Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
RSA No.564 of 2023
(In the matter of an appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908)
Chandramani Samal and another
….
Appellants
-versusSukanti Samal & Others
For Appellants
For Respondents -
….
-
Respondents
Mr.P.C.Mishra,Advocate
Mr.Prabin Dash, Advocate
On behalf of
Mr.S.K.Dash, Advocate
CORAM:
MR. JUSTICE A.C.BEHERA
Date of Hearing :04.02.2026:: Date of Judgment :19.02.2026
A.C. Behera, J.
This Second Appeal has been preferred against the
confirming judgment.
2.
The Appellants in this Second Appeal being the husband and
wife respectively were the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 before the
learned Trial Court in the suit vide C.S. No.20 of 2019 and
Appellants before the learned 1st Appellate Court in the first appeal
vide R.F.A. No.16 of 2023.
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 2 //
The Respondent No.1 in this 2nd Appeal was the sole
Plaintiff before the learned Trial Court in the suit vide C.S. No.20
of 2019 and Respondent No.1 before the learned 1st Appellate
Court in the 1st appeal vide R.F.A. No.16 of 2023.
The Respondent Nos.2 to 5 in this 2nd Appeal were the
Defendant Nos.3 to 6 before the learned Trial Court in the suit vide
C.S. No.20 of 2019 and Respondent Nos.2 to 5 before the learned
1st Appellate Court in the first appeal vide R.F.A. No.16 of 2023.
3.
The suit of the Plaintiff vide C.S. No.20 of 2019 before the
learned Trial Court against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 (Appellants
in this 2nd Appeal) was a suit for mandatory and permanent
injunction.
4.
The Plaintiff and Defendant No.3 in the suit vide C.S. No.20
of 2019 are wife and husband respectively.
The Defendant Nos.1, 4 and 5 are the three sons of the
Plaintiff and Defendant No.3.
The Defendant No.6 is the married daughter of the Plaintiff
and Defendant No.3.
The Defendant No.2 is the wife of the Defendant No.1 and
daughter-in-law of the Plaintiff and Defendant No.3.
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 3 //
5.
As per the averments made in the plaint of the Plaintiff
(Respondent No.1 in this 2nd appeal), the suit properties and the
house standing thereon exclusively belong to the Plaintiff. She
(Plaintiff) had purchased the same through registered sale No.1191
dated 08.09.1989 from one Chandramani Sethi on payment of due
consideration amount. As such, since the date of purchase, she
(Plaintiff) is the sole owner and in possession over the entire suit
properties. She (Plaintiff) has constructed a house on the part of the
suit properties. Therefore, she (Plaintiff) is the exclusive owner of
the suit properties and the house standing thereon. She (Plaintiff)
along with her husband i.e. Defendant No.3 are residing in the
house situated in the suit properties. The Defendant Nos.1, 2, 4, 5
and 6 have no right, title, interest and possession over the suit
properties and the house standing thereon. The suit properties and
the house standing thereon have been recorded exclusively in the
name of the Plaintiff. The two sons of the Plaintiff i.e. Defendant
Nos.4 and 5 are residing in separate places and they are not
residing in the house situated on the suit properties. One son of the
Plaintiff i.e. Defendant No.1 has made love marriage to the
Defendant No.2. After marriage, the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 were
residing with the Plaintiff and Defendant No.3 in the house situated
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 4 //
on the suit properties, but, subsequently, the Defendant Nos.1 and
2 tortured to the Plaintiff and Defendant No.3 mentally and
physically. For which, as per the request of the Plaintiff and
Defendant No.3, a village meeting was convened on dated
27.08.2012 and in the said meeting, the Defendant Nos.1 and 2
assured not to ill-treat the Plaintiff and Defendant No.3 further,
but, again the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 started ill-treating the
Plaintiff and Defendant No.3. For which, a meeting was convened
for the 2nd time at the instance of the Plaintiff. In the said meeting,
it was decided that, the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 will leave the house
of the Plaintiff situated on the suit properties, but, still then, the
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 did not leave the house of the Plaintiff,
rather they (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) continued their physical and
mental tortures on Plaintiff and Defendant No.3 as before. For
which, they (Plaintiff and Defendant No.3) were compelled to
reside in the rented house of their other sons and married daughter
i.e. Defendant Nos.4, 5 and 6. When, on dated 09.03.2019, the
Plaintiff came to her house situated on the suit properties from the
house of her married daughter i.e. from the house of the Defendant
No.6, the Defendant No.2 (daughter-in-law of the Plaintiff) started
scolding her and when, she (Plaintiff) informed the said incident
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 5 //
to her son i.e. Defendant No.1 (husband of the Defendant No.2),
then, the Defendant No.1 instead of allowing the Plaintiff and
Defendant No.3 to stay in that house rather assaulted and
threatened them (Plaintiff and Defendant No.3) to go away from
that house and reside elsewhere.
For which, she (Plaintiff) lodged F.I.R. on dated 10.03.2019,
but, the Police did not take any action against the Defendant Nos.1
and 2.
So, without getting any way, the Plaintiff approached the
Civil Court by filing the suit vide C.S. No.20 of 2019 against the
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 arraying other Defendants i.e. Defendant
Nos.3 to 6 as proforma Defendants praying for passing a decree for
mandatory injunction against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 for their
eviction from her house and to injunct them (Defendant Nos.1 and
2) permanently by restraining them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) from
coming upon her house after their eviction from the same and from
interfering with her possession in the same along with other reliefs,
to which, she (Plaintiff) is entitled for.
6.
Having been noticed from the learned Trial Court in the suit
vide C.S. No.20 of 2019, the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 (Husband and
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 6 //
wife) challenged the suit of the Plaintiff by filing their joint written
statement denying the above averments made by the Plaintiff in her
plaint taking their stands specifically that, the suit of the Plaintiff is
not maintainable. The Plaintiff has no cause of action for filing the
suit. The suit of the Plaintiff is grossly under- valued. Onus lies
upon the Plaintiff to prove her right and ownership over the Hindu
Joint family suit properties and to establish, from which source,
she (Plaintiff) got money to purchase the suit properties in her
name. The suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of the
Parties. They (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) are the members of one
family with the Plaintiff and they are residing in a common
residential house having its record in the name of the Plaintiff. The
Defendant No.2 along with her husband i.e. Defendant No.1 and
her in-laws (Plaintiff and Defendant No.3) are residing in their
joint residential suit house. They (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) denied
to the averments made in the plaint of the Plaintiff that, the suit
schedule properties belong to the Plaintiff. They (Defendant Nos.1
and 2) both have equal right, title, interest and possession in the
suit properties and the house standing thereon. The Plaintiff
(mother of the Defendant No.1 and mother-in-law of the Defendant
No.2) is a house-wife and dependent. She is not a earning lady and
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 7 //
she had no source of income to purchase the suit properties. The
Defendants are earning persons and during joint mess and family,
while they were going out of the village to earn money, the
Plaintiff was staying in the house. All sons of the Plaintiff have
paid money to the Plaintiff, as the plaintiff is their mother for
purchasing the suit properties. The suit properties were purchased
out of their joint fund in the name of the Plaintiff. They have
constructed the house on the suit properties. They (Defendant Nos.
1 and 2) are in peaceful possession over the suit properties and the
house standing thereon. They are residing in the same with their
children. The Plaintiff is only the nominal head and recorded
owner of the suit properties, but, actually, all the Defendants
including them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) are the joint owners of the
suit properties and house standing thereon. The house on the suit
properties is a joint and undivided house.
Due to some family disturbances, the Plaintiff and other
defendants have made conspiracy to oust them (Defendant Nos. 1
and 2) from their shared house in the suit properties, only, taking
the advantage of the revenue record of the suit house and the suit
properties in the name of the plaintiff. As, they (Defendant Nos.1
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 8 //
and 2) have right, title, interest and possession in the suit house as
well as in the suit properties, then, the suit of the Plaintiff against
them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) for their eviction from the same is
not maintainable under law.
Therefore, the suit of the Plaintiff is liable to be dismissed
against them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2).
7.
Basing upon the aforesaid pleadings and matters in
controversies between the parties, altogether seven numbers of
issues were framed by the learned Trial Court in the suit vide C.S.
No.20 of 2019 and the said issues are:Issues
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
Whether the suit filed by the
Plaintiff is maintainable?
Whether the Plaintiff has got cause
of action to file the suit?
Whether the suit is under-valued and
lacks pecuniary jurisdiction?
Whether the suit land along with the
house is the self-acquired property
of the plaintiff and the plaintiff be
considered as the exclusive owner of
the suit property?
Whether the Defendant Nos.1 and 2
can claim the house constructed
over the suit property as their shared
household?
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for
the relief of permanent injunction by
restraining Defendant Nos.1 and 2
from entering into the suit property
along with mandatory injunction by
directing eviction of Defendant
Nos.1 and 2 from the residential
house?
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 9 //
(vii)
8.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to
any other relief?
In order to substantiate the aforesaid reliefs, sought for by the
Plaintiff in the suit against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2, she
(Plaintiff) examined two numbers of witnesses from her side
including her as P.W.1 and exhibited several documents on her
behalf vide Exts.1 to 6.
On the contrary, in order to defeat/nullify the suit of the
Plaintiff, the contesting Defendant Nos.1 and 2 examined them as
D.W.1 and D.W.2 respectively without proving any document on
their behalf.
9.
After conclusion of hearing and on perusal of the materials,
documents and evidence available in the record, the learned Trial
Court answered all the issues in favour the Plaintiff and against the
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 and basing upon the findings and
observations made by the learned Trial Court in all the issues in
favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2, the
learned Trial Court decreed the suit of the Plaintiff on contest
against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 as per its judgment and decree
dated 31.03.2023 and 13.04.2023 respectively and passed a decree
for eviction against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 from the house
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 10 //
situated in the suit schedule properties directing them (Defendant
Nos.1 and 2) to vacate/leave the house in favour of the Plaintiff
within a span of one month and injuncted them (Defendant Nos.1
and 2) permanently from entering into the suit properties (both the
land and the house) immediately upon vacation of the suit house
assigning the reasons that,
“the suit properties and the house standing
thereon is the self-acquired properties of the Plaintiff
(Mother of the Defendant No.1 and mother-in-law of
the Defendant No.2) and she (Plaintiff) is the
exclusive owner of the suit properties and the house
standing thereon, in which, the Defendant Nos.1 and
2 have no interest and the suit house is not the shared
household of the Defendant Nos.1 and 2. The suit of
the Plaintiff is well maintainable for the reliefs sought
for by her (Plaintiff) against the Defendant Nos.1 and
2 in respect of the suit properties and house standing
thereon.
On the basis of the aforesaid observations, the
learned Trial Court passed the aforesaid judgment
and decree against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 in the
suit vide C.S. No.20 of 2019”.
10.
On being dissatisfied with the aforesaid judgment and decree
dated 31.03.2023 and 13.04.2023 respectively passed in the suit
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 11 //
vide C.S. No.20 of 2019 in favour of the Plaintiff and against the
Defendant Nos.1 and 2, the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 challenged the
same preferring the 1st Appeal vide R.F.A. No.16 of 2023 being the
Appellants against the Plaintiff arraying her (Plaintiff) as
Respondent No.1 and also arraying the Defendant Nos.3 to 6 as
Respondent Nos.2 to 5.
11.
After hearing from both the sides, the learned 1st Appellate
Court dismissed to that first Appeal vide R.F.A. No.16 of 2023 of
the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 as per its judgment and decree dated
31.10.2023 and 13.11.2023 respectively confirming/concurring to
the judgment and decree passed by the learned Trial Court in the
suit vide C.S. No.20 of 2019 in favour of the Plaintiff and against
the Defendant Nos.1 and 2.
12.
On being aggrieved with the aforesaid judgment and decree
of the dismissal of the first Appeal vide R.F.A. No.16 of 2023 of
the Defendant Nos.1 and 2, they (Defendant Nos.1 and 2)
challenged the same preferring this 2nd appeal being the Appellants
against the Plaintiff arraying her (Plaintiff) as Respondent No.1
and also arraying the Defendant No.3 to 6 as Respondent Nos.2 to
5.
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 12 //
13.
This 2nd Appeal was admitted on formulation of the
following substantial questions of law and the said substantial
questions of law are as follows i.e.:(i) Whether the suit property is the absolute
property of the plaintiff under the provision
of Section 14 of the Hindu Succession Act,
when the plaintiff P.W.1 herself admitted
that, she has no income of her own and the
property was purchased out of the income of
her husband?
(ii) Whether the reported decision between
Manohari Devi and others Vrs. Choudhury
Sibanava Das and others in AIR 1983
Orissa 135 is squarely applicable and
whether both the learned courts below
should have relied the said decision in
answering the issue i.e. whether the suit
property is the self-acquired property of the
Plaintiff?
(iii)
Whether the findings of the
learned courts below are acceptable in view
of the provisions of Section 12(2), 17, 19,
20, 22, 23, 25, 26 and 28 of the D.V. Act, in
respect of the matter i.e., whether defendant
Nos.1 and 2 can claim the house constructed
over the suit property as their shared
household?
14.
I have already heard from the learned counsel for the
Appellants and learned counsel for the Respondents.
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 13 //
15.
When, as per the findings and observations made by the
learned Trial Court as well as learned 1st Appellate Court on the
basis of the pleadings and evidence of the Parties, the aforesaid
formulated three substantial questions of law are interlinked having
ample nexus with each other, then, all the aforesaid formulated
substantial questions of law are taken up together analogously for
their discussions hereunder:16.
It is the undisputed case of the Parties that, the suit
properties, on which, the house stands, the same was purchased in
the name of the Plaintiff through registered sale deed No.1191
dated 08.09.1989 vide Ext.2 and the R.o.Rs thereof stands
exclusively in the name of the Plaintiff (mother of the Defendant
No.1 and mother-in-law of the Defendant No.2).
The law relating to the legal status of the property on the
basis of the sale deed and R.o.R. in the name of a female Hindu
like the Plaintiff in the suit vide C.S. No.20 of 2019 at hand has
already been clarified in the ratio of the following decisions:(i) In a case between Gangamma etc. Vrs.
G.Nagarathnamma and others reported in 2009
(II) CLR (S.C.) 483 in Para No.19 that,
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 14 //
When the properties, which stands in the
name of any female, she is the full owner thereof
and on which, the claim of the joint family
members out of joint family income cannot stand.
(ii) In a case between Marabasappa (dead) by
Lrs. and others Vrs. Ningappa (dead) by LRs.
and others reported in (2011) 9 SCC 451 that,
When, The suit properties stands in the name
of the Plaintiff’s mother-in-law, mother-in-law
becomes the full owner of the property by
operation of Section 14 of the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956.
17.
Here in this suit/appeal at hand, when, the suit properties and
the house standing thereon are in the name of the Plaintiff (mother
of the Defendant No.1 and mother-in-law of the Defendant No.2)
as per Exts.2, 3 and 5, then at this juncture, in view of the
principles of law enunciated in the ratio of the aforesaid decisions
of the Apex Court, it cannot be held that, the suit properties are the
joint and undivided properties of the Plaintiff and Defendants and
the house standing thereon is the shared household of the
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 (Appellants in this 2nd appeal).
For which, in other words, accepting the concurrent findings
of the learned Trial Court as well as learned 1st Appellate Court, it
is held that, the suit properties and the house standing thereon is
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 15 //
the exclusively owned properties and house of the Plaintiff
(Respondent No.1 in this 2nd appeal)
18.
Now it will be seen, whether the Defendant Nos.1 and 2
have their right to stay/reside in the house of the Plaintiff situated
on her properties against the wish of the Plaintiff, when, she
(Plaintiff) (mother of the Defendant No.1 and mother-in-law of the
Defendant No.2) is not interested to allow them (Defendant Nos.1
and 2) to stay/reside in her house alleging physical and mental
tortures against them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) on her (Plaintiff)
and her husband (Defendant No.3).
On this aspect, the propositions of law has already been
clarified by the Hon’ble Courts and Apex Court in the ratio of the
following decisions:(i) In a case between Ritesh Khatri Vrs. Shyam
Sundar Khatri reported in 2026 (1) CCC 110
(Raj.) that,
If, father allows his son/daughter to continue
in possession of his house or property or its
portion, same does not, by itself, create any legal
right in favour of the child to claim that, property
as his own, unless property is an ancestral or of
Hindu undivided property. Injunction against the
children sought for by the father is allowed.
(ii) In a case between Sachin and another Vrs.
Jhabbu Lal and another reported in AIR 2017
(Delhi) 1 in Para No.15 that,
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 16 //
where, the house is the self-acquired house of
the parents, then, son whether married or
unmarried has no legal right to live in that house
and he can live in that house only at the mercy of
his parents up to the time the parents allow.
Merely because the parents have allowed him to
live in the house so long as his relations with the
parents were cordial, does not mean that, the
parents have to bear his burden throughout his
life.
(iii) In a case between Suresh Sharma and
another Vrs. Dhanwanti Sharma reported in
2022 (3) Civ.C.C. 79 (Rajasthan) that,
Property of mother—Mother sought for
eviction of son and daughter-in-law—Mother
despite being the owner of suit property was
ousted out of it by son and daughter-in-law and
was meted out with severe ill-treatment including
mental, social and physical abuse by them—She
(Mother-in-law) categorically stated that, living
with the petitioners (Son and daughter-in-law)
would pose a threat to her life and mental well
being—Son and daughter-in-law rightly evicted
from suit property.
(iv) In a case between Anil Kumar Tiwary Vrs.
State of Jharkhand reported in 2021 (3) Civ.C.C.
664 (Jharkhand) that,
Property in question is the self-acquired
property of the senior citizen—Petitioners being
son and daughter-in-law are conjointly fighting
with senior citizen—Petitioners claiming right to
live in suit property, as earning of son is not
sufficient to hire separate house and daughter-inlaw has right to live in the house with full dignity.
Allegation of senior citizen is that,
Petitioners have been subjecting mental torture to
him, thus, he wants to evict both his son and
daughter-in-law. Petitioners rightly evicted.
(v) In a case between Namdeo s/o. Babuji
Bangde Vrs. State of Maharashtra and others
reported in 2022 (3) Civ.C.C. 131 (Bombay) that,
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 17 //
Eviction of son and daughter-in-law residing
in self-acquired property of senior citizens—
Safety and security of senior citizens shall be in
jeopardy unless son and daughter-in-law are
evicted—Son is not expected to brand his aged
father a „swindler‟ or then allege that, aged
parents have lost mental balance—Eviction order
upheld by observing that, it is absolutely
necessary to ensure the physical and emotional
health and safety of parents.
(vi) In a case between Krishan and another Vrs.
The Deputy Magistrate-cum-Appellate Tribunal,
Panipat and others reported in 2024 (1) Civ.C.C.
477 (P and H) that,
Property of mother—Mother sought for
eviction of sons—Mother is a 70 years old widow
lady and she is the owner of the property—
Petitioners have been misbehaving with their
mother—It is irrelevant, whether Petitioners have
any house or not, as it is the right of mother,
which is to be seen under the Act—In order to
ensure protection of mother, eviction of
Petitioners is necessary—Eviction order upheld.
(vii) In a case between Ravi Kumar Vrs. Deputy
Commissioner-cum-Appellate Tribunal, Jhajjar
and others reported in 2024 (1) Civ.C.C. 492 (P
and H) that,
Property of senior citizen—Eviction of son—
Petitioner son contended that, suit property is
ancestral property—However, no document or
material on record to show that, property is
ancestral in nature, in which, petitioner had any
right—More so, Petitioner himself raised the plea
in written statement that, he had contributed in
purchasing the house in question—Plea of
property being ancestral is contrary to said plea—
Mother of petitioner is thus, exclusive owner of
suit property—Order of eviction upheld.
(viii)
In a case between Deepak Kumar
and another Vrs. District Magistrate-cumPage 17 of 20
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 18 //
Appellate Tribunal, Hoshiarpur and another
reported in 2024 (2) Civ.C.C. 747 (P and H) that,
Eviction of son sought for by mother—
Mother is owner of the suit property—She is an
old person having no source of income and is
mentally and physically weak—Petitioners have
misbehaved with mother and did not provide her
with basic needs—Mother is not residing in the
suit property—Orders for eviction of Petitioners
rightly passed.
(ix) In a case between Rajeswar Prasad Roy Vrs.
The State of Bihar and others reported in 2025
(2) Civ.C.C. 403 (S.C.) that,
Eviction of son and daughter-in-law from
self-acquired property of senior citizen—Senior
citizen 75 years of age—Son and daughter-in-law
have not only encroached upon self-acquired
property, but, also threatened senior citizen of
false criminal complaints, abusing and creating
hurdles in running of Rest House and thereby
causing mental and physical harassment to old
parents. Eviction order against the son and
daughter-in-law rightly passed.
(x) In a case between Urmila Dixit Vrs Sunil
Sharan Dixit and others reported in 2025 (3)
Civil LJ 341 (SC) that,
The Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and
Senior Citizens Act, 2007 and Rules thereof are
the beneficial statute. The beneficial statutes must
receive liberal construction inconsonance with
the objects to be served by it. Courts or Tribunals
should adopt purpose oriented approach. Literal
construction be avoided. It is the duty of the Court
to discern the intention of legislature while
enacting it. Beneficial statute should be given
purposive construction, which should be line with
its object.
Statement of objects, reasons and preamble
of Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and
Senior Citizens Act, 2007 shows that, it is
indented towards more effective maintenance and
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 19 //
welfare of parents and senior citizens, it is as
such beneficial piece of legislation. In earlier
cases Supreme Court has highlighted that, it is
the social obligation of both sons and daughters
to maintain their parents, who are unable to
maintain themselves. Therefore, Court is bound to
advance social justice to them, when such case
comes before it. (Paras 8 & 11)
19.
Here in this suit/appeal at hand, when, the old mother of the
Defendant No.1 and old mother-in- law of Defendant No.2 i.e.
Plaintiff being more than 75 years in age is not interested to allow
her son (Defendant No.1) and Daughter-in-law (Defendant No.2)
to stay/reside in her house situated on the suit properties, in which,
she (Plaintiff) is the exclusive owner apprehending danger to her
life as well as to the life of her old husband i.e. Defendant No.3
alleging allegations against them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) that,
they (Defendant Nos.1 and 2) are giving physical and mental
tortures to her (Plaintiff) and her husband (Defendant No.3)
continuously, then at this juncture, in view of the principles of law
enunciated in the ratio of the aforesaid decisions of the Hon’ble
Courts and Apex Court, the judgment and decree for eviction from
the house situated on the suit properties passed against the
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 (Appellants in this 2nd appeal) and
permanent injunction against them (Defendant Nos.1 and 2)
immediately after their eviction from the suit house by the learned
RSA No.564 of 2023
// 20 //
Trial Court in C.S. No.20 of 2019 and confirmation to the same by
the learned 1st Appellate Court in R.F.A. No.16 of 2023 cannot be
held as erroneous.
For which, the question of interfering with the same through
this 2nd Appeal filed by the Appellants (Defendant Nos.1 and 2)
does not arise.
Therefore, there is no merit in this 2nd appeal filed by the
appellants (Defendant Nos.1 and 2). The same must fail.
20.
In result, the 2nd appeal filed by the appellants (Defendant
Nos.1 and 2) is dismissed on contest, but without cost.
The judgments and decrees passed by the learned Trial
Court as well as learned 1st Appellate Court in C.S. No.20 of 2019
and R.F.A. No.16 of 2023 respectively in favour of the Plaintiff
and against the Defendant Nos.1 and 2 are confirmed.
(A.C. Behera),
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
19th of February, 2026/ Binayak Sahoo//
Junior Stenographer
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BINAYAK SAHOO
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 20-Feb-2026 15:37:47
RSA No.564 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review