Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 1709 OF 2026
Petition under Arlicle 227 of the Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the order dated
17.04.2026, passed E.A.No.2 of 2024 in E.P.No.159 of 2024 in O.S No.421 of 2023, on
the file of the Court of the Principal Junior Civil Judge-Cum-Judicial Magistrate of First
Class at Kothagudem.
Between:
Chandra Venkateswarlu, S/o. Sivaiah, Age: 63 years, Occ: Agriculture, R/oH.No.9-1-46, Gattaigudem, Paloncha Town and Mandla, Bhadradri Kothagudem
District.
...PETITIONERI/DECREE HOLDER
AND
1. Arepalli Anjanneyulu,, S/o. Suryanarayana, Age: 55 years, Occ: Coolie, Fl/oH.No.25-1 -1 41, Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal,
2. Arepalli Satyanarayana, S/o. Suryanarayana, Age: 61 years, Occ: Coolie, FL/oH.No.25-'1-141 , Seetharmset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal,
3. Vemanana Venkata Naga Satyanarayana, S/o Adaiah, Age: 43 years, Occ:
Coolie, R/o- H-No. 25-1-139, Seetharamset, Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha
Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem district
4. Tadeti Satyam, S/o. Buchi Ramulu, Age: 55 years, Occ: Cootie, Rl/o H.No.25-1122, Seetharamset Banjar, Yenagunta Paloncha Mandal.
5. Todeti Ramana, S/o. Satyam, Age: 50 years, Occ: Coolie, Rl/o H.No. 25-1-127,
Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal.
6. Redimalla Nageswara Rao, S/o: Venkataiah, Age: 30 years, Occ: Coolie, Rl/oH.No.25-1-108, Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri
Kothagudem District.
-r{trcrE;iq!r:
7. Meka Vara Prasad, S/o Rama Rao, Age: 35 years, Occ: Coolie, Rt/o H.No.25-1-
144, Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri
Kothagudem District.
8. Meka Ratnali, S/o Rama Rao, Age: 42 years, Occ: Coolie, R/o H-No. 25-1-144,
Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem
District,
9. Yellala Yellaiah, S/o Mallaiah, Age: 38 years, Occ: Coolie, RJo H.No. 25-1-23,
Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem
District.
10. Kamana Narasimha Murthy, S/o Veera Raju, Age: 46 years, Occ: Coolie, Rt/o
H.No. 25-'l-144, Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri
Kothagudem District.
11.Jale Mangamma, W/o Ramulu (Late), Age: 50 years, Occ: Coolie, R/o H.No.251-125, Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri
Kothagudem District.
12. Chiraboina Mallaiah, S/o Yelamachaiah, Age: 55 years, Occ: Coolie, R/o- H.No.
25-1-115, Seetharamset Banjar, Yerragunta, Paloncha Mandal, Bhadradri
Kothagudem District.
13.Gaddam Ramesh, S/o Samuel, Age: 54 years, Occ: Business, RJo H.No.8-2-61 ,
Gattaigudem, Paloncha town and Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem District.
14.Gaddam Prasad, S/o Samuel, Age: 52 years, Occ: Business, R/o H.No. 8-2-61 ,
Gattaigudem, Paloncha town and Mandal, Bhadradri Kothagudem District.
...RESPONDENTS/JUDGMENT DEBTORS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2026
Petition under Sect on 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the
crder dated 17.04.2026, passed by the learned Principal Junior Civil Judge-CumJudicial Magistrate of First Class at Kothagudem, in E.A.No,2 of 2024 in E.P.No.159 of
2024 in 0.S No.421 of 2023, enabling the petitioner enter into the suit schedule property
with the aid of police protection, pending disposal of the above petition and pass
C:ounsel for the Petitioner: Mrs. B.Rachana Reddy representing
Sri. Mohd Baseer Riyaz
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr. B.S. Prasad representing
S ri. Ramu Nallamothu
The court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENIVAS RAO
Civil Revision Petition No.17O9 of 2026
oatefr.oa.zozo
Between:
Chandra Venkateswarlu
Petitioner/ Decree Holder
And
Arepalli Anjanneyulu and lhirtecn othcrs
Rcrsponden t s
ORDER:
This Civil Revision Petition has been filecl invoking the
provisions of Articlc 2'27 o( tht: Consiitt-ttion i-,l lrtclia aggricvcd b1'
the order dated 17.04.202(> passcd b1' tltt: lt:;trn, <l I)rinr:ipaJ Junior
Civil Judge-cum-Judicial Magistrate of First Cllass at Kothagudem,
(hereinafter referred to as 'the executing Court') in E.A. No.2 of 2024
in fi.P.No.I59 of 2024 in O.S.No.42 t r>l- 2o23, u'ht'rc trnde r thr:
application hled by lhe pctitioner/clccrcc holdcr seeking policc
protection for impleme ntation of the decree dated 1 1 .O3.2O24 in
O.S.No.42 1 of 2023 in respcct o[ thc F].P. schedule property \r'as
dismissed.
2.
Revision petitioner herein is thc decree holder and
respondents herein are the judgment debtors in the main tr.P I"or
thc sake of convenir:ncc, thc parties herein are referred to as they
were arravcd in ll.P.No.159 ol 2024 before the executing Court.
Brief facts of the case:
3.
I)ct1rroner,,r1cr rcc holdt-r filed a suit in O.S.No.421 of 2023
belore the trial C'ourL/exccuting Court for grant of perpetual
inlunr,'tron ri-'strainrnq Lhc rcspondenls/judgment debtors from
intr:rfcrLng s it:r il'il Ii I) s<'hedule propertv r.e. agricultural Iand
admeasuring .{c.2 20 gunLas in Sy.No.378, Ac.4-00 guntas in
Sy.No.3787 1, Ac 1 20 guntas in S1r.No.3757 1/A, Ac.O-20 guntas in
S_v.No ,176 rrnd Ac.(.) 2L) qLlntas in Sv.No.378/ 1/ 1 in all aggregating
to Ac.9 0O in a srngle c,rmpa<'t block situated at Paloncha Revenuc
Village and Mar-rdal, Bhadradri Kothagudem District (hereinafter
rclerrlcl to lrs'1hr: schcriLrlc propcrll.) stating that he had purchased
thc sanrc ft',r:r Ilirtirr.al l3ahcli throrrgh rcgrsrcred salc deed bearing
Nos.2796 of 2OA7 dirtecl 02.11.2OO7, 2537 o1' 2010 dated
11.06.2010. 1355 of 2()12 darcd 19.O3.2012.72 of 2021. dated
9.12.2O)1. Thr' saicl sLut \\as dccrecd on I1.03.2024. Thereafter.
rhc det ree holdcr lllcd fl.I).No. 159 of 2024 invoking the provisions of
Order XXI Rulc 32 oi tht' Code o[ Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter
relerred to as'thc C'.P.C.) sctking to issue',r,arrant of arrest against
-juctgmcrrr rtr.bLor- \os. t. .1. 7 ancl 9 lbr committing them
prtson zrnrl alsc lor grzlnI
tO CiVfl
ol police protecrion for
stricI
-
--
implementation of the decree by directing the S.H.O., Paloncha
Town P.S. In the said Il.l')., the decrt:e holdcr lilcd application uide
E.A.No.2 of 2024 under Section 151 ol the C.P.C. sccking protection
directing the S.Fl.O., Paloncha Town Police Station to provide
necessary pro[ection for implementation ol L]re decree of perpetual
injunction dated I 1 .O3.2024 . The cxe cuting Courl dismtssed the
said E.A. on 77 .04.2026. Aggrit:ved by the said order, the decree
holder fi1ed the present Civil Revision Petition.
4.
Heard Mrs.B.Rachana Reddy, Iearn<:d Senior Counsel,
representing Mr.Mohammad tsaseer Riyaz, Iearned counsel for the
petitioner/ decree holder and Mr.Lf .S.Prasad, learned Senior
Counscl, representing Mr. Ramu Nallamothu, lcarncd counsel for
respondent Nos.1 to 14/judgment debtors.
5. Submissions of the learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner/ decree holder:
5.1
Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the decree holder is
the absolute owner of the schedule property. In spite of the decree
of perpetual injunction grantcd by thc competcnt Civil Court, the
judgment debtors, without having any manner of right, are
interfering with the possession of thc decree holder and they are
trespassing into the schedule propertv and prevenling thc dccree
holder from entering into the schedule property and doing
agricultural actrvrtlcs iln(l Lhc judgment and decree passed by the
trial Cour-t rl:rrr:rl I 1.(13 202/+ are binrling upon them. In spite of the
same, thc JLLdgmcnl dr:brors have deliberately creating troubles to
the dccrce lrr:lder. 'l'hc decree holder liled several complaints
agarnst tlrr:nr :rnd basing on Lhc samc, Crime No. 109 of 2018 was
rcgistrrrecl on I.1 04.2018, Crime No.283 of 2022 was registered on
25.08.2022. Crine \o 167 ol 2022 was registered on 21.\'2.2022
and Clrime No.2'r3 ctl' )O21 ',r'as rcgistered on O2.O7.2024 and the
sairl cirscs :rrr: p,:nding bciore the lll Additional Judicral First Class
Magrstrate CoLrr: . I.,o:hagr:dcm. Subsequentll' when the judgment
debtors are trvir'.g to interfcrc rvith the possession of the decree
holder and prer,r'ntine him from doing agricuLtural activities on
04. 10.2025 and on 31.05.2026, the decree holcli:r Iodged the
complaint againsl them before Paloncha Tor.r,n Poli<:e Station, and
bascd on thc sa rl i omplaint. Crrmc Nos.372 of 2025 and 250 ol
2026 rr erc reglstcre(1.
5.2 l-earncd Se rior Counsel further submitted thal the decree
holder filed tr.P.No.15c) ol 2.024 to issue u'arrant of arrest against
judgmr:nt dcbtor Nos. L, 3. 7 and 9 for committing them to civil
prison. u.hereir-r tl.ie exr:cr-ttrng Court after taking into consideration
fhc oral ancl d,rcumcnt:rr,. e,. idcnce, allou,ed the E.P. on 17.04.2026
and issucd \1.e1rr:) tl of ar-rcst against j udgmr:nt debtor Nos
and 9 on pa\.nten I Ol prot.css
Accordingl_y, the decree
holder paid
-
-5
process. In the said E.P., l.he decrec holder liled E.A.No.2 of 2024
invoking the provisions of Section 151 of the C.P.C. seeking
protection and to direct the S.H.O., Paloncha Town P.S. to provide
necessary protection to the decree holdcr for implementation of the
decree dated I | .O3.2024
.
5.3 Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the executing
Court without properly considering thc cont(rntlons raiscd by thc
decree holder dismisscd tl'rc tr.A. solcly on tltc grounrl that thc
decree holder had filed E.P. for arrest of judgment debtor Nos.1, 3, 7
and 9, which was allowed, and the execution proceedings have
already been set in motion. Ilcncc granting ol poJicc aid in addition
to arrest ol judgment debtors w.ould amounr to duplication of
remedies and also the decree holder failed to place any independent
material before the executing Court to demonstrate that despite of
arrest of judgment debtors, thcrc cxisls a pr( scnt ncct'ssity
requiring intervention of the police lor implcmentation of decrec.
Though the relief sought in E.P.No.'159 ol 2024 and in E.A.No.2 of
2024 is different, mere filing of tr.[). for arrest of the judgment
debtors for committing civil prlson is not a bar sceking polict.'
protection and the impugned order passed by lhe executing Courl is
contrary to law.
.6
5,4 In suppo:t ol thc abovc said conrentions, Iearned Senior
Counscl relre:d r. pon thc ordcr ol the High Court of thc Karnataka at
Bengal uru in Sri
Balakrishna I{. P. and another v. Sri.
K.P.Puttaraju and others (Writ Petition No.51712 of 2019 (GMCI']C). datcd 07.07.201-). shcrcrn it n,as held that the Court is
having pos,er to grant po[ce aid for seeking implementation of the
temporan- injr-rr.ction order granted in favour of the plaintiff and
mcre liline oi applrcarion uncl<:r Ordcr XXXIX Ruie 2-A of the C.P.C.
seeking action rgainst Lhc dcfcndants for violation of injunction
order would not impcdrmenl to entertain thc appli<;ation for police
protecl-ion sceking [br enlorccment of thc temporary rnjunction.
5.5 Lcarnt'd qr r)r,)r (,)Liirscl l'urthcr rclied upon the judgment of
the High Court o[ Orissa at Cuttak in Sayed Ekrarn Saha v.
Haroon Khan and others (C.M.P No.14O of 2023, dated
12.\2.2O2.). \\ h!-rcLn jt rras hcld that the Court is having pou'er to
grant polrr:, a;cl lor rmp,r'mcnta ticln oI lhe aci intcrim injunction order
grantcd in lavoul of the petitioner under Section 151 of the C.P.C.
Lt:arned Sr nror Counscl also rclied upon the order of the High
Court ()l l-rcl ii ir -tr(' .rl \la.lr.1s rn Lakshmi Ammal w. Nalina
Ammal and others (C.R.P.(PD) No.1931 of 2O2l and C.M.P
No.15ot6 0f 2021, dated 21.02.2022), wherein it was held
ex('cutr()n CoLrrt is lt;trrng
rrnpiem tr.t Lirl ror. oi
pO,uvef
to grant police aid seeking
lhe le:r.t.r,c of pcrpetual
r
that the
in junction gran
ted in
-,7
favour of the plain ti ff/ decrec holdcr invoking the provisions of
Section 151 of the C-P.C. Hence filing of E.l) under Order XXI Rule
32 of the C.P.C seeking arrest of the judgment debtors for
committing them to civil prison under order XXI Rule 32 of the C.P.C
is not bar for seeking police protcctton for imple mentation of t.he
decree of perpetual inj unction.
6. Submlssions of the learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of respondents/judgment debtors;
6.1 Per contra, learned Senior Counsel submitted that E.A. No.2 of
2024 Illed by the petitioner seeking polce protection for
implementation of the decree oI perpetual injunction dated
11.O3.2024 invoking the provisions of Scction 151 of the C.P.C. is
not maintainable under lan' and thc cxecuting Court has rightll'
dismissed the E.A. There is no illcgality or irregularity in lhe
impugned order passed by the learned exccuting Court. Hence, the
present Civil Revision Petition is liable to be dismissed.
6.2 He further submittcd that pursuant to the ordcrs dated
17.04.2026 in E.P.No.l59 of 2024, execuLion Court had issued
warrants against judgment debtor Nos.l, 3, 7 and 9 and they were
produced before the executing Court and thel rverc sent to c'ivil
prison.
E
6.3 In support ol rhe above said contentions, learned Senior
Counsel rr:lir:rl Lrpon thc pnnciple laid dou,n by the Division Bench of
Hrgh Court ol Andhra l'radesh in D.Tulja Devi and others Vs.
Margam Shankar and anotherl, u'herein it rvas held that the
execntion pc[itron filed r-rnder order XXI Rule 32 of the C.P.C for
cx('clllLOn ol llrc: riccrr'c lor pcrpctual inlunction by arrest and
derention oI Ju(ignr(]ni ricbtor lo crvi) prison or t)). attachment of
propertv or bolh, pending consideration of such petition, the
execlrtlng C()Lrrt cannot ciirect the pofice to ensure obedience to the
dccrc'r:, '"'"hilc cx, rcrsing rhc pon'ers under section 15;1 of C.P.C, After
thc dccrec Lt becomc hnal or long thcreafter, if therr: is a violation of
injunction. bv the .judqment debtor, the Court which passed the
dcc:rec can c>r'dcr- dt lenrion ol thc' judgmenl debtors and attachment
ol'pr()pcrl\
Analysis:
7.
Havrn! c' rnsidclcd thc rival submrssions made b). the
respe('liVC partics and upon perusal of the material available on
recorct. it revcrals th:lt the rlecree holder filed a suit ir-r O.S.No.421 of
2023 lor grant rl pcrpctual injunction restraining the judgment
dr:btors from lntr.r-fcring,,r ith tl.rr: peaccful possession and enjoyment
oI rhc sctredrrie oropcrl.,. In the said suit, the judgment debtors
(2O1A) 2.\LD /-).2
were remained ex-parte and the e xecu ting Court on 1 I .O3 .2024
passed the judgment and decree in favour of the decree holder
restraining the judgment debtor Nos. 1 to l4 from interfcring with
the schedule property. [!vcn according to both the partics, the said
decree has become hnal.
8.
The record further reveals that the decree holder filed
E.P.No.159 of 2024 invoking the provisions ol Order XXI Rule 32 of
the C.P.C. seeking to issue warrant of arrest against judgment
debtor Nos.l, 3,7 and 9 and for committing them to civil prison and
also grant police protcction for strict- implcmcntation o[ the decree
by directing the S.H.O., Paloncha Town l)olrcc St.aLion.
9.
In the said E.P., the decree holder was examined as PW.1 and
on his behalf Exs.Pl and P2 were marked. The executing Court
after taking rnlo consideration the oral and documentary evidence
on record and after hearing both the parties allowed the E.P. in parr
on 17 .04.2026, and issued warrant of arrest against judgment
debtor Nos. 1, 3, 7 and 9 under Ordcr XXI Rulc 32 of the C.P.C. on
payment of process and posted the matrcr Lo 04.o5.2026.
10. In the said E.P., the decree holder also filed Fl.A.No.2 of 2024
in the month of July 2024 invoking the provisions of Section 151 of
lhe C.P.C. to grant police protection in hrs lavour and against the
ludgment dcbtc:s for strict implementation of the decree over the
schedrrle propcri\, br, clrrr:cting the S.H.O., Paloncha Town P.S.
1.
The recor,l ilrrt-her revcals that rhe decree holder in his sworn
affidavrt lilcd rn sLlpport ril ti.A. No.2 of 2024 state(l that in spite of
lhc dr:crec ol pcrpctual injunclion granted in his far.our on
11.03.202.1. \\ h(tn hc \\:,is attcnding his agricultura. operations that
rs manuring in rhr: sc:hedule property, judgment debtor Nos.1, 3, 7
and 9 intentio:rallv in gross disobedience ol the said decree,
obslrllcted him lro:r.r dorng thc same and therefore, sought police
protectlon in his iavour. Thc entire allegations are levelled against
judgment debto: Nos.l . ?,, 7 and 9 only and no allegations are
levclled agiLinst tllc other ludgmcnt debtors.
12. Durrng thc coursc ol hearing, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for.judqmr:nr debtors submitted that subsequent to filing
of this Civil Rt:vision Petition, judgment d<:btor Nos. 1, 3, 7 and 9
werc ;lrresle(1 arrrl ploclLrcccl bclbrc thc cxecuting Court and they
werc sent to cir rl prison. The said submissions have not been
disputcd bl tl.re L:arncd Senior Counsel appearing for decree holder.
13. It is alrr ad', stertccl s 1)r.r that thc petitioner in his application
i,e. E.A.No.2 ol 2021 has nor made any allegations against judgment
cleblor \os.2, .t to 6,8 irr.rd 1O to 1.+ that the1, are
decrCe Of iny,[tcrir1l :rnci ObslrucIing
disobeying the
lrom CtOing agfiCUitUfal
activities in the schedule property and entire allegations are levelled
against judgment debtor Nos. I, 3, 7 and 9 onll' and they werc
already sent to civil prison pursuant to the order dated 17.O4.2026
passed in E.P.No. 159 of 2024.
14. It is trite Iaw that solcly basing upon thc rclief sought in the
application, the party cannot seek police protection for
implementation of decree of perpetual injunction, in the absence of
any pleading. In the case on hand, the decrce holder filed E.A. No.2
of 2024 against judgmen t deb[or Nos. 1 to 4 seeking police
pro[ection for implementation of the injunction order, whereas in
the sworn alfidavit hled by the decree holder, hc made allegation
against the judgment debtor Nos.1, 3, 7 and 9 only that they are
threatening him and interfering with his agricultural activities in the
schedule property and no allegations wcre madc- against judgmcnt
debtor Nos.2, 4 lo 6, 8 and I0 to 14.
15, For the foregoing reasons, this Court is not inclined to deal
with the issue of Vhether the pe[itioner is entitled for grant of police
protection invoking the provisions of SecLion l5l o[ the C.p.C. for
strict implementation of the decree of perpetual injunction in
respect of the schedule property or not', in the present Civil Revision
Petition and the above said issue is left opcn to the parties, on thc
ground that the ordcr dated 17 .O4.2026 passcd in E.P.No.159 of
2024 tyas alreadr, enforccd against judgment debtor Nos.1, 3, 7 and
9 ancl tht:r \\ crc se nL to clvil prison and no allcgations u,ere made
agarnsl lhe othcr judgment debtors in E.A.No.2 of 2024. The decree
holder is granteri libertr to avail the remedies as available under
larr, il so ageric.rccr. In thc c,,'cnt oI filing ol an1, application, the
execu:ing Court s drrcctc'd to consider the same in accordance'"vith
law uninfluencecl b\ anv of the observation made in the impugned
order dated 17 O1.2026 or in this order. The judgment debtors are
also e ntrtlecl to ra,sc aLI r he gr,,unds u hich are available to thcm.
16. With the above said directions, the Civil Revisron Petition is
disposcd of Thert: shzrll be no order as to costs
As a scclr-r,'1. misccllancous pctitions, pending if any, shall
stand t:loseri
Sd/- K. BHAVANI SWAMY
IS ANT REGISTRAR
/ITRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To
of First Class at
1. The Principal Junior Civil Judge-Cum-Judicial Mag trate
Kothagudem.
2. One CC to Sri Mohd Baseer RiYaz, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Sri Ramu Nallamothu, Advocate [OPUCI
4. Two CD CoPies
pr
f+-
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0410812026
..4iYtL slart
c'-'
?/i
,;q
J
,,i
IO
ORDER
CRP.No.1709 of 2026
DISPOSING OF THE CRP
T
l>
e
J
1 7 AUI 2026
Z,
O;i
r, li
-\ /./
4-//
(1i;,5"-^';Y;lll)"'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review