Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010470872025
2026:CGHC:30149-DB
NAFR
INDRAJEET INDRAJEET SAHU
Date: 2026.07.23
SAHU
17:59:32 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WA No. 943 of 2025
1 - Chandra Kumar Vishwakarma S/o Ishwar Vishwakarma Aged About 57
Years R/o House No. 436, Ward No. 16, BNC Mil Chal, Upjail Ke Piche,
District - Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh
--- Appellant
versus
1 - Divisional Forest Officer Samanya Vanmandal (Purv) Bhanupratappur,
District Kanker, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Jila Vanopaj Sahkari Sangh Maryadit (Purv) Bhanupratappur Through
Prabandh Sanchalak District Kanker Chhattisgarh
3 - Rashtriya Tendupatta Majdoor Sangh Through Adhyaksh Shram Shivir
Baldevbag, District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh
4 - Peethasin Adhikari Labour Court, District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WA No. 946 of 2025
1 - Ashok Kumar Gupta S/o Ram Lal Gupta Aged About 64 Years R/o House
No. 1372, Ward No. 38, Shiv Nagar, Basantpur, District : Rajnandgaon,
Chhattisgarh
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1 - Divisional Forest Officer Samanya Vanmandal (Purv) Bhanupratappur,
District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Jila Vanopaj Sahkari Sangh Maryadit (Purv) Bhanupratappur Through
Prabandh Sanchalak, District : Kanker, Chhattisgarh
3 - Rashtriya Teudupatta Majdoor Sangh Through Adhyakash Shram Shivir
Baldevbag, District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh.
4 - Peethasin Adhikari Labour Court, District : Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
WA No. 949 of 2025
1 - Khelan Singh Bhardwaj S/o Shankar Singh Bharadwaj Aged About 60
Years R/o- House No. 1306, Ward No. 38, Shiv Nagar, Basantpur, DistrictRajnandgaon (C.G.)
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1 - Divisional Forest Officer Samanya Vanmandal (Purv) Bhanupratappur,
District- Kanker, Chhattisgarh
2 - Jila Vanopaj Sahkari Sangh Maryadit (Purv) Bhanupratappur Through
Prabandh Sanchalak District Kanker Chhattisgarh
3 - Rashtriya Tendupatta Majdoor Sangh Through Adhyaksh Shram Shivir
Baldevbag, District- Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh
4 - Peethasin Adhikari Labour Court, District Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellants
For State
:
:
For Respondent No.2
:
Shri Shrestha Gupta, Advocate.
Shri Shashank Thakur, Addl. Advocate
General.
Shri Mazid Ali, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ramesh Sinha, CJ
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Judgment on Board
16.07.2026
Per, Ramesh Sinha, CJ.
1.
Since common facts and issues are involved in all these writ
appeals, they are being heard and decided together by this common
judgment.
2.
These three writ appeals have been filed by the appellants with a
prayer to set aside the order dated 26.09.2011 passed by learned
Single Judge in three different writ petitions filed by the appellants
herein
i.e.
WP
Nos.2086/2001,
2091/2001
and
2092/2001
respectively, and to comply with the order/award passed by the
Labour Court, Rajnandgaon in the light of order dated 20.05.2025
passed by the Hon. Supreme Court in SLP(C) Nos. 19104 of 2023
and 21862 of 2024 in cases of similarly situated person i.e. Israr
Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif. For the sake of convenience, the
details of Writ Appeals are as underWrit Appeal
Arose out of-
WA No.943 of 2025
Writ Petition No.2086 of 2001
WA No.946 of 2025
Writ Petition No.2091 of 2001
WA No.949 of 2025
Writ Petition No.2092 of 2001
3.
In all these three writ appeals, application for leave to file writ
appeal (IA No.01/2025) have been filed by the respective
appellants. Since in the writ petitions, the present appellants were
not individually the parties and Rashtriya Tendupatta Majdoor Sangh
(in short, the Union) was the party respondent and the writ petitions
were disposed of on the ground that some of the members of the
respondent Union were reinstated on the post of Godown Keeper
with backwages, however, the respondent Union made statement
that they will not claim for backwages in future, therefore, the
present writ appellants have filed their writ appeals for which leave
to file writ appeal is required.
4.
In all these appeals the challenge is to the order dated
26.09.2011 passed by the learned Single Judge in respective writ
petitions and therefore in all these appeals applications for
condonation of delay (IA No.02 of 2025) have also been filed by the
respective appellants. Writ Appeal No.943 of 2025 is barred by 5101
days whereas Writ Appeal Nos. 946 and 949 of 2025 are barred by
5103 days.
5.
To decide the application (IA No.01 of 2025) for grant of leave to
file appeal, IA No.02 of 2025 for condonation of delay and also for
deciding the appeals, the facts of the case are that, the appellants
herein were working as daily wage employee on the post of Godown
Keeper under Divisional Forest Officer, General forest Division,
Bhanupratappur
prior
to
01.01.1997. The
respondent
No.3
Rashtriya Tendupatta Mazdoor Sangh moved an application before
the Deputy Labour Commissioner, Chhattisgarh seeding permanent
classification of petitioners and other similarly situated employees
and to provide them all benefits. The Deputy Labour Commissioner
referred the Industrial Dispute to Labour Court, Rajnandgaon. The
Labour Court registered the reference and award was passed on
23.03.2001 directing the respondent No.1-Divisional Forest Officer
to provide all benefits to the appellants herein treating them as
permanent employee on the post of Godown Keeper (Class-III)
w.e.f. 15.04.1999. Aggrieved by the said award of Labour Court,
Rajnandgaon dated 23.03.2001, the Respondents No.1&2 herein
preferred the aforementioned three writ petitions i.e. 2086/2001,
2091/2001 and 2092/2001 before this court without impleading the
appellants herein in whose favour the Labour Court had passed the
award. That, during pendency of writ petitions filed by the State, the
appellants were appointed on the post of Messenger (Class-IV Post)
on 22.09.2008 for a probation period of one year by State Small
Produce (Trade and Development) Co-operative Union, Raipur
which is a Co-operative Institution. The aforesaid writ petitions filed
by the Respondents-State were disposed of by learned Single
Judge vide order dated 26.09.2011 holding that subsequent to filing
of writ petitions, the members of Union (including appellants herein)
have already been regularized on the post of Messenger on
22.09.2008 and therefore nothing remains to be adjudicated in the
writ petitions. The Single Judge did not discuss the award passed
by the Labour Court whereby appellants herein were directed to be
treated as permanent employee on the post of Godown Keeper
which is a Class-III post whereas, the post of Messenger is a ClassIV post.
6.
One of the member of the respondent Union (Israr Ahmad Khan)
challenged the order dated 26.09.2011 passed by learned Single
Judge in WP No.2041 of 2001 before this court in Writ Appeal
No.339 of 2022. The Writ Appeal filed by Israr Ahmad was
dismissed vide judgment dated 10.04.2023, although the delay of
3161 days in filing the appeal was condoned. Vide SLP(C)No.19104
of 2023, Israr Ahmad Khan approached the Hon. Supreme Court
against the order dated 10.04.2023 passed in WA No. 339 of 2022.
Subsequently, another employee Mohd. Hanif also filed Writ Appeal
No.353 of 2024 before this court which was also decided on
21.06.2024 in the light of decision taken in WA No.339 of 2022 and
he too approached before the Hon. Supreme Court by filing his
SLP(C)No.21862 of 2024. Both these SLPs filed by Israr Ahmad
Khan and Mohd. Hanif came up for hearing before the Hon.
Supreme Court on 20.05.2025 whereby both the SLPs were allowed
to the extent that the award dated 23.03.2001 passed by the Labour
Court, Rajnandgaon, was upheld and the benefit for which the
appellants were entitled under the said award, were ordered to be
conferred to them within three months from the date of passing of
order by the Hon. Supreme Court. Thereafter the said employees
Israr Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif filed Contempt Petition (Civil)
No.5 & 6 of 2026 before the Supreme Court which was also decided
on 24.02.2026 in favour of the contempt petitioners. Review Petition
(C)No.9499-9500/2026 filed by the respondent No.2 also stood
dismissed on 21.04.2026. After passing of the order dated
20.05.2025 by the Supreme Court, the present three writ appeals
have been filed by the respective appellants.
7.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellants
would
submit
that
appointment of the appellants on the post of Messenger is not in
accordance with the order passed by the Labour Court. The Labour
court directed the appellants to be regularized on the post of
Godown Keeper w.e.f. 15.04.1997 and not on the post of
Messenger. Godown Keeper is a Class-III post whereas, Messenger
is a Class-IV post. Thus, learned Single Judge has erred in not
considering the award passed by the Labour Court dated
23.03.2001 in its true perspective and in mechanical manner have
disposed of the writ petitions on 26.09.2011, that too without
directing the affecting parties to be impleaded in the petition first. As
the learned Single Judge decided the petitions without impleading
the appellants herein as party respondents, they were not in
knowledge about pending litigation and therefore delay occurred in
filing these appeals may be condoned and consequently they be
granted leave to file appeals.
Leaned counsel for the appellants would further submit that
one of similarly situated employee namely Mohd. Hanif filed a Writ
Appeal before this court being Writ Appeal No.353 of 2024 which
was dismissed by the Division Bench of this court on 21.06.2024
holding that appellant Mohd. Hanif was not a party in the writ
petition, nor before the Labour Court. Against the said order of
Division Bench, the said employee preferred SLP before the
Supreme Court vide SLP(C)No.21862 of 2024. The said SLP was
allowed by the Supreme Court on 20.05.2025 whereby upholding
the order dated 23.03.2021 passed by the Labour Court, it was
ordered that for whatever benefits the appellants are entitled to
under the award of Labour Court, shall be conferred to them within a
period of three months.
One of the member of the respondent
Union (Israr Ahmad Khan) challenged the order dated 26.09.2011
passed by learned Single Judge in WP No.2041 of 2001 before this
court in Writ Appeal No.339 of 2022. The Writ Appeal filed by Israr
Ahmad was dismissed vide judgment dated 10.04.2023, although
the delay of 3161 days in filing the appeal was condoned. Vide
SLP(C)No.19104 of 2023, Israr Ahmad Khan approached the
Supreme Court against the order dated 10.04.2023 passed in WA
No. 339 of 2022. Subsequently, another employee Mohd. Hanif also
filed Writ Appeal No.353 of 2024 before this court which was also
decided on 21.06.2024 in the light of decision taken in WA No.339
of 2022 and he too approached before the Supreme Court by filing
his SLP(C)No.21862 of 2024. Both these SLPs filed by Israr Ahmad
Khan and Mohd. Hanif came up for hearing before the Supreme
Court on 20.05.2025 whereby both the SLPs were allowed to the
extent that the award dated 23.03.2001 passed by the Labour
Court, Rajnandgaon, was upheld and the benefit for which the
appellants were entitled under the said award, were ordered to be
conferred to them within three months from the date of passing of
order by the Supreme Court. Thereafter the said employees Israr
Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif filed Contempt Petition (Civil) No.5 &
6 of 2026 before the Supreme Court which has been decided on
24.02.2026 in favour of the contempt petitioners. Review Petition
(C)No.9499-9500/2026 filed by the respondent No.2 also stood
dismissed on 21.04.2026 and thus, the order of Supreme Court,
upholding the order of Labour Court, stands affirmed and the
appellants are entitled to be treated as permanent employee on the
post of Godown Keeper from 1997 itself.
He would further submit that the case of appellants herein are
squarely covered with the judgment of Supreme Court in
SLP(C)No.21862 of 2024 (Mohd. Hanif Vs. Divisional Forest Officer,
Samanya Vanmandal (Purv) Bhanupratappur & Others), therefore
the benefit flowing from the said order be also provided to the
appellants herein by allowing their writ appeals. Therefore, leave to
appeal may be granted in their favour, delay may be condoned and
their writ appeals may be allowed.
8.
On the other hand learned counsel appearing for respondent
No.1/State opposes the submissions made by the counsel for the
appellants and would submit that the writ appeals are hopelessly
barred by limitation and it is filed only after the order passed by the
Supreme Court. From 2011 till 2024-2025 these writ appellants have
not claimed their right and thus there is no sufficient explanation for
delay in filing the appeals and the writ appeals are liable to be
dismissed on this ground alone.
9.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2-Jila Vanopaj
Sahkari Sangh Maryadit, vehemently opposes the submissions
made by the counsel for the writ appellants and have submitted that
the writ appellants are seeking condonation of an inordinate delay of
more than about 14 years and there is no explanation for the same.
The present writ appellants were provided employment on the post
of Messenger in the year, 2008 and the writ petitions filed by the
Respondent-Union was disposed of in the year 2011. In the writ
petitions filed by the State, the respondent-Union were the
respondent and in that writ petitions the present writ appellants were
already provided employment and thus they were very well aware
about pendency of writ petitions and the order passed by Single
Judge on 26.09.2011. They accepted their employment on the post
of Messenger which is a Class-IV post and remained silent in
between that period. It is only when some of the employee Israr
Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif approached this court by filing writ
appeals and ultimately approached the Supreme Court in which
they got relief, the present writ appellants awoke and they have also
filed their writ appeals. The passive conduct of the writ appellants
disentitle them from the relief though their claims are similar. The
explanation about lack of knowledge of the litigation is not sufficient
to consider it proper explanation for such a long delay and the writ
appeals suffer from lack of diligence and vigilance on the part of
respective appellants. The condonation of delay are to be examined
independently and the present appellants cannot claim parity for the
same. In support of his submissions, he would rely upon the
judgment of Supreme Court in case of T.Gnanavel Vs. R.Sasipriya
and Others, 2026 Livelaw SC 457 and would submit that the
present writ appellants are fence sitters and cannot be permitted to
raise dispute after the matter has concluded. Relying upon the
judgments in Shoeline Vs. Commissioner of Service Tax &
Others, 2017(16)SCC 104 he would further submit that in these
cases the ratio of law laid down in Chairman, U.P. Jal Nigam &
Another Vs. Jaswant Singh & Another, 2006(11)SCC 464 has
been considered and declined to grant relief against stale claims.
On all these grounds, he opposes the submissions made by the
counsel for appellants and prayed for dismissal of all these writ
appeals by rejecting the applications i.e. IA Nos. 1&2 of 2025.
10.
We have considered the submissions made by the counsel for
the respective parties and perused the documents annexed with in
the writ appeals.
11.
Since the Coordinate Bench of this court had already condoned
delay of 4558 days in filing the writ appeal by the appellant Mohd.
Hanif (Writ Appeal No.353 of 2024) and the said finding of
condonation of delay has not been upset by the Supreme Court in
SLP(C)Nos.19104 of 2023 and 21862 of 2024 by its order dated
20.05.2025, the Review Petition filed by the respondent No.2 has
been dismissed by the Supreme Court on 21.04.2026 and further
that the claim as well as the issues involved in these writ appeals
are identical to the claim and issues involved in Writ Appeal
Nos.339/2022 and 353/2024, we are inclined to condone delay of
5101 and 5103 days in filing appeals and to grant leave to present
appellants to file writ appeals against the order dated 26.09.2011
passed in their respective writ petitions i.e. WP Nos.2086/2001,
2091/2001 and 2092/2001. Accordingly IA No.02 of 2025,
application for condonation of delay in filing the writ appeals in all
these writ appeals are allowed and the respective writ appellants
are granted leave to file writ appeals. Consequently, IA Nos. 2&1 of
2025 in all these writ appeals are allowed.
12.
With respect to claim of writ appellants in these writ appeals are
concerned, the Hon. Supreme Court has already upheld the order
passed by the Labour Court, Rajnandgaon, dated 23.03.2001 and
held that the writ appellants (Israr Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif)
are entitled to under the said award, shall be conferred to them
within a period of three months from the date of order. Therefore, as
we have already considered that the present writ appellants are also
claiming their entitlement being the member of Respondent No.2Union and similarly situated employees have already been granted
relief by the Supreme Court, we are not inclined to take another
view what has been taken by the Hon. Supreme Court in case of
Israr Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif.
13.
It is relevant here to take note of relevant part of the order
passed by the Hon. Supreme Court in SLP(C)Nos.19104 and 21862
of 2024 which is as under:
“Having considered the matters, we find that the order(s) of the
High Court cannot take away the rights of the appellants in their
personal capacity just because a stand has been taken by the
Union. Moreover, the High Court has not interfered or set aside the
award.
7. Accordingly, the appeals stand allowed to the extent that the
award dated 23.03.2001 passed by the Labour Court is upheld and
for whatever benefits the appellants are entitled to under the said
award, shall be conferred to them, within a period of three months
from today.”
14.
The respondents could not demonstrate that the case of present
writ appellants are distinguishable to the facts and claim of those
employees (Israr Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif) who have been
granted relief by the Hon. Supreme Court in the same set of facts
and under the same order dated 23.03.2001 passed by the Labour
Court, Rajnandgaon, and therefore, these writ appellants are also
entitled for the same relief as has been granted to Ishar Ahmad
Khan and Mohd. Hanif by the Hon. Supreme Court in their SLPs.
15.
Since the Hon. Supreme Court has already considered the cases
of similarly situated employees namely Israr Ahmad Khan and
Mohd. Hanif, the rights of present writ appellants cannot be denied
in view of ratio of law laid down by the Supreme Court in case of T.
Gnanavel (Supra) and Shouline (Supra), accordingly, we allow all
these writ appeals and the respondents are directed to grant
benefit to the present writ appellants also pursuant to the order
passed by the Labour Court, Rajnandgaon, dated 23.03.2001 as
has been granted to Israr Ahmad Khan and Mohd. Hanif.
16.
It is submitted by the counsel for the appellants at bar that
appellant Khelan Singh Bhardwaj (in Writ Appeal No.949 of 2025)
has been superannuated on 30.06.2026 and Ashok Kumar Gupta
(in Writ Appeal No.946 of 2025) is superannuated on 30.01.2023.
Since we have already upheld the entitlement of the writ appellants
in view of the order dated 23.03.2001 passed by Labour Court,
Rajnandgaon, they are entitled for consequential benefits uptill their
date of superannuation.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review