Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010669352017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3548]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL Nos: 1154/2017 &
2136/2017
M.A.C.M.A.No.1154 of 2017:
Between:
1. CH NAGALAKSHUMMA, YSR KADAPA DIST & 2 OTHERS,
W/O.CHINTALACHERUVU SUBBI REDDY HINDU, AGED 49
YEARS
R/O.D.NO.3/98,
BUDDAYAPALLE
VILLAGE
CHINNACHOWK PANCHAYAT KADAPA, YSR KADAPA
DISTRICT, AP
2. CHINTHALACHERUVU SUBBI REDDY, S/O.LATE PITCHI
REDDY
HINDU,
AGED
YEARS,
R/O.D.NO.3/98,
BUDDAYAPALLE VILLAGE CHINNACHOWK PANCHAYAT
KADAPA, YSR KADAPA DISTRICT, AP
3. CHINTHALACHERUVU SUJATHA, D/O.CHINTHALCHERUVU
SUBBI
REDDY
AGED
YEARS,
R/O.D.NO.3/98,
BUDDAYAPALLE VILLAGE CHINNACHOWK PANCHAYAT
KADAPA, YSR KADAPA DISTRICT, AP
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. GUNNAM VEERA VENKATA SATYANARAYANA E G DIST ANR,
S/O.VEERA SWAMY
SWAMY,, HINDU, AGED MAJOR OWNER OF
LORRY
BEARING
AP05
AP05-TU
TU
R/O.D.NO.2
R/O.D.NO.2-116-A,
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
GUMMALERU ALAMURU - 533 308 E.G.DISTRICT, AP
2. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP.BY ITS
BRANCH MANAGER YAM, 1ST FLOOR, HOUSALYA BHAWAN,
PRAKASAM ROAD, YANAM PONDICHERI
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC, aggrieved by the order and
decree passed in M.V.O.P.No.267/2012 dt. 25-102016 on the file of the
Court of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-Family Court-cum-VI
Additional District Judge, Kadapa, YSR Kadapa District, Andhra Pradesh
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(MACMAMP 2264 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased to condone the delay of 67 days in filing the appeal and pass
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. D KODANDARAMI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. P PHALGUNA RAO
2. T S RAYALU
APHC010012142017
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
M.A.C.M.A.
& 2136 of 2017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3548]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY,THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2136/2017
Between:
1. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
BRANCH MANAGER, YANANI, 1ST FLOOR, KOUSALYA
BHAWAN, PRAKASAM ROAD, YANAM, PONDICHERI.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. CHINTHALACHERUVU NAGALAKSHHUMMA 3 OTHERS, W/O
CHINTHALACHERUIRU SUBBI REDDY, AGE 44 YEARS, RIO
D.NO.3/98, BUDDAYAPALLE, CHINNACHOWK, PANCHAYAT,
KADAPA, YSR KADAPA DISTRICT.
2. CHINTHALACHERUVU SUBBI REDDY, S/O LATE PITCHI
REDDY, AGE 48 YEARS, RIO D.NO.3/98, BUDDAYAPALLE,
CHINNACHOWK, PANCHAYAT, KADAPA, YSR KADAPA
DISTRICT.
3. CHINTHALACHERUVU SUJATHA, D/O CHINTHALACHERUVU
SUBBI
REDDY,
AGE
YEARS,
RIO
D.NO.3/98,
BUDDAYAPALLE, CHINNACHOWK, PANCHAYAT, KADAPA,
YSR KADAPA DISTRICT
4. GUNNAM VEERA VENKATA SATYANARAYANA, S/O VEERA
SWAMY, AGE NOT KNOWN, BUT MAJOR, OWNER OF LORRY
BEARING AP-05-TU
TU-9645, R/O D.NO.2-116-A,
A, GURNMALERU,
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
ALAMURU-533 308, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying that the High Court
may be pleased to allow the MACMA and set-aside the order and
decree dt.25.10.2016 passed in MVOP No.627 of 2012 on the file of the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-Family Court-cum-VI Additional
District Judge, Kadapa.
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(MACMAMP 3833 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased condone the delay of 109 days in filing the appeal.
IA NO: 2 OF 2017(MACMAMP 3834 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased to grant stay of all further proceedings including execution of
the Order and decree dated 25.10.2016 passed in MV.OP No.627 of
2012 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-Cum-FamilyCourt-Cum:: VI Addl. District JUDGE, KADAPA, , pending disposal of the
MACMA
IA NO: 6 OF 2017(MACMAMP 29153 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. T S RAYALU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. D KODANDARAMI REDDY
The Court made the following:
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
COMMON JUDGMENT:
Heard,
Sri Lakshmi Harish, learned Counsel representing Sri D.Kodandarami
Reddy, learned Counsel for the Appellants-Claimants, and Mr.K.Vijay, learned
Counsel representing Sri T.S.Rayalu, learned Counsel for the second
respondent-National Insurance Company Limited.
2.
Dissatisfied with the Order and Decree, dated 25.10.2016, in
M.V.O.P.No.627 of 2012 passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cumFamily Court-VI Additional District Judge, Kadapa (hereinafter called as
‘Tribunal’), the Claimants-Appellants herein filed M.A.C.M.A.No.1154 of 2017,
seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the Tribunal. In contra,
the National Insurance Company Limited filed M.A.C.M.A.No.2136 of 2017,
challenging the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal.
3.
Since these two Appeals arise out of the Orders passed in
M.V.O.P.No.627 of 2012, this Court deems it appropriate to dispose of these
Appeals by way of this Common Judgment.
4.
Sri
Lakshmi
Harish,
learned
Counsel
representing
Sri D.Kodandaramireddy, learned Counsel for the Appellants, submits that
against the orders passed in M.V.O.P.No.627 of 2012 by the Tribunal,
M.A.C.M.A.No.1480 of 2017 was filed by the Claimants therein and
M.A.C.M.A.No.2114 of 2017 was filed by the Insurance Company before this
Court and a Division Bench of this Court partly allowed M.A.C.M.A.No.1480 of
2017 and dismissed M.A.C.M.A.No.2114 of 2017. He further submits that the
factum of occurrence of the accident and the rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the offending vehicle were affirmed by the Division Bench and,
therefore, the findings therein are squarely applicable to the present case.
Learned Counsel would submit that vide the Order, dated 25.10.2016, in
M.V.O.P.No.627 of 2012, the Tribunal has restricted the claim of the claimants
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
and failed to award compensation by not taking 50% future prospects of the
deceased and also awarding Rs.1,00,000/- towards love and affection,
Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of estate and Rs.25,000/- towards funeral
expenses.
5.
This Court, after due consideration of the orders passed by the Division
Bench in M.A.C.M.A.No.1480 of 2017 and M.A.C.M.A.No.2114 of 2017, finds
that these Appeals arise out of the same accident, which occurred on the
midnight of 01.06.2011, while the deceased-Chinthalacheruvu Vinay Kumar
Reddy along with three others and his driver were travelling in his Innova car.
6.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Appellants
further
submits
that
M.A.C.M.A.No.1154 of 2017 is filed by the parents and sister of the deceased.
He further submits that in view of the pronouncements of the order of the
Division Bench of this Court in M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1480 and 2114 of 2017, arising
out of the same accident, he need not emphasize the issue regarding the rash
and negligent driving of the driver of the lorry bearing No.AP 05 TU 8645
belonging to the first respondent. In respect of the second issue, framed by
the Tribunal, which was indeed taken note of by the Division Bench of this
Court, as to whether the entitlement of compensation in respect of the
Claimants therein, the Court has enhanced the compensation taking into
consideration the ratio laid down in the case of National Insurance Company
Limited vs. Pranay Sethi1.
7.
This Court accepts the arguments of the learned Counsel that the issue
regarding rash and negligent driving has already been considered and
decided by the Division Bench in the Appeals referred to above. Therefore,
this Court does not find it necessary to re-examine the said issue. Accordingly,
Issue No.1 framed by the Tribunal is answered in favour of the appellants.
(2017) 16 SCC 680
8.
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
The facts in the present Appeals and those in the Appeals before the
Division Bench are akin when juxtaposed, and there is no dispute regarding
the same and, therefore, with the consent of both parties, Issue No.1 is
answered without going into the facts of the case in detail.
9.
Coming to Issue No.2, framed by the Tribunal, which relates to the
determination of compensation, the learned counsel for the appellants has
drawn the attention of this Court to paragraph No.9 of the Judgment under
challenge and submitted that the Tribunal has grossly erred in hastily
concluding that Engineering Graduates are presently unable to secure
employment and that even Graduates are unable to obtain jobs with a salary
of Rs.10,000/- per month. On the basis of the said submission made by the
learned Counsel for the second respondent before the Tribunal, the Tribunal
proceeded to fix the notional income of the deceased at Rs.1,00,000/- per
annum.
10.
The multiplier method was applied based on the judgment in
N.Surender Rao and others v. B.Swamy and another 2, wherein the income
of the deceased was taken at Rs.12,000/- per month. The Claimants also
relied upon another judgment in B.Ramulamma v.Venkatesh Bus Union3 to
fortify their contention that, in the case of a B.Tech student, who died in a
motor accident, the Tribunal had considered the income of the deceased at
Rs.12,000/- per month.
11.
Disagreeing with the said contentions, the Tribunal fixed the annual
income of the deceased at Rs.1,00,000/- and applied the multiplier method as
laid down in the case of Sarla Verma and Others vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation and Another4, wherein the multiplier for the age group of 21–25
years is ‘18’. In the present case, the deceased was aged about 21 years and,
2014 ACJ 2613
2011 ACJ 1702 (AP)
(2009) 6 SCC 121
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
therefore, the application of the multiplier ‘18’ is appropriate. As there is no
rebuttal to the said finding, this Court confirms the opinion of the Tribunal in
adopting the multiplier ‘18’.
12.
As stated supra, the facts are not in dispute. The only contention
advanced by the learned Counsel for the appellants is that, in the case of
Engineering students, who died in motor accidents, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has considered the notional income at Rs.20,000/- per month and
applied the multiplier ‘18’, along with 40% towards future prospects. In support
of the said contention, the learned Counsel for the appellants relied upon a
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in S.Mohammed Hakkim v.
National Insurance Company Limited & Others5.
13.
In the said Judgment relied upon by the learned Counsel for the
appellants, an elaborate discussion regarding the notional income of a student
was made at paragraph 9, which reads as follows:
“Now coming to the quantum of compensation.
Admittedly, the age of the appellant at the time of the
accident was 20 years, and he was studying in the 3rd
year of Engineering College, Coimbatore. It is also not
disputed that the appellant had lost his left leg due to
the accident and thus, suffers from a 100% functional
disability. While determining the quantum of
compensation, the Tribunal had taken Rs.15,000 as
the appellant’s monthly notional income and the same
was affirmed by the High Court. However, the learned
counsel for the appellant would contend that the
appellant’s notional income ought to have been taken
as Rs.25,000 per month.”
14.
There is no reason for this Court to refrain from applying the principle
and ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court referred to above. The
deceased herein was admittedly an Engineering Graduate, which fact has not
been denied by either side. The only contention raised by the learned Counsel
2025 SC 749
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
for the respondents before the Tribunal, and reiterated in the present Appeals,
is that Engineering Graduates are presently unable to secure employment and
that even Graduates are unable to obtain jobs with a salary of Rs.10,000/- per
month.
15.
Mr.K.Vijay, learned Counsel representing Sri T.S.Rayalu, learned
Counsel for the Insurance Company, would contend that the Tribunal has
rightly fixed the notional income at Rs.1,00,000/- per annum. He further
submits that even if the notional income is taken at Rs.20,000/- per month,
instead of Rs.10,000/- per month, as fixed by the Tribunal, the income of the
deceased, along with future prospects at 40%, would come to Rs.28,000/- per
month, as per the guidelines laid down in Sarla Verma’s case (fourth cited
supra), which were subsequently upheld in Pranay Sethi’s case (first cited
supra). Out of the said amount, 50% has to be deducted towards the personal
and living expenses of the deceased and, therefore, the contribution of the
deceased to his family would be Rs.14,000/- per month.
16.
In oppugnation to the said arguments advanced by the learned Counsel
for the Appellants and the stand taken by this Court to fix the notional income
at Rs.20,000/- per month, as per the guidelines and ratio laid down in Sarla
Verma’s case and Pranay Sethi’s case, learned Counsel representing the
Insurance Company would emphatically state that the ratio laid down in the
said Judgments will not apply to the present case.
17.
In Pranay Sethi’s case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court awarded a sum of
Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and
Rs.40,000/- towards loss of consortium. Following the said principle, this Court
deems it appropriate to award a sum of Rs.15,000/- towards funeral
expenses, Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and Rs.40,000/- towards loss of
consortium to the Claimants-Appellants.
18.
It is needless to state that when an Appeal is filed against an order
challenging the compensation as not Just, it constitutes a continuous cause of
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
action. Hence, the Judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court can be made
applicable to the present case. Accordingly, the Order and Decree of the
Tribunal stand modified to the extent indicated below.
Description
Calculation
Income per month
Rs.14,000/-
Income per annum
Rs.14,000/- x 12
Compensation
on Rs.1,68,000/applying Multiplier
Consortium
claimants
19.
to
Amount (Rs.)
the Rs.40,000 x 3
Rs.1,68,000/x Rs.30,24,000/Rs.1,20,000/-
Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000/-
Loss of Estate
Rs.15,000/-
Total compensation
payable
Rs.31,74,000/-
At this point of time, learned Counsel for the Appellants has drawn the
attention of this Court to paragraph 16 of the Judgment in Kinnera Sridevi
and two Others vs. Gunnam Veera Venkata Satyanarayana and Another 6,
wherein the future interest @ 7.5% per annum granted by the Tribunal was
enhanced to 9% per annum considering the Judgment of the Apex Court in
Rahul Sharma and Another vs. National Insurance Company Limited and
Others7. As the Division Bench of this Court has modified the rate of interest
from 7.5% to 9% in one of the connected matters, this Court has no other
option except to follow the same and enhance the rate of interest from 7.5% to
9% per annum.
20.
In fine, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.1154 of 2017
is allowed, enhancing the compensation granted to the Claimants from
Rs.9,45,000/- to Rs.31,74,000/- with interest @ 9% per annum. The
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1480 and 2114 of 2017
(2021) 6 SCC 188
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1154
& 2136 of 2017
respondents 1 and 2 are directed to deposit the aforesaid enhanced amount
of compensation before the Tribunal, within a period of eight weeks from the
date of receipt of a copy of this Judgment, after deducting the amount, if any,
deposited earlier. On such deposit, the Claimants are entitled to withdraw the
same as per their apportioned shares before the Tribunal. The Claimants shall
pay the deficit Court fee on the compensation amount awarded over and
above the amount claimed in the Claim Petition. It is made clear that the
interest @ 9% per annum on the enhanced amount shall be paid from the
date of this order till the date of realization.
21.
In view of allowing the Appeal filed by the Claimants, the Motor Accident
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.2136 of 2017 filed by the Insurance Company
shall stand dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
22.
As a sequel, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
23.
Office to enclose a copy of the Common Judgment, dated 02.12.2024,
in M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1480 and 2114 of 2017, to this order.
16th February,2026.
Tsy/BMS.
_______________________
TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review