Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 34881
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERARAD
THURSDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JI,ISTICE S1RIAPARESH KUMAR SINGH
I.ND
THE HONOURAT3LE SRIJUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Preferred Against Order
Dated 2110412026 in WP No 1 239 ot 2026 on the file of the High Court.
Betweon
Chandrasekhar Goud, S/o. E. Laxman Goud Aged about. 58 years, Occ.
Business, R/o. H. No.6-3-1 1 00/1 /R, Jayaraja, Somajiguda, Hyderabad.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. Union of lndia, Ministry of Defence, Government of lndia. Represented by its
Secretary Room No 305 -'B'Wing, Sena Bhawan, New Delhi-1 10011.
2. The Chief Executive Officer, Secunderabad Cantonment Board, Court
Compound, Sardar Patel Road, Secunderabad-O3, CANTONMENT BOARD
3. The President, Secunderabad Cantonment Board, Court Compound, Sardar
Patel Road, Secunderabad-O3, CANTONMENT BOARD
4. Balajee Arun Educational Society, Rep. by its Chairman, M.Komuraiah,
S/o.M.Venkataiah, Office Plot No.44 and 42A, Behind Nacharam Telephone
Exchange, Malkajgiri Mandal, R.R.District
5. Srinivas, S/o.Not known Rl/o.Plot No.32lA, Mahendra Hills, Beside Tukaram
Gate Police Station, East Marredpally, Hyderabad
,..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased be pleased to
pass an order to directing the respondent no. 4 and 5 to not to carry out any
construction in respect of sanction granted by the respondent no.2 and 3 in favor of
the respondent no.4 and 5 in respect of PLOT NO. 14,15 &16, REV.SY.NO.7413'
MARREDPALLY,
SEVA MANDAL SOCIETY LTD, MAHENDRA HILLS, EAST
CANTONMENT tOTVATdS AN CXtCNt Of 975.48 SQ.MTR &1337 '79
SECUNDERABAD
Cantonrnent Boarcl,
Se.MTR vide True Extracts of Ordirary Board Meeting of th6
Board,
Secunderabad heid in the conference hall, office of the CantonmentSecr-rnderabad dat?d 22nd NCVEI\4BER, 2025, pending disposal of the Wilt Appeal'
:2
2{l
Petition urrcJet Secticn '151 CPr:) praying that in the circurnstances stated in the
af.iidavii file,l in sLpport of the petition, the High Court may be please'J to pass an
order to suspend the operation of the order daled 21-04-2026, passed in WRIT
PETITION No. 1239 Or 2026, pending disposal of the Writ Appeal.
Counse{ for the Aopeliant: SRI C.RAGHU, Sr.Counsel FIEP., SRI CH.SI-IRAVANI
counse' fo r the Respo ndent No' 1'
3llTi".T,3itif*Xt?i"0,"
Counsel for the Respondent No.2&3 : SRI K.R.KOTESHWARA RAO, SC FOR BOARO
c o u nse I f o r th e Re s p o n de nt N o. 4& 5 :€ R'
J_SHt+liULi,rr?.i
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
m
IN THE HIGH COI'RI F1OR TTIE STATE OF TELI\NGANA
AT IIYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE TTIE CHIEF JI'SUCE SRI APARESII
4IIMAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI WSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
of
Between:
DATEzoqfiT.ZO26
Chandrasekhar Goud
.Appellant
And
Union of India, Ministry of
Defence, Government of india,
Represented by its Secretary and
4 others.
.Respondents
JUDGMENT
Heard sri c.Raghu, rearned senior counsel representing
Ms.ch.sharvani, learned counsel for the appellant; Sri N.Bhujanga
Rao, learned Deputy soricitor General of India appearing
respondent No.1; Sri K.R.Koteswara Rao, learned Standing
counsel
for Secunderabad cantonment Board appearing for respondent
Nos.2
and 3; and Sri J.Kanakaiah, learned Senior counsel representing
P.Raghavendra Rao, learned counsel for respondent
for
sri
Nos.4 and 5 and
perused the record.
2.
This writ appeal is preferred, under clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, against the order dated 21.04.2026 passed
Single Judge in w.p.No.l23g of 2026. By the said
by the learned
order, the learned
single Judge dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellant herein,
holding that the dispute involves complex questions of title,
possession and identity of land, which are already pending before
competent civil Courts and are thus not amenable to adjudication in
writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Factual matrix
3.Theappellant(rn'ritpetitioner)claimstobeoneofthe
co-owners and persons in possession of land admeasuring 6413
sq.Yds. in sy.No.844l1, Block No.17, situated at Malkajgiri village,
GHMC, Matkajgiri circle and Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, having
purchased the same, along with the other co-owners, under a
registered Sale Deed dated 27.O7.2013 from one Sri D'
Laxminarayana.
4.
According to the appeliant, disputes concerning the identity dnd
demarcation of the subject land have existed even prior to the
appellant's purchase of the property. It is the case of the appellant
that the appellant's vendor had addressed representations to the
revenue authorities seeking demarcation of Sy'No'844/ 1 and action
against alleged encroachments. Reference is also made to certain
proceedings initiated by the revenue authorities including meetings,
reports and subsequent correspondence concerning the survey and
classification of the land.
5.
The appellant further asserts that after the purchase, steps
were taken for mutation of the property in the names of the
purchasers and that the revenue authorities processed the matter by
forwarding reports and sketches to the competent authorities.
6.
It is further case of the appellant that apprehending
construction activit5r over what he claims to be part of Sy.No.g44/1,
he submitted a representation dated r2.o4.2olr to the chief
Executive officer (cEo), Secunderabad cantonment Board requesting
that no building permission be granted in favour of respondent Nos.4
and 5. Pursuant thereto, the revenue authorities undertook a survey
on 06.02.2019, which, according to the petitioner, confirmed that the
disputed land falls in Sy.No.B44ll.
'7.
The grievance of the appellant is that notwithstanding the
above, respondent Nos.2 and 3 granted building permission in favour
of respondent Nos.4 and 5 in respect of Plot Nos.14, 15 and 16 in
Revised sy.No.74/3, Seva Mandal Society Limited, Mahendra Hills,
East Marredpally, Secunderabad cantonment. The appellant
contends that objections and representations submitted by him,
including a representation dated o3.o9.2024, were not duly
considered before the grant of such permission.
8.
contending that the grant of building permission was contrary
to the provisions of the cantonments Act, 2006 (for short, the Act),
and was made without proper verification of the rival claims over the
vi)Referenceisalsomadetothespeakingorderdated24.|2,2022
passedbytheCEO,SecunderabadCantonmentBoard'Itwas
submittedthatthesaidspeakingorderwasnotbindingupon
insofar as the subsequent grant of building
the appellant
permission was concerned'
vii) That the speaking order itself recognized the
pendency of the
civildisputeandspecificallyrecordedthatanyfuturebuilding
accordance with the
application wouid be considered only in
provisions of the Cantonments Act' 2006'
It was further
submittedthatthespeakingorderessentiallydealtwithtwo
distinctaspects,namely,theappellant'srequestforcancellation
ofthelayoutandpermissionsgrantedthereunder,andthe
considerationofanyfuturebuildingapplication,whichwas
expressly left open to be decided in accordance
with law'
viii)Thatafterthesaidspeakingorder,theappellantsubmitteda
fresh representation dated 03.og.2024 requesting
respondent
Nos.2and3nottograntbuildingpermissioninfavourof
conducting any
respondent Nos-4 and 5. However, without
by the
without considering the objections raised
enquiry,
appellant and without affording him an
opportunity of hearing'
respondent Nos.2 and 3 proceeded to
grant the impugned
building permission, thereby violating the principles
justice
of natural
ix) That respondent Nos.2 and 3 granted the impugned building
sanction without undertaking any physical verification or
enquiry regarding the identity of the land. tt was contended that
the land in question measures 6413 Sq.Yds. in Sy.No.844/ 1,
Block No.17, Malkajgiri Village, and not Sy.No.74 19 as claimed
by respondent Nos.4 and 5. According to the appellant, if a
proper field inspection was conducted, the identity of the
property would have been established beyond doubt.
x)
That the building permission in respect of Plot Nos.14, 15 and
16 was granted solely on the basis of an approved layout, the
very legality of which is under serious cloud. According to the
appellant, before approving the layout, the Cantonment Board
ought to have obtained the requisite revenue clearance,
conducted a physical survey.
xi) It was argued that the layout came to be sanctioned merely on
the basis of documents produced by the Society without any
field verification. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that
the Joint Survey conducted by the Revenue Authorities
confirmed that an extent of 64L3 Sq. Yds. formed part of
Malkajgiri Village and that there was no overlap with Sy.No.74.
Consequently, the approval of the layout without proper
verilication was itself illegal and all consequential permissions
granted thereunder were equally liable to be set aside .
xii) That the entire controversy centres around the identity and
physical location of the land, namely, whether the property falls
in
Sy.No.8a4l 1
of Malkajgiri Vitlage or Sy.No'74/9 of
Marredpally viltage. It was contended that the issue stood
conclusively determined by the Joint Survey conducted on
06.O2.2O19 by the Regional Deputy Director, Survey and Land
Records, Hyderabad, after issuing notice to all stakeholders,
inclucling respondent Nos.4 and 5. According to the appellant,
the survey categorically established. that the subject land falls
within Sy.No.844 ll of Matkajgiri Village and not in Sy.No.74. It
was further submitted that respondent Nos.4 and 5 have never
challenged the said survey proceedings and, therefore, the
findings recorded therein continue to bind the parties.
xiii) That the respondent authorities misread the contents of the
Joint Survey Report bv selectively relying upon the observation
regarding absence of overlap between the survey numbers while
completely ignoring the categorical finding that the disputed
land is situated in Sv.No.844l I of Malkajgiri Village.
xiv) That the grant of building permission is contrary to Section
181(a) of the Act, inasmuch as the applicant's right over the
land vras itself under serious dispute. In such circumstances,
the competent authority ought to have declined sanction until
the dispute relating to title and identity of the property attained
finality.
t
xv)
That respondent Nos.2 and 3 failed to ascertain the mandatory
NOC from the Mandal Revenue Officer (MRO) before granting
building permission in the Secunderabad Cantonment area,
thereby vitiating the entire decision-making process.
xvi)
That while the sanctioned layout reflected a total extent of only
Ll64 Sq.Yds. in Plot Nos.14, 15 and 16, the impugned building
permission came to be granted for an extent of 1337.79 Sq.Yds.
Thus, the discrepancy itself demonstrates complete nonapplication of mind and renders the impugned sanction
arbitrary and unsustainable.
xvii)
That the learned Single Judge erred in holding that affording an
opportunity of hearing to the appellant before grant of building
permission could not be treated as a mandatory requirement. It
was contended that the appellant, being a person asserting an
independent claim over the very land in question and having
submitted objections prior to grant of sanction, was entitled to
be heard before respondent Nos.2 and 3 took any decision
affecting his rights.
xviii)
That the learned Single Judge erred in holding that Section
131(a) of the Act, would become applicable
-only upon
establishment of a clear dispute affecting the applicant's title.
According to the appellant, the Joint Survey Report dated
06.0'2.2019 itself established the existence of a genuine dispute
regarding the identity of the land and, therefore, respondent
Nos.2 and 3 ought to have refused sanction.
xix) That the appellant cannot be accused of pursuing multiple
proceedings with the object of harassing respondent Nos.4
and 5-. That the various proceedings initiated by the appellant
arose out of distinct causes of action and were necessitated
solely to safeguard his claimed rights over the property in view
of the repeated attempts allegedly made by respondent Nos.4
and 5 to interfere with the same.
xx) That implementation of the order under appeal would result in
the appellant being dispossessed from the property in his
possession. That the appellant had established a strong prima
facie CaSe, the balance of convenience lay in his favour, and
refusal to interfere would result in irreparable injury and
prejudice to his asserted rights over the schedule property.
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
11. Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India appearing for
respondent No.1, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
Secunderabad Cantonment Board and learned counsel appearing for
respondent Nos.4 and 5, advanced the following submissions:
i) That the learned Single Judge rightly held that the dispute
between the parties pertained to the identity and location of the
land claimed by the appellant in Sy.No.ai+7 t of Matkajgiri
village uis-d-uis the land in respect of which building permission
had been granted to respondent Nos.4 and 5 in Sy.No.T4l9 of
Marredpally Village. That the controversy essentially involved
disputed questions relating to title, possession, identity,
boundary demarcation and competing claims over immovable
property, requiring appreciation of oral and documentary
evidence, survey records and field demarcation, which felt
within the exclusive domain of the competent civil Court.
ii) That the appellant had earlier instituted o.S.No.34T of 2ol7
seeking perpetual injunction in respect of the very same
propert5r, which came to be dismissed by judgment and decree
dated L6.o4.2o24. It was submitted that the trial court, upon
appreciation of the evidence held that the appellant had failed
to establish either title or possession, expressed doubt
regarding the competence of the appellant's vendor to convey
valid title and observed that the dispute involved complicated
questions of title incapable of adjudication in a suit for bare
injunction. According to the respondents, the appellant's claim
had thus already been subjected to judicial scrutiny.
t2
iii)
'l'l'rat. even according to the appellant, rvircn a First Appeai uide
S.R.No.8236 of 202.5 against the judgmenL in O.S'No'347 of
2Ol7 is pending belore the competent appellate Court, the
issues relating to title and possession remain sub judice before
the Civil Court and the lcarned Single .Judge rvas justified in
declining to adjudicate r;uch disputed ql-rcstic ns in cxercise of
s'rit jurisdiction.
iv) That thc survey report dated 06.02.2019 did not advance the
appeliant's case. It rvas contended that L'oth t^re parties sought
to place different interpretations upon the very same survey
report. While the appellant relied upon the report to contend
that the disputed land formed part :f Sy'No'844/ 1, the
respondents relied upon the report to dcfronstrate that there
was no overlapping between Sy No.844/ 1 of Malkajgiri Village
and Sy.No.74 of Marredpally Village. According to the
re spondents,
such conflicting interpre tations themselves
demonstrated that the controversy involved disputed questions
of fact requiring adjudication by the civil Court.
v) That the survey report dated 06.02.2019 specifically recorded
that there was no overlapping betwcen Sy'No.844/ I of
Malkajgiri Village and Sy.No.74 of Marredpally Village and that
the boundaries of the two Villages stood duly identified and
demarcated. According to the respondents, the report itself
established that the appellant's land was situated in
Sy.No.S4alL and not in Sy.No.74 and, therefore, the allegation
that respondent Nos.4 and 5 were laying
"i"i*
over land
situated in Sy.No.844l I was wholly misconceived.
vi) That the appellant had earlier submitted representations dated
O5.O8.2O22 and 29.11.2022 before the CEO, Secunderabad
Cantonment Board. Before the same were considered, the
appellant filed W.P.No.4356O of 2022. During its pendency, the
CEO passed a speaking order dated 24.L2.2O22 disposing of the
representations, whereupon the writ petition was closed
recording that the appellant's grievance stood redressed, while
reserving liberty to challenge the said order. It was submitted
that despite such liberty, the appellant did not challenge the
speaking order.
vii) That by the speaking order dated 24.12.2022, the request for
cancellation of the layout of Seva Mandal Society (Shantiniketan
Society) and the permissions granted thereunder was rejected,
noting that the layout had been sanctioned about four decades
earlier, had been fully developed, the common areas had vested
in the Secunderabad Cantonment Board and several houses
had already been constructed. The speaking order also
recorded that there was no overlap between Sy.No.74 of
Marredpally Village and Sy.No.844l 1 of Malkajgiri Village.
According to the respondents, the appellant neither challenged
nor disclosed the said order while repeatedly approaching the
authorities and this Court, thereby abusing the process of law.
viii)
That the lindings recorded in the speaking order, particularly
with regard to the absence of overlap between Sy.No.74 and
Sy.No.844/ 1, had attained finality in the administrative process
and could not be indirectly reopened by Iiling the present writ
petition.
ix)
That Plot Nos. 14, 15 and 16 formed part of the duly sanctioned
layout o[ Seva Mandal Society (Shantiniketan Society) situated
in
Sy.No.74/9, Mahendra Hills, East Marredpally,
Secunderabad Cantonment, which was approved by the
Secunderabad Cantonment Board uide CBR No.17 dated
01.10.1981. The said plots, according to the respondents, never
formed part of Sy. No. 844 / 7 of Malkajgiri Vitlage.
x)
That the layout was sanctioned in respect of land admeasuring
Acs.9.60 in Sy.No.74/9 belonging to the Society. The approved
Iayout provided for reservation of 407o of the total area towards
roads, parks, footpaths and green belt, which subsequently
vested in the Cantonment Board for the benefit of the plot
o\ /ners and the general public. The layout comprised 180 plots
and u'as bounded by Dhanalakshmi Co-operative Housing
Societl' on the North, a proposed 40 feet road on the South,
I5
Sy.No.844 /l
of Malkajgiri village on the East and rrimurthy
weaker sections co-operative Housing Society on the west.
upon development of the layout, the Society executed a Gift
settlement Deed dated 31.01. 1983 conveying tile common areas
in favour of the Cantonment Board.
xi) That, as per the sanctioned layout, plot Nos.14, 15 and 16 did
not share any common boundary with Sy.No.844l1 and that
only Plot No.17, Plot Nos.116 to 180 and the area earmarked for
the water tank abutted Sy.No.844/ 1 on the eastern side.
Therefore, according to the respondents, the allegation of
overlap or encroachment in respect of plot Nos.14; 15 and 16
was factually incorrect.
xii) That sy.No.Sa4l 1 of Malkajgiri Vitlage and sy.No.74l9 of
Marredpally Village are situated in different Villages and
different revenue districts. sy.No.844/ 1 falls within Malkajgiri
Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri District (formerly Ranga Reddy
District), whereas Sy.No.74/9 forms part of Marredpaly village
in Hyderabad District. It was contended that the rayout had
been sanctioned and fully developed long prior to the
appellant's purchase in the year 2}lg and, therefore, the
appellant could not subsequently assert any claim over land
forming part of the approved layout.
xiii) Reliance was zrlso placed upon the survey report dated
12.06.1998 submitted by the Deputy Director, Central Survey,
Narayanaguda, Hyderabad, wherein it was recorded that there
was no overlap between the boundaries of Malkajgiri Village and
Marredpally Village. According to the respondents, the
appellant, under the guise of asserting rights over Sy.No.844ll,
was attempting to lay claim over plots situated in Sy.No.74l9
forming part of the sanctioned layout.
xiv) That respondent Nos.4 and 5 initially submitted an application
datecl 02.01 .2025 seeking sanction of a building plan in respect
of Plot Nos.14, 15 and i6 in Sy.No.74/9. The application was
returned on 25.07.2025 pointing out certain objections,
whereafter a revised application was submitted. The revised
application was duly processed and sanctioned by the
competent authority of the Cantonment Board uide CBR
No. 1a(03) dated 22.11.2025 permitting construction
of a
building consisting of cellar, ground, first and second floors.
xv) That pursuant to the said sanction, respondent No.4 executed a
Mortgage Deed bearing Document No.2018 of 2025 dated
24.12.2025 in respect of 1O% of the total buiit-up area, in
accordance with the policy of the Cantonment Board. However,
before release of the sanctioned plan, the present writ petition
came to be filecl and this Court, by interim order dated
t7
09.01.2026, granted stay, in view of which the- sanctioned
permission had not been released.
xvi)
That the appellant had earlier filed W.p.No. t2698 of 2O2O
seeking a direction not to grant any layout or building
permission in sy.No.74 and its sub-divisions. The said writ
petition remained pending without any interim order. The
appellant had also instituted Contempt Case (CC) No.455 of
2023 alleging violation of the interim order, which came to be
closed on merits by order dated 14.06.2024.
xvii)
That the repeated institution of proceedings and submission of
representations by the appellant clearly demonstrate an attempt
to exert pressure upon the authorities and obstruct the
legitimate rights of respondent Nos.4 and 5 in respect of their
plots situated in the approved layout.
xviii)
That the appellant's reliance on Section 181(a) of the Act, was
misconceived. It was submitted that the provision applies only
where there exists a clear and established dispute affecting the
applicant's right over the land. In the present case, the
Cantonment Board acted on the basis of a long-standing
sanctioned layout and its consistent stand that there was no
overlap between Sy.No.74/9 and Sy.No.844/1. In the absence
of any conclusive adjudication establishing the appellant's
claim, no violation of Section 181(a) of the Act, could be
attributed to the respondent authorities.
xix)
That the plea of violation of the principles of natural justice was
equally untenable. It was submitted that the sanction pertained
to Plot Nos.14, 15 and 16 forming part of a duly sanctioned
layout approved on 01.10.1981 and was granted in exercise of
the Cantonment Board's statutory powers. Since the appellant
was neither an applicant before the authority nor a person
claiming under the sanctioned layout, but asserted an
independent claim over a different survey number, no prior
opportunity of hearing was required before grant of the building
permission.
xx) That the contentions relating to the alleged absence of a NOC
from the MRO and the alleged illegality in sanction of the layout
again involved disputed questions of fact requiring examination
of records and appreciation of evidence, which could not be
adjudicated in proceedings under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
12. We have taken note of the respective contentions urged and
perused the material on record including the pleadings, the survey
report dated 06.02.2019, the speaking order dated 24.12.2022 and
the judgment and decree in O.S.No.347 of 2017.
Consideration by this Coutt
Nature of the Dispute and Maintainability of Writ .Iuqisdictlon
13. The principal question that arises for consideration is whether
the learned Single Judge was justified in declining to exercise
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution on the ground that
the controversy between the parties involves disputed questions
relating to title, possession and identity of immovable property,
requiring adjudication by a competent Civil Court.
L4. Article 226 of the Constitution of India confers wide powers
upon the High Court to issue appropriate writs. However, it is to be
noted that such jurisdiction is essentially supervisory and cannot
ordinarily be invoked for adjudication of disputed questions of fact,
particularly where the controversy relates to title, possession,
boundary demarcation or identity of immovable property requiring
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence.
15. In the present case, the controversy centers around the identity
and location of the subject land in Sy.No.844l1 of Malkajgiri Village
and the land in respect of which building permission has been
granted to respondent Nos.4 and 5 in Sy.No.74lg of Marredpally
Village. The rival claims are founded on distinct sources of title. While
the appellant asserts rights under a registered sale deed dated
27.07.2013 and the connected revenue records pertaining to
sy.No.844/ 1 of Malkajgiri Village, respondent Nos.4 and 5 claim
through the-approved iayout of Seva Mandal Society
in sy'No'7419 of
Marredpally Village, sanctioned by the Secunderabad
Board on o1.10.1981. Therefore, the dispute involves
Cantonment
determination of
title, possession, identity and boundary demarcation of the
subject
land
16. It is also not in dispute that sy.No.844l1 of Malkajgiri Village
and sy.No.74/9 of Marredpally Viltage are situated in different
Villages and different revenue districts. The appellant
revenue records and the Joint Survey Report dated
relies upon
06'02'2019 to
contendthatthedisputedlandformspartofsy.No.s44ll,whereas
the earlier
the respondents rely upon the very same survey report,
survey report dated 12.06.1998 and the sanctioned
layout to contend
The
that there is no overlapping between the two survey numbers'
the same
divergent interpretation placed by both the parties upon
document itself demonstrates that the controversy cannot
be resolved
without detailed examination of evidence and demarcation of
the land
on the ground.
L7. Significantly, the appellant had earlier instituted o's'No'347 of
same
2017 seeking perpetual injunction in i:espect of the very
property' By judgment and decree dated 16.04.2024, the Civil
dismissed the suit upon recording findings that- the
Court
appellant failed to
establish title as well as possession and further observed that the
controversy involved complicated questions of title beyond the scope
2t
of a suit for bare injunction. Though the said judgment is presently
under challenge in First Appeal ufde S.R.No.8236 of 2025, the same
nevertheless demonstrates that the dispute has already undergone
judicial scrutiny before the competent Civil Court and continues to
remain sub judice before the appellate forum. The said judgment and
decree dated L6.o4.2024, is extracted hereunder for ready reference:
43. Hence, on careful etamination of pleading and euidence on record
it appears that plaintiffs are not certain in taking stand as to uhether
suit propertg is open land as mentioned in sclrcduled to tlrc plaint and
under Ex.Al or it lws either temporary or petmanent structures as
intended to be demonstrated uith Ex.A4 to A6 and Ex.A10. Tlrus, on
this score also plaintifffailedto bing claritg.
44. As noticed from tlrc record, Mr.Darji Balaiah @ Bala Kisttru is
stated to haue purchased ttrc land in suruey No.844 (sub division
844/ 1) ertent Ac. 334.00 guntas was ou)ned bg Balakisthu Darji
hauing purchased under agreement of sale in the gear 7903 uide Title
Deed No.lO/8 of 1313 Fa.sli dated 12 Dai 1313 fasli granted bg
Collectorate District, Baghar Nizam's State. Tlrc. agreement of sale is
not filed in present case and it is also not made clear as to uthetlrcr
this document utas pursued bg the reuenlte authorities.
45. The Gazettee notiftcation under Ex.All and information giuen bg
tlrc Talusildar, Malkajgiri sltow thnt land in surueg No.844/ 1 is
recorded as Gouernment Lqnd. Whereas, plaintiffs claim it to be patta
land. Houteuer, tltere appears no documentary euidence to sLnut that
land in surueA No.844/ 1 is patta land and Mr.Darji Balaiah @ Bala
Kisthu utas pattadar/ owner of such land. So, firstly the predecessor
in interest of plaintiff need to be get clarification/ declaration of right of
Mr.Darji Balaiah @Bala Kisthu ouer ttrc land in surueA No.844/ 1 utith
specifi.c extent.
As seen from Ex.A2 Mr.Darji Balaiah @ Bala Kisthu was
suruiued bA utfe, tu.ro sons and tuo daughters. In uiew of existence of
legal heirs of Mr.Darji Balaiah @ Bala Kisthu, hout Mr.Sataiah and
afier hi.s death his son Mr.LaxminaraAana claimed. exclusive ights
ouer tlrc estate lefi ouer the Mr.Darji Balaiah @ Bala Kisthu is not
made clear and their lies ambigaitg onthis aspect.
46. This brings the discussion to the issue of title claim laid bg the
plaintiffs ouer the suit sctrcdule propertg. With ambiguitg ouer ttrc titte
Jlow in respect of suit schedule propertg as discussed earlier, the legal
competence of Mr.Laxminaragana uendor of plaintiffs remain doubtful
to conueg title in fauour of ptaintiffs.
47. In tle present case, suit scLrcdule propertg is open land and for
deciding fhe possession ouer the open land one need to fall back on
proving the title ouer such open land and on tlrc pinciple of
possessron generallg follout title in case of open land.
48. The issues as qppears from pleading and euidence on record
touch upon the complicated title dispute uthich can not be adjudicated
in present suit uhere the scope does not pennit to giue finding the title
of plaintiffs ouer tlte suit schedule propertg.
49. For fhe discussion as taken up aboue, it is required to be held that
plaintiffs faited to proue their pleadings that theg are owner and in
possession of the suit schedule property. Accordinglg, issue no. 7 and
2 are answered against the plaintiffs.
18. Further, the appellant had earlier questioned the actions of the
Cantonment Board by filing W.P.No.43560 of 2022, pursuant to
which the CEO passed a speaking order dated 24.12.2022. The said
order, while rejecting the appellant's request for cancellation of the
sanctioned layout, also recorded that there was no overlap between
Sy.No.74 of Marredpally Village and Sy.No.844l1 of Malkajgiri Village.
The appellant did not challenge the said speaking order. These
circumstances reinforce that the controversy essentially pertains to
competing claims over immovable property and cannot be
satisfactorily adjudicated in proceedings under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
19. It is well settled that a writ Court will not conduct a roving
enquiry into disputed questions of title, nor will it weigh conflicting
survey reports and revenue records to determine possession. This
Court, in its '*,rit jurisdiction, cannot resolve intricate and disputed
questions of property title, boundary, or possession that require an
appreciation of competing evidence. Such issues necessarily require a
full-fledged trial before the competent Civil Court, where the parties
have an opportunity to adduce oral and documentary evidence and
establish their respective claims in accordance with law.
Effect of Dismissal of O.S.No.347 of 2(J7-7 and Pendency of ['irst
Appeal
2Q.. Insofar as the contention that the learned Single Judge erred in
taking note of the dismissal of O.S.No .347 of 2Ol7 and the pendency
of the First Appeal while declining to exercise jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution is concerned, we find no rnerit in the
contention. Though the appellant contends that the judgment in
O.S.No.347 of 2OI7, being one rendered in a suit for perpetual
injunction, does not operate as res iudicata, the fact remains that,
upon a fult-fledged trial, the civil Court recorded findings that the
appellant faited to establish either title or possession over the suit
property and also expressed doubt regarding the competence of his
vendor to convey vatid title. While these findings may not finally
determine title, they unmistakably demonstrate that the appellant's
claim is seriously disputed and is already pending adjudication before
the competent Civil Court.
2L. It is to be noted that the learned Single Judge has not treated
the judgment in O.S.No.347 of 2017 as operating as res judicata. The
learned Singte Judge merely took note of the fact that the dispute had
already undergone judicial scrutiny before the Civil Court and that
the appellant had carried the matter in appeal. Admittedly, the First
Appealagainstthejudgmentanddecreeino.s.No.347of2ol7is
pending before the competent appellate court. In such circumstances'
the learned Single Judge was justified in declining to
undertake
adjudication of the very same disputed questions relat'ing
to title and
possession in exercise of writ jurisdiction'
22. The record further discloses that the appellant had earlier
submitted representations dated 05.O8.2O22 and' 29'll'2022
before
the CEo, Secunderabad Cantonment Board. Before the said
representations were considered, the appellant filed
2022 seeking a direction for their consideration.
w'P'No'43560 of
During the pendency
of the said writ petition, the cEo passed a speaking order
the said
24.12.2022 disposing of the representations. Recording
dated
development, this court disposed of w.P.No.4356O of
2022 while
reserving liberty to the appellant to challenge the speaking
However, the appellant did not challenge the said speaking
order'
order'
2g. It is also borne out from the record that the appellant had
instituted w.P.No. 12698 of 2O2O seeking a direction not to
grant any
layout or building permission in Sy.No.74 or its sub-divisions,
further
wherein no interim relief was granted. The appellant had
initiated C.C.No.45 5 of 2023 alleging violation of the interim
order'
which came to be closed on merits by order dated 14'06'2024'
The
aforesaid sequence of events demonstrates that the dispute
has
remained the subject matter of multiple proceedings before different
forums. Therefore, when the questions relating to title, possession and
identity of the property are already pending before the competent civil
I
court and the appellate forum, we find no infirmity in the approach
adopted by the learned single Judge in declining to exercise writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution.
24. on perusal of the record, it discloses that the speaking order
dated 24.12.2022 came to be passed by the cEo, Secunderabad
cantonment Board, upon consideration of the appellant,s
representations dated 05.08.2022 and 29.11.2022. By the said order,
the appellant's request for cancellation of the layout of seva Mandal
Society (Shantiniketan Society) and the permissions granted
thereunder was rejected, having regard to the fact that the layout had
been sanctioned several decades earlier, had been fully developed, the
common areas had vested in the Cantonment Board and several plot
owners had already raised constructions. The order also recorded, on
the basis of the survey report of the Tahsildar, Malkajgiri Mandal, that
there was no overlapping between sy.No.74 of Marredpally village and
Sy.No.844 ll of Malkajgiri Village.
25. Regarding the issue as to the speaking order cannot be treated
as binding insofar as the subsequent grant of building permission
particularly when the order itself records that any future application
for building permission would be considered in accordance with the
provisions of the Cantonments Act, 2006, is concerned, this Court
does not find merit in it.
It is relevant to note that the speaking order did not finally
determine the question of grant of building permission. However, the
appellant's request for cancellation of the sanctioned Iayout and the
permissions granted thereunder stood rejected by the said order.
Admittedlv, when W.P.No.4356O of 2022 was disposed of, liberty was
reserved to the appellant to challenge the speaking order, but no such
challenge was made. Consequently, the administrative conclusions
recorded therein, including those based on the survey report, attained
finalitf in the absence of any chailenge and could not thereafter be
indirectly questioned in the present proceedings. Therefore, the
appellant cannot seek to reopen the very same administrative issues
in the present writ proceedings.
Applicability of Section 181(al of the Act and Principles of
Natural Justice
27. The appellant's contention that in view of the subsisting dispute
regarding the identity and ownership of the land, the respondent
authorities ought to have u'ithheld the sanction until such dispute
attained linalitl', is misconceived. The applicability of Section 18 1(a) of
the Act necessarily presupposes the existence of a clear and
established .dispute affecting the applicant's right over the property.
In the present case, the Cantonment Board proceeded on the basis of
a long-standing sanctioned layout and the consistent administrative
position that there was no overlap between sy.No.74/9 of Marredpally
Village and sy.No.B44ll of Markajgiri Village. In the absence
of any
conclusive adjudication establishing the appellant's claim, the action
of respondent Nos.2 and 3 in granting the impugned building
permission cannot be held to be contrary to Section 1s1(a) of the
Act.
28. Equally untenable is the contention founded on the principles
of natural justice. The building apprication submitted by respondent
Nos.4 and 5 was considered within the framework of a duly
sanctioned layout in exercise of the statutory powers of the
cantonment Board. Admittedly, the appellant was neither an
applicant before the authority nor a person claiming under the
sanctioned layout, but a third party asserting an independent claim
over a different survey number. Therefore, no prior opportunity of
hearing was afforded to the appellant before grant of the building
permrssion, particularly when his claim is already pending
adjudication before the competent Civil Court.
29. It is also not in dispute that the appellant had repeatedly
submitted representations before the authorities, which culminated in
the detailed speaking order dated 24.12.2022. Despite liberty granted
by this court, the appellant did not challenge the said order and
instead continued to pursue fresh representations. The principles of
natural justice cannot be stretched to require the authorities to
undertake a fresh enquiry or afford repeated hearings each time a
building application is submitted in respect of a duly sanctioned
layout. Thus, the grant of builciing permission by respondent Nos.2
and 3 neith6r contravened Section i81(a) of the Act, nor suffered from
any violation of the principles of natural justice.
30. The appellant has placed considerable reliance upon the joint
survey report dated 06.02.2019 conducted by' the Regional Deputy
Director, Survey and Land Records, Hyderabad, to contend that the
disputed land falls within Sy.No.844/ 1 of Malkajgiri Village. The
respondents, horvever, rely upon the very same report to contend that
it categorically records the absence of any overlap between
Sy.No.844 ,17 of Malkajgiri Village and Sy.No.74 of Marredpally Village
and, therefore, establishes that Plot Nos.14, 15 and 16 do not form
part of the appellant's land. The report also records that an extent of
6143 Sq. Yds. fails in Sy.No.844/ 1 of Malkajgiri Village while
simultaneously observing that there was no overlap betvreen the two
survey numbers.
31. It is to be noted that the said rival interpretations sought to be
placed upon the very same survey report clearly demonstrate that the
controverSy is essentially factual in nature. Determination of the true
import of the survey report, its correlation 'with the respective survey
numbers and the identity of the land woulci necessarily require
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence, examination of survey
records and, if necessary, expert evidence, all of which fall within the
domain of the competent civil Court. Such an exercise cannot be
undertaken in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Therefore, the survey report dated 06.02.2019 does not, by itself,
advance the appellant's case in the present proceedings and that the
disputed factual issues arising therefrom cannot be adjudicated in
exercise of writ jurisdiction.
Conclusion
.'.,'
{,
,"0'
'''32. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered view
that the dispute raised by the appellant essentially involves disputed
questions relating to title, possession and identity of immovable
prope{ty, which are already the subject matter of proceedings before
the competent civil forum. Therefore, the learned Single Judge
committed no error, either on facts or in law, in declining to exercise
jurisdiction under Article 226 of Constitution of India.
33. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed.
SD/. A.V.S. PRASAD
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
G
//TRUE GOPY//
SECTION OFFIGER
To,
1. One CC to tuls.Ct-lENNl\BOINA SHRAVANI, Ad,rocate. [OPUC]
2. i]ne CC to SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Sollq:itor General o1' lndia, High
,
Court for t|re Sta'le of Telangana at Hyderabad. [OF'UC]
3. One llC to SRI l^i:.R,KOTESWARA, SC for Secun;rJerab;rd Cantonnrent Board.
toPUCl
4. One CC to SRI P.RAGHAVENDRA RAO, ADVOCATE. [OPUC]
5. Two CD Copies.
BSK TIh.
HIGH COIJRT
DI\TEID; '0210712A26
R THT S
t
JUDGMENT
WA.No.499 of 2026
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT GOSTS
6 r
,.1
/l
/ JUt 2026
t /)a^r..a
rCH r_o
In
l.j
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review