Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 09-07-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S.M.SUBRAMANIAM
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE N.SENTHILKUMAR
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025 AND
C.M.P.Nos.29531, 29533, 29743 and 29744 of 2025
W.A.No.3589 of 2025
1. C.Venkatesan
2. M.Anbazhagan
..Appellants
-vs1. R.Karthikeyan
2. V.Mariappan
3. K.Gopinath
4. G.Thayalan
5. M.Eranian
6. Meenakshisundaram
7. T.Thirunavukkarasu
8. State of Tamil Nadu
Rep. by its Secretary to Govt.,
Home Department,
The Secretariat Chennai 09
9. The Director General of Police
Dr.Radhakrishnan Road,
Mylapore, Chennai 04
10.A.Arun
11.G.Karthik
12.A.Arun
13.S.Ameer ali Jinna
14.U.M.Avinash
15.R.Stephen Vinodh
16.S.Madhan Kumar
__________
Page1 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
17.Chelladurai
18.R.Tamilselvi
19.J.Deepa
20.Manoj Kumar
21.G.Gopal
22.Manoj M.T
23.C.Manjula
24.C.Madhavi
25.S.Elavarasi
(R23 to R25 impleaded as per order
dated 06.01.2026)
26.S.Shunmugasundaram
27.R.R. Venkatesan
28.N.Maharajan
29.D.Augustin
30.M.Ranjith
31.V.Dilipkumar
32.C.Kanagaraj
33.Ramakrishnan
34.R.Manjula Devi
35.P.Vijayakumar
36.R.Meena
37.K.Madhavan
(R26 to R37 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
38.S.Suresh
39.P.Samuthirakani
40.G.Gopinath
41.P.Ravindran
(R38 to R41 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
42.M.Jayalakshmi
43.V.Ananthi
44.R.Rajarajeswari
(R42 to R44 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
__________
Page2 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
45.M.Venugopal
46.P.Premkumar
47.M.Mukunthan
48.D.Manojkumar
(R45 to R48 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
49.S.Sathishkumar
50.G.Ponthilakraj
51.G.Vignesh Guru
52.S.Mani
(R49 to R52 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
53.R.Ramachandran
54.P.Shanthi
55.S.Mohandoss
56.S.Kanagaraj
(R53 to R56 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
57.G.Manikumar
58.C.A.Kesavan
59.K.Karuppasamy Pandian
60.R.Nandhakumar
61.D.Premkumar
62.B.Agilan Raj
(R57 to R62 impleaded as per order
dated 09.07.2026)
63.P.B.Theerthagiri
64.A.Manimekalai
65.P.Parthiban
66.K.Prithika Yashini
67.M.Karthikeyan
68.M.P.Dinesh Kumar
69.V.Dinesh
70.G.Selvakumar
71.D.Diwan Mydheen
__________
Page3 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
72.J.Ganesan
73.M.Selvakumar
74.M.Balasubramaniyan
75.S.Raja
76.R.Ramasamy
77.S.Ranjith
78.M.Rajkamal
79.A.Harun Ersath
80.K.R.Kumar
81.K.Marimuthu
82.Lavanya G
(R63 to R82 impleaded as per order dated
09.07.2026)
… Respondents
W.A.No.3607 of 2025
1. R.Karthikeyan
2. V.Mariappan
3. K.Gopinath
4. G.Thayalan
5. M.Eraninan
6. M.Meenakshisundaram
7. T.Thirunavukkarasu
… Appellants
-vs1. State of Tamil Nadu
Rep. by its Secretary to Govt.,
Home Department,
The Secretariat, Chennai 09
2. The Director General of Police
Dr.Radhakrishnan Road,
Mylapore, Chennai 4.
3. A.Arun
4. G.Karthik
5. A.Arun
6. S.Ameer Ali Jinna
7. U.M.Avinash
8. R.Stephen Vinodh
9. S.Madhan Kumar
10. M.Chelladurai
__________
Page4 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
11. R.Tamilselvi
12. J.Deepa
13. Manojkumar
14. G.Gopal
15. M.T.Manoj
16. C.Venkatesan
17. M.Anbazhagan
18. S.Shunmugasundaram
19. R.R.Venkatesan
20. N.Maharajan
21. D.Augustin
22. M.Ranjith
23. V.Dilipkumar
24. C.Kanagaraj
25. Ramakrishnan
26. R.Manjula Devi
27. P.Vijayakumar
28. R.Meena
29. K.Madhavan
(R18 to R29 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
30. M.Jayalakshmi
31. V.Ananthi
32. R.Rajarajeswari
(R30 to R32 impleaded as per order
dated 28.01.2026)
33. N.Prabhakaran
34. V.Jagadeesan
35. S.Manikandan
36. M.Santhana Bose
37. K.Ganapathy
38. A.Vimal Nathan,
39. M.Santhosh Kumar
40. N.Karthick
41. P.Muthumari Deventhirar
42. D.Rajiv Gandhi
43. Suresh Pandian
44. G.Jeya Pandi
45. C.Madhavi
46. R.Kanagavalli
47. M.Kamatchi
__________
Page5 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
48. K.Karthigai Selvi
49. V.Jothi Lakshmi
50. M.Benazir Begum
(R33 to R50 impleaded as per order
dated 09.07.2026)
… Respondents
W.A.No.3589 of 2025
Prayer: To set aide the order dated 19.11.2925 passed by the learned
Judge of this Hon’ble Court in W.P.No.39119 of 2025.
W.A.No.3607 of 2025
Prayer: To set aside the order passed in W.P.No.39119 of 2025 dated
19.11.2025 by allowing the Writ Appeal.
Case No.
For Appellants
For Respondents
W.A.No.3589 of 2025 Mr.Naveen Kumar Murthy
For Ms.S.Varsha
Mr.T.Gowthaman, AAG for R8 & R9
Mr.R.Prathapkumar for R10
Mr.C.Jayavel for R18 & R19
Mr.K.Venkat Ramani, Senior Counsel
For M.Muthappan
For R11 to 16, 26 to 37 & R57 to 62
Mr.MA.Gowthaman
For R23 to 25
Mr.Ravi For R38 to 41
Ms.Jayanthi K.Shan
For R42 to 44
Mr.L.Chandrakumar
For R45 to 48
Mr.Balan Haridas
For R49 to 52
Mr.S.T.S.Murthy, Senior Counsel
For Mr.Veerapandian For R53 to 56
Mr.Aditya B.Sarangarajan
For R63 to 82
W.A.No.3607 of 2025 Mrs.Dakshyani Reddy,
Senior Counsel
For Mr.K.Sathish Kumar
Mr.T.Gowthaman, AAG for R1 & R2
Mr.K.Venkat Ramani, Senior Counsel
For M.Muthappan
For R3, 4, 18 to 29 & 33 to 50
Ms.Jayanthi K.Shan
For R30 to 32
*****
__________
Page6 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
COMMON JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by S.M.Subramaniam,J.)
Under assail is the Writ Order dated 19.11.2025 passed in
W.P.No.39119 of 2025. Writ Petitioners are appellants in the present
Intra Court Appeals instituted under Clause 15 of the Letters Patent.
2. Dispute raised is regarding fixation of seniority amongst
Sub-Inspectors of Police initially appointed in Taluk Police Wing (TPW)
and Armed Reserve Wing (ARW). It is not in dispute that all SubInspectors of Police involved in the present lis were recruited in a
common recruitment made in pursuance of Recruitment Notification
No.110 dated 01.04.2010.
3. On the side of Appellants, it is contended that on their
transfer from ARW to TPW, their seniority is to be fixed taking into
consideration the marks obtained by them in the initial recruitment
process conducted in the year 2010. As per the judgment of Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Ranjit Singh and Others vs. State of
Tamil Nadu and Others1, seniority is to be fixed based on the marks
2025 INSC 612
__________
Page7 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
obtained by candidates in the examination, on the basis of which, they
have been recruited to service. Applying the ratio laid down by Apex
Court in Ranjith Singh’s case (supra), seniority of transferees,
transferred from ARW to TPW is to be fixed and consequently, their
promotions to the post of Sub-Inspector of Police are to be considered. It
is further contended that at the time of transfer of these Armed Reserve
Sub-Inspectors (ARSIs), it is stated by the Government that seniority will
be fixed under Rule 25(b) of Special Rules for Tamil Nadu Police
Subordinate Service Rules (in short 'TNPSS Rules'). Rule 25(b) of the
TNPSS Rules states that transfer of a person from one class or category
of service to another carrying the same pay scale shall not be treated as
"first appointment" to the latter for seniority purposes. Therefore, original
marks obtained by Sub-Inspectors of Police at the time of their initial
recruitment is to be taken into consideration for fixation of seniority on
their transfer from ARW to TPW.
4. Contesting respondents, currently serving in TPW would
oppose, by stating that marks obtained in the recruitment process in the
year 2010 was considered along with the option exercised by selected
candidates. Accordingly, selected candidates were either posted in ARW
or TPW. After joining duty either in ARW or TPW, separate seniority list
for both Wings have been drawn and being maintained for grant of
__________
Page8 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
promotion and other benefits within the Wing. The said Wing-wise
seniority in the present case has been followed for the past about 10
years.
Armed
Reserve
Sub-Inspectors
(ARSIs)
submitted
representations seeking transfer to TPW. Thus, based on their option,
they have been transferred to TPW. On such transfer, ARSIs have
foregone their initial ranking list prepared at the time of direct recruitment
to the post of Sub-Inspector. Thus, mark based ranking along with the
option was considered at the time of initial recruitment for the purpose of
posting selected candidates to ARW and TPW. Therefore, the ratio laid
down in Ranjith Singh’s case (supra) has no 9application for the reason
that Hon'ble Supreme Court considered fixation of seniority amongst
recruitees at the initial stage in the said case. In the present case,
dispute arose on transfer of serving Sub-Inspectors from ARW to TPW.
Therefore, the seniority is to be fixed based on Rule 25(a) of TNPSS
Rules.
5. Learned Additional Advocate General appearing on behalf
of State would reiterate, by stating that dispute in the present case is
about fixation of seniority amongst Sub-Inspectors, who all are already
working as Sub-Inspectors in ARW and TPW. It is not about fixation of
seniority in the initial recruitment. Thus, ratio laid down in Ranjith
Singh's case (supra) cannot be applied. In the present case,
__________
Page9 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
Department has to apply Rule 25(a) of TNPSS Rules. Accordingly,
transferred ARSIs ought to be placed below Sub-Inspectors, who all are
already serving in TPW.
6. This Court has considered rival submissions made
between parties to the lis.
7. Applicability of Rule for fixation of seniority is to be
considered in the present case. Uncontroverted facts between parties
are that all Sub-Inspectors involved in the present dispute relating to
seniority were recruited in the year 2010, pursuant to the Recruitment
Notification No.110 dated 01.04.2010. A perusal of Notification would
show that at the time of initial Direct Recruitment to the post of SubInspectors, marks obtained by selected candidates along with
preference
(option)
exercised
by
them
would
be
considered.
Accordingly, they would be posted either as ARSIs or TSIs. On issuance
of appointment orders, they are accordingly posted and serving in their
respective Wings and their seniority is maintained separately. After
serving about 10 years, ARSIs expressed their willingness to serve as
TSIs. Government considered their request and transferred them as
TSIs.
__________
Page10 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
8. In G.O.Ms.No.446, Home dated 27.05.2003, Government
stated that seniority of transferee ARSIs in the post of TSIs shall be fixed
with reference to the provisions contained in Rule 25(b) of TNPSS
Rules. Relying on the said Government Order, Appellants would submit
that their seniority is to be fixed based on the marks obtained in the
initial recruitment. In this context, it is relevant to consider the scope of
Rule 25(b) and Rule 25 (a) of TNPSS Rules and its applicability. Rule
25(a) and Second Proviso to Rule 25(a) reads as under:
“25 (a) The seniority of a person in any class or
category of the service shall, unless he has been reduced to
a lower rank as a punishment, be determined by the rank
obtained by him in the list of approved candidates drawn up
by the appointing authority, subject to the rule of reservation
where it applies. The date of commencement of his probation
shall be the date on which he joins duty irrespective of his
seniority, unless he has been appointed temporarily under
sub rule (d) of Rule 10 or sub rule (b) of Rule 15, as the case
may
be.
******
Provided further that in the case of Sub-Inspectors appointed
by transfer from Sub-Inspectors (Armed Reserve) in category
5, in class I of these Rules or by recruitment by transfer from
Sub-Inspectors in category 2 in rule 3 of the Tamil Nadu
Special Police Subordinate Service Rules, 1978 as the
case ,may be, irrespective of their actual date of such
appointment. Seniority shall be fixed below the direct recruits
in which they were recruited to their respective feeder
categories.”
9. What was set aside by Apex Court in Ranjith Singh's
case is Sixth Proviso to Rule 25(a) of TNPSS Rules issued in
__________
Page11 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
G.O.Ms.No.868 Home (Police VI) Department dated 21.11.2017.
Therefore, Rule 25(a) and Second Proviso to Rule 25(a) is not
connected with the judgment in Ranjith Singh's case, where seniority
amongst initially directly recruited candidates alone was considered and
not the seniority in respect of Sub-Inspectors, who all are transferred
from ARW to TPW. Rule 25(b) of TNPSS Rules reads as under:
“(b) The transfer of a person from one class or category
of the services to another class or category carrying the same
pay or scale of pay shall not be treated as first appointment to
the latter for purpose of seniority, and the seniority of a
person so transferred shall be determined with reference to
the date of his first appointment to the class or category from
which he was transferred. Where any difficulty or doubt arises
in applying this sub rule, seniority shall be determined by the
appointing authority.”
10. A close reading of Rule 25(b) would show that it is all
about fixation of seniority amongst transferee Sub-Inspectors. In other
words, seniority amongst Sub-Inspectors either in ARW or in TPW.
Thus, Rule 25(b) has no application in respect of Sub-Inspectors
transferred from ARW to TPW. Therefore, in respect of transfers made
from ARW to TPW, Rule 25(a) and Second Proviso would be applicable.
11. Second Proviso to Rule 25(a) of TNPSS Rules in
unambiguous terms, states that irrespective of their actual date of
appointment, seniority shall be fixed below direct recruitees in which
they were recruited in respective feeder categories. Therefore, it is all
__________
Page12 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
about fixation of seniority between two different wings, where different
kinds of Police training are provided. Sub-Inspectors appointed in ARW
are provided with separate training programme and Sub-Inspectors
initially appointed in TPW are imparted separate Police training. When,
at the willingness of Sub-Inspectors working in ARW, transfer was
effected to TPW as Sub-Inspectors, their seniority is to be fixed below
Sub-Inspectors serving in TPW, who all are already working there and
their seniority became settled. In other words, transferee Sub-Inspectors
from ARW are to be placed below Sub-Inspectors, who are all recruited
and posted initially in TPW. There is no inter-se dispute amongst SubInspectors appointed in ARW or TPW. Seniority dispute in the present
case is all about fixation of seniority of transferee Sub-Inspectors on
their transfer to TPW. Therefore, question of considering initial marks
obtained by candidates in the common recruitment may not arise at all.
12. Once marks and option exercised are considered at the
time of initial recruitment in the year 2010 and after their appointment at
their choice to different wings, separate seniority is maintained and after
serving about 10 years, further willingness is given to post them as TSIs,
and on such transfer, Rule 25(a) Second Proviso is to be applied.
Therefore, ARSIs, on their transfer to TPW are to be placed below TSIs,
who all are serving in the Department from the date of their initial date of
__________
Page13 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
recruitment from the year 2010. In other words, seniority of TSIs shall
remain undisturbed and transferred ARSIs are to be placed below TSIs.
13. Learned Single Judge in the Writ Order impugned also
considered the fact that ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Ranjith Singh's case has no application to the facts of the present case
relating to fixation of seniority amongst transferee ARSIs and TSIs.
14. In view of the facts and circumstances, this Court could
be able to arrive at an irresistible conclusion that finding given by Writ
Court in the impugned order is in consonance with Rule relating to
seniority applicable for the post of Sub-Inspector of Police in respect of
two different Wings, namely ARW and TPW. Thus, Writ Order stands
confirmed. Consequently, the present Writ Appeals are dismissed.
15. At this juncture, it is brought to the notice of this Court
that ARSIs, who were already transferred to TPW have not yet been
placed in the seniority list at all.
16. In view of the above submission, Department is directed
to ensure that seniority of Armed Reserve Sub-Inspectors (ARSIs) is
fixed in accordance with Rule 25(a) and Second Proviso of TNPSS
__________
Page14 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
Rules. Accordingly, their promotions are to be considered, as and when
their turn comes. No costs. Connected Miscellaneous Petitions are
closed.
(S.M.S.,J.)
(N.S.,J.)
09-07-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
AR
To:
1. The Secretary to Government,
State of Tamil Nadu
Home Department,
Fort St.George,
Chennai – 600 009.
2. The Director General of Police
Dr.Radhakrishnan Road,
Mylapore, Chennai 04
__________
Page15 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:2812
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
S.M.SUBRAMANIAM,J.
AND
N.SENTHILKUMAR,J.
AR
W.A.Nos.3589 and 3607 of 2025
2/2
09-07-2026
__________
Page16 of 16
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review