Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010181682024
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 1194 of 2024
Judgment Reserved on – 24/04/2026
Judgment Delivered on -16/07/2026
Judgment (Full) Uploaded on - 16/07/2026
1 - The United India Insurance Company Limited, Through Its Officer In Charge,
Kutchery Chowk, Raipur Tehsil And District Raipur Chhattisgarh (Appellant (Non
Applicant No. 3) (Insurer)
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Chandravati Devi Pahalwan Chandravati Devi Pahalwan, Wd/o Late Bhagwan
Prasad Prasad Pahalwan, Aged About 27 Years R/o Village Teduha, P.O. Bandha,
District Singrauli, Madhya Pradesh (Respondent No. 1 (Applicant No. 1) Claimant)
2 - Kumari Savita D/o Late Bhagwan Prasad Pahalwan, Aged About 9 Years R/o
Village Teduha, P.O. Bandha, District Singrauli, Madhya Pradesh Since Minor
Represented Through Her Mother Chandravati Devi Pahalwan, Wd/o Late Bhagwan
Prasad Pahalwan, Agead About 27 Years, R/o Village Teduha, P.O. Bandha, District
Singrauli Mdhya Pradesh, Respondent No. 2 (Applicant No. 2) Claimant)
3 - Krishna Prasad Pahalwan, S/o Late Bhagwan Prasad Pahalwan, Aged About 2
Years R/o Village Teduha, P.O. Bandha, District Singrauli, Madhya Pradesh Since
Minor Represented Through His Mother Chandravati Devi Pahalwan, Wd/o Late
Bhagwan, Prasad Pahalwan, Aged About 27 Years, R/o Village Teduha, P.O. Bandha,
District Singrauli, Madhya Pradesh. Respondent No. 3(Applicant No. 3) Claimant)
4 - Tejbali S/o Ramji Pahalwan, (Deleted Since Deceased) (Applicant No. 4
(Claimant)
5 - Butali Devi W/o Late Tejbali Aged About 67 Years R/o Village Teduha, P.O.
Bandha, District Singrauli Madhya Pradesh Respondent No. 4 (Applicant No. 5)
Claimant)
6 - Charan Singh, S/o Kodu Singh, C/o S. Narsimha Rao, S/o S. Appa Rao, Near
Ayush Provision Stores, Shivanand Nagar, Khamtarai, Raipur Chhattisgarh.
Respondent
No.
(Applicant
No.
1)
(Driver)
7 - S. Narsimha Rao S/o S. Appa Rao, Near Ayush Provision Stores, Shivanand
Nagar, Khamtarai, Raipur Chhattisgarh. Respondent No. 6 (Applicant No. 2) (Owner)
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant (s)
: Shri Abhishek Vinod Deshmukh, Advocate
For Respondent No.7/owner : Ms. Jyoti Kaushik, Advocate
For Respondent/claimants : Shri Rakesh Kumar Thakur, Advocate
&
MAC No. 2199 of 2024
1 - Chandravati Devi Pahalwan W/o Late Bhagwan Prasad Pahalwan Aged About 27
Years R/o Vill. Teduha, P.O. - Bandha, Dist. Singrouli, M.P.
2 - Ku. Savita D/o Bhagwan Prasad Pahalwan Aged About 9 Years Minor, Through
Their Legal Guardian/mother Appellant No. 1, R/o Vill. Teduha, P.O. - Bandha, Dist.
Singrouli, M.P.
3 - Krishna Prasad Pahalwan S/o Bhagwan Prasad Pahalwan Aged About 2 Years
Minor, Through Their Legal Guardian/mother Appellant No. 1, R/o Vill. Teduha, P.O.
- Bandha, Dist. Singrouli, M.P.
4 - Butli Devi W/o Tejbali Aged About 67 Years R/o Vill. Teduha, P.O. - Bandha,
Dist. Singrouli, M.P.
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1 - Charan Singh S/o Kodu Singh Through- S. Narsinghrao S/o S. Apparao, R/o Near
Ayush Provision Store, Shivanand Nagar, Khamtarai, Dist. Raipur, C.G. (Driver Of
Truck No. C.G.-04-Ja-8226)
2 - S. Narsinghrao S/o S. Apparao R/o Near Ayush Provision Store, Shivanand Nagar,
Khamtarai, Dist. Raipur, C.G. (Owner Of Truck No. C.G.-04-Ja-8226)
3 - United India General Insurance Company Ltd. Through- Incharge Officer,
Address- Kachahri Chowk, Raipur, Dist. Raipur, C.G. (Owner Of Truck No. C.G. 04-Ja-8226)
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellant (s)
: Shri Rakesh Kumar Thakur, Advocate
For Respondent /owner
: Ms. Jyoti Kaushik, Advocate
For Respondent/insurance co. : Shri Abhishek Vinod Deshmukh, Advocate
({Hon’ble Shri Justice Sachin Singh Rajput})
C A V Judgment
These two appeals under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
(for short ‘M.V.Act’) are arising out of common award dated 06/02/2024 passed
by the 1st Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Raipur, CG (for short
‘Tribunal’) in claim case No.13/2020 and they are being heard and decided by
this common order. By the impugned award, against a claim of Rs.35,34,000/-,
learned Tribunal has awarded compensation of Rs.31,74,000/- in favour of the
appellants / claimants.
These two appeals MAC No.1194/24 has been filed by the Insurance
Company whereas MAC No.2199/24 has been filed by the claimants.
2.
A claim application under Section 166 of the MV Act was filed by the
claimants seeking compensation of Rs.35,34,000/- on account of death of
Bhagwan Das Pahalwan in an accident that occurred on 01/12/2019 by rash and
negligent driving of the offending vehicle (Truck) bearing registration No.CG
04-JA-8226 driven by driver-Charan Singh, owned by Narsingh Rao and
insured with United India General Insurance Company Ltd. As per pleadings of
the claim application, the deceased was riding motor cycle bearing registration
No.CG-04-LJ-4505 and was going towards village-Urla from Birgaon. On
main road of pepsi square of village-Urla, the motor cycle was hit by the
offending vehicle resulting into severe injuries and his death on the spot. The
accident was reported in police station-Urla under Crime No.559/2019 and
offence under Section 304A of IPC was registered.
3.
As per pleadings of the claim application, the deceased was working as
JCB driver in Vandana Ispat, Raipur and was earning Rs.16,000/- per month.
Thus, claiming the abovestated compensation, the application was filed.
4.
The driver and owner of the offending vehicle submitted their written
statement and denied averments of the claim application. It was pleaded that
the accident had not occurred on account of rash and negligent driving of the
driver rather the deceased himself was riding his motor cycle rashly and
negligently without any license and thus, caused the accident. The driver and
owner are not responsible for the accident. The offending vehicle was insured
with the insurance company, thus, the driver and owner are not liable to pay
any compensation.
5.
The Insurance company also filed its written statement and denied the
averments of the claim application and in usual course pleaded that the driver
of the offending vehicle was not holding valid and effective driving license.
The deceased himself was responsible for the accident; there is a misjoinder
and non-joinder of necessary parties and it is also a case of contributory
negligence.
6.
On the basis of above broad pleadings, learned Tribunal framed four
issues. Evidence was led by the claimants to prove their pleadings. Learned
Claims Tribunal, on assessment of material evidence available on record,
decided the issue in favour of the claimants and awarded compensation of
Rs.31,74,000/- holding the owner/driver and insurance company jointly and
severally liable to pay compensation.
7.
Learned counsel for the insurance company argued that the learned
Claims Tribunal committed an error in holding the monthly income of the
deceased to Rs.15,000/- without any cogent and prudent evidence. The salary
slip exhibited by the claimants has not been proved in accordance with law. He
submits that interest of 7.5% awarded is also on the higher side.
8.
Per contra, learned counsel for the claimants would argue that the
Tribunal ought to have considered the monthly income of the deceased to
Rs.16,000/- as three salary certificates have been filed on record. Though the
same has been proved by the witnesses of the claimants, thus, the learned
Tribunal ought to have assessed the income of the deceased as per the salary
certificate. Therefore, prayed that suitable enhancement of compensation may
be made.
9.
Learned counsel for the owner supports the impugned award.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records
meticulously with utmost circumspection.
11.
The issue involved in this appeal is as to whether the learned Tribunal
was justified in awarding the abovestated compensation and according to
learned counsel for the insurance company, it requires suitable reduction
whereas learned counsel for the claimants prayed for enhancement of the same.
12.
The claimants have filed claim application inter alia pleading that the
deceased was working as JCB driver in Vandana Ispat Ltd. and his monthly
income was Rs.16,000/- per month. Learned Claims Tribunal, assessing the
evidence available on record, found monthly income of the deceased to
Rs.15,000/- per month. In order to prove the pleadings, the claimants examined
Chadravati Devi Pahalwan as AW1. According to her affidavit filed under
Order 18 Rule 4 of CPC, the deceased was the only bread winner of his family.
He was working as a driver of JCB vehicle and was earning Rs.16,000/- per
month. Apart from exhibiting the criminal papers, to prove negligence, she has
also exhibited the driving license of her husband along with his salary
certificate as Ex.P/13 to Ex.P/15. Perusal of her cross-examination by the
insurance company would indicate that no specific question with regard to
genuineness of the salary certificate Ex.P/13 to Ex.P/15 was asked, though the
driver and owner in their cross-examination have put a question that false
salary certificate Ex.P/13 to Ex.P/15 has been filed. This suggestion was denied
by this witness. In his pleading, it has been stated that the deceased was
working as JCB driver in Vandana Ispat Ltd., Raipur whereas perusal of
Ex.P/13 to P/15 would indicate that it is issued by Avinash Ispat Pvt. Ltd. It
would indicate that the deceased was working with Avinash Ispat Pvt. Ltd. as
Hydra Operator and as per Ex.P/13, his net salary was Rs.17,292/- for the
month of October-November, 2018.This certificate is dated 19/02/2019.
Ex.P/14 is the salary certificate of December, 2018 which indicate his monthly
salary as 15,200/- and after ESIC deduction of Rs.266/-, he was paid
Rs.14,934/-. Ex.P/15 would indicate that in the month of January, 2019, he was
paid salary of Rs.15566/- and after ESIC deduction, he was paid net salary of
Rs.15,294/-. Though in the pleadings it has been stated that the deceased was
working in Vandana Ispat Ltd., however, salary certificate was issued by
Avinash Ispat Pvt. Ltd. but this can throw some light with regard to the fact that
the deceased was a skilled driver. Ex.P/12C is the driving license of the
deceased, according to which, he was licensed to drive light motor vehicle and
motor cycle with gear.
13.
Considering the pleadings, evidence and exhibited documents, learned
Claims Tribunal found the monthly income of the deceased to Rs.15,000/-. The
date of accident is 01/12/2019. Initially, the claim application was filed by 5
persons, young widow of 27 years, two minor children aged about 9 and 2
years and parents aged about 70 years and 67 years respectively. During the
pendency of the claim application, the father of the deceased died and his name
was deleted from the cause title. Naturally, on the date of accident, five persons
were dependent upon the income of the deceased. Looking to the age of the
parents, naturally there would not be any earning member. If a person is
required to maintain a family of 5 persons, his income ought to have been
assessed looking to the above aspect also and his place of working.
Proceedings under the Motor Vehicle Act is summary in nature and strict
compliance of Evidence Act may not be necessary to prove a particular fact.
Apart from the three salary certificates, the pass book of the deceased is also on
record, according to which in the month of November, 2019 i.e. 1 month prior
to the accident, he was paid salary of Rs.13935/-. As the deceased was found to
be a skilled driver, his place of work was Raipur which is the capital city and
looking to the inflation, this Court does not find any illegality and irregularity
in assessing the monthly income of the deceased to Rs.15,000/- per month. So
far as submission of Shri Deshmukh with regard to higher interest is concerned,
it does not appeal to this Court. The learned Tribunal has exercised to award
the interest and this Court is not inclined to disturb that. Thus, the submission
of Shri Deshmukh is rejected.
14.
As this Court has affirmed the finding of taking monthly income of the
deceased to Rs.15,000/-, the submission of Shri Rakesh Kumar Thakur that
earning of the deceased should have been taken as Rs.16,000/- is also liable to
be rejected.
15.
Learned claims Tribunal after adding 40% future prospects and
deducting 1/4th for personal expenses applied multiplier of 16 holding the age
of the deceased to 32 years, awarded compensation of Rs.30,24,000/- for loss
of dependency. It has further awarded Rs.15,000/- for loss of estate,
Rs.15,000/- for funeral expenses, Rs.40,000/- loss of consortium and further
awarded Rs.40,000/- each to claimants No.2, 3 and 5 and thus, total
compensation of Rs.31,74,000/- was awarded.
16.
It is the settled principle of law that the Courts and Tribunals are required
to see whether just compensation is awarded. The compensation should not be
meager or in bonanza. In the opinion of this Court, the compensation awarded
by the learned Claims Tribunal appears to be just compensation and does not
require any interference either reducing the same or enhancing. Thus, both the
appeals filed by the Insurance company as well as the claimants are liable to be
and are hereby dismissed.
Sd/-
(Sachin Singh Rajput)
JUDGE
Deepti
Digitally
signed by
DEEPTI
HARIKUMAR
DEEPTI
HARIKUMAR Date:
2026.07.16
16:47:10
+0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review