The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. With the aforesaid observations C.O 4600 of 2006 stands disposed of.
23. No order as to costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
CO 4600 of 2006
Chabi Roy & Anr.
Versus
Amulya Das & Ors.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Gopal Chandra Ghosh, Sr. Adv
Ms. Suravi Ghosh
Ms. Parnashree Samanta
Heard on
:
08.05.2026
Judgment on
:
08.05.2026
Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J :
1.
Affidavit-of-service filed on behalf of the petitioner today in Court
be kept with the record. In spite of service none appears on behalf of
the opposite parties.
2.
This revisional application has been filed challenging the order
dated September 12, 2005 and September 26, 2006.
3.
By order dated September 12, 2005 an application was filed on
behalf of the plaintiff in the suit to defer the cross-examination of
P.W.2.
4.
Upon consideration of the materials on record and in view of the
fact that P.W. 2 could not be produced for his cross-examination,
such application was disposed of in consideration of the fact that the
CO 4600 of 2006
plaintiff was not in a position to bring P.W. 2 for his crossexamination by the defendants. On such consideration, the learned
Trial Court recorded closing of evidence on behalf of the plaintiff and
fixed the suit for evidence on behalf of the defendants.
5.
The predecessor-in-interest of the present petitioner, namely,
Nagar Chandra Roy filed a suit being Title Suit No. 336 of 1993
against the opposite party together with one Prafulla Chandra Roy for
declaration of his tenancy rights in respect of one room on the
southern side with partly covered veranda along with bath of privy
with other common amenities on the first floor of premises No. 176/3,
Bipin Behari Ganguly Street, P.S.- Muchipara, Kolkata- 700012 at a
monthly rental of Rs. 10/- payable to English Calendar month since
1961. The tenancy sought to be declared in the suit was under Late
Prafulla Chandra Roy.
6.
According to the case made out in the plaint, defendant No. 4
Prafulla Chandra Roy took the lease of premises No. 176/3, Bipin
Behari Ganguly Street, P.S.- Muchipara, Kolkata- 700012 from one
Raichand Dey who was the owner of the property. The lease was valid
for a period of 35 years expiring in the year 1995 upon certain terms
and conditions. According to the terms and conditions of the lease,
Late Prafulla Chandra Roy was permitted to induct sub-tenants in
respect of the premises leased out to him. In accordance with such
terms and conditions, Prafulla Chandra Roy inducted several tenants
in the said premises including Nagar Chandra Roy i.e. predecessor-in-
CO 4600 of 2006
interest of the present petitioners in respect of a portion of the
property as mentioned above. During his lifetime, Prafulla Chandra
Roy used to realize rent from the tenants including the predecessorin-interest of the present petitioners and used to issue due rent
receipts.
7.
In 1993, the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners came to
know that the heirs of Raichand Dey, the erstwhile owner of the
premises transferred the premises in favour of the opposite party
herein. According to the case made out by the petitioner, the opposite
parties, on the basis of a degree passed against Prafulla Chandra Roy
intended to evict the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners from his
lawful tenancy under the said Prafulla Chandra Roy. In such
backdrop, the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners filed a suit for
declaration that he was a tenant in respect of the premises mentioned
in the schedule of the plaint under the opposite parties with a further
declaration that the opposite parties had no right to evict the
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners from the said premises
without due course of law. It was also urged that the decree passed in
Title Suit No. 95 of 1971 against Late Prafulla Chandra Roy was not
binding upon the predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners. The
plaintiff also prayed for ancillary reliefs in the form of permanent
injunction.
8.
The predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners filed an application
for temporary injunction in the said suit. An interim order of
CO 4600 of 2006
injunction was passed which was subsequently made absolute upon
appearance
of
the
defendants/opposite
parties.
The
suit
was
contested by the opposite parties by filing written statement. It was
the contention of the opposite parties that the decree passed in Title
Suit No. 95 of 1971 against Prafulla Chandra Roy, the lessee, was
biding upon the predecessor-in-interest of the opposite parties and he
had no right to occupy any portion of the suit properties.
9.
The original plaintiff i.e. Nagar Chandra Roy died leaving behind
the present petitioners as his legal heirs and they have been pursuing
the Title Suit No. 336 of 1993 upon the death of their predecessor-ininterest.
10. In the course of hearing of the suit, the petitioner no. 1 was
examined as P.W. 1. He was cross-examined and discharged. Affidavitin-chief of P.W. 2, one Mr. K.D. Mukherjee, an advocate and
neighbour of the petitioner, was filed. However, due to his serious
illness, P.W. 2 could not appear before the Court on the date fixed for
his cross-examination. Adjournments were sought on the ground of
illness of P.W. 2, however, evidence on behalf of the petitioner was by
an order dated September 12, 2005. Later on, the opposite
parties/defendants
filed
an
application
for
appointment
of
a
handwriting expert to examine the signature of Prafulla Chandra Roy
on the rent receipt granted in favour of the petitioners which were filed
on behalf of the petitioners and were marked as exhibits. Such
application on behalf of the opposite parties/defendants was rejected.
CO 4600 of 2006
Thereafter, the opposite paties filed another application seeking crossexamination of P.W. 1 on recall with respect to the rent receipts issued
by Late Prafulla Chandra Roy. The petitioners/plaintiffs contested the
said application filed on behalf of the opposite parties/defendants.
However, by the impugned order, the petition stood allowed by learned
Trial Court.
11. By order dated September 26, 2006 an application was filed on
behalf of the defendant to cross-examine P.W. 1 on recall. Such
application was allowed by the learned Trial Court by the impugned
order.
12. The impugned order noted the proposed questions to be put to
P.W.1 on his cross-examination on recall.
13. It is submitted by learned Advocate for the petitioner/plaintiff
that by allowing the cross-examination of P.W 1 on recall, the
defendants sought to introduce additional evidence. He referred to the
notice in the impugned order to the effect that at the time of crossexamination of P.W. 1 a suggestion was confronted to such witness to
the effect that rent bills concerned were manufactured and also that
the said Prafulla Chandra Roy never signed in Bengali. However, later
on it transpired that the said Prafulla Chandra Roy used to issue rent
receipts in Bengali as well. So far as the proposed questions to be
confronted to P.W. 1 in his cross-examination by the defendant on
recall is concerned the impugned order has noted the aforesaid four
questions which are as follows:-
CO 4600 of 2006
“1. Did you file any rent receipt signed by Prafulla Chandra
Roy in English ?
2. If it’s not so, would you now file such rent receipts before
this Ld. Court ?
3. How are you related with Prafulla Chandra Roy ?
4. Have you any document to show such relationship with
Prafulla Chandra Roy ?”
14. Learned Advocate for the petitioner refers to question no. 2 to
submit that by such question proposed to be put to P.W. 1 at his
cross-examination, the defendants in the suit reiterated from crossexamination of P.W.1 in itself suggesting that the rent bills filed on
behalf of the plaintiffs were manufactured. It was also suggested in
the cross-examination that the Prafulla Chandra Roy never signed in
Bengali. It was in aid of such cross-examination that the defendant,
by the impugned order, was allowed to cross-examine the witness
which would amount to introduction of new documents.
15. As noted above at the time of hearing learned Advocate for the
petitioner/plaintiff
submitted
that
he
has
served
upon
the
defendant/opposite parties time and again but the defendants failed
to appear in the present proceedings.
Learned Advocate for the
petitioner also submitted that the defendant/opposite parties have
also not been taking any steps in the original title suit before the
learned Trial Court and a suit has been fixed for ex-parte hearing.
CO 4600 of 2006
16. So far as the proposed questions to be put in cross-examination
of P.W. 1 on recall are concerned, it appears that P.W. 1 was also
cross-examined on behalf of defendant extensively. The questions
noted by the learned Trial Court goes to show that P.W. 1 was already
cross-examined earlier on such facts and further cross-examination of
P.W. 1 on recall was not at all required.
17. From the impugned order it also transpires that the learned Trial
Court allowed the application of the defendant for cross-examining
P.W. 1 on recall in consideration of the fact that it will not prejudice
the case of the plaintiffs.
18. With respect not causing any prejudice to the case of the
plaintiffs is not the sole consideration for allowing an application for
recall of the witnesses already examined. One has to establish that
such cross-examination is actually envitable for the purpose of proper
adjudication of the disputes involved in the suit.
19. In the aforesaid circumstances the instant revisional application
is allowed.
20. The impugned order dated 26th September, 2006 is hereby set
aside.
21. So far as the impugned order dated September 12, 2005 is
concerned, it is submitted by the learned Advocate for the petitioner
that the issue involved in such order has become infructuous and no
further order need be passed in this respect.
CO 4600 of 2006
22. With the aforesaid observations C.O 4600 of 2006 stands
disposed of.
23. No order as to costs.
24. Urgent certified website copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
given to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.)
Rohit
A.R. (Court)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review