Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:44123
CGHC010392262026
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by SUMIT
WP227 No. 1317 of 2026
SUMIT KUMAR
Date:
KUMAR 2026.10.13
11:27:07
+0530
1 - Chandratan Lakhotiya Son Of Late Ramnarayan Lakhotiya, Aged About
97 Years Resident Of Village Khandsara, P. S. Tehsil And District Bemetara
C.G.
2 - Girish Kumar Lakhotiya, Son Of Shri Chandratan Lakhotiya, Aged About
62 Years Resident Of Village Khandsara, P. S. Tehsil And District Bemetara
C.G.
3 - Shyamsundar Lakhotiya, Son Of Shri Chandratan Lakhotiya, Aged About
60 Years Resident Of Village Khandsara, P. S. Tehsil And District Bemetara
C.G.
4 - Hukumchand Urf Govind Lakhotiya Son Of Shri Chandratan Lakhotiya,
Aged About 56 Years Resident Of Village Khandsara, P. S. Tehsil And District
Bemetara C.G.
5 - Gopal Lakhotiya, Son Of Shri Chandratan Lakhotiya, Aged About 52 Years
Resident Of Village Khandsara, P. S. Tehsil And District Bemetara C.G.
6 - Smt. Leela Devi, Wife Of Shri Chandratan Lakhotiya, Aged About 87 Years
Resident Of Village Khandsara, P. S. Tehsil And District Bemetara C.G.
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Smt. Padma Urf Anushri Wife Of Shri Harish Laddhad, Daughter Of Shri
Chandratan Lakhotiya, Aged About 57 Years Resident Of Khandsara, P. S.,
Tehsil And District Bemetara C.G. Presently Resident Of 101 Shri Ganpati
Apartment, Khare Town, Dharampet, Nagpur, Maharasthra
2 - Smt. Megja Bafma. W/p Shri Abhishek Bafna, Aged About 32 Years
Resident Of Ward No. 1, Near Union Bank, Ahiwara, Tehsil Dhamdha, District
Durg C.G.
3 - Smt. Hemlata, W/o Shri Rakesh Jain, Aged About 52 Years Resident Of
Ward No. 5, Nagar Panchayat Berla, Tehsil Berla, District Bemetara C.G.
4 - Sharda Devi, W/o Of Shri Subhash Jain, Aged About 61 Years Resident
Of Ward No. 5, Nagar Panchayat Berla, Tehsil Berla, District Bemetara C.G.
5 - Lobhan Singh Verma, S/o Bhagirathi Verma, Aged About 50 Years
Resident Of Village Singpur, Post Jhal, Tehisl And District Bemetara C.G.
6 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Collector District Durg C.G.
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent No.6 :
Mr. Ankur Agrawal, Advocate
Mr. Karan Kumar Baharani, P.L. for the State
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J.)
Order on Board
12/10/2026
1.
Heard.
2.
Present is writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India filed
by the petitioner against the impugned order dated 11.08.2026 passed
by learned Second Civil Judge, Junior Division, Bemetara in Civil Suit
No. 2A/2025, whereby the application filed by the petitioner under
Order 14 Rule 5 of CPC has been rejected.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that the petitioners
are the defendants No.1 to 6 before the learned trial Court where the
respondent No.1 is prosecuting a suit for declaration of title, partition,
separate possession and permanent injunction over the suit properties
shown in the Schedule – A, B, C, D and E annexed with the plaint. The
plaintiff is claiming that she is the grand daughter of Late Ram Narayan
and the defendant No.1 is son of Late Ram Narayan, who is the father
of the plaintiff and the defendants No.2 to 5 are her brothers and the
defendant No.6 is her mother. The defendant No.1 is still alive and the
plaintiff being the daughter of the defendant No.1 can not claim
partition during lifetime of her father as the property is the ancestral
property. The learned trial Court though have framed issues with
respect to entitlement of the property, however, the relevant issue with
respect to the right and title of the defendant No.1 and their entitlement
of the suit property, no issue has been framed by the learned trial
Court. The defendants No.1 to 6 have filed an application under Order
14 Rule 5 of the CPC for framing of additional issues but the same has
been rejected by the learned trial Court saying that the issues which
have already been framed by the learned trial Court covers the entire
controversy between the parties and there is no need to frame
additional issues as has been proposed by the defendants No.1 to 6. In
support of his submission, he would rely upon the judgment of Kritika
Jain v. Rakesh Jain & Anr., 2025 SCC OnLine Del 7712. He would
further submit that without there being any proper issue, the parties
may deprive from leading evidence and to decide the real controversy
between the parties, the additional issue is required to be framed,
therefore, the impugned order may be set aside and the learned trial
Court may be directed to decide the allow the application filed by the
petitioners and to frame additional issues, which has been proposed by
the defendants No.1 to 6.
4.
I have heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the
document annexed with the petition.
5.
The controversy in the present case revolves around the partition of the
ancestral property between the parties and their right to claim the
partition, as the defendants No.1 to 6 have raised objection that the
father of the plaintiff is still alive, who is defendant No.1 and during his
lifetime, the plaintiff cannot claim partition over the ancestral property.
6.
After having gone through the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial
Court has framed the following issues in the suit :“1. क्या वादपत्र के साथ संलग्न अनुसूची-द भाग 1-4 में वर्णित ग्राम खसरा,
रायखेड़ा, बंसापुर, जगमड़वा तह० व जिला बेमेतरा स्थित वाद ग्रस्त भूमि
वादिनी एवं प्रतिवादी कं 0 01 से 05 के संयुक्त स्वामित्व की पैतृक संपत्ति है?
2. क्या वादी, वादपत्र के साथ संलग्न अनुसूची - द भाग 1-4 में वर्णित ग्राम
खण्डसरा रायखेड़ा, बंशापुर, जगमड़वा तह० जिला बेमेतरा वादग्रस्त संपत्ति
पर वादिनी एवं प्रतिवादी क्रं ० (1) से (05) के साथ बराबर-बराबर हक एवं
हिस्सा होने की घोषणा पाने प्राप्त करने के अधिकारी है?
3. क्या वांदिनी उक्त वादग्रस्त संपत्ति का विभाजन कराकर प्रतिवादी क्रं ० (1) से
(05) से 1/6 अंश का रिक्त आधिपत्य प्राप्त करने के अधिकारी है?
4. क्या प्रतिवादी कं 0 7 से 10 की भूमि जो कि वादपत्र के साथ संलग्न अनुसूची
ई में वर्णित वादग्रस्त भूमि जिसे प्रतिवादी कं 0 2 एवं 3 के द्वारा विक्रय की गई
है, उसे अंतिम विभाजन के समय विक्रे तागण प्रतिवादी क्रं ० (2) एवं (3) के
हिस्से में समायोजित किया जाये?
5. क्या वादिनी उक्त वादग्रस्त भूमि के संबंध में प्रतिवादीगण के विरूद्ध स्थायी
निषेधाज्ञा का अनुबोध प्राप्त करने के अधिकारी है?
6. सहायता एवं व्यय?”
7.
The defendants No.1 to 6 have filed an application and proposed the
following issues:“(i) क्या प्रतिवादी क्रमांक 2 एवं 3 के द्वारा जो भूमि प्रतिवादी क्रमांक 7 से 10
का विक्रय किया है वह उनके स्वयं की भूमि थी?
(ii) क्या ग्राम जगमड़वा की भूमि खसरा नंबर 45 एवं 54 प्रतिवादी क्रमांक 2
गिरीश लखोटिया को श्रीमती सुनीता लखोटिया एवं मयंक लखोटिया से
विनिमय में प्राप्त भूमि है?
(iii) क्या वाद में पक्षकारों का असंयोजन है?
(iv) क्या अनुसूची द भाग 1 की ग्राम रायखेड़ा की भूमि खसरा नंबर 47/1,
47/2, 70, 72 एवं 74 की भूमि की प्रतिवादी क्रमांक 4 एवं 5 के द्वारा क्रय
कर उनकी स्वयं की अर्जित भूमि है?
(v) क्या अनुसूची अ से स की भूमि के एक मात्र स्वामी प्रतिवादी क्रमांक 1 है,
इसलिये वादिनी द्वारा प्रस्तुत उद्घोषणा एवं बटवारा का वाद पोषणीय है?”
8.
The framing of the issues has been provided under Order 14 of the
CPC and Rule 1 of Order 14 provided the framing of the issues and the
material propositions of law or facts which a plaintiff must allege in
order to show a right to sue or a defendant must allege in order to
constitute his defence. Issue arises when a material proposition of fact
or law is affirmed by one party and denied by other. Rule 3 of Order 14
provided the materials from which the issue may be framed. The
learned trial Court after considering the pleadings of the plaint as well
as written statement filed by the parties, framed the aforesaid issues.
Admittedly, there is no counter-claim filed by the defendants. Rule 5 of
Order 14 empowered the learned trial Court to amend the issues or
frame additional issues on such terms as it thinks fit and to amend the
issues before passing the decree as may be necessary for determining
the matters in controversy between the parties. After having gone
through the pleadings and proposed issues and the controversy
involved in the present suit, the learned trial Court has observed that
the issues proposed by the petitioners/defendants No.1 to 6 are
already covered within the issues which has already been framed and
there is no need to frame additional issues.
9.
From perusal of the proposed issues, it transpires that the defendants
are claiming their own right over the subject property for which they
sought framing of the additional issues and since there is no counterclaim filed by the defendants, such issue cannot be framed as has
been proposed by the defendants. From perusal of the proposed
issues in their application, it further transpires that the controversy is
entirely covered in the issues which has already been framed by the
learned trial Court.
10. After having gone through the entire material produced in the present
writ petition and the issues which has already been framed by the
learned trial Court and the proposed issues, this Court does not find
any illegality or perversity or any jurisdictional error in rejecting the
application filed by the petitioners. The judgment relied upon by the
learned counsel for the petitioners is distinguishable on the facts of the
present case, and therefore, no benefit could be extended by the said
judgment.
11. The writ petition accordingly fails and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
JUDGE
Sumit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review