The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. As it was representcd before the trial Court that appeal was preferred only against the dismissal of thc suit for specific performance but not against the counter claim, this Court considering their argumcnts held that appeal is not maintainable as no appeal rvas preferred against the Order of the counter claim. Admitterllr', appeal u'as noL decided on merits and it is lirst appeal on.Judgment of the trial Court. Therefore, considering the arguments ol thc revicu' petitioner and also the citations statcd above, this Court finds it just and reasonable to allow the review petition. In the result, the Review Civil Miscellaneous Petition is allowed by setting aside the Judgment of this Court in A.S.No.229O of 20O3 dated 17.11.2022. Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed. SdI K. SRINIVASA RAO I I //TRUE COPY// V To, The Principal Senior Civil Judge, RR District at NTR Nagar, Hyderabad (O S No. 1 18 of 1995)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3208 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY,TFIE FIRST DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE P.SREE SUDHA
REVIEW C.M.P. No. 2 ot 2022
tn
APPEAL SUIT NO: 2290 OF 2003
Between:
1. C.Satyanarayana, died per LR's,
2. C. Padmaja,, Wo. Late C. Satyanarayana, R/o. 2-2-114611612, New
Nallakunta, Hyderabad.
3. C. Akshay, S/o. Late C. Satyanarayana, No. 2-2-114611612, New Nallakunta,
Hyderabad. (3rd Appellant is being minor rep. by his mother and natural
guardian Smt. C. Padmaja, Appellant No.2) (Appellants 2 & 3 brought on
record as LR's of the deceased 1st Appellant
...APPE LLANT/APPE LLANTS/PLAINTIFF
AND
'1
. S. Ramulu(died) per LRs
2. Narsu bai, Wo. Late S. Ramulu
3. S. Raju, S/o. Late S. Ramulu
4. S. Sujatha, D/o. Late Sri S. Ramulu
5. S. Rama, S/o. Late S- Ramulu
.
RESPON DENTS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS
Review Petition filed under order 47 rule 1 & 2 Rlw 151 of CPC Praying that in
the Circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds the High Court may be
pleased to review the Judgment daled 17 -11-2022 passed in A.S. No. 229012003 by
the High Court of Telangana Hyderabad.
This Petition coming on for hearing and upon perusing the ground of appeal, the
Judgment and Decree of the Lower Court and the material papers in the case and
--upon hearing the arguments of SRI B. IvIOHAN, Advocate for the Appellants and
SRI V HARI HARN. Advocate for the Respondents.
The Court made the following:
i-,
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE P.SREE SUDHA
Rev.C.M.P.No.2 of 2022 in A.S.No.229O of 2OO3
ORDER:
This Review Civil Miscellancous Petition is filecl against
the Judgment of this Court in A.S.No.2290 of 2O03 dated
17.1t.2022.
2.
Appellants herein mainly contended that husband o[
second appellant late C. Satyanarayana filed a suit in
O.S.No.118 of 1995 for Specific Performance of Agreement of
Salc and to register the sale deed in lavour ol
appellants/ plaintiffs regarding the suit schedule property by
receiving balance sale consideration ol Rs.7O,OOO/- and to grant
perpetual injunction restraining the respondent/defendant not
to interfere with the peace ful possession. and enjoyment of the
suit property. The {irst Respondent/defendant in his written
statement disputed that there is no agreement of sale and the
amount paid by the plaintiff is only a loan transaction. He
further made counter claim in the written statement to declare
document dated 14.1O.1991 as security bond towards loan of
Rs. 1,15,O00/- paid by plaintiff to the defendant and to declare
the same as null and void and also requested for delivery of the
I
possession in his favour. 'lhe trial Court after framing of issues
and aftcr considering the entire evidence on record came to the
erroneous conclusion ar-rd dismissed the suit for specilic
performance' of agrcement o[ sale and decrecd the counter claim
of the defcndant by the Judgment and decree dated 22.07.2OO3.
Aggrieved b1. the said Judgment appeal suit was preferred and
the same was dismissed by Judgment of this Court in
A.S.No.229O ol 2OO3, dated 17.1 1.2022 on the ground that
appeal n'zrs prefcrred on l_r' against the finding with regard to
non-granting specific performance of Agreeme nt, but not against
counter claim, as such appeal is not maintainable. Appellants
filed only one appeal and not preferred any appeal against the
counter claim of the respondent/defendant.
3.
Appellants further contended that the trial Court decided
the issues between the parties by a single trial and passed
Judgment dismissing the claim of the plaintiff and allowed the
counter claim of the defendant. As the suit and counter claim is
decided in one suit, filing of two appeals is not required. They
relied upon the Judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of Narrz'hari and others Vs. Shankar and othersr arrd in
' 1950 scc onlinc sc
.r
I
the case ttf K.A.Natesa Cheetiqr Vs. Nine Krisbaniab Chettgl
and also in the case of M/s. Ra,mno,th Exports Pvt. Ltd,, Vs.
Vinita Mehta and anothe€.
4.
The respondent/defendant filed the counter claim in the
suit and a single/composite decree was drawn in the said suit
with regard to counter claim also, as such single appeal is
prelerred before this Court. In view of the amendment carried
out in C.P.C, memorandum of Appeal is not requircd to be
accompanied by a decree sheet as per the provisions of Order 4l
ruie 1 and Order 20 rule 6-A of Code. The rule 6-A of Order 20
of the Code came into effect from Ol.O7.2OO2. As per the above
amendment, it is possible to file appeal only on the basis of
Judgment and memo appeal need not be accompanied by a
copy of the decree. In this case, composite decree was hled
along with the appeal as there is one trial, one finding and one
decision and thus single appeal is maintainable.
5.
They further stated that right to appeal is a substantial
right of a party and substantial rights should not be allowed to
be defeated on technical grounds. They also stated that in
I l97O SCC Online AP 143
r
2022 Livelaw (SC) 564
,,
-
interpreting an-y procedural law, u,here more than one
interpretation is possible, the one q,hich curtails the procedure
without alluding justice is to be adopted. The procedural law is
always subservient to aid of justice. As per Order 20 rule 19(2)
of CPC, appeal from decree passed in suit, where a counter
claim has been made, can be filed as if no counter claim has
ilS
such there is no necessity for hling separate
appeal where
counter claim preferred in the suit has been
been filed,
decreed b1, the trial Court. Appeal is a continuation of the
proceedings oI lhc originerl Court, i.e. sub-jurdice. The findings of
the trial Corrrt on issues did not attain finality and thus it
cannot be operated as res-judicata. The lirst appeal is a
I
valuable right of the appellant and the firsl Appeliate Court is
required to address on all the issues and decide the appeal
assigning valid reasons either in support or against by reappraisal. The appellate Court has to record its findings basing
on the oral and documentary evidence led by the parties. As
there is error apparent on the face of the record, requested the
Court to revierv the Judgment.
I
6.
Heard the arguments of both sides and perused the
record and also the Judgment passed by this Court.
7.
Perusal of the record shows that suit for specific
performance was hled in O.S.No. i 18 of 1995 requesting the
Courl to direct defendant to execute and register sale deed in
favour of ptaintiff regarding suit schedule property i.e, house
admeasuring an extent of 367 Sq.yrds by receiving balance sale
consideration of Rs.7O,O0O/- and also restraining the defendant
from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of
suit property and for other reliefs. In the written statement filed
by the defendant, it was clearly stated that it is a written
statement cum counter claim and he denied the contentions of
the plaintiff, In the counter claim, he mentioned that the
occupation of the suit schedule property by the plaintiff is as a
tenant only. When a legal notice was issued on 02.O3.1995,
after receiving the same he filed the suit and thus he made
counter claim requesting the Court to declare the fabricated
document dated 14.10.1991 as a securitj, bond towards loan of
Rs. 1,15,000/- and to declare
it as null and void and also to
deliver the possession of the suit property in his favour.
8.
The learned Counsel for the revision petitioners relied
upon the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Narahari and others Vs. Shankar and othersj in t'hich it
was held as loilows
"8. Tlrcre is also a later decision of the Judicial
Committee of the State in Bansilal Vs. MohanLal, where
the utell-knoun ond exltaustiue authority t,f the Lahore
High Court in Lachhnti Vs. Bhulli was followed. In tLe
Lahore case, there u'ere tu)o cross-suits about the same
subject motter, ftled stnrultaneousl!.1 betLueen the same
parties, whereas in the present case, there was only suit
and one Judgment uas qiuen by the tial Court and euen
in the first appeal to the Sardar Adalat. there was onlg
one Judgment, in spite of there being tu.to appeals by the
lu.,o sels of defendartts.
9. The plaintiffs irt thei appeal to the HigLt Court haue
impleaded all the defetld.rrlls as respondents and their
praAer couers botlt tlu, appeals and they haue paid
consolidated couft .fee for the whole suit. It is notu utell
settled tllat u,there there has been one tia\ one finding
and one decision, t.here rteed not be tuto appeals euen
though ttuo decrees trt.ag haue been dra u.tn up. As hc-s
been obserued bg Tek Chand,J in his learned Judgment
in Lachhmi Vs. Bhulli mentioned aboue, tle detennining
factor is not the decree but tLe matter in controuersy. As
he puts it later in his Judgment, tte estoppel is not
aeated by the decree but tt can only be created by tLe
judgment. The question of res judicata arises only when
there are tuo suits. Euen tuhen there are ttuo suits, it
has been held that a decision giuen simultaneouslg
cannot be a decision in the former suit."
He aiso relied upon the Judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in the case of M/s. Ramnath Exports Ptlt,Ltd Vs. Vinita
Mehta and another,s in which it was held as follows:
l9-50 scc online s(-- 3 |
' 2022 Live Law (SC) 564
I
I
Er-'
"The procedurctl defect may fall within the puruiew of
irregulaity cLnd capctble of being cured, but it should not
be allotued to defeat the substantiue right accrued to the
lltigant Luithout affording reasonable opportunity. An
appeal is a continuation of the proceedings of the
ortginal court. Ordinarily, the first appeal inuolued a rehearing on low os tLtell as on fact as inuoked by an
aggrieued person. The fi,rst appeal is a ualuable right of
tte appellant and there in all questions of foct and latu
are open for consideration bg re-appreciating the
mateial and euidence. The first appellate court is
required to address on all the issues and decide the
appeal ctssign{ng ualid reasons either in support or
against bg re appratsal. It must record its findings
deaLing all the issues, consideing oral as utell as
documentctry euidence leci by the parties."
9.
He also relieci upon the Judgment of the Andhra Pradesh
High Court in the case of K.A. No,tesrr Chettiar I/s. Niine
Krkbniab Chettg and another,6 in which it was held as
follows:
"28. ll*Lat emerges from the two decisions of the
Supreme Court referred to aboue is that where tLte suits
or oppeals raise onla common issues /or decbion and
there has been one trial, one finding and one decision, an
appeal ogainst the decree in one suit or the appeal uill
not be barred by res judicata bg not filing an appeal
against tLe decree in the other suit or the appeal. But
uhere the subject matter of each of the tu.to suits or the
oppeals is different and tLLe decision in the tuo
proceedings thus stated in one judgment, reallg omounts
to two decisions and not one decision common to both the
proceedings, an appeal filed against tLrc decision in one
proceeding uill be baned bg the rules of res judicata if no
o
t9;0 scc online AP l4l
I
s
-
appeal is filed agairtst tLrc decision in the other
proceedings."
10. As it was representcd before the trial Court that appeal
was preferred only against the dismissal of thc suit for specific
performance but not against the counter claim, this Court
considering their argumcnts held that appeal is not
maintainable as no appeal rvas preferred against the Order of
the counter claim. Admitterllr', appeal u'as noL decided on merits
and it is lirst appeal on.Judgment of the trial Court. Therefore,
considering the arguments ol thc revicu' petitioner and also the
citations statcd above, this Court finds it just and reasonable to
allow the review petition.
In the result, the Review Civil Miscellaneous Petition is
allowed by setting aside the Judgment of this Court in
A.S.No.229O of 20O3 dated 17.11.2022.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
SdI K. SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
I
I
//TRUE COPY//
V
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Senior Civil Judge, RR District at NTR Nagar, Hyderabad (O S
No. 1 18 of 1995)
2. One CC to M/s B. MOHAN, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Sri V. Hari Haran, Advocate [OPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
DL ,{
HIGH COURT
DATED:01102!2A22
-/
/o?
I€
ORDER
1 4 iiiAB 2021
AS.No.2290 of 2003
REVIEW
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS PETITION
IS ALLOWED
\
.+
^D
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review