Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010209702025
2026:GAU-AS:1098
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5528/2025
CHAN MIAH
S/O- LATE MOHAMMAD ALI PRAMANIK, VILL.- BIRSING PART-III, P.O.
AND P.S. FAKIRGANJ, DIST. DHUBRI, ASSAM, PIN- 783330.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT
OF ASSAM, PANCHAYAT AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT, GUWAHATI.
2:ZILA PARISHAD
DHUBRI
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
GURU TEGH BAHADUR ROAD
WARD NO.1
BORO BAZAR DHUBRI
DISTRICT- DHUBRI- 783301.
3:BIRSING JARUA ANCHALIK PANCHAYAT
REPRESENTED BY THE PRESIDENT
DHUBRI
DISTRICT-DHUBRI
ASSAM
4:BLOCK DEVELOPMENT OFFICER
BIRSING JARUA DEVELOPMENT BLOCK
DHUBRI
DISTRICT-DHUBRI
ASSAM
5:BIRSING GAON PANCHAYAT
Page No.# 2/7
REPRESENTED BY THE PRESIDENT
VILLAGE- BIRSING PART-I
PO AND PS-FAKIRGANJ
DISTRICT-DHUBRI
PIN-783330.
6:SECRETARY BIRSING GAON PANCHAYAT
VILLAGE- BIRSING PART-I
PO AND PS-FAKIRGANJ
DISTRICT-DHUBRI
PIN-783330.
7:MD. SUJAB ALI
SON OF MAJER ALI
VILLAGE -BIRSING PART-II
PS- FAKIRGANJ DISTRICT-DHUBRI
PIN-783330
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. K K DEY, MR V K BAROOAH
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, P AND R.D., FOR CAVEATOR,MR S KHOUND,MR D J
MEDHI
BEFORE
Hon’ble MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Advocate for the petitioner
:
Advocate for the respondents :
Shri K.K. Dey, Advocate.
Shri S. Dutta, S.C., P&R.D. Deptt.,
Shri S. Khound, Advocate, R/7 &
Ms. M.D. Bora, S.C., IWT.
Date on which judgment is
:
NA
:
29.01.2026.
Reserved.
Date of pronouncement of
Judgment.
Whether the pronouncement :
NA.
Page No.# 3/7
is of the operative part of the
judgment?
Whether the full judgment
:
Yes.
has been pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Shri K.K. Dey, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Shri S. Dutta,
learned Standing Counsel, P&RD Department, Assam as well as Shri S. Khound,
learned counsel for the respondent no. 7. Though the Inland Water Transport
Department is not a party respondent in this petition, for a complete resolution of the
lis involved, on a request of this Court, Ms. M.D. Bora, learned Standing Counsel, IWT
has appeared and assisted this Court. Pleadings have been exchanged.
2.
The challenge in this writ petition is with regard to the rejection of the bid of the
petitioner which he had submitted for settlement of the Birsing Jogomaya Ghat of
River Brahmaputra in the district of Dhubri. As per the projected case, the Birsing
Gaon Panchayat had issued an NIT on 03.06.2025 for settlement of the aforesaid Ghat
in which, the petitioner had participated. It is contended that the bid which he had
offered at Rs. 99,000/- was identical to the bid of the respondent no. 7. According to
the petitioner, there is a prescription in the Tender Conditions that, in the event more
than one financial bid is found to be identical, recourse of drawing of lots has to be
taken which was not done and the settlement was made in favour of the respondent
no. 7.
3.
Shri Dey, learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn the attention of this Court
to Clause 14(a) of the NIT which prescribes that in case the same tender value is
submitted by more than one bidder, the same would be settled by holding a lottery
Page No.# 4/7
amongst the bidders. He has submitted that the aforesaid condition has been blatantly
violated and the settlement has been made in favour of the respondent no. 7 in an
arbitrary manner.
4.
On the other hand, Shri Dutta, learned Standing Counsel, P&RD, by drawing the
attention of this Court to the affidavit-in-opposition filed on 24.10.2025 has submitted
that the projection on facts made by the petitioner is not correct. He has submitted
that the recourse to the provision of Clause 14(a) of the NIT would be taken only
when the financial bids of two valid bidders are found to be identical. In the instant
case, however, the bid of the petitioner was found to be defective on more than one
count. He has submitted that the petitioner did not submit the Police Verification
Report (PVR) and duly attested passport photo. Further, the registration certificate of
the petitioner was not legible and the boat insurance was also not furnished by the
petitioner.
5.
In this regard, he has drawn the attention of this Court to the Comparative
Statement of the respective bidders which have been enclosed as Annexure-6 to the
affidavit-in-opposition filed on 23.10.2025. He has submitted that there is a clear
noting in the consideration of the bid of the petitioner that the same was rejected due
to insufficient documents. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to the Remark
column which contains certain reasons of such rejection.
6.
Shri Khound, learned counsel for the respondent no. 7, while endorsing the
submission of the learned Standing Counsel, has additionally submitted that the
settlement has been rightly given to his client inasmuch, as the aspect of taking
recourse to Clause 14 of the NIT would not arise in the instant case.
7.
Shri Dey, learned counsel for the petitioner, in his rejoinder, has submitted that
Page No.# 5/7
after exchange of affidavits, it was revealed that the respondent no. 7 was also not
qualified in terms of Clause 36 of the NIT. He has submitted that as per the aforesaid
clause, a bidder is required to be a registered owner of the boat and in the instant
case, it is not in dispute that the boat of the respondent no. 7 was taken on hire.
8.
The rival submissions have been duly considered and the materials placed before
this Court have carefully been examined.
9.
The primary challenge instituted in this writ petition is against the order dated
20.08.2025 issued by the respondent no. 6 whereby the settlement of the Ghat in
question was given to the respondent no. 7. From the pleaded case, the basis of the
challenge was upon Clause 14 wherein, there is a requirement to take recourse to
draw of lots when the financial bids of more than one bidder are identical. It appears
that the financial bid offered by the petitioner and the respondent no. 7 is the same.
However, it transpires that the bid of the petitioner was rejected which is reflected
from the comparative statement enclosed to the affidavit-in-opposition. Such rejection
was because of non-fulfillment of certain requirements and the same, as such is not
the subject matter of challenge. The learned counsel for the petitioner has also fairly
submitted that the grounds for such rejection are based on records and the same can
be verified only from the records. As mentioned above, the grounds, as elucidated in
the affidavit-in-opposition as well as from the comparative statement are that the
petitioner did not have the requisite documents required for consideration of the bids.
The learned Standing Counsel has highlighted four defects which have been
mentioned above.
10.
At this stage, this Court is also required to consider the submissions made by
Shri Dey, learned counsel for the petitioner that the bid of the respondent no. 7 is also
defective being in violation of the requirement of Clause 36. There is no dispute in law
Page No.# 6/7
that averments made in a reply-affidavit can also be treated to be a part of the
pleadings. In this regard, one may gainfully refer to the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Sri-La-Sri Subramania Desika Gnanasambanda
Pandarasannidi Vs. State of Madras & Anr. , reported in AIR 1965 SC 1578, the
relevant observations being extracted below:
“17. That takes us to the consideration of the question as to whether the two
reasons given by the High Court in support of this decision are valid. The first
reason, as we have already indicated, is that the High Court thought that the plea
in question had not been raised by the appellant in his writ petition. This reason is
no doubt, technically right in the sense that this plea was not mentioned in the
first affidavit filed by the appellant in support of his petition; but in the affidavit-inrejoinder filed by the appellant this plea has been expressly taken. This is not
disputed by Mr. Chetty, and so, when the matter was argued before the High
Court, the respondents had full notice of the fact that one of the grounds on which
the appellant challenged the validity of the impugned Order was that he had not
been given a chance to show cause why the said notification should not be issued.
We are, therefore, satisfied that the High Court was in error in assuming that the
ground in question had not been taken at any stage by the appellant before the
matter was argued before the High Court.”
11.
However, this Court is of the opinion that when the petitioner has failed to make
a specific challenge with regard to the aspect of rejection of his bid, the aforesaid
question of deciding the legitimacy of the bid of the respondent no. 7 may not arise in
the present case.
12.
In the conspectus of the aforesaid discussions, this Court is of the opinion that
no case for interference is made out and accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.
This Court, however, clarifies that the issue as to whether it is mandatory for a bidder
Page No.# 7/7
to be the registered owner of a boat or a registered boat can be hired by a bidder is
left open to be decided in an appropriate case.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review