Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No.13
14.10.2026
Court. No. 12
GB
MAT 1782 of 2026
With
CAN 1 of 2026
CESC Limited
Vs.
Smt. Sutapa Nath & Anr.
Mr. Dr. Madhusudan Saha Roy,
Mr. Debanjan Mukherjee
Mr. Bidyut Kumar Halder,
Mr. Indranil Halder,
Ms. Neha Singh
1.
… for the Appellant.
… for the Respondent No.1.
The CESC Limited is the appellant. The appellant is
aggrieved by the order dated September 28, 2026,
passed in WPA 26103 of 2026. By the interim order, the
learned Judge directed restoration of supply as
payment of 50% of the finally assessed amount had
been made.
2.
The final order of assessment was passed on September
21, 2026 and the appellant was granted liberty to prefer
an appeal. The matter has been kept pending before
Her Lordship to be listed two weeks after the vacation.
3.
Mr. Dr. Saha Roy, learned advocate the CESC Limited
submits that the order for restoration of supply is
contrary to law and in violation of the statutory
provision.
Restoration
of
supply
which
was
disconnected on account of pilferage, can only be made
upon payment of the entire finally assessed amount. He
relies on two Division Bench judgments passed in the
matter of Md. Iftekhar – versus – CESC Limited
& Anr. in MAT 510 of 2026 and in the matter of
Santosh Agarwal – versus – CESC Limited &
Ors. in FMA 197 of 2022. Relying on the decision of
a Full Bench in the matter of Prabhat Pan – versus
– State of West Bengal reported in 2015 (2) CHN
(CAL) 185, it is submitted that the order of the learned
Single Judge is per incuriam and contrary to the
Division Bench judgments. The learned Single Judge
had digressed from the settled proposition of law.
4.
It is further submitted that in the decision of Anurag
Kumar Singh & Ors. – versus – State of
Uttarakhand & Ors. reported in
AIR 2016
Supreme Court 4542, the Hon’ble Apex Court held
that judicial discretion could not be exercised by court
when the statute was clear. Discretion could not exist
when there was but one lawful option. He prayed for
setting aside of the order impugned.
5.
Mr. Halder, learned advocate for the writ petitioner
submits that, at least three Division Benches of the
High Court in MAT 553 of 2013, MAT 1784 of 2016
and MAT 607 of 2010 had permitted restoration of
supply upon payment of 50% of the assessed amount
and made the payment of remaining 50% subject to the
result of the statutory appeal.
6.
We are not impressed with the submissions of Mr.
Halder in view of the provision of Section 135(1A) of the
Electricity Act, and the proviso. The same is quoted
below:“Section 135 (1A)
(1A) Without prejudice to the provisions of this
Act, the licensee or supplier, as the case may
be, may, upon detection of such theft of
electricity, immediately disconnect the supply
of electricity:
Provided that only such officer of the licensee
or supplier, as authorized for the purpose by
the Appropriate Commission or any other
officer of the licensee or supplier, as the case
may be, of the rank higher than the rank so
authorised shall disconnect the supply line of
electricity:
Provided further that such officer of the
licensee or supplier, as the case may be, shall
lodge a complaint in writing relating to the
commission of such offence in police station
having jurisdiction within twenty four hours
from the time of such disconnection:
Provided also that the licensee or supplier, as
the case may be, on deposit or payment of the
assessed amount or electricity charges in
accordance with the provisions of this Act,
shall, without prejudice to the obligation to
lodge the complaint as referred to in the
second proviso to this clause, restore the
supply line of electricity within forty-eight
hours of such deposit or payment.”
7.
The 3rd proviso to Section 135(1A) clearly mandates that
on deposit and/or payment of the assessed amount in
accordance with the provisions of the Act, supply shall
be restored within 48 hours from such deposit and the
deposit will be without prejudice to the rights and
contentions of the consumer.
8.
Regulation 6.3 of 55/WBERC dated August 7, 2013
provides that the supply of electricity to a consumer
whose supply had been disconnected in terms of the
Regulation 4.2.1 shall be reconnected by the licensee at
the earliest and positively within 48 hours from the
time of payment of the assessed amount. Regulation
4.2.1 deals with disconnection of supply upon detection
of theft or unauthorized use. By passing the interim
order, Her Lordship has rewritten the statute. It was
not a situation in which discretion could be exercised.
9.
Although, Mr. Halder has tried to persuade us to agree
with the directions passed by the Division Benches of
this Court, we respectfully disagree with those for the
following reasons:a) In none of the decisions, the issue was
decided by applying the legal provision.
b) The proposition of law was not considered.
c) No ratio had been laid down.
10.
Under such circumstances, we agree with the decision
of the two Division Benches passed in FMA 197 of 2022
and MAT 510 of 2023. The relevant portions of the
decision in FMA 197 of 2022 are quoted below:“Having heard the learned Counsel for the
parties and on perusal of the record, it is
noticed that learned Single Judge has not
committed any error in reaching to the
conclusion that against the final order of
assessment the appellant should avail the
remedy of appeal under Section 127 of the
Electricity Act, 2003. Since, an alternative
efficacious remedy of appeal is available,
therefore, no ground was made out to
entertain the writ petition. So far as the issue
on grant of reconnection on payment of 50%
of the assessed amount is concerned though
under Section 127(2) of the Act an appeal is
maintainable on deposit of half of the assessed
amount but that is not enough for restoration
of the electricity connection in a case of theft of
electricity. In view of the contents of inspection
report appellant cannot contend that the case
is not covered by Section 135. Learned Single
Judge has rightly taken note of the provisions
of the Sections 126, 127 and 135 of the Act while
reaching to the conclusion that the appellant is
not entitled to reconnection merely on deposit
of 50% of the amount.
This Court also in the matter of Biswajit Bose
and Anr. vs. CESC Limited and Ors. by order
dated 06.04.2022 passed in MAT 414 of 2022
considering the similar issue had held that:
“So far as the issue of right to file an appeal
and its hearing is concerned, under Section 127
of
the
Electricity
Act,
appeal
becomes
maintainable against an order of assessment
if the appellants deposit half of the assessed
amount in terms of sub-section (2) of Section
127 subject to the other provisions of the Act.
But the issue which has been raised in the
matter is about restoration of electricity
connection on deposit of 50% of the amount.
Third proviso of Section 135(1A) of the Act
provides for restoration of electricity on
deposit of payment of assessed amount which
reads as under:
“135(1A) – Without prejudice to
the provisions of this Act, the licensee or
supplier, as the case may be, may, upon
detection of such theft of electricity,
immediately disconnect the supply of
electricity; Provided that only such
officer of the licensee or supplier, as
authorised for the purpose by the
Appropriate Commission or any other
officer of the licensee or supplier, as the
case may be, of the rank higher than the
rank so authorised shall disconnect the
supply line of electricity; Provided
further that such officer of the licensee
or supplier, as the case may be, shall
lodge a complaint in writing relating to
the commission of such offence in police
station
having
jurisdiction
within
twenty four hour from the time of such
disconnect; Provided also that the
licensee or supplier, as the case may be,
on deposit or payment of the assessed
amount or 5 electricity charges in
accordance with the provisions of this
Act, shall, without prejudice to the
obligation to lodge the complaint as
referred to in the second proviso to this
clause, restore the supply line of
electricity within forty-eight hours of
such deposit or payment.”
Regulations have also been framed in exercise
of the powers conferred by the Electricity Act,
namely,
the
West
Bengal
Electricity
Regulatory Commission (Electricity Supply
Code) Regulations, 2013 and Regulation 6
relates
to
reconnection
of
supply
and
Regulation 6.4 which is relevant, reads as
under:
“6.4. Where a consumer served with the
order
of
provisional
assessment
under
regulation 5.2 or the order of final assessment
under regulation 5.4 accepts such assessment
and wishes to pay the assessed amount, he
may submit an application to the licensee in
the format as in Annexure – 2 within two
working days from the date of receipt of the
order of provisional assessment or final
assessment, as the case may be, and the
licensee shall provide him/serve upon him
bill(s) for the purpose within forty eight hours
of receipt of such application to enable the
consumer to pay the amount provisionally or
finally assessed. On payment against such
provisional or final bill by the consumer, the
reconnection shall be done within 48 hours.”
The above regulation also provides that on
payment of provisional or final bill by the 6
consumer the reconnection will be done within
48 hours.
Having perused the order of the learned Single
Judge, we find that the learned Single Judge
has refused to direct reconnection of electricity
on deposit of 50% of the assessed amount
having due regard to the provision of
contained in Section 135(1A) of the Act and
Regulation 6.4.
Hence, we are of the view that the learned
Single Judge has not committed any error in
not accepting the prayer of the appellants for
restoration of the electricity only on deposit of
50% of the assessed amount.”
11.
We further quote the decision of Md. Iftekhar in
support of the same proposition.
“3) The Court cannot rewrite the law nor can
the regulations be construed. Under Section
135(1A), third proviso read with Clause 6.3 of
the Regulation 55/WBERC dated August 7,
2013, the consumer whose supply has been
disconnected on the ground of theft or
unauthorized use of electricity can seek
reconnection without prejudice to all other
statutory remedies, upon deposit of the finally
assessed amount.”
12.
Accordingly, the order impugned is set aside.
13.
However, if the writ petitioner is inclined to obtain
electric connection, CESC Limited will grant such
connection and we direct as hereunder:i) Restoration of supply upon payment of
reconnection charges shall be made within 48
hours from date, in view of the payment of 50%
of the assessed amount, i.e., Rs.1,28,935.50/-.
ii) Remaining 50% shall be paid in four equal
monthly instalments along with current electric
charges.
iii) First of such instalment shall be paid along
with current bill in November 2026 and month
by month, every months, till liquidation.
Fraction if any, will be added to the last
instalment.
iv) In case of failure to pay any of such
instalments, the CESC shall disconnect the
supply.
14.
Accordingly, the appeal and the application are
disposed of.
15.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied
for, be given to the parties upon compliance of all
necessary formalities.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review