
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
condition to Dr. S. Sen, as he was not examined. Mr. Khatiwada further
submitted that there is no acceptable evidence with regard to criminal
intimidation.
10.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for
the parties and have perused the materials on record.
11.
The substratum of the complaint case is that there was
dishonest concealment of pre-existing condition of Hypothyroidism
despite specific enquiries made and that the appellants were threatened
with dire consequences and with filing of false cases.
12.
Cheating is defined in Section 415 of the IPC which provides
as under:“415. Cheating.—Whoever, by deceiving any person, fraudulently or
dishonestly induces the person so deceived to deliver any property
to any person, or to consent that any person shall retain any
property, or intentionally induces the person so deceived to do or
omit to do anything which he would not do or omit if he were not so
deceived, and which act or omission causes or is likely to cause
damage or harm to that person in body, mind, reputation or
property, is said to “cheat”.
Explanation.—A dishonest concealment of facts is a deception
within the meaning of this section.”
13.
A perusal of Section 415 IPC goes to show that this Section
has two parts. While the first part of the definition relates to property,
the second part need not necessarily relate to property. While in the first
part, the person must “dishonestly” or “fraudulently” induce the
complainant to deliver any property, in the second part, the person
should “intentionally” induce the complainant to do or omit to do a thing.
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
In order to constitute the offence of cheating, the intention to deceive
should be in existence at the time when the inducement was given. The
explanation to the Section also provides that a dishonest concealment of
facts is a deception within the meaning of the Section. Section 417
provides that whoever cheats shall be punished with imprisonment of
either description for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine,
or with both.
14.
Criminal intimidation is defined under Section 503 IPC and
Section 506 IPC provides for punishment for criminal intimidation.
Section 503 IPC reads as follows:“503. Criminal intimidation.-Whoever threatens another with any
injury to his person, reputation or property, or to the person or
reputation of any one in whom that person is interested, with
intent to cause alarm to that person, or to cause that person to do
any act which he is not legally bound to do, or to omit to do any act
which that person is legally entitled to do, as the means of avoiding
the execution of such threat, commits criminal intimidation.
Explanation- A threat to injure the reputation of any deceased
person in whom the person threatened is interested, is within this
section.”
15.
In order to appreciate the contentions advanced in the light
of the legal provisions as noticed hereinabove, it will be apposite to,
broadly, take note of the evidence on record.
16.
In her evidence, the appellant no.1 stated that the accused
persons were introduced by her son-in-law Dr. S.B. Gupta by forwarding
an e-mail received from Shri Chandrika Sah to her younger son Shri
Ashok Prasad. The e-mail contained two attachments being the
photograph and bio-data of respondent no.1 and that being impressed by
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
the bio-data of respondent no.1, they wanted to consider the proposal for
marriage with appellant no.2, who is a B. Tech in Electrical and
Electronic Engineering and who was working on contractual temporary
basis in Aircel. A meeting was, accordingly, held on 10.02.2012 at the
Guest House of Central Water Commission, Tadong, which was attended
to by the prospective groom and bride along with their family members.
They had shared and exchanged information regarding education, health
and other issues and it was impressed upon by the accused persons that
the respondent no.1 was not under medication for any illness.
Accordingly, the appellants and their family members decided to hold an
engagement ceremony on 11.02.2012 at Gangtok and finally, marriage
was solemnized at Siliguri in between the appellant no.2 and the
respondent no.1 on 30.04.2012 and for the marriage ceremony, all
arrangements were made by the appellants in view of the request made
by Shri Chandrika Sah, the father of the prospective bride, as he was
based in New Delhi. The respondent no.1 was seemingly physically and
mentally unfit and was unable to perform day to day house hold work
which was noticed by all. The respondent no.1 was taken to New Delhi by
her father on 02.06.2012 to perform certain rituals. The appellant no.2
had also gone to New Delhi to bring back the respondent no.1 on
07.07.2012 and both of them came back together to Singtam on
12.07.2012. She started complaining of fatigue very frequently and had
developed abscess under her arm requiring immediate medical attention
and accordingly, she was taken to Medica North Bengal Clinic, Siliguri by
the appellant no.2 for treatment where she was attended to by Dr.
Shantanu Kar, who suggested surgery. She was also examined by
another Doctor, namely, Dr. S. Sen and during the course of interaction
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
with him, respondent no.1 disclosed that she had been a patient of
Hypothyroidism for last many years and was also under medication. She
had also disclosed about the irregular menstrual cycles she was suffering
from for many years. The test conducted showed her TSH (Thyroid
Stimulating Hormone) was 6.92 as against expected normal range of
0.27-4.2. One more Doctor, namely, Dr. V. Sarkar was also consulted to
manage her abscess. On being queried as to why the medical condition
existing prior to marriage was not disclosed, the respondent no.1 had
responded that she had apprehension that if the same was disclosed, the
appellant no.2 would not have married her. It was deposed by the
appellant no.1 that the foundation of marriage was laid by the accused
persons by concealing material facts and by resorting to falsehood and
misrepresentation with dishonest intention. On 12.9.2012, Shri Ankit
Gupta came to their residence and made a request to let the respondent
no.1 visit her uncle at Chapra. The request being acceded to, they left for
Chapra on 15.09.2012. It transpired that, thereafter, they had left for
New Delhi on 19.09.2012 and since then respondent no.1 had been
residing in New Delhi where she took treatment for her ailment of
Hypothyroidism at VMMC and Safdarjung Hospital. She had sent her
medical report of October, 2012 via e-mail which showed TSH value at
6.92 (Exhibit-9) and another report showing TSH level at 10.73 as on
05.10.2012. On receipt of the aforesaid reports, the appellant no.2 had
consulted
doctors
who
indicated
that
there
would
be
medical
complication during pregnancy and that the children born will have
physical as well as mental abnormality. When confronted with such
revelation, the respondent no.1 disclosed that she was apprehensive that
if her medical condition was disclosed, the appellant no.2 would not have
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
married her. Thereafter, the accused persons started threatening them
over telephone stating that false case of dowry and torture would be filed
against the appellants. The appellant no.1 also deposed in tune with the
statements made in the complaint petition regarding the visit to the
house of the father-in-law of Smt. Asha Prasad and what transpired
there. She also deposed that in a reply dated 21.03.2013, Exhibit-13,
sent through a lawyer, in response to a legal notice dated 13.02.2013
issued on behalf of the appellants, while leveling false allegations against
them it was admitted that the respondent no.1 had been suffering from
Hypothyroidism prior to her marriage,
17.
In her cross-examination, the appellant no.1 admitted that a
case under domestic violence and a case under Section 498 A IPC were
filed by respondent no.1 and that on 31.12.2012, the respondent no.1
had filed a complaint before Delhi Women Commission and that they
were asked to appear on 17.04.2013. She admitted in her crossexamination that they had not filed any medical documents to affirm that
there existed any pre-existing history of Thyroid before marriage. She,
however, denied the suggestion regarding demand of dowry and inflicting
of mental and physical torture on respondent no.1.
18.
The evidence of appellant no.2 is almost identical with the
evidence of appellant no.1. The cross-examination is also more or less on
the same lines. He admitted that the authenticity of the conversation
recorded in Exhibit-11 was not verified from the laboratory.
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
19.
In his evidence, Shri Sushil Lepcha, who is a friend of the
appellant no.2, had deposed that he had attended the marriage of
appellant no.2 and was aware that the appellants had made due
enquires about education, health and other related issues of respondent
no.1 before finalizing the marriage. After marriage whenever he visited
the house of the appellants, he found the respondent no.1 sick and
unwell and one day he had seen the brother of respondent no.1 taking
her away with luggage. He was also told by the appellant no.2 that his
in-laws had committed breach of trust by concealing the ailment of the
respondent no.1 and that the accused persons were consistently
threatening them with filing of false criminal cases against them.
20.
The evidence of Smt. Asha Prasad is also more or less in the
same line as that of appellant nos.1 and 2. In addition, she had deposed
that her father who retired from service as Headmaster passed away in
the year 2006. She is a permanent employee of Sikkim Government being
a Graduate Teacher (Science). It is stated that before marriage when
specific information regarding education, health and other related issues
of the respondent no.1 was sought for, they were informed that
everything about her health was good and she was not under any
medication for any illness and on the basis of such positive assertion
only, marriage was solemnized. Immediately after the marriage, it was
found that she was physically unfit and was unable to perform simple
tasks and without make-up she appeared to be pale. The subject of her
illness was brought to the notice of father of the respondent no.1, when
he had visited them to take respondent no.1 to New Delhi and even then
he had assured that there was nothing to worry about. She stated that
they had left on 22.12.2012. She further deposed that after filing of the
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
complaint, the respondent no.1, in connivance with the parents and
brother, lodged a false domestic violence case in August 2013 and a false
case of demand of dowry in the year 2014 and extorted a sum of
Rs.3,30,000/-.
21.
Her cross-examination was in line with the cross-examination
of the appellants and response was also similar. She had, in her crossexamination, admitted that there is no documentary proof of payment of
Rs.3,30,000/- by way of demand draft. She also stated that she was not
aware of any complaint being lodged against her by respondent no. 1.
22.
In her evidence, respondent no.1 stated that she was not
suffering from any illness prior to her marriage. She deposed that she
was made to work day and night in the matrimonial home and was never
allowed to take any rest and even when she was suffering from abscess,
there was no respite. The appellants and family members always taunted
her. She was beaten and slapped many times by complainants and their
family members. She was treated for abscess at Siliguri, where she was
advised to check her Thyroid and for the first time Thyroid was checked
on 27.8.2012 and then only she came to learn that she was having
Hypothyroidism. She had never given any statement to doctors at Siliguri
that she had Thyroid problem for many years and that she was under
medication for Hypothyroidism. Demand for dowry was also made
repeatedly after marriage and the situation became worse after her
return from consultations with the doctors at Siliguri. Her brother was
compelled to come and she was forced to leave with her brother on
15.09.2012 to stay at her native place for some months. The appellant
no.2 who had accompanied them to Siliguri had told her that he would
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
come to New Delhi and take her back, but he did not come. She further
stated that though she used to call the appellant no.2 and her in-laws to
take her back to Singtam and such request was also made by family
members, it was informed that only if their demands were met, they
would take her back and left with no other option, she had filed a
complaint before the Delhi Women Commission on 31.12.2012 (Exhibit7) in which summons were issued directing the appellants and other
family members to appear on 17.04.2013 and as a counter-blast, the
complaint case was filed by the appellants on 13.06.2013. It is stated
that the appellant no.2 had sent her original educational certificates
through the husband of Smt. Asha Prasad and her mother, along with an
aunt, had gone to Chapra, Bihar only to collect the educational
documents and not to destroy the matrimonial relationship of Smt. Asha
Prasad.
23.
In her cross examination, the respondent no.1 stated that she
had sent the Exhibits 9 and 10 to the complainant. She also admitted
the receipt dated 12.01.2011 for test for Thyroid issued by Hindlabs New
Delhi (Exhibit-A11). She admitted that before marriage there were
specific talks about her health and as she had no health issues and was
healthy and not suffering from any disease, it was stated accordingly.
24.
Evidence of Smt. Laxmi Sah, Shri Chandrika Sah and Shri
Ankit Gupta are also in similar line. The cross-examination is in similar
direction and the responses are also in the same line as given by the
respondent no. 1.
25.
In the complaint petition, Exhibit-20, date of occurrence was
shown on 30.12.2012 at around 12.00 hours. However, it is striking that
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
neither in the complaint nor in the deposition of the witnesses of the
appellants there is any reference to what transpired on 30.12.2012.
However, it has come on record that one day later, on 31.12.2012, the
respondent no.1 had filed a complaint before the Delhi Woman
Commission.
26.
In Shafhi Mohammad (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had
observed that electronic evidence is admissible and provisions of Section
65A and 65B of the Evidence Act are by way of clarification and are
procedural provisions. It is held that if the electronic evidence is
authentic and relevant the same can certainly be admitted subject to the
Court being satisfied about its authenticity and procedure for its
admissibility may depend on fact situation such as whether the person
producing such evidence is in a position to furnish certificate under
Section 65B(h).
In the facts of the instant case where except for
tendering a CD as an Exhibit, namely, Exhibit-11, since no attempt was
made by the appellants to prove its contents as well as its authenticity,
the CD cannot be held to have established the alleged conversation
between the appellant no.2 and respondent no.1 wherein respondent
no.1
purported
to
have
admitted
her
pre-existing
condition
of
Hypothyroidism. The respondent no.1 was stated to have told Dr. S. Sen
about her pre-existing medical condition of Hypothyroidism prior to
marriage. Dr. Sen would have been a disinterested witness and his
evidence could have thrown much light. However, the appellants chose
not to examine him.
27.
Exhibit-13 is a reply given by learned Advocate on behalf of
the accused persons named in the complaint petition to the legal notice
dated 13.02.2013 issued on behalf of the appellants. Much reliance is
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
placed on Exhibit-13 by Mr. Namka to contend that there is an
admission with regard to pre-existing condition of Hypothyroidism. That
enquiries were made by the appellants prior to engagement ceremony
with regard to educational, health and other related issues of the
respondent no.1 is an admitted position. A perusal of Exhibit-13 goes to
show that there is a categorical assertion in Paragraph 7 that the
accused persons did not conceal anything including any disease suffered
by the respondent no.1 and that since the dowry demands made could
not be fulfilled, allegations of cheating are leveled. It is also stated in
Paragraph „e‟ that the situation turned for the worse after the appellants
had learnt about the respondent no.1 suffering from Hypothyroidism.
However, at the same time, it was stated in Paragraph „2‟ that the
appellants had responded positively to the disease as curable one and
not a serious issue. Though there is some inconsistency, it cannot be
deduced
from
Exhibit-13
that
the
same
established
beyond
all
reasonable doubt that the respondents had concealed a pre-existing
disease. It is to be noted that the respondent no.1 was taken to Siliguri
for medical attention as an abscess had developed under her arm and
during the process of investigation, it was detected that the respondent
no.1 was suffering from Hypothyroidism. The respondent no.1, who was
working as a Web Designer and had obtained 88.8% of marks in M.Sc
(Environmental Science) from Benaras Hindu University, had stated that
she was surprised when she came to know that she was suffering from
Hypothyroidism. There is no evidence that after marriage the respondent
no.1 was taking any medicine. It is, however, admitted by the respondent
no.1 in her cross-examination that Exhibit-A11, which is dated
12.01.2011, i.e., prior to marriage, relates to her. Exhibit-A11 is marked
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
as a report. A perusal of Exhibit-A11 goes to show that it is a receipt for
test of Thyroid panel-I and not a report. A test conducted for Thyroid
Panel-I does not mean that one is suffering from a Thyroid disease as the
report may either indicate evidence of parameters being outside the
normal range from which attending doctor may diagnose that the patient
is suffering from some Thyroid disorder, or the parameters being within
range. Exhibit-A11 does not, by itself, establish a pre-existing disease
relating to Thyroid. The appellants did not examine any witness from
Hindlabs, the diagnostic centre which had issued the receipt ExhibitA11, for bringing on record the test report of Thyroid Panel-I test. There
is no documentary evidence demonstrating in categorical terms that the
respondent no.1 was suffering from Hypothyroidism or was taking
medicine since before marriage. In that context, though the respondent
no.1 in her evidence had stated that for the first time Thyroid was
checked on 27.08.2012, which is in contradiction to Exhibit-A11, the
same will not have any material bearing in the facts and circumstances
of the case.
28.
Though allegations of dowry and torture have been deposed to
by the respondents, this Court has refrained from making any
observation on that aspect as cases in relation to such allegations are
pending and such issues have not fallen for consideration in this case.
Whether aforesaid cases had been filed falsely or without any basis is for
the Court adjudicating such cases to determine. Filing of a case, per se,
cannot come within the purview of criminal intimidation. The father-inlaw of Smt. Asha Prasad was also not examined by the appellants to lend
credence to the allegation that Smt. Asha Prasad was threatened in his
presence.
Crl. A. No.13 of 2018
(Chandrawati Devi & Anr. Versus Sharda Gupta & Ors.)
29.
In view of the above discussion, I find no merit in this appeal
and accordingly, the appeal stands dismissed.
30.
Registry will send back Lower Court Record.
( Arup Kumar Goswami )
Chief Justice
Approved for reporting
Internet
/Avi
: Yes
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review