Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.40917 of 2023
Chandra Shekhar Hota
….
Petitioner
Mr. T. Pattnaik, Advocate on behalf of
Mr. V. Mahapatra, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha and
Others
….
Opposite Parties
Mr. P.K. Panda, ASC
CORAM:
JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
Order No.
03. 1.
This
matter
ORDER
05.02.2026
is taken up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer:“In the circumstances, it is most graciously prayed
for that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:
i. issue a Writ and/or Writs setting aside letter dated
07.12.200 (Annexure-10) passed by the Opposite Party
No.2;
ii. issue a Writ and/or Writs directing the Opposite Parties
to grant pay protection in favour of the Petitioner by
counting the past services rendered by the Petitioner under
the Finance Department as Assistant Commercial Tax
Officer;
// 2 //
iii. to pass any other or further order (s) as deemed just
and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
4.
It is contended that petitioner while continuing in
the Finance Department as an Asst. Commercial Tax
Officer basing on the order of appointment issued on
08.11.2010 under Annexure-1, he made his application
to appear the OCS Examination, 2011 pursuant to the
advertisement issued by the Odisha Public Service
Commission vide Advertisement No.05 of 2011-12. It is
contended that after making the application to take the
OCS Examination, 2011 under Annexure-2, petitioner
sought
for
permission
to
appear
the
Preliminary
Examination of the said Examination.
4.1. It
is
contended
that
vide
office
order
dated
18.06.2014 under Annexure-3, permission was accorded
with
the
Examination
permission
to
appear
the
Preliminary
of the OCS Examination, 2011. It is
contended that after coming out successful in the
prelims, petitioner when sought for further permission to
appear the main examination, the same was also allowed
by the Finance Department vide office order dated
05.08.2014 under Annexure-2.
4.2. It is contended that petitioner, when ultimately was
selected to appear the personality test, he again sought
for permission, by making an application through proper
channel on 04.01.2016 forwarded on 05.01.2026 so
available under Annexure-5 series. Since prior to holding
// 3 //
of the personality test, so held on 20.01.2016, petitioner
was not given any permission even though such an
application submitted by the petitioner on 04.01.2016
was duly forwarded to the Commissioner of Commercial
Taxes vide letter dated 05.01.2016 under Annexure-5
series, petitioner on bonafide impression that such a
permission will be accorded post facto, appeared the
personality test on the date fixed and finally selected for
his appointment.
4.3. It is contended that on being duly selected vide
Notification
dated
23.02.2016,
so
issued
by
the
Commission under Annexure-6, petitioner was appointed
to the post of Group-A (Junior Branch) of Odisha Police
Service,
vide
Notification
dated
04.03.2016
under
Annexure-7, so issued by the Home Department-Opp.
Party No.2. Petitioner accordingly was relieved by the
Finance
Department
vide
communication
dated
02.04.2016 under Annexure-8. In terms of the said
permission given by the Finance Department-Opp. Party
No.1, petitioner joined as a Deputy Superintendent of
Police
in
terms
of
Annexure-7
Notification
dated
04.03.2016.
4.4. It is contended that even though petitioner was duly
permitted to appear the OCS Examination, 2011, with
due permission granted vide Annexure-3 and 4 and
appeared the personality test after making the required
// 4 //
application seeking such permission under Annexure-5
series and was also relieved after coming out successful
in
the
OCS
Examination,
vide
Annexure-8,
petitioner became eligible and entitled to get the benefit of
pay protection in terms of Office Memorandum issue on
06.06.1980 under Annexure-11 and Office Memorandum
dated 29.10.1992 issued by the Finance Department
under Annexure-12. But such claim of the petitioner
when was rejected by the Home Department-Opp. Party
No.2
vide
the
impugned
communication
dated
07.12.2020 under Annexure-10, the present Writ Petition
was filed challenging the same.
4.5. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that
petitioner was permitted to appear the Preliminary and
Main exam of OCS Examination, 2011 vide orders issued
under Annexure-3 and 4 and application made by the
petitioner seeking permission to appear the personality
test was duly forwarded under Annexure-5 series. Hence
it cannot be held that petitioner appeared the OCS Exam,
2011 without being issued with the permission by Opp.
Party No.1. After coming out successful and on being
appointed vide Notification dated 04.03.2016 under
Annexure-7, petitioner was relieved by Opp. Party No.1 on
02.04.2016 under Annexure-8. Hence the ground on
which petitioner’s claim to get the benefit of pay
protection was rejected vide the impugned order under
// 5 //
Annexure-10, is not sustainable in the eye of law and
requires interference of this Court.
4.6. Mr. P.K. Panda, learned Addl. Standing Counsel on
the other hand made his submission basing on the stand
taken in the counter affidavit so filed by Opp. Party No.2.
It is contended that in terms of office Memorandum dated
06.06.1980,
petitioner
since
prior
to
making
the
application to take the OCS Examination, 2011, never
obtained the NOC from the Govt. in view of the stipulation
contained in Annexure-11, petitioner is not eligible and
entitled to get the benefit of pay protection. Stipulation
contained in office Memorandum reads as follows:“It has, therefore, been decided that in the cases
where Government Servants take examinations conducted
by Service Commissions, Boards etc. for appointment to
new posts or where they apply for posts in the same or
other Departments through proper channel, and on
selection are asked to resign their posts for administrative
reasons, the benefit of service may, if not otherwise
inadmissible under the Rules, be given to them for fixation
of pay in the new post treating the resignation as a
technical formality. ”
4.7. It is contended that since petitioner prior to
appearing the OCS Examination, 2011, never obtained
the NOC from the Competent Authority and made the
application under Annexure-2, even though subsequent
permission was accorded to appear the prelim and main
examination vide orders issued under Annexure-3 and 4,
but the same is not in compliance to the requirement of
the office memorandum dated 06.06.1980.
// 6 //
4.8. It is accordingly contended that since petitioner
never followed the stipulation contained in the office
Memorandum dated 06.06.1980, his claim was rightly
rejected vide Annexure-10 and it requires no interference.
5.
To the submission made by learned Addl. Standing
Counsel, learned counsel for the petitioner made further
submission contending inter alia that in the meantime,
Govt. in the Finance Department vide office order dated
22.10.2024 under Annexure-13, has taken the following
decision:“Therefore, to save applicant employees from
harassment and also the Department from such unproductive
work, Slate Government in Finance Department do herby
grant its standing permission and No Objection Certificate in
favour of all officers of OFS, OTAS, Odisha Service of Auditors
(Common Cadre Auditor) and Odisha Sub-ordinate Finance
Service Cadres and other employees working under its
administrative control for applying for any job elsewhere or
for appearing in any recruitment examination subject to
following conditions:1. The employee shall not neglect his/her official
duties/responsibilities for appearing in any examination or
for applying for any job.
2. The employee must take prior permission of competent
authority for leave and Head Quarter leaving permission,
wherever required, for appearing in any recruitment
examination/job interview.
3. This Standing Permission/NOC shall not be construed as
permission of the Department to relieve the employee from its
administrative control. In case the employee is selected for
the job applied for, he/she must seek approval of this
Department, through proper channel, to be relieved from
his/her current service. Notwithstanding anything contained
in this order, in public interest or for any other justifiable
reason, the Department reserves the right to refuse to relieve
the employee from his/her current service.”
// 7 //
5.1. It is accordingly contended that since petitioner
appeared the OCS Examination, 2011 both prelims and
main, after due permission granted vide order under
Annexure-3 and 4 and his application to grant permission
to appear the personality test was duly forwarded under
Annexure-5 series, no fault can be found with the
petitioner, in taking the examination and consequentially
getting the benefit of appointment under Annexure-7. Not
only that after being so appointed, petitioner was relieved
without any objection vide Annexure-8.
6.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
considering the submissions made, this Court finds that
petitioner while continuing as ACTO in the department of
Finance in terms of Annexure-1 order, he made the
application to appear the OCS Examination, 2011 under
Annexure-2. As found, petitioner was granted permission
to appear the prelims and subsequently the main
examination of the OCS Examination, 2011 vide orders
issued under Annexure-3 and 4. Prior to taking the
personality test so fixed to 20.01.2016, petitioner sought
for permission by making an application on 04.01.2016
and the same was duly forwarded vide letter dated
05.01.2016 under Annexure-5 series.
6.1. Since petitioner was earlier allowed to appear the
prelim and main examination with due permission vide
order under Annexure-3 and 4, petitioner under bonafide
// 8 //
impression that such permission will be given appeared
the personality test and was also got selected. Petitioner
after being appointed vide Notification dated 04.03.2016
under Annexure-7 of Opp. Party No.2, was relieved by
Opp. Party No.1 vide order dated 02.04.2016 under
Annexure-8, without any objection.
6.2. Since petitioner was allowed to appear the prelim
and main examination of the OCS Examination, 2011
with due permission vide Annexure-3 and 4 and he also
made an application seeking permission to appear the
personality test vide Annexure-5, it is the view of this
Court that the same amounts to compliance of the
requirement of the office Memorandum dated 06.06.1980
under Annexure-11.
6.3. It is also the view of this Court that since petitioner
without any objection was relieved vide letter dated
02.04.2016 to take up the new assignment, the ground
on which petitioner’s claim has been rejected vide the
impugned order under Annexure-10, is not sustainable in
the eye of law.
6.4. Therefore, this Court while quashing the impugned
order dated 07.12.2020 under Annexure-10, direct Opp.
Party No.2 to extend the benefit of pay protection in
favour of the petitioner. This Court directs Opp. Party
No.2 to do the needful with passing of a fresh order as
// 9 //
expeditiously as possible preferably within a period of 2
(two) months from the date of receipt of this order.
7.
The Writ Petition stands disposed of accordingly.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Basudev
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASUDEV SWAIN
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 10-Feb-2026 11:30:14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review